MOST FAIR JUDGE

I think Jatin Lalit.
ID likes everyone.
Adesh and Himesh are biased, I feel.

ID definetly is the fairest judge.
i wouldnt place aadesh at no.2 as he is always praising his students and trying to cover up there mistakes

Ismail Durbar is the Fairest Judge

I would say Ismail is the fairest judge, he is honest but still gives the contestants confidence to continue. I like that. After him I would have to say Jatin Lalit. Aadesh and Himesh are biased most of the time, and always compliment their contestants, but Jatin Lalit and Ismail compliment all contestants equally

even i think ismail is the fairest judge..he is encouraging all the partcipants evenly.

Yeah, totally agree. ID is very fair. He encourages every contestant fairly and gives good marks to everyone. On the other hand, HR is acting very childish lately. He only promotes his gharana and is pretty stingy in giving marks to other good singers.

ID is the fairest. HR is definately the most biased. n adesh is 2nd on the list cuz he is not as extreme as HR. adesh is supportive and shows confidence in his students n HR is juz overconfident. he acts silly n tht too only when it comes to vinit asthough the others in his gharana dun exist.

IT IS ISMAEL DARBAR.
AND HE HAS THE TOP CONTESTANTS OF THE CHALLENGE 2005

NIHIRA & DEBOJIT

classyhombre,

I agree with you 100%.