Ramayan Canon Discussions|| DT NOTE P.20|| - Page 30

Originally posted by: ananya3129

What about your views about Uttara Kanda

I personally don't believe it as at the end of Yuddha kanda Valmiki ji has told Rama ruled for 10000 years and I like it that way. After going through so much they lived happily ever after and ehen time came they left for Vaikunth. I know Uttara Kanda shows the RamaRajya part and Mata Sita's sacrifices but still I think its an interpolation

Views well as i said I don't know vr or Rcm but yes scene twice uttar Ramayan part.

Ab usmein aage kya kahein

Rajyaabhishek ke baad ki story hai which everyone knows.

So I don't know what else to say here.

Originally posted by: ananya3129

What about your views about Uttara Kanda

I personally don't believe it as at the end of Yuddha kanda Valmiki ji has told Rama ruled for 10000 years and I like it that way. After going through so much they lived happily ever after and ehen time came they left for Vaikunth. I know Uttara Kanda shows the RamaRajya part and Mata Sita's sacrifices but still I think its an interpolation

I also don't feel it as Maharishi Valmiki's writing....I think in somewhere in end of Yuddhkand only...it's written that "this is it;this is Ramayan"....which sort of tells he is telling ;here ends ramayan.He sort of gave proper ending by such statements as u said Ram then ruled for 10000 years.He also states what is meaning of Ramrajya.

And I felt on reading Uttar kand that it somehow doesn't match Valmiki's way of writing;what we say in Hindi as "Shaili"...

I feel ki baad me Ramrajya ke ideals samjane ke liye ye addition kiya hoga as interpolation.

Probably this may be the reason why Tulsidas ji also stops on Lanka Kaand...and ends on Ram rajyabhishek and just gives avdhaarna of Ramrajya.He just mentions Luv Kush are sons of Siya Ram.

So here ending my pov, I may be wrong,,but I feel it as a later on addition to give glance of Raja Ram and ruling ideals and moral dilemma of Raja still why and how rajdharm needs to be kept above personal dharma like Sita maa parityag story and last me Lakshman parityag story.😊

I was referring to SKR

Originally posted by: ananya3129

I was referring to SKR

Yaar I hv to post twice as msg doesn't post 🤦

Skr means siya ke ram well I never saw the show toh what can I say

I saw only a bit as Ashish Sharma was there

But jitna dekha appeal nahi kiya so left it

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Yaar I hv to post twice as msg doesn't post 🤦

Skr means siya ke ram well I never saw the show toh what can I say

I saw only a bit as Ashish Sharma was there

But jitna dekha appeal nahi kiya so left it

That show is a dhabba.

I have watched some clips where Mandavi qas cheering for Ravan to win Swayamvar

Another one where Mata Sita was angry and scolding Lakshmana for cutting Shurpi's nose

These are some examples, there are a lot of these mangadhhan stories

Originally posted by: ananya3129

That show is a dhabba.

I have watched some clips where Mandavi qas cheering for Ravan to win Swayamvar

Another one where Mata Sita was angry and scolding Lakshmana for cutting Shurpi's nose

These are some examples, there are a lot of these mangadhhan stories

Yes idhar udhar I did hear that show was mutilated too much.

I wanted to see for Ashish as he was fantastic in gunahon ka devta and cgm

But here i couldn't just see

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Yes idhar udhar I did hear that show was mutilated too much.

I wanted to see for Ashish as he was fantastic in gunahon ka devta and cgm

But here i couldn't just see

Ashish is a great actor but for some reason I couldn't visualize him as Shri Rama, hence didn't watch the show.

Before Sujay I absolutely loved Gurmeet as Shri Rama. He gave those divine vibes.

Originally posted by: ananya3129

Ashish is a great actor but for some reason I couldn't visualize him as Shri Rama, hence didn't watch the show.

Before Sujay I absolutely loved Gurmeet as Shri Rama. He gave those divine vibes.

To be in skin of ramji woh calmness, softness and divine look hona chahiye

Which arunji had and which gurmeet had and now I see in sujay

But no offense no one else came close to looking like ramji

More ranting on SKR

There Ayodhya people were extremely regressive and only Mithla wale were progressive

Sunayana was worried for Sita' s alliance as she was not her biological child

Only Siya Ram had children but all three bros and sis were childless

Mithila wale knew about Vanvas beforehand

Matlab kuch bhi

Originally posted by: ananya3129

More ranting on SKR

There Ayodhya people were extremely regressive and only Mithla wale were progressive

Sunayana was worried for Sita' s alliance as she was not her biological child

Only Siya Ram had children but all three bros and sis were childless

Mithila wale knew about Vanvas beforehand

Matlab kuch bhi

X pe dangal krne walo mein I'm already there I've hated everything about that show, if I start, I wont stop

I had such high hopes with the way it began and to be honest their actors also weren't bad. But jo gandagi machai unhone .. bhagwan kasam.

And then few actors started defending whatever they were showing .. I gave up then, it was worse than trying to talk to a wall. Proper gonecase.