Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 8 - Page 43

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I wrote my update before reading the others. This is an addendum because the episode is such - upsetting, explosive, thought provoking.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads...

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, and has the moral high ground, which Vikrant does'nt have in the latter half, but he does not disappoint initially.

For once, I watched the episode not as a Manvik but as a genuine viewer, because the episode has been executed like that. Vikrant's confusion, and ethical dilemma is extremely well depicted, Adnan is great as usual. His way of handling Mannat, his conflict with Puneet, the moment he questions Bobby, superb acting.

So is Abeer as Puneet, his pale face, his face when he looks at his father after seeing the chain...superb. His conflict when Vikrant says the police have to be called, on one hand he wants to do the right thing, but on the other, it is his father.

Ayesha as Mannat, she is superb in the initial part when Puneet questions, her, and the slow build up of anger on realising Bobby is going to get away. Her scorn for ARS, because she knows ARS knows and is hiding the truth. In the end, she has nothing to hold onto, but then she gets enraged and bursts out at Bobby. She does plead with Vikrant to believe her but the evidence is not supporting her.

Worst people and against whom our ire should be directed are Ronnie, Raveena and ARS. Ronnie is the biggest disappointment.

The episode is very well directed, well enacted. Superbly executed, the build up of each family member...each one stops short when Puneet or Raveena question...what if she says it is Ronnie (Vikrant)... what if she says it is Gagan (Keerat).

And that is how it is...a perp in the family is hard to accept. So for today i let Vikrant and Mannat be...their perspectives are built up very organically. Both are correct.

Worth a watch...I sincerely feel this show deserves to get good TRPs, because everything is so logical.

I also hope they wrap this up quickly...too much tension.

You are just awesome ..this is what exactly i felt while watching the episode ..

Everyone’s pov was brilliantly shown. I just got irked by the chain evidence .m sure the makers would take care of it ..and was so angry when o saw ppl bashing Vikrant on X

Not going on X because I don’t seem to get their POV

Loved Vikrant when he showed disgust when he saw the evidence and also he stated that they should give it to police for investigation and whatever be the result ..we should accept it

Loved Mannat when she knows the truth and can’t afford to stay quiet because she knows the criminal deserves to be punished ..there is no other way to it

They couldn’t have executed it in a better way ..

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

tagging my team vikrant folks

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

I rewatched the episode ..Vikrant was actually calmly handling the entire situation ..and never for once he disbelieved mannat ..

He knows mannat from last 2 months and his family for the last 30 years It’s not easy for him to believe everything

The chain evidence ..let’s see what they do with it

I am back to loving Vikrant because as meg said ..he even offered. Mannat to go to someplace else a stalk about it .. It’s very unfair to expect everything proper and correct from Vikrant just because he is the ML and nothing from mannat

First of all she shouldn’t have kept the chain to herself but then she had no choice it time ..it was just overwhelming for her

All are right and wrong here .. It’s just emotions that they are getting swayed away

Big picture .. is being overlooked

Tagging you as well.

Originally posted by: scarlett22

I wrote my update before reading the others. This is an addendum because the episode is such - upsetting, explosive, thought provoking.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads...

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, and has the moral high ground, which Vikrant does'nt have in the latter half, but he does not disappoint initially.

For once, I watched the episode not as a Manvik but as a genuine viewer, because the episode has been executed like that. Vikrant's confusion, and ethical dilemma is extremely well depicted, Adnan is great as usual. His way of handling Mannat, his conflict with Puneet, the moment he questions Bobby, superb acting.

So is Abeer as Puneet, his pale face, his face when he looks at his father after seeing the chain...superb. His conflict when Vikrant says the police have to be called, on one hand he wants to do the right thing, but on the other, it is his father.

Ayesha as Mannat, she is superb in the initial part when Puneet questions, her, and the slow build up of anger on realising Bobby is going to get away. Her scorn for ARS, because she knows ARS knows and is hiding the truth. In the end, she has nothing to hold onto, but then she gets enraged and bursts out at Bobby. She does plead with Vikrant to believe her but the evidence is not supporting her.

Worst people and against whom our ire should be directed are Ronnie, Raveena and ARS. Ronnie is the biggest disappointment.

The episode is very well directed, well enacted. Superbly executed, the build up of each family member...each one stops short when Puneet or Raveena question...what if she says it is Ronnie (Vikrant)... what if she says it is Gagan (Keerat).

And that is how it is...a perp in the family is hard to accept. So for today i let Vikrant and Mannat be...their perspectives are built up very organically. Both are correct.

Worth a watch...I sincerely feel this show deserves to get good TRPs, because everything is so logical.

I also hope they wrap this up quickly...too much tension.

Ronnie gonna be more disappointing in future episodes IF Og plot is followed here i.e. Raveena takes revenge & tells everyone the secret of Aman once Bobby gets caught.

In OG, Ronnie starts disliking Mannat bcz of the secret of Aman being out.

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

Tagging you as well.

So no team manvik folks are tagged eh 😅

Thanks for the tag. Excellent analysis...

Whenever Vikrant walks into Saluja Mansion along with Malla, gharwale sab milke Mannat ki dhulai kar rahe hote hai...

Originally posted by: WittyKittyVixxy

Frankly I should actually be quitting ITV years ago. Coz I detest MLs being made to look to be successful and super rich businessmen yet so easily manipulated. I seriously want to kick their nuts to kingdom come.

Vikrant too gets manipulated by a bimbo like Malla & a sly fox like ARS. Heck he can’t even see through all the lying that goes on around him. He has never truly recognised ARS’ and Malla’s pattern of bad mouthing Mannat. I understand him believing his parents, but why all and rich sundry ??

Ayesha was superb today especially when she shoved Bobby and yelled at him. That shove will be the trigger for him to further want to hurt Mannat.

Right now, I am off Team ManVik coz the makers are dragging that too much. Right now forget jodi ki lovestory,just give me a guy who has brains & can connect dots and read people properly.

@Deepa sorry

BTW, how did Raveena get a DUPLICATE of a gift given by Neetu??

https://x.com/Samson17406961/status/1909444747753640177

Credit to the Twitter handle....I loved this bit.

She trusts him completely...

Originally posted by: WittyKittyVixxy

Frankly I should actually be quitting ITV years ago. Coz I detest MLs being made to look to be successful and super rich businessmen yet so easily manipulated. I seriously want to kick their nuts to kingdom come.

Vikrant too gets manipulated by a bimbo like Malla & a sly fox like ARS. Heck he can’t even see through all the lying that goes on around him. He has never truly recognised ARS’ and Malla’s pattern of bad mouthing Mannat. I understand him believing his parents, but why all and rich sundry ??

Ayesha was superb today especially when she shoved Bobby and yelled at him. That shove will be the trigger for him to further want to hurt Mannat.

Right now, I am off Team ManVik coz the makers are dragging that too much. Right now forget jodi ki lovestory,just give me a guy who has brains & can connect dots and read people properly.

@Deepa sorry

BTW, how did Raveena get a DUPLICATE of a gift given by Neetu??

I am not enjoying this show .. it is too dark n depressing..

Yesterday episode I saw Vikrant is trying to protect Mannat from storm .. and they play wahe guru ..

But just last week one girl of the same age was raped brutally …. Why do they show Fl will be protected but other lesser mortals will be crushed..The scene of the crime was totally cleared .. and people were working normally as if nothing happened

Then Derek is going to get punished for life for something he never did .. are we supposed to call this the protagonist family

Will a simple sorry justify and make us root for Ronnie who choses to protect Vikrant n puneet and let young poor people who work for him Derek and Shalini get crushed ..

Bobby is not the only person who should get punished , ARS, Raveena , Ronnie all should be arrested for abetting the crime .. and hiding evidence

I cannot root for Vikrant as an employer or even as a ML because he failed Shalini and then failed Derek .
What good this wahe guru wahe guru will do for him .,

A true sardar will be fair to all and impartial .. not just protect the one who he is attracted to and bla bla bla