Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 28 - Page 4

Originally posted by: Moor278

As I said I was paraphrasing...

in yesterday's episode before revealing the ONS, Mannat tells Vik that to not hurt someone we hide secrets so deep that we tend to forget them.. then they start looking for papers.. After all the drama.. he asks her why didnt she tell him... she repeats that you were distraught.. I couldn't see you in pain.. and you had anyway decided on the divorce.. telling the truth wouldn't have changed anything... hence I didn't tell you. .

Happened in parts.. but the combined effect tells me Mannat is not going to reveals Mallas hand behind the multiple assaults on her 😕

Vik now knows the biggest deception... theres no point in telling him the depths to which Malla can go...

Telling truth would have done, free him of everyday guilt 😔, kaha ka logic hai , wrong in thinking that there wasn't much difference...As she couldn't see him in pain and guilt ,she should have had opted for revelation..that was much more relief than living in guilt ..Here the writers have messed up with her character 😕

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Telling truth would have done, free him of everyday guilt 😔, kaha ka logic hai , wrong in thinking that there wasn't much difference...As she couldn't see him in pain and guilt ,she should have had opted for revelation..that was much more relief than living in guilt ..Here the writers have messed up with her character 😕

Totally... they made her withhold it for whom??? Malla???

But Vikrant wouldn't have accepted it either. As we kept discussing Mannat doesn’t know what transpired that night. All she knows is nothing happened. Yesterday's was probably the first time Vik actually told her the details. He did say in store room confrontation but she was drugged .. doesnt count.

And like he himself said... he needs proofs...

I feel it could have happened a little differently... Mannat telling him... he doubts and then over hears Malla Aish convo... or something like that. Iss truth reveal ko thoda drag karna tha...

Vik's instant reaction was good but that too was odd given his usual nature. I expected him to sulk .. not immediately give in 😂😂😂

But ofcourse naye track ki jaldi hai where ManVik have to be together 🤦‍♀️

Varna shayad ye aata bhi nahi. 😐

And his dialogue was definitely a premonition of Amans birth truth track.

Mannat will hide again... to protect him and he will MU. 😭

Originally posted by: Moor278

Totally... they made her withhold it for whom??? Malla???

But Vikrant wouldn't have accepted it either. As we kept discussing Mannat doesn’t know what transpired that night. All she knows is nothing happened. Yesterday's was probably the first time Vik actually told her the details. He did say in store room confrontation but she was drugged .. doesnt count.

And like he himself said... he needs proofs...

I feel it could have happened a little differently... Mannat telling him... he doubts and then over hears Malla Aish convo... or something like that. Iss truth reveal ko thoda drag karna tha...

Vik's instant reaction was good but that too was odd given his usual nature. I expected him to sulk .. not immediately give in 😂😂😂

But ofcourse naye track ki jaldi hai where ManVik have to be together 🤦‍♀️

Varna shayad ye aata bhi nahi. 😐

And his dialogue was definitely a premonition of Amans birth truth track.

Mannat will hide again... to protect him and he will MU. 😭

To be honest, i also expected this truth reveal to be a bit more elaborate ..

It’s a big thing ..and yes even i wanted vik to be mad and furious for some more time ..

They rushed it

Originally posted by: Moor278

Totally... they made her withhold it for whom??? Malla???

But Vikrant wouldn't have accepted it either. As we kept discussing Mannat doesn’t know what transpired that night. All she knows is nothing happened. Yesterday's was probably the first time Vik actually told her the details. He did say in store room confrontation but she was drugged .. doesnt count.

And like he himself said... he needs proofs...

I feel it could have happened a little differently... Mannat telling him... he doubts and then over hears Malla Aish convo... or something like that. Iss truth reveal ko thoda drag karna tha...

Vik's instant reaction was good but that too was odd given his usual nature. I expected him to sulk .. not immediately give in 😂😂😂

But ofcourse naye track ki jaldi hai where ManVik have to be together 🤦‍♀️

Varna shayad ye aata bhi nahi. 😐

And his dialogue was definitely a premonition of Amans birth truth track.

Mannat will hide again... to protect him and he will MU. 😭

What is this protection yaar? Hiding things ?yeh baatein chupane wale nahi hai....

Anyways it will be an open secret after sometime..why should she hide ?

Just to create MU..😢

Originally posted by: Moor278

Totally... they made her withhold it for whom??? MALLA???

But Vikrant wouldn't have accepted it either. As we kept discussing Mannat doesn’t know what transpired that night. All she knows is nothing happened. Yesterday's was probably the first time Vik actually told her the details. He did say in store room confrontation but she was drugged .. doesnt count.

And like he himself said... he needs proofs...

I feel it could have happened a little differently... Mannat telling him... he doubts and then over hears Malla Aish convo... or something like that. Iss truth reveal ko thoda drag karna tha...

Vik's instant reaction was good but that too was odd given his usual nature. I expected him to sulk .. not immediately give in 😂😂😂

But ofcourse naye track ki jaldi hai where ManVik have to be together 🤦‍♀️

Varna shayad ye aata bhi nahi. 😐

And his dialogue was definitely a premonition of Amans birth truth track.

Mannat will hide again... to protect him and he will MU. 😭

Bold even I feel for Malla..

Yesterday also she meant for malla,not to reveal ??? .

Vik's reaction lacked intensity and he should be more angry for such an important revelation, immediately making him to surrender is a bit odd for his character ,though it's nice to see them together ❤️

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

What is this protection yaar? Hiding things ?yeh baatein chupane wale nahi hai....

Anyways it will be an open secret after sometime..why should she hide ?

Just to create MU..😢

It’s not some truth to protect him..it’s to set him free ..

There is nothing to protect him here ..it’s not like he committed some murder while he was on drugs or under some drug influence

In fact here he is innocent ..

Originally posted by: Jyotsna09

Bold even I feel for Malla..

Yesterday also she meant for malla,not to reveal ??? .

Vik's reaction lacked intensity and he should be more angry for such an important revelation, immediately making him to surrender is a bit odd for his character ,though it's nice to see them together ❤️

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

Vikrant’s reaction was good when he became angry and all but they made him soften quickly ..

That's why I said intensity, it was good but not intensified due to immediate surrender ..

It was script's fault not actor's

Addy did brilliantly, sudden changes in emotions were done extraordinaryly...

See there are few things why Mannat didnt tell him...

Some Vik himself acknowledged... like the need for proofs...

And Mannat very rightly pointed out that if you love someone you can have an emotional reaction to them but not accuse of murder...👏

So her not telling him in absence of proof was logical... also like she said he had decided to divorce Malla... so what was the point anyway...

She hasn't even told him that ARS spiked her coffee and not Shalini even though they have patched up now...

Writers (in the earlier episode)... even made him say that he feels himself responsible for Mallas downgrade.... how?... that was completely illogical... that way Vik doesnt even realise that Malla might have orchestrated all this with some ulterior motive in mind... and I refuse to believe his version of sweet innocent Malla... he was being very naive then .. inspite of knowing she can poison innocent children...😢

That said... Vik believed Mannat this time because he heard and saw some proofs himself... again its not Mannats words but his own conviction that made him believe Mannats words without proof...

Now just imagine this in context of Neetu...

Mallas crimes are out in open, yet Vik took time to accept ... Mannat tried that for Neetus poisoning... but she couldn't convince him properly... all we got is Mannat might have misunderstood...

With Amans truth around corner.. it would be a huge test of Vikrants trust on Mannat... one that he has gained now... will he believe her over Neetu??? Without proofs????

Writers are giving this hint repeatedly... Neetu always asking him what if Mannat blames me? And he has not responded ever.

And I am glad Dhairya is here now... Mannats words will have some weight and an external support.. it wont be Mannat accusing Neetu for the sake of it... but some truth to it.... depends on how Vik sees it.

I will still stay this truth reveal was rushed. Should have been gradual 👍

Originally posted by: Moor278

See there are few things why Mannat didnt tell him...

Some Vik himself acknowledged... like the need for proofs...

And Mannat very rightly pointed out that if you love someone you can have an emotional reaction to them but not accuse of murder ..👏

So her not telling him in absence of proof was logical... also like she said he had decided to divorce Malla... so what was the point anyway...

She hasn't even told him that ARS spiked her coffee and not Shalini even though they have patched up now...

Writers (in the earlier episode)... even made him say that he feels himself responsible for Mallas downgrade.... how?... that was completely illogical... that way Vik doesnt even realise that Malla might have orchestrated all this with some ulterior motive in mind... and I refuse to believe his version of sweet innocent Malla... he was being very naive then .. inspite of knowing she can poison innocent children...😢

That said... Vik believed Mannat this time because he heard and saw some proofs himself... again its not Mannats words but his own conviction that made him believe Mannats words without proof...

Now just imagine this in context of Neetu...

Mallas crimes are out in open, yet Vik took time to accept ... Mannat tried that for Neetus poisoning... but she couldn't convince him properly... all we got is Mannat might have misunderstood...

With Amans truth around corner.. it would be a huge test of Vikrants trust on Mannat... one that he has gained now... will he believe her over Neetu??? Without proofs????

Writers are giving this hint repeatedly... Neetu always asking him what if Mannat blames me? And he has not responded ever.

And I am glad Dhairya is here now... Mannats words will have some weight and an external support.. it wont be Mannat accusing Neetu for the sake of it... but some truth to it.... depends on how Vik sees it.

I will still stay this truth reveal was rushed. Should have been gradual 👍

Bold I didn't get it yesterday also..

When did he accuse her of murder , she means to say, Varun is accused of murder ???

How is it related here? He doesn't have anything emotional connection to Varun . .