Colors of Life- Prithvi and Mrinal Part 30 updated page 48 - Page 12

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

anshvi

@anshvi

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#111

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD
^^ sometimes we are unable to see the darkness within us, that's when subconsciously we do things which we feel is right but in reality it's wrong. Noone is wrong on this earth, everyone is human being. U yourself are calling Kosha grey but your description makes her sound like a very selfless lover. Then how did she become grey. In those days polygamy was practiced. Kosha's profession is of a prostitute, there's nothing wrong in loving Tailap who is also in love with her. Then why to even call her a grey character?
She's grey because her deeds are spreading negativity. Maybe she's not aware of it but she is causing destruction.
Jakkala is of course grey but unlike Kosha doesn't hide behind the mask of true love or greatness.
Hence I like her more than Kosha n Tailap.

See why I call her grey is because she is in love with a 'married' man..her actions cause pain to Jhakkala

Like I said she is selfish to others by being in love with Tailap...that is what I wrote if u read it

That is why for me she is grey..her actions hurt Jhakkala but it doesn't mean she is not in love with Tailap..Also as I said if she was a sati savitri or a selfless woman then she would have understood Jhakkala's pain and if and when Tailap will ask her to become a queen then she will not accept it..that is what will make her pure and selfless which she is not

The point of the discussion was is Kosha really a 'doormat' whose only aim is to remove Jhakkala from her place and become a queen..is she a woman who doesn't love Tailap and is simply using him ..doesn't that make her black ?

She is a grey character who has done the wrong thing by loving a married man.. she is a character who loves Tailap but has desires as well..having desires makes her a flawed character but doesn't clarify if Her love for Tailap is fake or not

Like I said..what if Tailap asks her to become a queen and she does enjoy the perks and pleasures of being a queen..will that mean she doesn't love Tailap or that she is a woman who loves him and also enjoys being his wife and a queen..doesn't that make her grey ?

The point is very simple...I only stated that she does love Tailap in my opinion and if she is using him and doesn't love him at all then that we will get to know in future for sure.

You say Kosha hides behind mask of true love or greatness...I personally think if she wanted to be great then she wouldn't have given it back to Jhakkala in the court...also how are we sure that she hides behind a mask of greatness or true love.

Jhakkala is also grey for me..because she did burn down the brothel and rather than telling Tailap the reality she simply lied to him and put the whole blame on Mrinal..her actions also did spread negativity right..and she did try to cover up her mistake by putting entire blame on Mrinal

Was Jhakkala right in putting the whole blame on Mrinal ? No she wasn't .. Didn't she hide behind a mask?

For me neither Jhakkala or Kosha are better than one other...They are both complex and grey..Yes I do sympathise more with Jhakkala coz her only mistake was burning the brothel and lying to Tailap about it..she is right in wanting her rights.

As I said Tailap and Kosha both are wrong for having an extra marital affair but the situation is complex because Tailap never loved his wife and fell for Kosha which is wrong, Kosha has fallen in love with a married man which again is wrong.. like u said it is not wrong to be in love and in those days polygamy was practiced..it was 9th century which makes things more complicated and then we have Jhakkala who has every right to detest Kosha but then some of her actions are not justified...perhaps why I understand the point of view of all 3.

But the point of the discussion was as I mentioned is Kosha's love for Tailap a mere pretense or genuine..is she a mere dormant who is negative and wants to be a queen or a grey character who has flaws, has desires and is selfish for being in love with Tailap

Edited by anshvi - 6 years ago

Quote

Mano.M

@Mano.M

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 6 years ago

#112

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD
This is what i had written long ago 😆
Of course it's nothing as good as Shruthi di's analysis😆

------

Tailap n Mrinal are transparent grey characters. We know what is there aim, what are they up to. What will they do next, even Jakkala we know about her thoughts.
But Prithvi n kosha have more to their characters, than what meets the eyes, they say something but do something else.
IMO while this nature of Kosha will be destructive nature of Prithvi will be constructive.
That's why we got Kosha in the main promo. It had Mrinal,Prithvi nKosha.
Both kosha n pv are artists. Art/love might have negative effects as well as positive effects.
I think Kosha will show negative effects n pv will show positive side ...
Just a thought😆
I may be over thinking though 😆

-----

and that's a very good take😆😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 6 years ago

#113

Originally posted by: -Mano-

and that's a very good take😆😆

Really??

I was half asleep when I wrote this 😆😆

Quote

Mano.M

@Mano.M

Achiever

+ 3

Posted: 6 years ago

#114

Originally posted by: shruthiravi
@Mano that's the point, can you trust again and again when your trust is broken. How much and to what extend. How many blames Prithvi will take for Mrinal, how many times he will bow for Mrinal, believe me it is something only God can do. Trusting us humans again and again when we betray his trust so many times with our actions based on our perceptions.

So may be that's why his birth is a Mystery
hinting of some Godly nature

Quote

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 6 years ago

#115

Originally posted by: anshvi

But the point of the discussion was as I mentioned is Kosha's love for Tailap a mere pretense or genuine..is she a mere dormant who is negative and wants to be a queen or a grey character who has flaws, has desires and is selfish for being in love with Tailap

Of course Jakkala is grey, I am saying she doesn't wear a mask of mahaanta, so she is better than Kosha , still she is irritating.

Well putting the blame on Mrinal isn't fully misleading Tailap

Because Mrinal doesn't care whether Kosha lives or dies, she was worried abt the other woman in brothel not Kosha, infact she herself allowed Jakkala to do "anything" with Kosha which includes killing as well, just she didn't want innocent ppl to die.

Tailap on the other hand hardly cares abt other women of brothel. He cares just about kosha n his Akka did want to throw her out of his life via Jakkala.

But yes as u said it was finally Jakkala's call and now she wants Tailap to think it was done by Mrinal alone.

Bold- it was never the point of discussion that whether her love is pretense or not atleast not from my side, maybe u misunderstood my post, I said earlier only that maybe her love is genuine it might not be a pretence, but having such desires itself is not right.

In other words, her love isn't that selfless, because it is creating problems in many ppl's life. N whether she knows abt the ill effects of her love or not n is doing everything consciously has to be seen, as of now I feel she isn't aware of her negativity n causing negativity towards others subconsciously

So she is grey. In short we are saying the same thing, just that u are finding the trio fascinating, n I am not😆

About Tailap, I am not saying he doesn't love Mrinal as a sister. But his love for Kosha takes the priority over Mrinal as well. Given a chance to choose between desires n duties, Mrinal will choose her duties over her personal desires but Tailap will choose his own love life over his duties.

Edited by CutiepieAD - 6 years ago

Quote

anshvi

@anshvi

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#116

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD

Of course Jakkala is grey, I am saying she doesn't wear a mask of mahaanta, so she is better than Kosha , still she is irritating.
Well putting the blame on Mrinal isn't fully misleading Tailap
Because Mrinal doesn't care whether Kosha lives or dies, she was worried abt the other woman in brothel not Kosha, infact she herself allowed Jakkala to do "anything" with Kosha which includes killing as well, just she didn't want innocent ppl to die.
Tailap on the other hand hardly cares abt other women of brothel. He cares just about kosha n his Akka did want to throw her out of his life via Jakkala.
But yes as u said it was finally Jakkala's call and now she wants Tailap to think it was done by Mrinal alone.

Bold- it was never the point of discussion that whether her love is pretense or not atleast not from my side, maybe u misunderstood my post, I said earlier only that maybe her love is genuine it might not be a pretence, but having such desires itself is not right. Hence she is grey.

About Tailap, I am not saying he doesn't love Mrinal as a sister. But his love for Kosha takes the priority over Mrinal as well. Given a chance to choose between desires n duties, Mrinal will choose her duties over her personal desires but Tailap will choose his own love life over his duties.

Well my point of discussion with Shruthi was that only if Kosha is a mere doormat who pretends to be in love only so that she can take Jhakkala's place as a queen or that she is a grey character who is a flawed 'human' for having desires and being selfish for being in love with Tailap

That is what i clarified in the post...I myself m saying that she is grey for being in love with Tailap. So, i guess point of discussion got deviated 😆

See if Kosha wears a mask or not remains to be seen which will get cleared in future episodes

Now coming to Jhakkala...well putting blame on Mrinal is not misleading but putting 'entire' blame on her is..She didn't admit that she was the one who gave orders of burning the brothel

Yes that is what makes Mrinal complex and grey as well...She doesn't care if Kosha lives or dies..she was worried about other innocent women about whom Jhakkala didn't care which makes her grey as well

Tailap did confront Jhakkala that does she realize how many innocent women died...So, I guess he did care about them...that is precisely why he brought them up when he confronted Jhakkala otherwise he would have spoken only about Kosha.

Yes I agree...definitely if given a choice between duties and his love...Tailap will choose Kosha

But If given a choice to choose between duties and his sister...Tailap will choose his sister as well

But if it comes to choose between Kosha and Mrinal...I don't think it is fair to compare both...Yes i do think that circumstances will make him choose Kosha

Like i said if Mrinal tried to kill Kosha then obviously he will side with Kosha but if the case was reversed and he found out that Kosha tried to kill Mrinal then I am sure he would have chosen Mrinal over Kosha and not Kosha over Mrinal in that case .

But then the circumstances will play a major role in the show and Tailap will choose Kosha over others ...He will go against Mrinal as well once she will fall for Prithvi.

similarly like u said if given a choice Mrinal will choose duties over Tailap or any other family member but if she has to choose between Tailap and PV can she make a choice ?

So, that was my point that I don't think Tailap loves Kosha more than Mrinal coz these two relations are very different...I can say that he loves Kosha more than Jhakkala..that i can compare but I can't compare his love for his sister with the love he has for his lover just like we won't be able to compare if Mrinal loves PV more than her brother.

P.S. - Yes I do find the trio fascinating coz I can't pin point if one right or other is wrong...all 3 are grey , complex, flawed and caught in a web of circumstances...I feel bad for all of them and do understand their point...Also for me Jitin is fantastic as Tailap..Tailap is not an easy character to perform..He is super complex and this character emotes through eyes which Jitin does so well...Plus Piyali as Jhakkala is good as well...So, i am enjoying their scenes...Also Divyangnana as Kosha is decent too but i wish she speaks more normally rather than in poetic tone but yes kudos to her for taking up such a challenging role..I am sure it must be difficult to play this kind of role.

So, i find these actors great who have put in a lot of effort for their roles and their characters fascinating

😊

Edited by anshvi - 6 years ago

Quote

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 6 years ago

#117

Anshi I changed my post

Earlier I wrote PV n Tailap but anyway that's a very far fetched idea as we need to see till what extent Mrinal falls for Prithvi. But I think going by current characterisation her duties come over everyone, later if she falls for Prithvi, Tailap will be her duty n Prithvi her love, she'll choose Tailap . But if Tailap is given a choice to between his duty towards Mrinal, his obligation for her , he won't choose her, but he will choose Kosha .

I too find the actors great but I am talking about the characters which are quite irritating. There are other ppl too like Sindhu etc they too are working hard, and they too are grey, a little balancing of screen space won't be bad like they did last week 😊

N please don't think I am one of those who likes a character just because he's being played by my favorite actor. I liked Aneri but didn't like Saanjh n for the same reason I don't like Kosha 😆😆 here Jitin is good but Tailap, he's like Arjun 😆

Even in this show my fav character is Mrinal though I am not Sona fan, I am Mrinal's advocate, remember😉😆

Edited by CutiepieAD - 6 years ago

Quote

anshvi

@anshvi

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#118

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD
Anshi I changed my post
Earlier I wrote PV n Tailap but anyway that's a very far fetched idea as we need to see till what extent Mrinal falls for Prithvi. But I think going by current characterisation her duties come over everyone, later if she falls for Prithvi, Tailap will be her duty n Prithvi her love, she'll choose Tailap . But if Tailap is given a choice to between his duty towards Mrinal, his obligation for her , he won't choose her, but he will choose Kosha .

I too find the actors great but I am talking about the characters which are quite irritating. There are other ppl too like Sindhu etc they too are working hard, and they too are grey, a little balancing of screen space won't be bad like they did last week 😊

Like I said i find the characters interesting and the actors portraying them makes it very more pleasurable to watch them on screen...Yes I like Sindhu as well..Sunil is a fantastic actor..Since discussion is about trio hence i mentioned them

In fact my fav ship is PriLap, SinLap and PriLapRaj 😆

And yes the thing i love about the show is that it is well balanced and here all characters have got their stories as well as screen space...That is what makes the show interesting for me...Unlike other shows where only leads take up 99% of screen space while supporting cast acts like a statue 😆

So, kudos to the makers for doing justice to the actors and the characters so far and this departmant so far I have no complaints with the makers

Again as i said choosing someone and loving someone are two different things...If Mrinal will choose Tailap coz he will be her duty over Mrinal then it won't mean that she loves PV any less...and that was exactly my point...Even if due to circumstances he chooses Kosha over Mrinal then it won't mean he loves Mrinal any less or Kosha more than Mrinal...There can't be comparison between love for a brother and love for a husband...love for a sister and love for a lover/wife

I was not talking about duty vs love but love vs love...When it comes to duty vs love I agree with what u have written

Hahahah...same here i like Jenny but never justified Maya but loved her portrayal of Maya...I was not a fan of Aneri and still understood Saanjh...here I am not a huge fan of any of these actors but liking the characters so far...I am one of those who know how to distinguish between an actor and a character they portray 😃

Edited by anshvi - 6 years ago

Quote

CutiepieAD

@CutiepieAD

Sparkler

Posted: 6 years ago

#119

^^ the show isn't well balanced , that's evident. This trio eats up max screen time. Also their story is being stretched . There is more story in Malwa side which they are rushing. But I think after Bhoj's entry it'll balance out, I really hope.

Still if u feel so, let's agree to disagree😊

But yes makers are doing justice to actors more than other shows. It's the only show in which all the cast name is mentioned in the credits.

Btw in which show did u see leads having max screen space😆

It's always some villain or vamp which has max to do 😆

Edited by CutiepieAD - 6 years ago

Quote

anshvi

@anshvi

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 6 years ago

#120

Originally posted by: CutiepieAD
^^ the show isn't well balanced , that's evident. This trio eats up max screen time. Also their story is being stretched . There is more story in Malwa side which they are rushing. But I think after Bhoj's entry it'll balance out, I really hope.
Still if u feel so, let's agree to disagree😊

But yes makers are doing justice to actors more than other shows. It's the only show in which all the cast name is mentioned in the credits.

Btw in which show did u see leads having max screen space😆
It's always some villain or vamp which has max to do 😆

Heheheh..yes i do disagree 😆 but there is a reason why you feel that way in my opinion ...In Manyakhet we were introduced with all the characters very early on and they are getting explored well

while in Malwa Bhoj, Sindhu's wife have been introduced now...Creatives can't introduce 20 characters together and then give screen space to all.

Malwa's characters are introducing now and I am sure they will get screen space as well ..U did see that Bhoj got good screen space in his very first episode and so did Savitri...She had scenes with almost everyone

Vilas's story with Bhoj hasn't even started...once it will start then they will get the screen space

In Malwa...we had Kallari, Sindhu and mainly Singhdant besides PV and all of them had significant screen space.

In Manyakhet...Tailap has scenes with Mrinal and with Guru Aditya as well and Jhakkala has scenes with Vilas's mom as well.

Also we need to understand that these two are not mere part of a love triangle but part of the Manykhet clan as well so they are bound have good amount of scenes...This love triangle is what will create problems hence it is a part of the story

Although I do find Manyakhet characters more complex...In Malwa we only have a grey Sinhu and negative Mahakai while rest are positive

Yes some parts may have been rushed here and there but over all i do think that this is one show where characters and actors are getting their due

Heheheheh...Agree villains have more screen space 😆 no arguments here 😆

Edited by anshvi - 6 years ago

Quote

1 ... 10 11 12 13 14 ... 39

Top