WALK-OUT

ID
The reason has been discussed so much that adding anything can start a controversy.So soory i'm not giving it.

None of them. You should have thought about the rules (public voting), before you decided to participate. When it is in your favor, all is well, then when it's not...Wah, wah, wah, Boo hoo hoo. Grow up Judges! Yes II2, I can understand their frustration, but there is no solution when the rules have already been predetermined.

vinit himani and hemchandra - cause vinit and they all rockzzz..... 😉 😉 😉

i would say its ID,
thats becoz only after his walk-out
debo started becoming the no.1 contestant..

Walkout ka koi asar hona chahiye..
vinit-hema and himani did it,
lekin uska koi asar nahin.. But, II2, i
dnt know wat will happen

Absolutely right........
Walk is never a good thing.
You have to abide by the rules which has been set.Otherwise you have to disapprove it before the show starts. Infact, I would say rather then walking out, Ismail should have not approved for public voting before the agnipariksha round when this was discussed with the mentors earlier. Why it was approved then?
None of the walk-out is noble.

Coming to vinit-Himani and Hema, that was absolutely stupid. But I heard that some mentor instigated though not sure about this. But I would say that even if one of the mentor instigated, these three should have been intelligent enough to put their foot down to say no to their mentors. And about Hema, he has a sportsmanspirit, I can clearly see it.But he was just dragged into this. But after that he gave such a tremendous performace that I was moved by it and it should have been Hema who should have won the competition after Nihira's elimination. But again public voting 😡 but before getting eliminated, he gave genuine speech. And about these three judges in Indian Idol, I can say that they were terribly dissappointed but again walk-out se kya hota hain? RULE IS RULE and you have to abide by it. And I am happy that Amey refused for re-match. He would have lost few fans due to this. But after his yesterday's spirit, I am sure he has gained more and more fans.

I think II2 Judges Bcoz -
II2 Judges responded instantly when Amey got eliminated.
While Vinit-Himani-Hemu and ID took 1 episode to decide whole situation. Everything was like drama. If one really feels bad/good about something , the response is naturally very immediate.

While these people's walkout reaction was something like they are feeling unsafe themselves. If ID felf that Nihira's elimination was not right.. then y didn't he walked out in that movement itself?
It's whole preplanned drama.

While II2 judges are nothing 2 do with these contestants, they are not mentors. They wint get trouble if somebodu gets eliminate.
But though they did what they feel... instantly....
😳

itz tru dat ID started it but i would say none. 😊

ID and II-2.....protest against injustice

Vineet/Himani- Nautanki

I do not... even ID did nautanki 😳
Does he need 1 week to feel Injustice ???
😳

No walk out can be justified. But, I give the 3 kids more credit since their young and foolish. Still Wrong.

The- Adults, I'm sorry, but grow up- pun intended. 😊