Pracchand Ashok - Episode Discussion Thread #1 - Page 143

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.4k

Views

41.8k

Users

16

Likes

2.6k

Frequent Posters

chabalas thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Group Promotion 3 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: Yashikha16

Plastic flowers, jo uss zamane mein plastic bhi nahi tha. Aur shayad there were no mattresses too, but apparently A Shock was lifting up Sushima's mattress.🤣🤣

Let's be happy that we dint get another Hulk moment of Ashok lifting the cot with one hand and eating some random fruit with other hand smiley37

NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: Yashikha16


I even saw that being written on Quora that Justin is 1 of the 2 Maryan king's son from his Yavana's wife. Maybe the user said it was from the Bhavishya Puran. Well, I don't know for sure, nor can quote it, but it was definitely on Quora

Bhavishya Purana is a very late addition, probably in 18th or 19th century, and also Google translation from Sanskrit to English also varies. One translation says Chandragupta married Suluva , daughter of King of the city, another translation says he married a daughter of a Yavana king named Suluva. It's very ambiguous atleast for non Sanskrit reader.

The official translation by scholars is that Chandragupta was originated from Shakya Clan, he married a daughter of a Yavana ruler named Suluva of Paursa.

If this girl was daughter of Seleucus? Highly unlikely because Sanskrit word for Persia is Parsika not Paursa. Maybe a north western lower satrap he was and the girl would be mixed.

This woman probably succeeded Durdhara as Agramahishi after Durdhara's death as the verse says Chandragupta ruled with her as his queen.

Justin is a Roman name. Romans at time of Chandragupta had no physical or marital connection with him.

Megasthenes had mentioned Chandragupta had many sons but according to customs he would give them Indian names like Bindu gave Sushim despite born from Diana in the show. Antiochus was born from his Persian wife yet Seleucus gave him a Macedonian name.

You can say just how Durdhara and Nand Nandini are mixed similarly Helena and daughter of Suluva are also mixed and dumbos say he only had two wives when Mudrarakshasa, Mahavansh Tika, Megasthenes, buddhist legends of Burma and Arthashastra in very bold words say he had many queens and many children.😂🤣 Just because they didn't play any significant role in history their names got lost. It's not their fault they didn't have guts to rebel against Bindusara so that their names could be recorded 😂🤣

Just imagine why would he make anyone his Agramahishi if he didn't have other wives. There was no need to make someone Agramahishi if you only have her as his wife. Just call her Mahishi only then, why Agra? 😂 You know common sense is very uncommon and most people don't look at these minor details and prefer to accept whatever the crap entertainment media shows or writes 😂

Edited by NostalgiaLove - 8 months ago
NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: Yashikha16


I even saw that being written on Quora that Justin is 1 of the 2 Maryan king's son from his Yavana's wife. Maybe the user said it was from the Bhavishya Puran. Well, I don't know for sure, nor can quote it, but it was definitely on Quora

Speaking of Quora

https://www.quora.com/Is-Justin-the-son-of-Chandragupta-Maurya/answer/Jean-Summers-23?ch=15&oid=1477743688557673&share=2b9ac95c&srid=3rf5tZ&target_type=answer

https://www.quora.com/Is-Justin-the-son-of-Chandragupta-Maurya/answer/Chandralekha-47?ch=15&oid=1477743701177542&share=8a2f1243&srid=3rf5tZ&target_type=answer

Edited by NostalgiaLove - 8 months ago
mushat thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Jimmy Jab Games Season 8 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: chabalas

Let's be happy that we dint get another Hulk moment of Ashok lifting the cot with one hand and eating some random fruit with other hand smiley37

Aab Bindusara ke karabaas ke loha todega AShock smiley37

NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: mushat

Aab Bindusara ke karabaas ke loha todega AShock smiley37

https://youtube.com/shorts/gXzlI7HkHy0?si=txSEAqOTXap2SLlp

🤣😂

Word Count: 1

mushat thumbnail
Anniversary 9 Thumbnail Jimmy Jab Games Season 8 0 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 months ago

yeah same scenes with yeaaaah yeaaaah BGMsmiley37
NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: mushat

Aab Bindusara ke karabaas ke loha todega AShock smiley37

https://youtube.com/shorts/WLHG1LiCo1E?si=y3oFM_kKIffiVY8X

More accurate for the show 😂🤣

NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

https://youtube.com/shorts/jivVVj7OCY8?si=bWNjHCn5m-wPKlqC

Ashok should marry her instead, much better than marrying Karu 😂🤣

NostalgiaLove thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 0 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 0 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 months ago

Chandragupta and daughter of Suluva or Princess Suruva (forgotten queen of Chandragupta Maurya, mentioned in Bhavishya Puran) , chief queen after death of Durdhara. Her father was named Suluva who was Yavana king of Paursa (probably a city or Nagar). She probably would see Helena as a rival as both were Yavanas. They are often mixed aa one as Seleucus and Suluva sound very similar. 😂🤣🤌

Ashok boasted about feudatory kings giving daughters in marriage, Samudragupta also boasted about it in his Inscription which he inscribed in Ashok's pillar 🤣.😬🙄😒

image (16).jpg

Edited by NostalgiaLove - 8 months ago
Yashikha16 thumbnail
Anniversary 10 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 months ago

Originally posted by: NostalgiaLove

Bhavishya Purana is a very late addition, probably in 18th or 19th century, and also Google translation from Sanskrit to English also varies. One translation says Chandragupta married Suluva , daughter of King of the city, another translation says he married a daughter of a Yavana king named Suluva. It's very ambiguous atleast for non Sanskrit reader.

The official translation by scholars is that Chandragupta was originated from Shakya Clan, he married a daughter of a Yavana ruler named Suluva of Paursa.

If this girl was daughter of Seleucus? Highly unlikely because Sanskrit word for Persia is Parsika not Paursa. Maybe a north western lower satrap he was and the girl would be mixed.

This woman probably succeeded Durdhara as Agramahishi after Durdhara's death as the verse says Chandragupta ruled with her as his queen.

Justin is a Roman name. Romans at time of Chandragupta had no physical or marital connection with him.

Megasthenes had mentioned Chandragupta had many sons but according to customs he would give them Indian names like Bindu gave Sushim despite born from Diana in the show. Antiochus was born from his Persian wife yet Seleucus gave him a Macedonian name.

You can say just how Durdhara and Nand Nandini are mixed similarly Helena and daughter of Suluva are also mixed and dumbos say he only had two wives when Mudrarakshasa, Mahavansh Tika, Megasthenes, buddhist legends of Burma and Arthashastra in very bold words say he had many queens and many children.😂🤣 Just because they didn't play any significant role in history their names got lost. It's not their fault they didn't have guts to rebel against Bindusara so that their names could be recorded 😂🤣

Just imagine why would he make anyone his Agramahishi if he didn't have other wives. There was no need to make someone Agramahishi if you only have her as his wife. Just call her Mahishi only then, why Agra? 😂 You know common sense is very uncommon and most people don't look at these minor details and prefer to accept whatever the crap entertainment media shows or writes 😂


Are you a historian? If yes, and are asked to write or direct a historical show or play or movie, do it!

Top