SBS - Ashni celebrating there one month Anniversary - Page 6

Originally posted by: deepa_jd

she knows ashu not gonna believe her.. so she will get in CID mode herself !
but they dont have much choice other than dragging this thing ,till SK is fit 2 walk..
once he joins KGH and mallu wont see him much in home,thats when d mallu v/s nidhi story will start i think!

Jaise hi Ashu thik ho jaega as she is faking Mallu bhi thik ho jaegi aur piche piche KGH join kar legi. Nidhi dabbawali banke lunch for 2 pouchaegi.

I am so glad there was a segment where there was a suggestion to rename the show as Saath Nibhana Saathiya...I only hope this reaches KPji's ears...his ghamand on his hatke show needs to break...this track is in fact a straight lift from that show...the track where the ex comes to live with a couple just ended on that show...I know because my mom watches it religiously...and the ex even makes an attempt on the wife's life by trying to cause a fire...that a truly eclectic show had to come to this...borrowing from one of the most regressive and backward saas-bahu shows on Indian TV today...but of course the one with the huge TRPs...for all his bravado, KPji is now reduced to begging for the TRP crumbs too...apparently he has in the past been associated with Ekta's show...can't be an entirely new experience for him hence!

Is there a link to this segment?

If we sit back and think for a second, this whole delibrate butchering of Ashu's character seems so OTT, so contrived that somehow I cannot help but think there is something else going on here, something that will be revealed., like Ashu also faking to a certain extent. All the extra effort that is going into making the viewers hate Ashu, through the Ashu-Mallu scenes, their apparent enjoyment at all the angry reactions, the FB interactions just seems like a big stunt. It seems they want the viewers to feel this way. But why?

Yes, KP loves Mallu, but he is not the only one involved here and I cannot believe the entire PH and SET all love Mallu to the same extent! Not possible! When KP went overboard with his negativity during CB's heart attack, he had to redeem Ashu, when he went overboard with age-gap stuff in Feb, SET CVs took over and got things back under control. THey redeemed Ashu once more by making him a romantic on V-Day and after that till his accident. So, why would SET allow a blatant sabotage of their show by creating such widespread hatred for their lead? Nidhi being upset and crying and over-exposure to Mallu is not helping TRPs anyway, so that explanation is just rubbish! Unless they have another solid reason?

Hiding from all tamatars, andas, jootis...

Originally posted by: aardhan

Is there a link to this segment?

If we sit back and think for a second, this whole delibrate attempt to butcher Ashu's character seems so OTT, so contrived that somehow I cannot help but think there is something else going on here, something that will be revealed., like Ashu also faking to a certain extent. All the extra effort that is going into making the viewers hate Ashu, through the Ashu-Mallu scenes, their apparent enjoyment at all the angry reactions, the FB interactions just seems like a big stunt. It seems they want the viewers to feel this way. But why?

Yes, KP loves Mallu, but he is not the only one involved here and I cannot believe the entire PH and SET all love Mallu to the same extent! Not possible! When KP went overboard with his negativity during CB's heart attack, he had to redeem Ashu, when he went overboard with age-gap stuff in Feb, SET CVs took over and got things back under control. THey redeemed Ashu once more by making him a romantic on V-Day and after that till his accident. So, why would SET allow a blatant sabotage of their show by creating such widespread hatred for their lead? Nidhi being upset and crying and over-exposure to Mallu is not helping TRPs anyway, so that explanation is just rubbish! Unless they have another solid reason?

Hiding from all tamatars, andas, jootis...

Originally posted by: achiever

araadhan.. KP is so arrogant on FB so naturally all jootas and andaas r thrown at him..

from wer i see, he and Cvs r trying to justify Ashu's behaviour by going thru our posts.. every time v raise an issue v c an answer ditto like ours in nxt to nxt epi.. i have observed this pattern for a while now.. so i think thy r following our reviews and trying to make it more entertaining.. bt the problem is thy cannot let go the mallu gajar for TRPs.. tht thy think is generating quite a reviews positive or negative..

bt the problem is

Well, they are generating a buzz, that's for sure but that buzz is not being translated into TRPs. So, what then is point in continuing with this madness? EVen I noticed that CVs do answer to our comments, but why do they then ignore our main issue which is Ashu's character?They can show this Mallu care in a positive way as well, if they show Ashu taking into account Nidhi's feelings and acting on them, or even if he indulges in such a thought process wondering what Mallu's problem is or how he can balance both women, this track would become more digestable to the viewers. If they show him drawing the line by gently making some excuse to Mallu, then it would become more positive.

That's precisely what I am wondering here. Why are they trying to give explanations rather than make some subtle changes unless its part of some grand scheme? At the end of the day, SET is a commercial channel that is dependent on finance and so TRPs and if one character, like Mallu is able to create buzz but not TRP, why would a channel want to hold on to such a character? Wouldn't you prefer to chop off a limb rather than risk your entire life?

Originally posted by: achiever

araadhan.. KP is so arrogant on FB so naturally all jootas and andaas r thrown at him..

from wer i see, he and Cvs r trying to justify Ashu's behaviour by going thru our posts.. every time v raise an issue v c an answer ditto like ours in nxt to nxt epi.. i have observed this pattern for a while now.. so i think thy r following our reviews and trying to make it more entertaining.. bt the problem is thy cannot let go the mallu gajar for TRPs.. tht thy think is generating quite a reviews positive or negative..

bt the problem is

It is true that BB has been used as the mouthpiece of the creaives to explain/ justify their stance..however, the point is am sure even they are aware that their explanations cut no ice...and yet, they are carrying on with this regressive nonsense which far exceeds even Kekta in terms of manipulation...I have a feeling that this week's TRPs will get them to take a call on this track...the last two weeks have been more or less stable...even they have the good sense to know the sudden rise was because of the combined TRPs...and the drop last week was very marginal...I have a feeling that they are covering their bases...if the TRPs drop further, they may decide to show Ashu as faking too...and have the last laugh...if, God forbid, there is a rise in TRPs, then we can probably brace ourselves for more of this crap!.

Mallu's shadi was a disaster and so she can not stand happy marriages! Ab to use shadi shabd se hi itna nafrat ho gayi hogi ke she might be planning on ruining Ashni marriage. Who knows she might cook stories to make her kabab me haddi dost Ashu side with her views!

Rupanjal, you have raised another valid issue about Mallu. That's another thing that has been bothering from the start. Mallu's timeline and they way she wormed her way into Ashu's house definitely hs some loop holes. Now, whether its poor script and direction or real clues to this track is anybody's guess.

1. Mallu's timeline - When Ashu sees Mallu she has been in the hotel for a week, add a couple of days for travel, a couple of days before the maid finds and gives her her passport.
Assumptions -
Assuming the maid story is true
Assuming she was able to reach India without raising any suspicion
Assuming in her mental state she was actually able to make the travel, the stop overs, etc and manages to get on the right flight, then
WOuld it not have been at least 10 days between when she was beaten and when Ashu saw her? HOw is it she looked that she had been beaten just a day or two ago? THis does not add up.

2. Mallu's parapet drama - This happens after Ashu sees her medical file. So he has definitely seen the report on her wounds. DO you think he saw something, like the time of Mallu's injury that raised a red flag. I still cannot digest the someone in that condition could understand the following -
Two nurses talking about Ashu's discharge and instantly acting on it
UNderstand Ranga when he said Ashu was in the parking lot, and why did he have to be so specific about Ashu's location
Mallu was sedated with what, was it a drug or just saline water? WHatever she was given had no effect on her, she was so clear when she spoke to Ashu from that parapet, both in her speech and in her thoughts and she was awake even when she got to Ashu's house. SHe is not a super human to not be influenced by the drug. So, what was she administered and did Ashu have a hand in this?

Originally posted by: aardhan

Rupanjal, you have raised another valid issue about Mallu. That's another thing that has been bothering from the start. Mallu's timeline and they way she wormed her way into Ashu's house definitely hs some loop holes. Now, whether its poor script and direction or real clues to this track is anybody's guess.

1. Mallu's timeline - When Ashu sees Mallu she has been in the hotel for a week, add a couple of days for travel, a couple of days before the maid finds and gives her her passport.
Assumptions -
Assuming the maid story is true
Assuming she was able to reach India without raising any suspicion
Assuming in her mental state she was actually able to make the travel, the stop overs, etc and manages to get on the right flight, then
WOuld it not have been at least 10 days between when she was beaten and when Ashu saw her? HOw is it she looked that she had been beaten just a day or two ago? THis does not add up.

2. Mallu's parapet drama - This happens after Ashu sees her medical file. So he has definitely seen the report on her wounds. DO you think he saw something, like the time of Mallu's injury that raised a red flag. I still cannot digest the someone in that condition could understand the following -
Two nurses talking about Ashu's discharge and instantly acting on it
UNderstand Ranga when he said Ashu was in the parking lot, and why did he have to be so specific about Ashu's location
Mallu was sedated with what, was it a drug or just saline water? WHatever she was given had no effect on her, she was so clear when she spoke to Ashu from that parapet, both in her speech and in her thoughts and she was awake even when she got to Ashu's house. SHe is not a super human to not be influenced by the drug. So, what was she administered and did Ashu have a hand in this?

Originally posted by: GoodOne

<font color="#6600ff">Perfect Analysis BUT... given the past , where logic has been ignored, it could be twisted into anything or just one of the many faux pas of the story/direction.</font>

<font color="#6600ff">I guess that's what the CVs want from the viewers- keep on guessing , we will do what we want and change it at anytime as per our convenience.</font>

<font color="#6600ff">Did u see in one of the Segments from yesterday when the reporter asked Rukhsar - Is Mallika faking? she replied audiences will have to watch & decide.</font>

<font color="#6600ff">So there is a strong chance that there may be something BIG in the backdrop which will be revealed later or they are just cooking up another Ekta type story till SK recovers.</font>

<font color="#6600ff">I hope they come up with something mind-boggling and then justify why Ashutosh is being so insensitive to Nidhi and stooping low to combing M's hair even.</font>

Anupma, sorry did not answer your PM. I certainly did not meant to be rude. Maybe I will make this a separate thread and post all these arguements there. I know no one believes that Ashu could be faking but we can always have this counter arguement that he is faking becoz he has some doubt and wants to find out about Mallu.

As far as Ashu's character is concerned, his behavior towards Mallu and Nidhi hs been stretched so far that the CVs have pushed themselves against the wall. There is now only one way to redeem his character and that is to reveal that he was faking to some extent. THere is no doubt that he cares for Mallu but to what extent and does that include excluding his wife to this extent, ignoring all her feelings and her silent pleas for some emotional support from him? SO here Cvs have let themselves with no choice, either we all hate Ashu forever for the way he is behaving or come to know he was faking and earning everyone's admiration once more. THey have only one choice here.