Shilpa giggles, SLB mismatch

More than giving appropriate comments to the participants, Shilpa is laughing and giggling and saying the same things to all the participants or repeating what Farah and Snjay say. Sony should have paid Karishma ant let her be the judge. At least we would have heard some intelligent comments.

Sanjay Leela Bhansali seems such a mismatch. The only person who fits the bill is Farah khan.

Your thoughts?

I agree .I also felt that Shilpa wasnt enjoying herself at all.She was sober faced throughout and thinking for words/comments.
Sanjay was ok but farah was good as usual

I tend to disagree. Sanjay is a good match. A little known fact about Sanjay is that he started his career as a Choreographer and an Art Director.

Shilpa is a total mismatch. She was short of words,lacked originality in terms of talking & giving points.

I agree with HariOm. The only capable judge is Farah Khan, and maybe (a little bit) Sanjay. But, Shilpa is not apt to make any comments, since she is clueless!

Shipla is an awesome dancer, I was expecting her to speak more about the performances. Farah will obviously be a natural considering she is a choreographer, this is definately for her. Sanjay and Shilpa just seem like a mismatch for the show. With the American version of this show, all three judges are choreographers and know exactly what to look for when judging and criticizing contestants.

i woz thinkin da same !
shilpa kept sayin lag raha tha aap boht maza lele ke nach rahe the !
n it got borin after a while

may be she didnt hv comments 😉

i think farah and slb r both good
shilpa is not tht goodddddddddd

Originally posted by: haripatti

I tend to disagree. Sanjay is a good match. A little known fact about Sanjay is that he started his career as a Choreographer and an Art Director.

Shilpa is a total mismatch. She was short of words,lacked originality in terms of talking & giving points.

Didn't know that !! Well then he must know what he's talking about.
I thought Shilpa would have some good input because she's a dancer.

yea farah bein a choreographer waz amazin.... sanjay waznt tht bad either.. atleast he had his own points to put forward... but shilpa waz da odd one out i din like her at all