Katha Ankahee -- #15 daily EDT - Page 61

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

100.7k

Users

53

Likes

2.9k

Frequent Posters

Eternalallure thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: mango.falooda

after many months, I just watched some of last week's episodes. some thoughts:


my context:

I gave up on this show because I was irritated that viaan's transformation happened too suddenly and same with katha's acceptance. he didn't struggle in a logical way and all of a sudden became saintly which just made me roll my eyes.

their love story beginning was so meh because it didn't feel authentic at all. instead of tuning in, I tuned out they basically brushed the ONS under the rug and neither talked about it.

was so weird that katha was so nonchalant about what happened like she was regular on tinder/bumble type app and all of this is hota rahte hain types.

the other part of the love story that turned off viewers including myself was the inequality between katha and viaan. by becoming a saint, he went to the extreme where katha was always on top and he was on bottom. he was trying to make up for everything by putting her on a pedestal and it was always about what she wants.

so those were some of the reasons I totally lost interest with the show and especially with some really boring tracks that felt like vlogs, I dropped it months ago.


given that context, here is my view:

katha has always been an extreme mother and her relationship with aarav always felt strange. even the kid was weird with him acting like an adult at times. so I remember reading that one of the objections that maya had was that as a single mother, katha would always prioritize her son. basically maya was proved right.

from the onset, katha went beyond normal to save her son by agreeing to the ONS without even telling viaan what the money was for. it was always about her pride and her ego that she wouldn't lean on anyone and do it all herself.

she justified her actions that she was right in pursuing the ONS because it was for her son and viaan had committed a sin. that was then never really revisited. so she never struggled with the consequences of the night and having doubts about whether she did right or wrong. it was always about aarav and his needs.

if aarav had hated viaan, she would have rejected him from the start. she would have never even looked at viaan. there was no push pull to their story and everything happened too easy.

now, the truth came out, viaan got dumped and she didn't look back.

the new engagement is most like arranged marriage which the garewals set up. she sees aarav as needing a male presence in his life as she is not able to handle it. I won't be surprised if the new guy is closely related to the garewals and is actually some cousin or something. so she might see it as going back to the old circle.

for katha, aarav is always #1. if she can do ONS for him without blinking an eye, she would also get engaged and get married to someone else without batting an eye. even if she has feelings for viaan, she will push it down because everything is always about aarav.

viaan was from the beginning a distance #2. they never really had a push pull argument back and forth about the ONS track. he never fought back and just accepted that he was the bad guy.

she compartmentalized. by not fighting for viaan with the garewals, it shows that heart of heart, she still saw viaan as the sinner and herself as some innocent puppet. she has never accepted that what happened between them was her choice and it was consensual even if she was under duress.

basically viaan ends up being the bad guy while she gets to walk away. if she had fought for viaan, she would have to admit that what happened between them was her own doing to a certain extent.

so basically katha is being katha.

I don't know if you've watched the og or not, but compared to that ML, Viaan's journey was a lot more believable😂


As I've said before too, he's like the FL of the show. Too nice, too noble, loyal to a fault, too sacrificing, family-oriented. Apart from his one fault-his thinking about women-the man is shown almost saintly. And that sainthood just elevated in Katha's influence. Both mahaan people mixed their mahaanta and became the most mahaan couple ever. Saare human emotions and reactions khatam ho gye aur bas mahanta hi reh gyi.


Viaan gave her a free pass to walk all over him. His every action began to be taken with the goal to please katha. He felt guilty and that guilt drove every thought. He wanted Katha to stay at EC and that gave her an upper hand in professional space also. There's clearly a power imbalance in their relationship, and Katha is the one who wears the pants. She is driving the car and he is just riding shotgun. I hope this breakup balances out their relationship a bit more now. Or maybe tip the scales in his favour. He also deserves to be chased for once.

mango.falooda thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Eternalallure

I don't know if you've watched the og or not, but compared to that ML, Viaan's journey was a lot more believable😂


As I've said before too, he's like the FL of the show. Too nice, too noble, loyal to a fault, too sacrificing, family-oriented. Apart from his one fault-his thinking about women-the man is shown almost saintly. And that sainthood just elevated in Katha's influence. Both mahaan people mixed their mahaanta and became the most mahaan couple ever. Saare human emotions and reactions khatam ho gye aur bas mahanta hi reh gyi.


Viaan gave her a free pass to walk all over him. His every action began to be taken with the goal to please katha. He felt guilty and that guilt drove every thought. He wanted Katha to stay at EC and that gave her an upper hand in professional space also. There's clearly a power imbalance in their relationship, and Katha is the one who wears the pants. She is driving the car and he is just riding shotgun. I hope this breakup balances out their relationship a bit more now. Or maybe tip the scales in his favour. He also deserves to be chased for once.

I actually did watch the original in fan edit version many years ago -- so only couple scenes pretty much. I watched it out of pure curiosity as I heard the series was popular. initially I was wondering why any woman would find this ML attractive but over time, I got it. smiley36 but yea, I enjoyed what I saw of the original. the ML never lost his spine. I really want to watch the arabic version which I heard is excellent but I can't find it. sigh.

viaan's turn for sainthood just made my eye roll. nothing about it made sense to me. we can all say that we have faced situations that made us change but none of us changed in instant for the better and that to sainthood. that is just bakwas. 😂😂😂 the truth is we all struggle with changes whatever it brings. we push against it and it is more like inch by inch change especially when it has to do with long held wounds and negative thoughts.

I have said this before but viaan entered into a cult when he fell in love. everything was about how he saw the light and katha is his sun or some nonsense. 😂 so from the start, she was walking all over him and he like an idiot basically acted like she is CEO. he stopped pushing back or even challenging her at any turn. when you give in to all the time, there is no respect or appreciation from others because they know they can walk all over you and you will take it with a smile.

the scene where he was begging and pleading with her just made me eye roll. where is the anger? where is the self-respect? so yea, he needs to grow a spine. he needs to respect himself and feel he is worthy of love and not beg for tidbits. he should be his own light.

Eternalallure thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: mango.falooda

I actually did watch the original in fan edit version many years ago -- so only couple scenes pretty much. I watched it out of pure curiosity as I heard the series was popular. initially I was wondering why any woman would find this ML attractive but over time, I got it. smiley36 but yea, I enjoyed what I saw of the original. the ML never lost his spine. I really want to watch the arabic version which I heard is excellent but I can't find it. sigh.

viaan's turn for sainthood just made my eye roll. nothing about it made sense to me. we can all say that we have faced situations that made us change but none of us changed in instant for the better and that to sainthood. that is just bakwas. 😂😂😂 the truth is we all struggle with changes whatever it brings. we push against it and it is more like inch by inch change especially when it has to do with long held wounds and negative thoughts.

I have said this before but viaan entered into a cult when he fell in love. everything was about how he saw the light and katha is his sun or some nonsense. 😂 so from the start, she was walking all over him and he like an idiot basically acted like she is CEO. he stopped pushing back or even challenging her at any turn. when you give in to all the time, there is no respect or appreciation from others because they know they can walk all over you and you will take it with a smile.

the scene where he was begging and pleading with her just made me eye roll. where is the anger? where is the self-respect? so yea, he needs to grow a spine. he needs to respect himself and feel he is worthy of love and not beg for tidbits. he should be his own light.

There's an Arabic version too? I didn't know that. I think the OG one was popular more because the leads' were a couple in reality too. Or they became one after the show or something like that. I just know they have kids too.


I had a lot of problems with the OG one. Especially relating to the leads. Viaan attained sainthood, and that OG one never changed. He was distrustful of women from start to finish, and of his wife too. The surveillance, getting her secretly followed, checking her mails, getting suspicious of every male colleague, berating her for getting a write-up in some magazine or whatever, keeping things from her. Neither did his mentality regarding women changed in general. His issues just weren't addressed. Just because he loved the FL very much, his negative qualities were supposed to be forgiven. There were some admirable qualities in him, but overall he was such a red flag. And the FL was a selfish, narcissistic, stubborn red flag too. So, I guess they both were match made in heavensmiley36


Viaan, on the other hand, became such a green flag he could have been used as a traffic light.smiley37

So focussed he was on the light of the jugnu, he couldn't see the bad attributes of it. Put her on a pedestal and almost worshipped her. She could never be wrong in his eyes. I guess love really is blindsmiley36

As they say, the one who loves more hurts more smiley13

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: mango.falooda

I actually did watch the original in fan edit version many years ago -- so only couple scenes pretty much. I watched it out of pure curiosity as I heard the series was popular. initially I was wondering why any woman would find this ML attractive but over time, I got it. smiley36 but yea, I enjoyed what I saw of the original. the ML never lost his spine. I really want to watch the arabic version which I heard is excellent but I can't find it. sigh.

viaan's turn for sainthood just made my eye roll. nothing about it made sense to me. we can all say that we have faced situations that made us change but none of us changed in instant for the better and that to sainthood. that is just bakwas. 😂😂😂 the truth is we all struggle with changes whatever it brings. we push against it and it is more like inch by inch change especially when it has to do with long held wounds and negative thoughts.

I have said this before but viaan entered into a cult when he fell in love. everything was about how he saw the light and katha is his sun or some nonsense. 😂 so from the start, she was walking all over him and he like an idiot basically acted like she is CEO. he stopped pushing back or even challenging her at any turn. when you give in to all the time, there is no respect or appreciation from others because they know they can walk all over you and you will take it with a smile.

the scene where he was begging and pleading with her just made me eye roll. where is the anger? where is the self-respect? so yea, he needs to grow a spine. he needs to respect himself and feel he is worthy of love and not beg for tidbits. he should be his own light.


Well, excluding the recent development where he is literally pleading till death and not going away I found his character development much more believable.


I haven't seen the OG but, from what I have heard, OG ML was a literal douchebag. However, Viaan wasn't that big of a douchebag. He had some good character traits before the ONS offer as well which were shown on screen. He knew how to behave with her mother and his other women employees. He also straight up fired Shamita (also, it was the same day his father died and Teji was holding a paath at her house for him) instead of saying anything else and probably handled her for many days before which were not shown. So, he was a good human being overall except for his flawed mentality. After ONS offer, we got to see more development and got to know more about his character about all his goodness and stuff which were supposed to be present before ONS. So, I found his transition believable.


His sainthood took time. I think it happened after he proposed to Katha. His resentment towards his father's 2nd wife took time and he still had biases against her for a very long time.


But, after recent development, he needs to stop following around and grow a spine.

Tenochtitlan thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Eternalallure

There's an Arabic version too? I didn't know that. I think the OG one was popular more because the leads' were a couple in reality too. Or they became one after the show or something like that. I just know they have kids too.


I had a lot of problems with the OG one. Especially relating to the leads. Viaan attained sainthood, and that OG one never changed. He was distrustful of women from start to finish, and of his wife too. The surveillance, getting her secretly followed, checking her mails, getting suspicious of every male colleague, berating her for getting a write-up in some magazine or whatever, keeping things from her. Neither did his mentality regarding women changed in general. His issues just weren't addressed. Just because he loved the FL very much, his negative qualities were supposed to be forgiven. There were some admirable qualities in him, but overall he was such a red flag. And the FL was a selfish, narcissistic, stubborn red flag too. So, I guess they both were match made in heavensmiley36


Viaan, on the other hand, became such a green flag he could have been used as a traffic light.smiley37

So focussed he was on the light of the jugnu, he couldn't see the bad attributes of it. Put her on a pedestal and almost worshipped her. She could never be wrong in his eyes. I guess love really is blindsmiley36

As they say, the one who loves more hurts more smiley13


There are huge cultural differences between turkey and India. Unlike India which is brimming with pseudo-feminist shows on the other hand, in Turkey (in many arab countries as well), many things which are violation of women's rights for us, are normal in their religion and their country as well. Also, their shows are a bit gender neutral.


Indianization of this show was really important or else this show would have never prospered in India if adapted directly.


One of the reason I liked this show was because, it was gender neutral. Katha apologised and thanked Viaan on many occassions even though she didn't liked Viaan around her because she felt the need to. I don't remember the last time I saw something like this from a female lead. But now, it is taking the same route as many of the ITV shows of that of pseudo-feminism


If you ask me and yourself as well, you would not have sympathized with Viaan right now if his redemption was not shown as it was shown on screen. You would have not forgiven Viaan. Asking for ONS at workplace is in itself big of crime. Viaan didn't find Katha at bar for a hookup that he offered her money for a night. Indian audiences would have never accepted the story if Viaan's redemption wasn't shown as it was shown.


Their pair was absolutely fine. They had a great understanding and story should have ended at them getting married and living happily ever after. But, alas, it is a show and writers write the fate not the characters so, the weird development happened and now entire character of Katha is being questioned.

Edited by abca19510 - 2 years ago
wrongturn722 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: Eternalallure

As they say, the one who loves more hurts more smiley13

Sun'ne walon suno aisa bhi hota hai

Dil deta hai jo woh jaan bhi khota hai

Pyaar aisa jo karta hai

Kya mar ke bhi marta hai

Aao tum bhi aaj sun lo........

😌🙂

Anj_01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: wrongturn722

Na na, keep going ... Your rant against katha and gawarwals is more interesting than entire show...

I can keep listening to people bashing katha and peeps in the show for hours

Sukoon 😌

And yes, bring Viaan 1.0 back....

Afterall katha indeed is being a gold digger and proved viaan 1.0 correct na... So, he also needs to come back to neutralise katha the poisonous


Katha - the poisonous smiley37

I like the name

Wait.... doesn't it means a poisonous woman as in Katha naginsmiley37

After all usne viaan ko dasa hi hai.

kinu17 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: wrongturn722

Sun'ne walon suno aisa bhi hota hai

Dil deta hai jo woh jaan bhi khota hai

Pyaar aisa jo karta hai

Kya mar ke bhi marta hai

Aao tum bhi aaj sun lo........

😌🙂

3d smileys graphicsyaar if u recite this kind of sher then tears fell from eyes..dil toh baccha hai jee..smiley13smiley36 waise hi devdaas has promised to visit only for his shayeri in to the jail to his jail friends and for jailer saab..feel bad for devdaas him now yahaan aap bhi sher shayeri karoge toh hai rabba..smiley36
kinu17 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: wrongturn722

I guess many old viewers might be having same thoughts...

But my reason for following DT and this show's forum is this forum and people talking here gives a feeling of yes I'm not alone and there are people whom I can look upto... This forum doesn't make me feel much lonely as whenever I feel like it, I visit KA, SRGMP, Indian Idol forum and see people expressing and many people think the way I'm thinking regarding something too... That's why even the show went from bad to worst still I'm here to see people bashing the show, the characters and makes me feel like yeah I'm not the only one bashing... People are there too 😌🙌

u r rite..i watch this show or not it doesnot matter once a day or few times i love to visit this forum coz some funny comments make me happy .,after few comments i read understand story mai whats cooking..smiley36.i always write funny comments coz according to me its fantasy indian show, plus i am not doing PHD abt this show thus no patience for to write loooooooooong comment as thesis smiley12 smiley36 no arguments ,fighting for nothing thus like to visit this gali mai..Thanks emoticons

https://youtu.be/kaOIxll4LCA?si=FkROMGxjj0RDtW9K

Edited by kinu17 - 2 years ago
wrongturn722 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago

Originally posted by: kinu17

3d smileys graphicsyaar if u recite this kind of sher then tears fell from eyes..dil toh baccha hai jee..smiley13smiley36 waise hi devdaas has promised to visit only for his shayeri in to the jail to his jail friends and for jailer saab..feel bad for devdaas him now yahaan aap bhi sher shayeri karoge toh hai rabba..smiley36

Mai kya ji... Gaana hai ji ye to...

Om Shaanti Om movie ka...

Lo ji aap bhi sun lo ji

https://youtu.be/ymuNkKuToao?si=TmfZHhUC9tveCY6U


Hakuna Matata, Yani koi chinta nahi

Hakuna Matata, Mil kar lute maze.

Maro tang aur zindgi kar lo sidhi,

gum ko maro goli, bato khushi...

Hakuna matata... Timon aur pumba 😌❤️

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".