Jai or Pia’s Fault? - Page 2

[

you r forgetting one thing;

bani wanted him to hate her and she did a fair job of convincing him.He did want to know the truth but bani didnt want to tell him.He s gulty of not confessing to her,that's all

i am not supporting anyone here .i am just putting things in perspective.

frankly my dear now i don't give a damn. The serial leaves me cold.

but again u r also forgetting one thing varun that JW was quite sure that there is some reason behind whatever bani was doing and even when massi fell ill she told him that whatever bani is doing is for benefit of JW then why he didn't believe massi and went to dubai with pia. why on earth only pia was the only person he took along, don't he had any other capable person to go and what was the point of taking pia when she working independently for his some other office. so i think jai was still attached to pia unconsciously and ONS was result of that.

anyways every one has his/her own beliefs and sorry if any of my comments u find offending.

swati

swati

how can u ask and mind u bani didnt even ask a person to keep faith in u when u go about systematically breaking their heart.
jai is a human not a god for heaven's sake.though i hate him for being such a namby pamby now and not a man enough to own up.
as far as being with pia is concerned, it could be that she was their in his subconscious.....all the more reason why he went ahead with the ons......it must have fleetingly ofcourse been very soothing for him to see his old flame crawling back to him especially after the woman whom he truly loved had spurnned him and did not want anything to do with him

and i have taken no offence,dear.Its good that we have such invigorating and passionate discussions about a fictional character 😆 😆

and though i do maintain that the ons was bani's fault but we must keep in mind that she did all this in good faith and with good intentions.Of course her modus operandi was not correct,as can be seen from the fall out.......in a way jai and bani have become a victim of circumstances and i guess that's what we call- LIFE

how could he have got to the bottom of the truth if bani doesn't want to tell him and has got all others to not tell him.
aren't you being a trifle harsh with jai.bani was the one calling the shots.even if she was doing all this for him,she should have gone about quietly and got the divorce.Jai was ready to give her the divorce without the theatrics she subjected him to.Her wanting the divorce did not break him.It was the way she treated him that broke him. This again shows jai's love for bani...what hold she hs\ad over him..how vulnerable he was where she was concerned.when pia left him ,he was plain angry but bani shattered him emotionally.....he might have been stronger etc etc...but he wasn't .....what bani did to him he couldn't handle....

Originally posted by: varun261969

how could he have got to the bottom of the truth if bani doesn't want to tell him and has got all others to not tell him.
aren't you being a trifle harsh with jai.bani was the one calling the shots.even if she was doing all this for him,she should have gone about quietly and got the divorce.Jai was ready to give her the divorce without the theatrics she subjected him to.Her wanting the divorce did not break him.It was the way she treated him that broke him. This again shows jai's love for bani...what hold she hs\ad over him..how vulnerable he was where she was concerned.when pia left him ,he was plain angry but bani shattered him emotionally.....he might have been stronger etc etc...but he wasn't .....what bani did to him he couldn't handle....

i think the reason for jai not finding the truth was that jai is 40+ and is a buddha now and woh sathiya gaya hai. that's why he was not to find and he has no brain cells left to think about anything. it is high time JW shld die and we can have a duplicate of him who is somewhat younger for bani.

as far as bani not telling him the truth, the reason behind this was that she just don't want to hurt his feelings and she was of the view that he killed her mother and she was leaving him and don't want him to be heart broken because of deeds of his family. the other reason for bani not telling him was that bani was quite immature and really young as compared to experienced JW so i can easily forgive bani for her deeds, but whatever jai has done can never be forgiven.

swati

Originally posted by: swatinarang

i think the reason for jai not finding the truth was that jai is 40+ and is a buddha now and woh sathiya gaya hai. that's why he was not to find and he has no brain cells left to think about anything. it is high time JW shld die and we can have a duplicate of him who is somewhat younger for bani.

as far as bani not telling him the truth, the reason behind this was that she just don't want to hurt his feelings and she was of the view that he killed her mother and she was leaving him and don't want him to be heart broken because of deeds of his family. the other reason for bani not telling him was that bani was quite immature and really young as compared to experienced JW so i can easily forgive bani for her deeds, but whatever jai has done can never be forgiven.

swati

well in a way you're right .what 40 year old man can handle a hyper active 23 year old detective-actress(since she was acting for jai)-miss know it all all rolled into one..

I'm just surprised jai didnt have a heart attack earlier on😆😆

swati ,we'll agree to disagree😆

well in a way you're right .what 40 year old man can handle a hyper active 23 year old detective-actress(since she was acting for jai)-miss know it all all rolled into one..

I'm just surprised jai didnt have a heart attack earlier on😆😆

swati ,we'll agree to disagree😆

well varun i can say jasoosi is in dixit's blood first it was bani and now rano who followed pia and came to know about the truth and some how jasoosi is raashi's blood as she was the person who motivated bani to start her jasoosi. But i think rano is a better detective than bani.

but let me tell u that bani was also responsible for ONS if on that day stupid bani may not have saved JW from that gunner this ONS may not have happened at all with no JW in picture. so i also agree with u that bani is responsible for ONS.😉

and ya of course we will agree to disagree and it was a really a nice discussion.

swati