Where is the grandeur? A Debate

Rockerchic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
RC was just looking at the TRPs of the last few months because analyzing audience reaction is a kind of hobby.

Uptill about four months ago (more or less) the TRPs were steady at three point something and on grander occasions they reached the latter half of three maybe even touching four.

IPK initially had one competitor, the show on Colors. Now it has two with the inclusion of the one of Life Okay. IPK isn't too bad a show, yes it has witnessed some poor acting and screenplay in the past few weeks, but over all a fairly watchable show.

Obviously IPK lost viewers during the GH track and Kidnap track. But now the track is fairly good and far cry better than what it was in January (Before Payaash wedding) which was a highly boring track and yet it had a TRP above 3. Why is that?

Some say 'Sarun' lost chemistry. You can't just loose chemistry- it there or it's not. And Sanaya and Barun have great chemistry- yes they still do.

And the story, although kind of over zealous, is interesting enough. RC wanted to find out what was so great about the other shows? So RC forced herself to watch a few episodes.

Do they have better actors? Hell no.
Do they have a better storyline? Not really.
Are their creatives better? They are all equally good or they are all equally bad. Indian soaps don't really concentrate on the technical aspect of art of acting.

But both the shows are significantly better than IPK in one aspect- The grandeur ie The set, the hype, the costume, the editing.


At the end of the Television appeals to the sense of sight. A great story isn't enough, you need to appeal to this aspect of the viewership.

I mean honestly Santivan looks like a haunted house in need of a major spring clean up.

Barun and Sanaya are the hottest actors on television (no debate here) i thought it was physically impossible to make them look bad. I was proved wrong. Same brown shirt, same red anarkali- I mean it screams indifference. Out of curiosity who are hairstylists of IPK? Fire them ASAP.

The Remarriage is one of the very anticipated tracks of IPK. Everyone wants to be part of Arnav and Khuhsi's wedding.

When you reuse props and costumes it shows indifference. No wonder the audience lost interest. When you show that you've spent money it will automatically quip the curiosity of the audience. This is basic PR skills.

With the half backed apology from Arnav- I'm sorry it didn't strike a chord with me (I understand it's importance and it's essence but as a scene it didn't appeal to me.) The set up for it and their costumes and the lighting were all pathetically horrible.

We here at IF can tell what scenes will make the show better, but to implement it in the grandest way possible lies with the PH alone.

On contrary to popular notion acting and story have very little to do with popularity. Unless the PH upgrades it's set, get better costume designers and hairstylists, actually tries to implement some gimmicks in editing, IPK's TRPs won't go up. Period.

Standard Disclaimer- I am never EVER watching those shows again. Ever.

~Rockerchic.

Edited by Rockerchic - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

2.8k

Users

15

Likes

79

Frequent Posters

Rockerchic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Isn't the like button working or is that just for me?
OmNaMaSteOm thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Rockerchic

Isn't the like button working or is that just for me?


its not working - its every body
nice topic for debate by the way


Well as far as i am looking at it - the entire team seem lost in trying to get the trps back & so there are not really bothered about the look of the show - which is very much reflecting.

As an audience im tired of seeing the same set, costume again & again
i even memorized the dresses Sanaya is wearing

Even the camera focus makes me feel the cast is not together while shooting - too many close ups is a turn off.

The worst part of all this is the support characters have better costumes then the leads - that is the sorry state of the show at present

Not promoting their show is also a major reason.

Edited by Harshitha - 13 years ago
_disha_ thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Yes i totally agree with ur post/thoughts... I also felt that earlier ( like really long ago during office episodes etc ) the episodes looked much glossier,crispy or whatever the word is if u know what i mean.
Ya we all love Barun and Sanaya but sometimes they themselves look so bored in the scenes its weird.
But of course i am a crazy fan and i watch and re watch almost all episodes 😆 !!! But the TRP audience is not that loyal towards our show.
MentalExotica thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Ok I have always wished for each and every member of my family who watch TV soaps to watch IPKKND (read grandma and Ma)

So they watch the child bride show and why you ask?

Amma - Because the lead actress is getting a dream wedding and finally the much deserved happiness!

MentEX - Oh wait we are getting that too in our show Amma?

Amma - really? but look at all the set up for this

MentEX - Ok i'll get RC to argue with you

Life OK = larger than life man, Lord Shiva and a great Indian wedding which was advertised to bits - Devi Mayya has kripa on them.

Core TRP audience prefers BV cos they have a connect with the lead female.

But my aunts who watch it call in the Khushi show which makes me so 😳

TRP's have taken a major set back and they need urgent CPR

Chalo I ventured in again! Kissy wissy!
Edited by MentalExotica - 13 years ago
..mrinalini.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Promos...grandeur...Costumes...and to top it all off Good execution...

IPK has an "aesthetic" storyline...it has good actors...But the place they fall flat on is execution and of course budget...Sometimes they cut cost in a way that totally pisses me off!!

The PH needs to wake up from their slumber and realize IPK is their biggest Show...A show that runs on an enviable 8pm time slot in an enviable channel...The PH must respect that fact and take care of the above...

Chemistry...is very much there..So is acting!Half-baked scenes won't do,period!!

Execution lao..TRP badhao..bas keh diya!!😉
inspiringstars thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Nice analysis...completely agree with it.
They should work on some glaring issues that audiences see, but they seem to neglect.
The past and the remarriage seems to be an interesting plot, but as your saying direction and the screenplay has to be consistent. otherwise, they will blow up the only chance this show has to redeem in the audience's eyes. Atleast for me, if they don't deliver for these few months in the current track, I am done...I mean I am not threatening to not watch it again...I might be watching it, but the fan in me, will die!

P.S., Can I add you as a buddy? Your debates are interesting, and I always strive to interact with interesting people...LOL!!!
Edited by inspiringstars - 13 years ago
Happy-go-lucky thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
Agree with all your points... I couldn't bring myself to watch the other shows but one thing I know for sure- brighter and lavish sets attract viewers (read TRP junta), it's just sort of like some natural reflex that you take an instant liking to it, visual relief or something like that ( I don't know if my blabbering makes sense...) P.s. Why didn't you put up your standard disclaimer this time, I really like it (no, I'm serious, really, no sarcasm this time...) :-)
Edited by Happy-go-lucky - 13 years ago
Rockerchic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: disha.paul

Yes i totally agree with ur post/thoughts... I also felt that earlier ( like really long ago during office episodes etc ) the episodes looked much glossier,crispy or whatever the word is if u know what i mean.

Ya we all love Barun and Sanaya but sometimes they themselves look so bored in the scenes its weird.
But of course i am a crazy fan and i watch and re watch almost all episodes 😆 !!! But the TRP audience is not that loyal towards our show.



True that. To have inspired cast you should have an inspired set.
Rockerchic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: MentalExotica

Ok I have always wished for each and every member of my family who watch TV soaps to watch IPKKND (read grandma and Ma)


So they watch the child bride show and why you ask?

Amma - Because the lead actress is getting a dream wedding and finally the much deserved happiness!

MentEX - Oh wait we are getting that too in our show Amma?

Amma - really? but look at all the set up for this

MentEX - Ok i'll get RC to argue with you

Life OK = larger than life man, Lord Shiva and a great Indian wedding which was advertised to bits - Devi Mayya has kripa on them.

Core TRP audience prefers BV cos they have a connect with the lead female.

But my aunts who watch it call in the Khushi show which makes me so 😳

TRP's have taken a major set back and they need urgent CPR

Chalo I ventured in again! Kissy wissy!



That's pretty much what happens in my household too!

They have really horrible publicity. And really is 4lions really that poor a PH that they can't afford good costumes for their leads alteast? Oh well.
Edited by Rockerchic - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".