Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 17 - Page 36

Originally posted by: Moor278

I dont want Mannat to confess first... she is absolutely right where she stands...

She can confess only and if Vikrant triggers her tremendously... and her confession might come out as a rant... I see no other way

My new theory is ViMal shaadi rukegi but there will be pause and ManVik wont happen so soon

Bold: I'm with you there. I'm all for a girl confessing to a guy first but one needs to read the situation before doing so. There are times when there are signs the guy is also interested and you can see there are clear signs a relationship can be formed. Or if you like the guy and he seems available, it's also worth the gamble since he is available. In this case Vikrant is now off the market. What benefit is there in confessing. Mannat will scar herself for life and be off love and be scared to fall in love again.

Originally posted by: Mona_HappyLife

💯

Also Mannat did not even get any time to have some calm introspection related to Vikrant. Ladki kisi na kisi situation mei fass jati hai since she has joined Mezbani.

And when Vikrant was actually going to propose her, he fell ill and then all that chaos happened.

How is she even supposed to think straight ?

If only Vikrant after that night fiasco had taken some time to continue from were he stopped then today's fake engagement situation wouldn't have arisen but as bad luck they say Sunita passed away.

Also no self respecting girl be it Mannat or anyone would chase a guy who is committed to another girl who is her bestie. Ek toh sis code will break + incessant taunts of SM members. How much will a girl take??

Just like men have bro code system, girls have sis code too. 2 girls wont chase the same guy just like the boys wont chase the same girl.

Haina, this is why I was hoping they add Puneet to the mix so Vikrant gets a taste of his own medicine which he is giving Mannat. But alas, they want a 3rd angle and it has to be a girl like always

I don't know what's in store, but I don't want Mannat to confess until and unless Vikrant reveals this was all a fake drama he started to get her to confess.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Batao kyaa theory hain , I don't want Shaadi anyways

Sometimes I feel Vikrant doesn't pay attention to Mannat's emotional state and is in his own world since he realized he loves Mannat. Yesterday too got the same feeling after Mannat told him Malla is his kismat and how can she express anything to him💔.

Originally posted by: Bettyscar

Bold: I'm with you there. I'm all for a girl confessing to a guy first but one needs to read the situation before doing so. There are times when there are signs the guy is also interested and you can see there are clear signs a relationship can be formed. Or if you like the guy and he seems available, it's also worth the gamble since he is available. In this case Vikrant is now off the market. What benefit is there in confessing. Mannat will scar herself for life and be off love and be scared to fall in love again.

Bold, this exactly was what Mannat was telling Vikrant in yesterday's episode 😭.

Originally posted by: truptishree

Count me in. Even I didn’t find that dialogue odd. At first i did find it bit odd knowing his character but when I again listened it properly there is a different meaning to it. Whenever she will say no he will try to find a reason for her yes that means he will do something for it and wait for her that’s what I interpreted from that line. Hope I am making sense here.

About Mannat I agree without this drama IDT she would’ve realised what’s in her heart and she is still holding herself back because of the promise she made to Malla.

Again agree about FL. IDK why they want to show FL Mahan yaar? Show her like a normal girl and from this era where Girls don’t mind to propose a guy if they like him. Why every time boy has to propose? and as such nowadays girls are very bold and don’t mind to say what they feel👏👏

TBH I am confused about Mannat because we don’t see her pondering over about Vikrant. She is stuck on ARS but whenever she sees Vikrant with Malla then we see her sad face and feeling bad but then what? Understandable that she has things going on her back of the mind but then what about her heart and Vikrant.

I prefer a FL who will say what she wants irrespective of the outcome.

You know I used to watch one regional show and i loved it. Beautiful love story . Principles vs Love.

Both ML and FL used to open their mouth at right time and at right place. FL was not ready to accept that she loves ML but she gives in for love she has for ML. ML breaks up with her after knowing she lied to him that she is his Teacher’s daughter and he will never accept him as SIL but FL apologies to him, convince him that we will be together in this fight and we will persuade my father. She stands by ML against her father and they both convince him. TBH I loved this show because both ML and FL stood by their love and fought for it.

I would love to see this kind of story here. ML and FL actually fighting for their love. Here we see only ML making an efforts and FL is busy finding proofs.

Sometimes even I wonder for a moment keep aside Vikrant’s feelings but what about Mannat? What will be her limit to acknowledge her feelings openly?

We can judge Vikrant for this plan but at least that guy is making an effort so Mannat will acknowledge her feelings. Looking at Mannat IDT so she would’ve ever thought on those lines that she loves him. Because of this though it’s idiotic plan but it’s arousing feelings in Mannat be it jealousy or hurt seeing Vikrant with someone else. Hope she will openly acknowledge her feelings 🤞🧿

@Trupti loved your earlier review and agree with your thoughts on Vikrant.

And I’m with you and @Saichin on Vikku’s dialogue on her ‘no’. He isn’t forcing his yes on her ( his attempts to get close and intimate with her, he doesn’t feel is stepping over the line or not respecting her boundaries as it’s within his masterplan) but trying ways to convince her and bring out her realisation and confession.

As to why a FL can’t be the one proposing I totally agree but feel in situations where there is a class/wealth difference the middle class person’s intentions are clouded with not being after the other’s wealth. This would have to be focussed on a lot in the show and this story doesn’t have that track. To make it easier its the wealthier lead proposing to the less wealthier one. And this could be why they aren’t showing Mannat’s side of having fallen in love with him or fighting for her love until he has openly declared his love and to his family.

Mannat’s focus on ARS is shown very loosely, writers haven’t a strong plan on how it’s related to Shruti or saving her life/finding a donor….. I feel they need to have one scene of Mannat either visiting Shriti ma, or even getting emotional over her photo that they showed weeks ago, just to show Mannat’s priority is her mother.

Originally posted by: Rdigest

Batao kyaa theory hain , I don't want Shaadi anyways

Sometimes I feel Vikrant doesn't pay attention to Mannat's emotional state and is in his own world since he realized he loves Mannat. Yesterday too got the same feeling after Mannat told him Malla is his kismat and how can she express anything to him💔.

Abhi puri tarah se paki nahi hai.... was waiting for some BTS.. do you want a half cooked one?

Mannat is definitely going through grief though it's not been shown to us. She is trying to distract herself as much as she can, not get effected by Vikrant's proximity, hiding her sadness seeing Vikrant with Malla like in the chunari rasm, pushing him away and telling him he is taken😔.

I don't know from character perspective what else or how else can she convey to Vikrant to stop this since she does see he is trying to get her to confess from last episode, which is totally wrong from Mannat's point of view. Hoping they stick to Mannat not confessing and Vikrant backs out of this realizing how wrong this is considering even his family is not aware of this fake drama.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Abhi puri tarah se paki nahi hai.... was waiting for some BTS.. do you want a half cooked one?

Half cooked bhee chalega, we are stuck with the stale biryani we cooked for another week or so with the kind of BTS we have so far

Originally posted by: Shazia_h

@Trupti loved your earlier review and agree with your thoughts on Vikrant.

And I’m with you and @Saichin on Vikku’s dialogue on her ‘no’. He isn’t forcing his yes on her ( his attempts to get close and intimate with her, he doesn’t feel is stepping over the line or not respecting her boundaries as it’s within his masterplan) but trying ways to convince her and bring out her realisation and confession.

As to why a FL can’t be the one proposing I totally agree but feel in situations where there is a class/wealth difference the middle class person’s intentions are clouded with not being after the other’s wealth. This would have to be focussed on a lot in the show and this story doesn’t have that track. To make it easier its the wealthier lead proposing to the less wealthier one. And this could be why they aren’t showing Mannat’s side of having fallen in love with him or fighting for her love until he has openly declared his love and to his family.

Mannat’s focus on ARS is shown very loosely, writers haven’t a strong plan on how it’s related to Shruti or saving her life/finding a donor….. I feel they need to have one scene of Mannat either visiting Shriti ma, or even getting emotional over her photo that they showed weeks ago, just to show Mannat’s priority is her mother.

Bold , very well written and in this case Mannat has faced the discrimination and classist taunts every single day from the Salujas and Raisinghs even to the extent of calling her a thief and honey trapping Vikrant infront of Vikrant.