Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 8 - Page 42

Episode Discussions

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.5k

Views

99.6k

Users

40

Likes

6.3k

Frequent Posters

Uma85 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Rdigest

It's a miragesmiley36. None of the Saluja's or singhs are what they appear from outside excluding Vikrant and Punnu. Yes Punnu did show something in his reaction today for a moment smiley42.

Rest are all in for their own selfish reasons and waiting to swallow each other like slithering snakes at the 1st opportunity they get.

I do agree Gagan might have his own hidden agenda but atleast when it comes to crime doings esp. when it is associated with Salujas , I felt no better person could support Mannat other than him !!!

Deepa11q thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 1 years ago

I rewatched the episode ..Vikrant was actually calmly handling the entire situation ..and never for once he disbelieved mannat ..

He knows mannat from last 2 months and his family for the last 30 years It’s not easy for him to believe everything

The chain evidence ..let’s see what they do with it

I am back to loving Vikrant because as meg said ..he even offered. Mannat to go to someplace else a stalk about it .. It’s very unfair to expect everything proper and correct from Vikrant just because he is the ML and nothing from mannat

First of all she shouldn’t have kept the chain to herself


All are right and wrong here .. It’s just emotions that they are getting swayed away

Big picture .. is being overlooked

Edited by Deepa11q - 1 years ago
Deepa11q thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Deepa11q

I rewatched the episode ..Vikrant was actually calmly handling the entire situation ..and never for once he disbelieved mannat ..

He knows mannat from last 2 months and his family for the last 30 years It’s not easy for him to believe everything

The chain evidence ..let’s see what they do with it

I am back to loving Vikrant because as meg said ..he even offered. Mannat to go to someplace else a stalk about it .. It’s very unfair to expect everything proper and correct from Vikrant just because he is the ML and nothing from mannat

First of all she shouldn’t have kept the chain to herself


All are right and wrong here .. It’s just emotions that they are getting swayed away

Big picture .. is being overlooked

tagging my team vikrant folks

kinu17 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: Lipstickqueen

I’m just reading updates. I can’t watch; it’s very disturbing. To be honest I’ll be shocked if Raveena and Ronnie get punished. I’m hoping they will but not confident. I don’t trust ITV women writers.

i have stopped watching too since many wks read the written update..enough..very disappointed, disturbing to watch all garbage from those adults 😕..I just dont know every single things in this world has been changed or upgraded but itv soaps r never change ..smiley29
scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago

Before reading the updates, I am going to write mine.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads to it.

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, which the morally correct one. There is no way she is wrong!

- ARS, drags Mannat to the Saluja hall, where she accuses her of stealing the passports. Puneet asks her very politely why, and she says there's a reason for it, she accuses Bobby of Shalini's rape. Puneet is going to hit her, when Vikrant enters with Malla...and stops him.

- Mannat states her case, clearly in front of everyone. She asks Malla to support her, tell people she doesn't lie, before that ARS stops Malla.Mannat says I asked her to vouch for me because she knows me for a long time.

Vikrant logically, tells her, I have known this man from my childhood. Therefore, I am asking you if you have proof, show it.

Puneet gets aggressive & Mannat cutely, goes and stands behind Vikrant. And concurrently, Vikrant very decently, says maybe Mannt is feeling awkward to talk in front of everyone, so can we talk in private. Puneet refuses saying let her say whatever in front of everyone. He asks Vikrant, would he have been this calm if she had accused Ronnie?

Gagan, again very calmly & in all decency says let's all move out, let's give Mannat a chance. SHe is Malla's friend, Vikrant's friend, give her that space. he asks Mannat specifically, did she talk about it to anyone. She refuses and he says to the others, she came to us first, tried to protect the family's name so she deserves a hearing.

So Vikrant, Puneet, Malla and Mannat are there, Mannat shows the necklace. Puneet compares it with his phone picture, and he becomes pale (brilliant, absolutely brilliant acting by Abeer). Vikrant is shocked.

Meanwhile, the disgusting people Raveena, ARS, Ronnie, are discussing what evidence could Mannat have? Neetu also comes there so everyone is tense.

Malla yells out to her mom loudly and everyone comes running to the hall. Vikrant says there's blood on the chain, we have to give it to police for examination, this is the question of two lives at stake. By this time, he has realised the enormity of what would happen, if the right person escapes. Shalini and Derek, two lives would be destroyed. Neetu clarifies that the chain was given by her, so she knows it is Bobby's.

As Vikrant calls the police, Raveena stops him and takes out a similar chain.

Next round of accusations on Mannat. Raveena, ARS takes turns at taunting her, ARS says, she is taking revenge on Puneet because he rejected her in the practical rounds. Puneet tells her he didn't expect this from her.

Mannat listens to everyone, is also comparing both the necklaces and bursts out in anger. That she knows the perp is Bobby. He calls everyone betaji, and finds excuses to touch young girls. She moves towards him while she says he should be hanged, that's when Vikrant steps in, pushes her away and episode ends.

Edited by scarlett22 - 1 years ago
WittyKittyVixxy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Frankly I should actually be quitting ITV years ago. Coz I detest MLs being made to look to be successful and super rich businessmen yet so easily manipulated. I seriously want to kick their nuts to kingdom come.

Vikrant too gets manipulated by a bimbo like Malla & a sly fox like ARS. Heck he can’t even see through all the lying that goes on around him. He has never truly recognised ARS’ and Malla’s pattern of bad mouthing Mannat. I understand him believing his parents, but why all and rich sundry ??

Ayesha was superb today especially when she shoved Bobby and yelled at him. That shove will be the trigger for him to further want to hurt Mannat.

Right now, I am off Team ManVik coz the makers are dragging that too much. Right now forget jodi ki lovestory,just give me a guy who has brains & can connect dots and read people properly.

@Deepa sorry

BTW, how did Raveena get a DUPLICATE of a gift given by Neetu??

nutmeg7 thumbnail
Posted: 1 years ago

Thank you for your detailed updates. smiley31

WittyKittyVixxy thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: scarlett22

Before reading the updates, I am going to write mine.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads to it.

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, which the morally correct one. There is no way she is wrong!

- ARS, drags Mannat to the Saluja hall, where she accuses her of stealing the passports. Puneet asks her very politely why, and she says there's a reason for it, she accuses Bobby of Shalini's rape. Puneet is going to hit her, when Vikrant enters with Malla...and stops him.

- Mannat states her case, clearly in front of everyone. She asks Malla to support her, tell people she doesn't lie, before that ARS stops Malla.Mannat says I asked her to vouch for me because she knows me for a long time.

Vikrant logically, tells her, I have known this man from my childhood. Therefore, I am asking you if you have proof, show it.

Puneet gets aggressive & Mannat cutely, goes and stands behind Vikrant. And concurrently, Vikrant very decently, says maybe Mannt is feeling awkward to talk in front of everyone, so can we talk in private. Puneet refuses saying let her say whatever in front of everyone. He asks Vikrant, would he have been this calm if she had accused Ronnie?

Gagan, again very calmly & in all decency says let's all move out, let's give Mannat a chance. SHe is Malla's friend, Vikrant's friend, give her that space. he asks Mannat specifically, did she talk about it to anyone. She refuses and he says to the others, she came to us first, tried to protect the family's name so she deserves a hearing.

So Vikrant, Puneet, Malla and Mannat are there, Mannat shows the necklace. Puneet compares it with his phone picture, and he becomes pale (brilliant, absolutely brilliant acting by Abeer). Vikrant is shocked.

Meanwhile, the disgusting people Raveena, ARS, Ronnie, are discussing what evidence could Mannat have? Neetu also comes there so everyone is tense.

Malla yells out to her mom loudly and everyone comes running to the hall. Vikrant says there's blood on the chain, we have to give it to police for examination, this is the question of two lives at stake. By this time, he has realised the enormity of what would happen, if the right person escapes. Shalini and Derek, two lives would be destroyed. Neetu clarifies that the chain was given by her, so she knows it is Bobby's.

As Vikrant calls the police, Raveena stops him and takes out a similar chain.

Next round of accusations on Mannat. Raveena, ARS takes turns at taunting her, ARS says, she is taking revenge on Puneet because he rejected her in the practical rounds. Puneet tells her he didn't expect this from her.

Mannat listens to everyone, is also comparing both the necklaces and bursts out in anger. That she knows the perp is Bobby. He calls everyone betaji, and finds excuses to touch young girls. She moves towards him while she says he should be hanged, that's when Vikrant steps in, pushes her away and episode ends.

loved this review. Expressed a lot of what I felt.


Deepa11q thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Vikrant

Posted: 1 years ago

Originally posted by: WittyKittyVixxy

Frankly I should actually be quitting ITV years ago. Coz I detest MLs being made to look to be successful and super rich businessmen yet so easily manipulated. I seriously want to kick their nuts to kingdom come.

Vikrant too gets manipulated by a bimbo like Malla & a sly fox like ARS. Heck he can’t even see through all the lying that goes on around him. He has never truly recognised ARS’ and Malla’s pattern of bad mouthing Mannat. I understand him believing his parents, but why all and rich sundry ??

Ayesha was superb today especially when she shoved Bobby and yelled at him. That shove will be the trigger for him to further want to hurt Mannat.

Right now, I am off Team ManVik coz the makers are dragging that too much. Right now forget jodi ki lovestory,just give me a guy who has brains & can connect dots and read people properly.

@Deepa sorry

BTW, how did Raveena get a DUPLICATE of a gift given by Neetu??

Lol why r u saying sorry to me?

See we all have different opinions ..that doesn’t make us right or wrong..

It’s matter of perspective ..

I am here for Adnan khan and honestly he is just nailing with his performance ..and the way Vikrant Saluja has been written ..m actually impressed ..he is not just a black and white character ..he has life in it ..he makes mistakes and also realises them ..

M all here for my Vikrant boy!!

And manvik..they are the most realistic couple u have seen..ppl fight and argue and yet are they for each other ❤️❤️❤️

scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 1 years ago

I wrote my update before reading the others. This is an addendum because the episode is such - upsetting, explosive, thought provoking.

First off, as much as we are dreading the 'get out', I will come to that later, because there's a scenario that leads...

Second of all, for all those bashing Vikrant, no, he does not come off badly in the episode.

Thirdly, for all those who might blame Mannat, she is also perfectly right in her perspective, and has the moral high ground, which Vikrant does'nt have in the latter half, but he does not disappoint initially.

For once, I watched the episode not as a Manvik but as a genuine viewer, because the episode has been executed like that. Vikrant's confusion, and ethical dilemma is extremely well depicted, Adnan is great as usual. His way of handling Mannat, his conflict with Puneet, the moment he questions Bobby, superb acting.

So is Abeer as Puneet, his pale face, his face when he looks at his father after seeing the chain...superb. His conflict when Vikrant says the police have to be called, on one hand he wants to do the right thing, but on the other, it is his father.

Ayesha as Mannat, she is superb in the initial part when Puneet questions, her, and the slow build up of anger on realising Bobby is going to get away. Her scorn for ARS, because she knows ARS knows and is hiding the truth. In the end, she has nothing to hold onto, but then she gets enraged and bursts out at Bobby. She does plead with Vikrant to believe her but the evidence is not supporting her.

Worst people and against whom our ire should be directed are Ronnie, Raveena and ARS. Ronnie is the biggest disappointment.

The episode is very well directed, well enacted. Superbly executed, the build up of each family member...each one stops short when Puneet or Raveena question...what if she says it is Ronnie (Vikrant)... what if she says it is Gagan (Keerat).

And that is how it is...a perp in the family is hard to accept. So for today i let Vikrant and Mannat be...their perspectives are built up very organically. Both are correct.

Worth a watch...I sincerely feel this show deserves to get good TRPs, because everything is so logical.

I also hope they wrap this up quickly...too much tension. smiley13

Related Topics

Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 40 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission given by leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 1 years ago

Permission given by Leprechaun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: purplegirl7 · 1 years ago

Welcome to Chat Corner for Mannat forum We can do gupshup here

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: nutmeg7 · 2 months ago

WRITTEN UPDATES AND DAILY DISCUSSION THREAD NO 39 Welcome to Mannat - Har Khushi Paane Ki EDT Permission given by leprecheun

Expand ▼
Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki thumbnail

Posted by: Shemer · 9 months ago

Welcome to BTS Thread of MHKPK...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".