Colors of Life- Prithvi and Mrinal Part 30 updated page 48 - Page 23

i actually dont know if sindhu deserved complete forgiveness or a life term in jail. how easy is it for prithvi to live with the killer of his father, ok prithvi beleves in forgiveness n all but how easy it is for his mother to live with his dead husbands killer. how easy will it be for savitri to live with a murderer in the same room who she saw killing in front of her own eyes, will she be able to trust him again? And how sensible it is to let a person who has killed his own father open. That too when a few minutes ago he was justifying his killing. he still thinks of prithvi as a threat & has not even accepted his wrong thinking. i do not think it was right for prithvi to just forgive sindhu or just thrust forgiveness on other people.

Shruthi, yes Savitri and Vatsa are portraying the positive women's nurturing beautiful. This is one of those golden period in Indian history where some lived by virtue and brave women. Where people kept their promises and forgiveness really resulted in repentance. But now many are not valid anymore.

Btw, what is your thought on Mrinal slapping PV. Is there a reason behind or is it just misunderstanding on her behalf. And her being accused for a crime that she did not commit

Originally posted by: naq5

i actually dont know if sindhu deserved complete forgiveness or a life term in jail. how easy is it for prithvi to live with the killer of his father, ok prithvi beleves in forgiveness n all but how easy it is for his mother to live with his dead husbands killer. how easy will it be for savitri to live with a murderer in the same room who she saw killing in front of her own eyes, will she be able to trust him again? And how sensible it is to let a person who has killed his own father open. That too when a few minutes ago he was justifying his killing. he still thinks of prithvi as a threat & has not even accepted his wrong thinking. i do not think it was right for prithvi to just forgive sindhu or just thrust forgiveness on other people.

I also think prithvi is one person who as a king has different yardsticks for his family & other praja. Im sure if mahakai was the only one involved or someone else, he would have given a life term if not death.

I am also not convinced regarding Prithvi judgement
but atleast he is not biased just for his family
yes he trusts his close ones but not biased
He spared a person when there was this very first African attack
He later spared Mrinal after Rangaostav attack
He spared those Adivasis instantly who came to kill him
he spared Taliap and Also Mrinal too
that too when Mrinal stabbed his father in front of his eyes
So forgiveness is natural to him
If Mahakai really repented he might have spared him too

Also it's difficult for Sindhu to face his Mother, Wife and Son
not the other way around
If u see when Prithvi announced his decision
Sindhu's Mother and wife were happy
So Prithvi is not thrusting it on them

Only thing I didn't like was
what about people of Malwa
they too lost their once beloved king
Sindhu for now is repenting for sure
but the depth and sincerity of his repentance in long run will move Malwa
so the right and wrong of Prithvi's decision rests on Sindhu

Shruthi di that is even my doubt

@aditi my problem was reason for forgiveness was not shown. It was a flaw in the script. Prithvi's thoughts, his dilemma was not dealt with. Throughout I am seeing that flaw, his thoughts are not dealt with. Biggest plus of SKR was Ram's thoughts, his dilemma's were dealt with which made Ram more humane and we could connect to him. Here base of Prithvi's decision is missing.

@ShruthiRavi
that's the problem they are not showing what Prithvi is going through
They showed it when Prithvi realized his mistake of choking Mrinal(Post she stabbed SD)
and he realized what he needs to do
A similar scene was needed here too

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@aditi my problem was reason for forgiveness was not shown. It was a flaw in the script. Prithvi's thoughts, his dilemma was not dealt with. Throughout I am seeing that flaw, his thoughts are not dealt with. Biggest plus of SKR was Ram's thoughts, his dilemma's were dealt with which made Ram more humane and we could connect to him. Here base of Prithvi's decision is missing.

If it was to show Prithvi can forgive his father's killer it shouldnt have been his brother, it should have been a third party to show the impact.

Though I agree to Mano Prithvi is not partial to his family as far as forgiveness goes, but it didnt cut ice when Sindhu was pardoned. Script has flaws and I hope in their attempt to make Prithvi the messenger of love and peace he is not made all suffering God and an aura given to him.

@visa I dont know why she slapped him, but my guess is that she thinks Prithvi had played the game of love with her and trapped her. She thinks that way because she is doing that to him

@naq I also dont support Prithvi on the forgiveness part.

i dont understand mrinal.

Originally posted by: shruthiravi

@aditi my problem was reason for forgiveness was not shown. It was a flaw in the script. Prithvi's thoughts, his dilemma was not dealt with. Throughout I am seeing that flaw, his thoughts are not dealt with. Biggest plus of SKR was Ram's thoughts, his dilemma's were dealt with which made Ram more humane and we could connect to him. Here base of Prithvi's decision is missing.

If it was to show Prithvi can forgive his father's killer it shouldnt have been his brother, it should have been a third party to show the impact.

Though I agree to Mano Prithvi is not partial to his family as far as forgiveness goes, but it didnt cut ice when Sindhu was pardoned. Script has flaws and I hope in their attempt to make Prithvi the messenger of love and peace he is not made all suffering God and an aura given to him.

@visa I dont know why she slapped him, but my guess is that she thinks Prithvi had played the game of love with her and trapped her. She thinks that way because she is doing that to him

@naq I also dont support Prithvi on the forgiveness part.

I was ok Sita's thoughts were not shown, because it was Siya ke Ram and it was about Ram. It was like Ram knew how Sita would behave, he knew her thoughts and he manipulated them to give her justice as well bring law for larger good.