Director's Cut - October 22, 2012

GirlOfFire thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Welcome to another edition of Director's Cut


"What is important is to spread confusion, not eliminate it"
- Salvador Dal


Usually its my friend, Ruby (redwine1 to the uninitiated) who does a Pause-Release to explain how a shot is being taken or the meaning of a shot. Now I'm not a director nor do I pretend to be one. But today's episode left me with one feeling.



What puzzled me about today's episode is almost the entire cast. In almost every sequence I found one or more characters' expression puzzling - because their reactions are so illogical. With perhaps the exception of Aarav and Khushi and the doctor.

Not just the reactions, but the little events that occured throughout the episode left me scratching my head.

Firstly, the doctor comes to see Aarav. A little boy has fainted. He opens his bag and has the EXACT medication that little Aarav needs. He does not ask the people standing around if the little one is allergic to anything, or if the little one has a pre-existing condition. Just takes out a bottle and voila! slams it in.

Notice all the adults around. Each and everyone is way OTT in their expressions. Really? Are all adults that uber-sensitive to injections that not even one of them allows him to hold their hand while he gets a shot?

Then comes Mami's killer dialog - the child eats, walks and talks like ASR. And everybody instead of looking puzzled, giggle and smile sweetly. Now, what kind of reaction is that? Khushi is obviously getting worried, but do the adults think that ASR was such a shudh person that he did not have sexual relationships before? Isn't this the same ASR that wanted to live with his girlfriend Lavanya? So why would a small smidgeon of doubt not be there in their minds also? I would have preferred an uneasy look on Anjali's and Nani's face, as well as Payal's. THIS would have been the right reaction.

Let's move on..

Arnav and Sheetal come in. Sheetal runs to her son, obviously worried about him. And its also obvious she wants to get the heck out of the house as soon as possible. She thanks Khushi prettily, she's obviously uncomfortable around the wife. Doesn't greet anyone, no manners. What were the script/dialog writers thinking? I find her expressions very hard to read, and so far her character is still under wraps so I'll leave that for now.

Arnav goes to the garden to stop little Aarav and finds he has things in common with him. The gardening. A little boy giving a tip on roses to someone who's main solace was gardening all these days. Especially since Arnav has been tending his MOTHER's rose garden all these years. So I am left scratching my head. Did he not know tea-leaves are good for roses - that's a pretty basic tip, right? Again, I'm not a gardener and even I knew it. Ah well.

Mami comments on how they look like father and son. This is a big one. If I were the director, there should have been shock on the faces of at least Nani and Anjali and puzzlement on Payal's and perhaps a little bit of worry. Could it be?

The fact that the entire hen coop is unaware of the possibility of its being Arnav's son is just too much to handle.

For a detailed analysis of the matches between Arnav and Aarav, please head down to Redwine1's post. All I will say is, all of those traits are TAUGHT behavior, not a single one is GENETIC. So, why rub it in our faces?

Coming to Arnav, he is mostly wooden today. I found his expressions bland to say the least. The one scene where he rocked is when he starts naming his fictitious girlfriends. So much for not liking girls! Arnav bitwa, college se hi hotwa, hunh? Of course, like a lot of people, I was left scratching my head about his expression in the hug. But like I said, Barun has always been uptight in the vertical hugs, much better in the horizontal ones. 😳

I also liked his honesty with Khushi. That part of it is completely in character and in line with his relationship with her. He has never been anything but completely honest with her since they acknowledged their love. I loved Khushi here too.

Another head scratcher from little Aarav: He tells his mother - 'Please don't tell anyone that I fainted.' I am wondering who or who all this 'ANYONE' is. And if there is an 'ANYONE' then why was the child left alone, not once but twice?

Now for the serious part.

In any relationship, its very hard to deal with a partner's ex - wife, girlfriend, whatever. Relationships get strained and marriages break up for these reasons. On top of that, to be confronted with a child that is possibly your partner's is very hard to take for any woman, no matter how strong. It underlines the fact that your partner once had the same intimate relations with another woman that he had with you. It doesn't matter that the past is in the past. What matters is that on a daily basis you have to deal with that knowledge that you were not the first in his life. Even if a man swears up and down that he is in love with you, there will always be the feeling that there is a part of his past that you will never be able to share. It's a devastating feeling for most women.

The one thing about IPK that has always bothered me, as it has with a lot of readers on this thread is the trivialization of issues that have enormous social impact - suicide, abortion, miscarriage, infidelity, adultery and now the possibility of an illegitimate child. We understand that these are devices in the story and serve as wheels to take the story from point A to point B. However, these are also sensitive issues, and while I do not want to sound like a rabid feminist - please give these issues the due respect they deserve.

And finally a little bit of muskaan (thanks, Ritu for your keen ears)
Did anyone notice that Chotey has now officially become BADA PACKET?? 😛

And oh, By the Way - if you missed any of our previous threads, you can find them in



[/NOCOPY]



Edited by GirlOfFire - 13 years ago


DO NOT COPY THIS POST AS THIS IS EXCLUSIVE TO INDIA FORUMS


Created

Last reply

Replies

63

Views

12.8k

Users

35

Likes

618

Frequent Posters

redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
WELCOME TO GUL'S TUTORIALS


gul Khan's tutorials a special 10 pointer rapid learning guide

Since TAM has taken a break from helping Gul put her YO YO TRP theory into action .. our esteemed producer has shifted her lens to acquire more knowledge .. of the scientific kinds ..

So heres .. Guls Khan's guide to learning .. Genetic mapping of hereditary traits .. through a ten pointer ...

if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck.. it must be WHAT THE F**K !!!!!

Now if u were doing genetic mapping of hereditary traits .. heres what u must look for ..
  • The said progeny shud sport completely same hairstyle as the specimen parent .. even down to the Yuckky gel therapy
  • The said progeny shud have exact same dressing style as the specimen parent .. infact .. the colours shud also match .. if the clothes look like papa gap & kid gap .. then heres ur match.
  • The said progeny shud have exact same walking style like the specimen parent .. if it walks like the . then what the ..
  • The said progeny shud have exact same .. eating habits like specimen parent .. that it shud like .. a heavily buttered toast .. & a glass of juice ..which is full of glucose .. a must for any diabetic patient .
  • The said progeny shud have exact same mannerisms like the specimen parent .. like they shud be exclaiming the same wonderours expression "WHAT THE"
  • The said progeny shud also have the same diction & voice modulation like the specimen parent .. like mumbling is very important genetic trait passed down generation after generation
  • The said progeny shud have the exact same leisure habits like the specimen parent .. like if the parent likes to garden .. then the child shud be more knowledgeable & accomplished at the same .. this is another very highly matched genetic trait .. also the progeny & specimen parent shud share the same passion for business news story .. the child shud be addicted to profit & loss of companies .. even if would have trouble spelling balance sheet .. there thats a Fabulously close match
  • The said progeny shud have an abhorrence for girl child like the specimen parent .. he shud be wary of "KIDS" around him even though he is a kid .. the clear hint to this will be that the kid does not go to school but loiters around toy shops when his mother is out of house
  • The said progeny shud have be an atheist like the specimen parent .. this is another very important character trait .. known to be passed on from generations to generations .. normally from male parent to male heir .. this one skips the women of the gene pool completely
  • The said progeny .. shud excatly like the male specimen parent .. find the lady of the hour "khushi" crazy but cute ...
Now if the above traits match .. whoa . u got ur self a kid .. sorry .. the specimen parent got itself a kid ..


A serious issue of child out of wedlock .. once again triviallised .. once again made into a joking matter by our esteemed writers .. one wonders .. if this was how u showed a match between a child & a parent ..

Ques time dear team IPK ..

1. To Writer : do u seriously want to tell us .. this is the creative research u came up with to sow a seed of doubt into the lady of the hours mind .. wudnt .. just the fact that Sheetal . had a past with Arnav .. she is unmarried with a kid .. who looks just like Arnav .. wud that not have sufficed .. how do u expect .. similarity in gardening to be taken as a genetic trait passed on thru father to son .. r u not now .. the victim of ur own clever planing .. have u not LET OUT THE PLOT BY UR OWN SELF .. ???

2. To the Director : clearly .. Arshad Khan is shooting for Qabool hai .. as our very own esteemed producer Gul khan has mentioned .. now .. what shocks me is how come Arshad Khan's name still appears on credits ?? are u okay mr. khan to lend ur name to such extremely shoddy piece of creative work??

3. To the Channel : clearly there is a rocking ship on ur docks .. wud u like to clean ur docks .. & make the ship sail without any problems .. or u r happy with all the debris lying on the waterfront ?? if Arshad is doing qabool hai .. then who is directing IPK ?? & why is arshad's name still appearing on the credits .. now my question to u .. is why dont u clean up ur credits line .. why not remove all the honarary names which are nowhere associated with the show ..

4. To the Production House : sincerely wish u all the best for ur new venture .. awaiting ur interview directing us to watch the same .. like u did in the past .. but this time around ... hopefully u realise the scope of ur current serial is the biggest u have ever reached .. more people are in love with this .. a huge loyal base .. hopefully u will not alienate this base of people .. from never watching ur shows .. since after a point ur shows seems to prefer the Bizarre form of story telling


________________________________________________________________________



This is the first time on IPK .. i felt the entire creative team was on holiday while planning the execution of this track .. the story idea as always is perfect .. yes this is logical story line progression .. but screenplay ... is at its worse ever .. cant even begin to say how bad the direction of the episode was ..

will direct u to a scene tonite .. for me .. this was the day that for the first time i closed the television screen before i watched the entire episode ..





please for a moment pause on the long awaited LONG HUG between Arnav & Khushi .. now if any one of u cud pls tell me .. what Barun's expressions meant in that HUG .. wud seriously appreciate it .. have asked Chowna to gimme a uncut version of the same .. will put it up .. as soon as i get it ..

To me he looked like he was planning his date schedule in his mind .. i need to wrap up here .. run for dubbing of my film .. then run from there go for dance practise .. oh god need to squeeze some time for my gyming as well .. oh god .. when do i get time shave ??

GUD NITE .. & yea .. cant believe i am still saying this .. but yes . CU at the IPKS ..


ENJOY THE EPISODE


[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eY1EERd1gtM&feature=youtu.be[/YOUTUBE]


THE HUG UNCUT

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DowloHjtCKo&feature=youtu.be[/YOUTUBE]

PICTURE COURTESY : FB
THE LINES IN RED COURTESY : GIRLOFFIRE
VIDEO COURTESY :

Edited by redwine1 - 13 years ago
Lizzy2012 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
The Return of coincidences -


Inbestigation Karega Padi



Hey DM ,Thought it was only La ...suddenly this sheetal has sprung up from somewhere? How many saheliyaan did ArnavJi have and how many are out to ...😉😛Raksha Karna DM


***********************************************************************************************************************
Today for me was the continuation of the Friday episode's plot about planting a thought that aarav might be arnav's son in Khushi's mind..

How did this idea get placed and crystallised in Khushi's mind...I Talk ASR,Walk ASR,Garden ASR,Eat ASR,Smirk ASR,hate ASr LIke.etc etc..What The
And not the least get all the members of the Ashantivan to admit that Aarav does all the above in ASR isstyle befitting ASR's chotey..To put in Mami's language..Bada Packetwa jaisan hain chota packetwa..bilkul same to same ...secondly ,ASR's dislike of kids played on and aarav's breakage of this barrier in ASR put in the limelight again by the members of the Ashanthivan..another Point To be noted is that of Sheetal's reluctance to stay for long at the Raizadas.. what a clichd route to take my lovely writers and creative team...

Baccah ka coincidence part over , the aspersion has been cast and the implications firmly entrenched in khushi's mind..what next???????????Khushi's unease over the entire Happenings fuels her" inbestigation"...Hey Devi maiyya..Did Khushi acquire a penchant for inbestigation when she in came in contact with PDA-prithvi detective agency or is it The bond mami's influence at work..Bhatever that is..Neber phear when Khushi's mind starts ticking..we gets Arnav's clear answers to Khushi's vague questions..what Khushi wants to question is the similarities between the Aarav and aarnav..what Khushi wants to question is the kind Of relationship that sheetal and ASR shared..what Khushi wants is a reassurance about his relationship with Sheetal..but the truth that Sheetal was His ex girlfriend and that ASR had "uncomplicated" "unemotional" relationships with girls before she taught him about love drags Khushi's brains in to her "jalebi Bai "mode..on the surface she is shooing away her worries with his reassurances but deeper doubts plague her leaving her unsatisfied..

The creatives team seems to be playing on the " wife "sentiment of the female audiences..the Jealousy and Unease of the "mature"wife over the husband's past that too if it is in the form of an illegitimate child..again let me say that I am able to visualise the future of this plot..it would be to bring in Passion fuelled by Jealousy in Arhi's life,it would be to strengthen the "trust"quotient in their Marriage,it would serve as a Catalyst in the growth of their love..BUT the execution seems to have Failed the plot till date..no one could see the love in the hug today,no one could see the reassurance in the Rabba ve tunes..all one could see was the clichd boring plot a la ekta style meandering...


Coming to sheetal's role..It seems so similar to the shyam's character..initially coming across as a very decent person who ingratiates herself or himself with Khushi's Family...after the character establishment they start going on establishing their Agenda..so the plot is set in layers ..as the layers starts to peel the audiences start realising the true face of the character ..the unveiling of intent takes places in stages... we have just touched the tip of the iceberg with sheetal ...till date she has come across as a person who is uneasy with ASR because of her past.she tries to avoid him or is it really so???????????????we can just wait watch as the plot unfolds..

Going by the past history of IPK, i would safely assume sheetal and
aarav will seem like a threat to Arhi Fairytale ...BUT DM places these hurdles in front of these two to give their union so much of strength that no cosmic or human force would be able separate them..

That's it from me today..Happy reading till we meet tomorrow





Edited by Lizzy2012 - 13 years ago
meghavn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Now this is/was Rabba Vey's




But what was this?


Edited by meghavn - 13 years ago
chowna thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Dear DC friends

This is my last pictorial post for some time

i will be on and off in the forum for the month
I should be back by Nov 20th

I would be on the move that makes it very difficult to dedicate time
towards pictures

I would be still uploading the eps and uncuts but pictures
if i get time would post them
if not then sorry

todays eps in pic



The more and more she sees him the more she is convinced




no doubt all the sheetal and all those u mentioned form the past want u you are droolworthy





Now Khushi turn to say this image is stuck in my head

Mamiji u just added more to the fire thats in khushi's head




Mr Raizada you were truthful but the interpretation of this by yours truely one and only will be something to wait and watch






Precap welcome back where were you lost last week


How well does a husband know his wofe he know what she is thinking
keep on going as the storm is watiing to be unleashed
u will have to figure out whats bothering her




This sceen woudl be intresting to watch in the future how it pans out

in the sceen if u notice

khushi is at one side where sheetal is with the kid the rest of the family is in between and nani is alone standing while Arnav is left alone



I will leave you all with this



uncut

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29A7RfNsUtc
&feature=youtu.be[/YOUTUBE]
Edited by chowna - 13 years ago
bidz thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Before the episode aired, I wanted to know from Arnav the status of his relationship with Sheetal. He didn't disappoint me. His response was as expected. They were "seeing" or "dating" each other, and soon, they (he) realized that they were not in love and (he) broke up.

I do not believe that Arnav was in a physical relationship with her at all. There were quite a few pointers towards this fact. First, the way Arnav said it was way too casual. Had he slept with her, even if it held no meaning for him, knowing the depth of his character, he would have mentioned about this to Khushi. To me the way he said it, implied that they were both bored, had nothing better to do, decided to hook up, give it a name (gf-bf), as that sounds cool and fashionable at that age, and then called it quits as they (he) soon realized that the relationship had no future/meaning.

Arnav has never been attracted to the likes of Sheetal or Lavanya. While the women have always been attracted to him, his status, and his money, he has cared two hoots about them. I think this is the same Lavanya story repeated with Sheetal, except that, then, Khushi was not in the picture. So, he didn't have to use Sheetal like he used lavanya to keep Khushi at bay. He was much older when he dated Lavanya, so in all likelihood, whatever "relationship" he had with Lavanya was a little bit more mature compared to Sheetal.

I am afraid he broke Sheetal's heart, the same way he broke Lavanya's. Fortunately for Lavanya, Khushi had changed her for the better, hence, she was able to leave gracefully. Unfortunately for Sheetal (and for us), that seems not to be the case.

Sheetal's character intrigued me today. So here is the first peak into her character analysis-

She seems to be an introvert, and is not able to express her feelings too easily. She also seems to have a very big ego. Couple of things sounded really strange to my ears.

One, when Anjali mentioned how come she didn't know her, she mentioned very strangely that they just took one class together. For some reason, Sheetal doesn't want Anjali to know of her past relationship with Arnav. Not at this point at least. She did try to hush up the matter rather quickly. Is it her ego preventing her from acknowledging anything more here?

Two, she told Khushi that she and Arnav weren't good friends. Arnav found it strange that she said that. I think deep down she resents Arnav for the way he treated her, and therefore refuses to acknowledge her past relationship with him. Had she been as okay as him, she would have laughed it off and moved on. My gut is that she is obsessively in love with Arnav, at the same time, resents him for dumping her. To me, she is behaving like a "scorned" lover. Her "ego" prevented her from telling Arnav what she actually felt about him when he rejected her, and she went along with him when he said that they probably didn't suit together.

I found the child's antics a bit too OTT. I know they want to make the kid look very similar to Arnav, but I think they are going a bit too far with it. The family and the audience have both got it. Please don't rub it in more CVs. It is quite distasteful for the nerves.

An average episode overall. Not bad for a Monday!

Edited by bidz - 13 years ago
mahamluvsbs thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
arn't they so damn cuteee
Edited by mahamluvsbs - 13 years ago
coolgal270 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
An episode which plants a seed of doubt in Khushi's mind, a uncomfortable thought, fear and restlessness, and it triggers some thinking from her end ...The similarities are far too many to be called as coincidences anymore!! And she is just realizing that...


Some thoughts to ponder:

  • The child is calm and composed while being administered with injection..but the elder ladies surrounding him are in pain..Khushi the most as she visibly flinches..Liked that...seemed natural to me..

  • Manorma Mami innocently compares him to be like Arnav's child and makes Khushi anxious...She is already thinking in those lines and is getting a little worried by all this. For her, it is like "its just not me, even they see many many similarities between the two"..

  • I would like to see how far the CVs will go and show the "resemblance" between the two ASRs..I am now starting to get bored..but i get it, its important for the storyline they are weaving..So I will just wait patiently.

  • Aarav's "Main behosh hi accha tha " to khushi was nicely done by the kid...he has started growing on me. I really find him adorable!!😊

  • Ok..When has Arnav asked khushi for "Toast and Juice"?..I missed it I think because I couldn't remember saying him that ever!

  • Sheetal enters along with Arnav, Goes straight to her son and comforts him and herself..I get it...But after that, She completely forgets she is in someone's house, there are elders around her and she does not greet anyone.. I get her urgency to see her son..Its ok...but after that is done, the least she can do is greet people in the house...
    I dont know why but this lack of mannerism grates on my nerves...A thank you to Khushi is 👍🏼...but not acknowledging and greeting everybody else in the house, esp elders 👎🏼..Dont know if the character is like that or is it a miss while directing...

  • Itna chota baccha and that much knowledge on plants?..😕...Arnav's expressions mirrored mine 😆

  • Anjali asks "Aap Arnav ke saath college mein thi na, Lekin humein kaise nahin pata"??
    And Sheetal replies
    "Hum bas ek hi class mein they"..
    I am conphused...how does that answer Anjali's question??😕😕..Does it mean that they were classmates in just one subject and that's what she means when she says "hum ek hi class mein they"??

  • Aarav's "Bye" is recipricated by Arnav with a smile ...Khushi is surprised, Anjali is impressed and Arnav looks shell shocked..😆...I liked Barun here...I mean more than the usual...😆

  • Loved the last segment...Khushi is little troubled...And she knows the only one who can ease her mind is Arnav...She approaches him carefully, almost gently...And talks about Sheetal!! She is not trying to pry and find out about his past..She just wants to know genuinely about the lady who is her hubby's old friend..Normal curiosity, thats all...
    But she gets a shock when she learns that she was more than a friend, even if it was only for briefest period of time..

    I liked both the actions/reactions of Arnav and Khushi..For khushi it is big deal..oh yes..it is...But for Arnav, it is nothing..coz from his end, he was not into it that much..And He honestly tells her that...that he had even forgotten about all that and only remembered when he saw her...And thats why he didnt even tell Khushi before because there was nothing to tell...

    And here,Khushi has probably always thought Lavanya to be the first woman in Arnav's life and thus she is visibly shocked...and understandably upset...Also from her point of view, she is right when she says why he didnt tell her before..

  • Now she is anxious to know the names of every women who has been part of his life..
    He jests and teases her.,..and she falls into the trap...but then she realizes this and is overcome by relief!! Loved Loved the fact that she pushes him,hit him...and he catches her hands to ward off her strikes...😳😃 **the guesthouse scene, anyone??**😛..This is the Feisty pair we all love, isn't it...😆

    He hugs her to tell her it is only she who matters, who showed him what love is..before that, it was all inconsequential!!😳


  • Although he passed the "I had so many GFs" thing , off as a joke, I think he was not joking...And I have no problem with that...It makes the character more "Real" to me.. Only thing is,he knows this subject is distressing to his dear wife...He knows the gentle heart that resides in her and things like this, these past relations, can cause her pain...And I think somewhere in the back of his mind, he is worried about this...He hugs her to comfort both of them...Mainly her but slightly himself as well...

  • He tells Khushi that Sheetal is a single mother and that has caused a fervor in her heart!!
    Lets see how she takes it further and eases her doubt!!

  • Precap: Loved it...And Bankelal is something that only Khushi can come up with 😆!!
    I love the setting!!...Both of them relaxed, near the poolside...just talking to each other at the end of the day..without the worldly tensions...The only things that matter are them, their love, their life and things happening around them.. A very realistic scene...and for that very reason, I already love it...but will write more on it tomorrow..
    BTW, I really like the nigh-suit of khushi..its suits Sanaya!! 😊..and what to say about Barun and the way he looks in that T-shirt!!😳

  • I really liked Sanaya today..Her expressions were very good...Calm, composed from outside, but turbulent within!!😊
If this track is handled with proper execution, we will have great episodes ahead!! Already the pace is building up and there is curiosity to know what will happen next.. I just hope they dont loose out on the execution part...that is the thing I am worried about!! Rest, I Hope, I am going to enjoy!!


Love, Sumi
Edited by coolgal270 - 13 years ago
Tia.0 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
I don't have much to say about today's episode. Except a few points.

1. Arnav told Khushi that he forgot about Sheetal and only remembered when he saw her that he was seeing her in college. But when he did remember her, then the honest thing would have been telling Khushi right away to avoid future misunderstandings. Those who berated Khushi for hiding Shyam's truth from Arnav even though she was not even in a relationship with him, should now berate ASR for the same reason.

2. If Arnav appoints Sheetal in his office, it will be highly unethical not to mention inappropriate because of their past history. I'm sure Arnav won't like it if Khushi appoints her ex (assume she had one) as chef in Shaantivan considering she spends most of her time in kitchen like Arnav spends in office.

3. There is also the uncomfortable factor. Sheetal may not mean anything to him, but he should know that it isn't that easy to forget past. If it was, he would have forgotten his and move on way before. Now that he is married, he needs to think about his wife's comfort level. Just because she liked La who was one of his ex, does not mean she needs to be comfortable with whichever ex pops up in his personal or professional life. It's his responsibility to keep his past where it belongs - far away from his present and future.
caltoon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Reserved...updated.

This take is going to encompass the last three episodes (Thursday, Friday and Monday) ' they kind of flow together and, in a way, I'm glad I got to watch all three in one shot due to all the traveling I did the last weekend. The picture is becoming a little clearer and a few things that had been kind of tingling at the back of my mind suddenly made a little more sense.

Overall, I liked all three episodes though the scenes between Khushi and Aarav in the toy shop were a tad stretched for me. I felt Monday's was the best episode in terms of presentation and pacing. I'm constantly surprised that the team that gave us today's episode also managed to give us last Wednesday's sloppy and badly executed one ' I guess it's all part of our show's charm and we need to learn to take it in stride and move on when it happens. Knowing there is the possibility of a rainbow around the corner seems to work in the show's favour 😊

Let me first talk a little about the equation between Arnv and Khushi post re-marriage. I've loved all their interactions (barring a few scenes of Khushi in the cinema hall which were frankly OTT and way too unrealistic for me). Arnav Singh Raizada has been a huge revelation for me since the re-marriage. Don't get me wrong - he is still completely true to character and has not changed in any fundamental way but he has turned out to be a lot more patient, easy going, laidback and indulgent with Khushi as a husband. We have never before been privileged to see how ASR would behave in a relationship where his heart was involved - now we know. I love how he indulges Khushi (so quick to give in to taking her to a Hindi film as opposed to the Derby or even an English film), how he takes all her crazy antics in stride (his reaction when she did her Hollywood actress act for him in the presentation room ' he scolded her quite mildly for him and then immediately melted once he realized what her intentions were and proceeded to flirt with her), how he unabashedly enjoys her childish and adorable ways (watching her replay the bashing she supposedly gave the goons with the sabzi with a smile in his eyes and his expression when she gave the jagruk nari speech to his family and preened at Anjali assuring NK that he would be safe with Khushi at the sabzi mandi), how much he appreciates every little thing that Khushi does for him (the breakfast in bed and the candle she lit with the jalebis he'd worked so hard to make as an apology for her), how he un-selfconsciously allows the little boy in him to peep out in her presence (I was upset today and decided to do what you do when you're upset and Khushi, where is my gift? I hope you didn't forget it in your gussa) and how openly he shows his love for her and his appreciation at having her in his life. He does get justifiably angry when Khushi manages to hit his sore spots (the possibility of losing her due to how she always throws herself into whatever fray is happening around her and takes impulsive risks without thinking of the consequences) and hurt when he feels that she does not understand the only expectation that he has of her (not wishing him or fussing over him on his birthday or wanting to spend time exclusively with him) but he is very reasonable even in his anger and hurt (none of the biting cutting words that he used to such devastating effect in his previous interactions with her) and quick to calm down once he's gotten the message across and realizes how contrite she is. I also love how he never sulks quietly but is forthright with her about his disappointment, hurt or expectation and then moves on without holding any grudges ' a quality in a partner absolutely worth its value in gold as anyone who's experienced a relationship will agree with me 😆 He is the first one to reach out and try to resolve the issue when they have a disagreement even when he knows he is not the one at fault - again, a beautiful quality that tells us so much about ASR and how much he loves his Khushi.

Moving onto Khushi ' she has also been a revelation for me post re-marriage. I'm glad that she is still very much her own person and hasn't reverted to playing the traditional role of a rich man's indulged wife. She is very much the old Khushi but freed of shackles and worries ' all the obstacles to a bright and happy future with the man she loves and who loves her back have been cleared. Yet, I sense a disquiet in her, almost a hidden and probably a subconscious one that leads to her acting out in her own unique way. Just like she cannot stay quiet for too long since she feels the stillness of the world around her, she seems to not be able to be still and just spend some time alone with her husband who just wants to shower her with some attention ' it is almost as if she dare not take even a small break from her frenetic pace of activities or her hidden fear will rise to the surface and she will not be able to shove it down and move on. This is something that I've been sensing for a while now ' it was kept in check while there were big issues to deal with like revealing Shyam to Anjali and being a pillar of strength to Arnav as they went through the process of outing Shyam.

This subconscious disquiet I sense in her has nothing to do with not understanding ASR's expectations of their relationship. She may not have a good handle on that yet but, on the other hand, she does understand him at his core - his insecurities, his weaknesses, the full effect of the past on him, his strength and his heart (once she calmed down in his mother's garden, she was quick to reassure him that she wasn't going anywhere ' she understood the essential nature of his anger and worry very well and she's always known exactly how to reassure him and make him feel better ' a fact, he openly acknowledged to her the night of their wedding). My take on this is that she will have a lifetime to find out, understand and give him what he expects of their relationship (it will come with experience) but her understanding of the complex and complicated man that ASR is, is priceless ' it is something that has always come instinctively to her, something that she didn't need to learn and something that possibly cannot be learned. So, why does Khushi act up so much with Arnav? Why does the Khushi who is able to empathize so much with complete strangers not allow the man she loves so much any leeway with her? At first, I thought it was a feeling of security ' of knowing that you were loved back immensely and unconditionally. We have never during the lifetime of the show ever seen anyone indulge Khushi this much or even have any circumstances where Khushi felt the complete freedom to be demanding in any way. She was always dealing with issues ' the aftermath of coming to Delhi due to the revelation of the fashion show tapes, being the only breadwinner for the family, trying to hold the family together while dealing with her own private demons after Babuji's attack, dealing silently with ASR's rejections and the thought of marriage to Shyam, Shyam's truth and the decision to keep it from the Raizadas while dealing with the repercussions of Payal being married into the very same family that they'd decided to keep Shyam's dirty secret from, the forced marriage and its repercussions on her family, ASR's family and the equation with ASR, dealing with Shyam's unwanted attentions, ASR's accusations about Shyam and his leaving for London and finally, his kidnapping and her struggle to bring him home safely while not being able to let anyone know about the truth. She tends to take on the burdens of her loved ones on her own shoulders and has never felt completely free to do as she likes and nor has there been anyone who indulges her like ASR ' maybe her Babuji did when he was well and we've been given some hints about it though probably not to the extent that ASR does. Being a wife and a much loved one at that should have opened the world out to Khushi ' instead, we see her indulging in very un-Khushi like tantrums that Arnav then indulges by trying to pacify her with a combination of his signature teasing, flirting, challenging and newly added ones of reasoning with her and showing her his love for her by his actions ' be it going to the effort of making jalebis for her or trussing her up and taking her to his mother's garden and bowing his head in respect and letting her know how special she is and how he think she is a much better person than him. I've been thinking about this since this aspect of Khushi has been played out on our screens and it finally struck me that perhaps I'd been reading it worng ' it is not security in Arnav's love that makes her behave like this, it is the very opposite ' her insecurity in his love, in the extent of his feelings for her or more precisely, in the permanence of his feelings for her. She is not calculating or manipulative but is subconsciously testing the boundaries of their relationship ' almost as if to see what she can get way with when it comes to Arnav and at what point will he explode and revert back to the shaitaan from the raajkumar. It's possible Arnav understands this and this is his way of letting her know he is going nowhere and his feelings for her will not be affected no matter what - not sure of this bit from Arnav..will need to watch it play out.

To understand this, we need to take a look at the entire relationship between Arnav and Khushi from Khushi's point of view. It starts with Arnav saying cutting and wounding words to Khushi, usually unfair ones at that, and that too while his eyes and his body language are at odds with his words and behaviour. Then he eventually softens up and uses the strong physical attraction that exists between them (here too, he is at an advantage since he can identify the physical attraction between them for what it is while Khushi is just unnerved and unable to give a name to their sizzling chemistry) to draw her to him and finally when she is about to succumb/realize that there is something between them, he rejects her and usually does so very cruelly - ASR is busy trying to convince himself more than her that there is nothing between them'that there cannot be but that is something that she doesn't understand or see ' all she sees is a man rejecting her after drawing her closer to him. Khushi then goes into her shell, internalizes her pain and comes back out stronger and determined to avoid ASR but ASR is unable to let go off her and misses no opportunity to say biting things when he does meet her. Things are terrible between them until a chance opportunity changes the dynamics of their relationship and they eventually get back at an even keel - a volatile one where even a wrong word could set fire to a conflagration but still a temporary truce of sorts. Then, the whole vicious cycle repeats itself. This happened when they first met and culminated in the Diwali missed kiss, where ASR then runs off like the hounds of hell are after him and impulsively declares in front of the the family and crowd that he wants to marry Lavanya all the while watching Khushi's reaction to his announcement and then finally and devastatingly rejects her with his words on the verandah of her house when she runs after him to thank him for bringing her purse back. Khushi is devastated and tries to move on after making some very painful decisions and then is gobsmacked at his reaction to her news of being enagaged. She asks him very poignantly ' aap, kya chahte hai humse? Am I not already giving you what you asked me for...I have made my peace with it..so why are you behaving this way. ASR goes berserk and we see the cruel side of him all roiled up with jealousy and unhappiness and trying to make her admit farak padta hai which he thankfully stops when he realizes what he is doing to her and himself in his mad rage but not before before planting some substantial wounds on Khushi. Things cool down while they work together to get Payal and Akash together and he breaks up with Lavanya. Then, the advent of NK, makes ASR repeat the entire vicious cycle. He says cutting things to her in his jealousy, regrets it, does all the running after her using the substantial physical attraction they share (my husband very memorably stated during this phase, that ASR ran after Khushi like a sexy puppy dog) and right when she is finally brought to believe that he has some feelings for her, she is faced with his ruthless blackmail and the humiliating demand for a temporary six month marriage. My heart broke for Khushi when she covered her face with her hands and cried after she accepted his demands. Then followed the marriage and Khushi's abandonment by her family and the alienation from his family while from Khushi's perspective, ASR's life continued as previously with a few minor wrinkles. The wounding and hurtful behaviour from ASR and their fights continued until Khushi made a resolve to try and get out of the marriage by irritating ASR. Things calmed down a little but ASR's hot and cold behaviour towards her continued ' holi and the aftermath, Heer Ranjha and the aftermath and finally living in the Gupta house where Khushi didn't know whether she was coming or going with his constant cycle of softening towards her and then pushing her away from him. The attempted suicide (which is the only thing in the entire show that I just couldn't swallow apart from Khushi bringing back Shyam back for Anjali) would have made a little more sense if they showed Khushi driven to it by the constant cycle of rejection and hurt. We notice that every time ASR rejects Khushi, he has to work that much harder next time to convince her to that he is truly softening towards her. That kind of repeated rejection does something to a woman's psyche ' any woman but especially one that is barely even starting to comprehend what her feelings for ASR might mean. That is why Khushi kept attempting to leave ASR for Di, for his own happiness, for his family's happiness...in fact, for all sort of assorted reasons ' at some level, she didn't want to wait for the cycle to end and wanted to remove herself from further rejection. It was partly responsible for her not believing that their marriage was complete, not wanting to take their relationship any further and running away from his physical advances. ASR, at some level, does understand that and verbalized it to some extent on their bachelor party night. I'm one of the minority that believe that they just kissed that night and made out a little but didn't go all the way because ASR was very aware of his treatment of her in the past and Khushi's belief system and would never have asked that of her, especially since he knew how hard it had been for him to get her to finally trust him. Also, asking for it one night before the marriage he worked so hard to give her made absolutely no sense - he'd waited 6 months and he couldn't wait one ore night! I'd also thought that if ASR had been late to the mandap and Khushi had left, something would have broken inside her because he would have proven the unholy cycle of their relationship she so dreaded true again in her mind and rejected her yet again. If that had happened, I'm not sure how ASR would have been able to convince Khushi of his feelings for her.

My take on this whole aspect is that Khushi has not forgotten ' in fact, her readiness to accept his apology for all the hurt and move on had puzzled me for a bit but wanting to forgive someone and being convinced in your very soul that the man who professes to love you now has changed are two very different things. ASR will eventually need to address some of the invisible wounds on Khushi's psyche he inflicted in his path to coming to terms with his own feelings for her. How can ASR convince Khushi he's not going to revert back to their cycle? Is it a gradual process'will only a lifetime of unconditional love and support provide solace to the deep wounds in her heart left by his past behaviour or will the arrival of Sheetal and Aarav bring it to the fore for Khushi and force ASR to deal with it if he doesn't want to lose her? Looks like the second option will play out.

This subconscious disquiet in Khushi also manifested itself in her reaction to Aarav. The only people in this entire mix who've had really incomprehensible reactions to Aarav's superficial similarities to Arnav and people noting it are Sheetal and Khushi. The audience is waiting for Sheetal's reaction and characterization to play out - currently she just looks uncomfortable and awkward and tries to get away from ASR and his family. But Khushi? I thought Khushi's reaction was very abnormal ' why should she automatically feel a sense of disquiet at the similarites that a boy (who happens to be Arnav's college classmate's mother and that is all she knew during the whole scene where the Raizada family is commenting on the similarities between chhota packet and bada packet) displays with her husband. ASR was no playboy or cad and Khushi knows very well how his past has coloured his views on relationships, fidelity and personal responsibility. I thought Mami, Nani, Anjali and even Payal's reaction to the similarities way more realistic and normal ' how is it that three people who have known Arnav longer do not jump to the same conclusion that Khushi seems to be heading towards? It also seems strange that Khushi doesn't seem to notice what Mami very nicely said ' that Aarav is similar to the current Arnav, not the younger Arnav at Aarav's age ' again, Khushi's own subconscious fears coming to bear here, I think.

It has been interesting to see Arnav and Sheetal's interaction ' he seems very comfortable and even indulges in some small talk. I wonder how much is because of the softening of his facade post Khushi, how much due to some level of comfort in their past relationship/friendship in college and how much because he understands that Sheetal is an introvert and he exerts himself to save their short interactions the usual awkwardness. Nothing in his demeanor with her or when discussing the relationship with Khushi suggests any awkwardness ' whatever it was that that they had, it seemed to not have ended on a bad note for him. It was also not memorable enough for him to remember. I loved the scene where he tells Khushi that Sheetal and him were briefly involved in college ' not apologetic about his past and completely forthright. He does apologize about not telling her earlier but confesses that there was nothing to tell and that he barely remembered the relationship or Sheetal because it did not register much with him. Not only does he think that Khushi has nothing to feel jealous or possessive about, he is able to even tease her when she questions him further about the past women in his life. I para-phrase here - You know how I used to be..in fact, am'did not have many friends and did not easily talk to people' and she was very like me'so we used to talk and became good friends 'we went out for a few dates but there was nothing there..so we broke up. Beautifully written and wonderfully and maturely enacted. A few dates do not a relationship make,. So it looks like they were barely involved. In fact, I would be very surprised if they'd even had a sexual relationship, because it never even occurs to ASR (who we now know is aware that Sheetal is a single mom) that Aarav could be his given the surface similarities he has probably noticed and Khushi has pointed out a couple of times, the child's age and his past (non) relationship with the child's mother.

I must admit that I'm looking forward to seeing this play out - to see how ASR manages to overcome the festering sore in Khushi that his past behaviour has caused, how Khushi reacts once she is convinced that Aarav is Arnav's child (she seems to be heading that way from all the evidence), what Sheetal is here to do (it is too much of a coincidence that a few days after the last obstruction to Arnav and Khushi living happily together is gotten rid of, conveniently along comes a supposed woman from the ASR's past complete with a child that acts like him) and very curious to find out who is pulling the strings of this whole drama ' Sheetal or someone else from ASR's very colourful past that he has declared he wants to move on from. It should also be interesting to see how ASR fights for Khushi. ASR has never had to fight for Khushi's love ' he mostly spent all his energy and time fighting his feelings for Khushi. By the time, he was ready to acknowledge to himself what he felt for her, he already knew of her feelings for him. She came back with great risk to her life to rescue him'twice and almost managed to fall off a cliff in the process the second time around. He has stood up for her to Dadi, society, his family and even hers ' for her rightful place in his house, as his wife, within his family and society and attempted to give her the dream wedding she was denied the first time around and to wipe out the bad memories from the forced marriage he was responsible for but he has never had to fight for her love. She, on the other hand, has been alienated from everyone that she loved due to his actions and managed to fight, survive and come back out stronger with no help from him ' it should be interesting to see how he fares in a somewhat similar situation.

A few other observations :

- How cute were Khushi and Arnav during the whole how many girlfriends have you had in the past scene ' his sudden change from reasoning with her to teasing her, her growing outrage as he drones on with his list of names...his face scrunched up with the effort of remembering all of them, him trying unsuccessfully to hide his amusement at her believing him so easily and then her beating up on him at him daring to not take her question seriously enough and, finally, him stopping her mid tirade and letting her know that nothing meant much to him before he met her ' she taught him what love meant, everything before was just white noise.

- ASR is good with kids ' his interactions with Aarav have been very genuine and realistic and free of any kind of awkwardness I'd thought would characterize him being anywhere near kids. Is it because Aarav is a little like him ' serious and a bit shut down from the outside world? Is it because he is male and a little easier for ASR to relate to ' though you'd think living in a mansion surrounded by a lot of women would make this a non issue? Or is it that falling in love has changed his perspective on children just like it has on marriage?

- Loved the two little girls teasing Aarav ' their giggling and his serious affront at them daring to do so was very endearing.

- Loved the precap, Khushi and her rangeen kal and BankeyLal chakkar and ASR's expression at the new level of craziness about to befall him.


Edited by caltoon - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".