Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 8 - Page 44

Originally posted by: Aadi04

I am not enjoying this show .. it is too dark n depressing..

Yesterday episode I saw Vikrant is trying to protect Mannat from storm .. and they play wahe guru ..

But just last week one girl of the same age was Ra…. Why do they show Fl will be protected but other lesser mortals will be crushed..

Then Derek is going to get punished for life for something he never did .. are we supposed to call this the protagonist family

Will a simple sorry justify and make us root for Ronnie who choses to protect Vikrant n puneet and let young poor people who work for him Derek and Shalini get crushed ..

Bobby is not the only person who should get punished , ARS, Raveena , Ronnie all should be arrested for abetting the crime .. and hiding evidence

I cannot root for Vikrant as an employer or even as a ML because he failed Shalini and then failed Derek . What good this wahe guru wahe guru will do for him .,

I understand the frustration- what they are showing in name if drama is gruesome crimes that trigger lot of people but positive charcters acts like its some small family fued.

they should have kept it to kitchen politics, namak mirch dal ke dish karab kiya type issues. This murder ra*e and kidnapping is too much to deal as fictional plots for entertainment and see lackluster treatment.

I am loosing interest, too bad such good chemistry goes to waste due to poor creativity

Originally posted by: KarwaChothThali

I understand the frustration- what they are showing in name if drama is gruesome crimes that trigger lot of people but positive charcters acts like its some small family fued.

they should have kept it to kitchen politics, namak mirch dal ke dish karab kiya type issues. This murder ra*e and kidnapping is too much to deal as fictional plots for entertainment and see lackluster treatment.

I am loosing interest, too bad such good chemistry goes to waste due to poor creativity

Exactly.. kitchen politics , exam paper getting leaked all this can be brushed off , not murder , rape and kidnapping..

For me Bobby is not the only culprit right now .. there are 3 others who should get punished too for hiding the crime and trying to frame Derek an innocent in this

I think this is a channel directive, unfortunately.

Because a similar track ran in another Rangila show, couple of months ago, SA by someone in the family.

I know it is a hard watch

IPL plus Navratri...

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I think this is a channel directive, unfortunately.

Because a similar track ran in another Rangila show, couple of months ago, SA by someone in the family.

I know it is a hard watch

IPL plus Navratri...

Who wants to watch this on tv to boil their blood leaving Navratri and IPL?

Cutting Ravan promos of vamps before Ramnavmi, while IPL is ongoing shows their disconnect with viewers and adamancy to stick to their prerogative.

This rape track with unnecessary flash back scenes to assault scenes can attract perverts only. Mezbani hailed as bestplace to work after ra*e happened on its premises, making ml and other char be happy about it shows how tone deaf they are. Women don’t like that who are majority of viewers.

And, Evidently they are not getting trp for this BS track anyways.

Itv these days is more agenda driven. Dysfunctional family and infidelity is what they want to normalize- so such is content.

AT the end of this never ending track, I really hope Derek and Mannat quit Mezbaani. I know the FL has to find a way back but why should Derek?

Originally posted by: Aadi04

I am not enjoying this show .. it is too dark n depressing..

Yesterday episode I saw Vikrant is trying to protect Mannat from storm .. and they play wahe guru ..

But just last week one girl of the same age was raped brutally …. Why do they show Fl will be protected but other lesser mortals will be crushed..The scene of the crime was totally cleared .. and people were working normally as if nothing happened

Then Derek is going to get punished for life for something he never did .. are we supposed to call this the protagonist family

Will a simple sorry justify and make us root for Ronnie who choses to protect Vikrant n puneet and let young poor people who work for him Derek and Shalini get crushed ..

Bobby is not the only person who should get punished , ARS, Raveena , Ronnie all should be arrested for abetting the crime .. and hiding evidence

I cannot root for Vikrant as an employer or even as a ML because he failed Shalini and then failed Derek .
What good this wahe guru wahe guru will do for him .,

A true sardar will be fair to all and impartial .. not just protect the one who he is attracted to and bla bla bla

Totally agree with you. The innumerable negative aspects of the show makes truly enjoying the show,tough.

This ML isnt even bothered that the kitchen was cleaned up.

your point on playing waheguru for him is absolutely valid.

Lol ARS in this scene 🤣🤣🤣

https://x.com/Samson17406961/status/1909437082419806500?t=JtsA_23VMV4-6HAfaFB81g&s=19

I am late but finally watched the episode and loved it. So ARS was damn sure that Mannat with Harneet did that drama on road and dragged her inside the house. They found Bobby and Raveena’s passport in Mannat’s bag. All were questioning her why she did that?

Bobby was also threatening her. God! I just hated him the way he came near her good Ronny stopped him. TBH I really loved Mannat here the way she answered him and shoved him that was bloody brilliant. Ayesha was really amazing here🧿

Punnu was damn angry and tried to hit her but Vikrant came on time and stopped him.

Today I don’t want to get into details much about the episode because episode was full of accusations and manipulation. Mannat tried to prove she is right that Bobby assaulted Shalini and ARS,Bobby,Raveena tried to prove her wrong.

Only Vikrant and Gagan I found them sensible today , they wanted to hear what Mannat exactly have to say.

Vikrant thought may be Mannat is not comfortable showing proof in front of everyone so he wanted to talk alone even Gagan supported that. Gagan please always stay sober, you are indeed a smart guy.

I loved how he talked with Mannat. Such a stark difference between Gagan’s “beta” and Bobby’s “beta ji”. You can clearly feel that. Gagan’s is filled with love and Bobby’s with underlying lust. Seriously whenever he says Beta ji I just want to hit him🤬

ARS,Bobby and Raveena all were shocked that Mannat has proof. Only ManVik,Malla and Punnu were present when Mannat showed them that chain. Punnu was shocked because Mannat was indeed telling truth. Malla called everyone and told them that Mannat is telling the truth Bobby in fact is a culprit. Vikrant wanted to call cops and hand over that evidence to them so after investigation truth will be out and they will accept court’s decision regarding this case❤️

But Raveena stopped him and told him that this is not Bobby’s chain, she has Bobby’s chain. In fact Bobby was with her on that night and they were here in the house. She showed all of them that other chain.

Neetu was damn sure that chain with Mannat is Bobby’s because she only gifted him on their Wedding Anniversary. Ronny made her keep quiet. TBH I didn’t like Ronny here but you can clearly feel his dilemma. He was scared if he tells the truth then Raveena will bring Vikrant’s past and he can’t afford to loose Vikrant. Ronny I am really angry at you , you are also a part of this manipulation 😡

Vikrant thought that may be Mannat misunderstood because there are similar looking chain but Mannat was adamant that Bobby is lying and he should get punished for his crime then Vikrant lost his cool. Let’s see what happens next. Really looking forward to next episodes till Bobby’s truth comes out.

IDK about others but today I really felt bad for Vikrant. Such a devious family he has. They all are taking advantage of his pure soul. I just loved that he gave Mannat a fair chance to say and after seeing that picture on Punnu’s phone he wanted to call cops and hand over that evidence. He was ready to face those consequences but his family made him believe otherwise. I didn’t find his behaviour wrong because he did tell Mannat that I know this person from childhood and held his finger while learning to walk. He can’t do this(Wish he remembers his childhood). In fact I found him true to his character righteous ,he was ready to do the right thing.

Can we actually blame him for believing his family? We know Mannat is right but he doesn’t know that Bobby is actual culprit and his family is shielding him by producing fake evidence and fake narrative.

His Chachi showed him chain and told Bobby was with her then what he can do?

He thought maybe Mannat misunderstood because of chain and Shalini’s behaviour.

IDK why we can’t accept that ML can get influenced by his family,his emotions. If we change the scenario FL is at ML’s place then we will say poor girl! Look at her every body is taking advantage of her then why not for ML? Here also everyone is behind that kiddo. Everyone has an agenda when it comes to Vikrant. His parents they don’t want to reveal his past for their own selfish reasons. ARS, Bobby even Punnu and others behind his money and business.

If I remember correctly Shruti also manipulated Mannat by that fake photo of her so called Mom with the help of Harneet. She even deleted Sonia’s photo from Mannat’s phone. She lied to her for all those years that time we felt so bad for Mannat. We were like poor girl, Shruti should tell her the truth. Even now Harneet knows that Sunita is not Sonia but she is keeping quiet. This is also manipulation.

Vikrant is also getting manipulated by fake evidence and fake narratives that means is he dumbo? Him believing his family makes him wrong ? Then Mannat is also in same category of his. She also can’t sense so many wrong things are happening in front of her eyes.

If Mannat gets deceived by her Mom then so sad! poor girl! but when Vikrant gets deceived by his family then he is being stupid. Seriously hight of hypocrisy 💔

For everyone their family is important and I don’t think Vikrant was wrong. On the contrary I loved that he was ready to go against his Chachu because that chain belonged to him but Raveena played her game very well. Neetu said she gifted Bobby that chain if that chain is personalised then they might have a proof otherwise no use.

Anyways for me under the circumstances Vikrant’s behaviour and anger is justified. I think tomorrow we will get that famous “Get lost” dialogue.

P.S. I really loved today’s episode,everyone did good specially that Bobby actor. He was really brilliant.

For me today stars of the episodes are Adnan and Ayesha. They both were brilliant throughout the episode. Ayesha was so good specially where Mannat back answers and shoves Bobby. That was bloody brilliant ❤️🧿

Adnan he was so amazing yaar! His body language,expressions specially when he saw photo on the phone, that defeated look and when Mannat refused that angry look everything was just perfect and on point. ❤️🧿 just loved him. I literally felt bad for Vikrant yaar! No one should get a family like this. Everyone is selfish and using him as an excuse for their own selfish reasons.

I wanted to keep it short but look at my post😜

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I wrote my update before reading the others. This is an addendum because the episode is such - upsetting, explosive, thought provoking.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads...

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, and has the moral high ground, which Vikrant does'nt have in the latter half, but he does not disappoint initially.

For once, I watched the episode not as a Manvik but as a genuine viewer, because the episode has been executed like that. Vikrant's confusion, and ethical dilemma is extremely well depicted, Adnan is great as usual. His way of handling Mannat, his conflict with Puneet, the moment he questions Bobby, superb acting.

So is Abeer as Puneet, his pale face, his face when he looks at his father after seeing the chain...superb. His conflict when Vikrant says the police have to be called, on one hand he wants to do the right thing, but on the other, it is his father.

Ayesha as Mannat, she is superb in the initial part when Puneet questions, her, and the slow build up of anger on realising Bobby is going to get away. Her scorn for ARS, because she knows ARS knows and is hiding the truth. In the end, she has nothing to hold onto, but then she gets enraged and bursts out at Bobby. She does plead with Vikrant to believe her but the evidence is not supporting her.

Worst people and against whom our ire should be directed are Ronnie, Raveena and ARS. Ronnie is the biggest disappointment.

The episode is very well directed, well enacted. Superbly executed, the build up of each family member...each one stops short when Puneet or Raveena question...what if she says it is Ronnie (Vikrant)... what if she says it is Gagan (Keerat).

And that is how it is...a perp in the family is hard to accept. So for today i let Vikrant and Mannat be...their perspectives are built up very organically. Both are correct.

Worth a watch...I sincerely feel this show deserves to get good TRPs, because everything is so logical.

I also hope they wrap this up quickly...too much tension.

Word, the episode was great and infact it was explosive.

Bold red- these 3 were disgusting to the core and made me skip many scenes. I couldn't barely to see them on my screen 🤢

Originally posted by: scarlett22

AT the end of this never ending track, I really hope Derek and Mannat quit Mezbaani. I know the FL has to find a way back but why should Derek?

Mannat should quit the place aswell, the greatest Saluja - singhs restaurant