Give Shefali Birla her voice

Mahima, Parth and Shivu have plans to suck the life out of Abhir.

A senior doctor should have some knowledge of child psychology. Mahima rightly pointed out inconsistencies in Manjiri's behaviour however at the same time physically intimidates a six year old.

This track won't work, meaning we are watching child abuse.

Shefali hasn't opened up at all.

Abhimanyu retaliated when the situation went out of control otherwise he is in denial.

too much of negativity won't do good.

Shivu can cause permanent damage. Shefali is the right person to bring Birlas back to their senses provided she opens her mouth

First of all it's very obvious for a child to get jealous of other kids for many different reasons , especially when it comes to family . Whether someone accepts it or disdains it , that's child psychology and expecting a kid to behave 'mahaan' beyond his natural instincts is ignorance.

Shivu needs to be told that he has his own place which is irreplaceable especially with respect to his parents and yes his violent aspect and bullying does needs to be corrected.

How abhi is in denial? By asking his kid to stay with him?

He's the only person actively trying to make a safe environment for kids- ruhi shiv and abhir for all of them. He has raised points to his mom and whoever has wronged the kid. Just walking out of a problem isn't long term solution.

Originally posted by: Phir_Mohabbat

How abhi is in denial? By asking his kid to stay with him?

He's the only person actively trying to make a safe environment for kids- ruhi shiv and abhir for all of them. He has raised points to his mom and whoever has wronged the kid. Just walking out of a problem isn't long term solution.

Which problem? Manjari problem ?

Originally posted by: Phir_Mohabbat

How abhi is in denial? By asking his kid to stay with him?

He's the only person actively trying to make a safe environment for kids- ruhi shiv and abhir for all of them. He has raised points to his mom and whoever has wronged the kid. Just walking out of a problem isn't long term solution.

Did he ask Abhir do you want to stay with me? Mama aur Papa ne kya bola apko? counsellors are absolutely necessary in Abhir's case.

Screenplay writer Bhavna Vyas has absolutely no clue about the mental turmoil that goes on in six year old.

Abhir does not exhibit age appropriate behaviour.

Abhimanyu hasn't recognised basic symptoms of withdrawal in his own child

Ether he has taken Abhir for granted or overlooked his state of mind.

No offense to anyone.

My post is a pointer to all those MBBS grads in Birla house. Family members are living under one roof without any bonding. Relationships aren't healthy at all, therefore a tilt in the balance disturbs entire household.

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Did he ask Abhir do you want to stay with me? Mama aur Papa ne kya bola apko? counsellors are absolutely necessary in Abhir's case.

Screenplay writer Bhavna Vyas has absolutely no clue about the mental turmoil that goes on in six year old.

Abhir does not exhibit age appropriate behaviour.

Abhimanyu hasn't recognised basic symptoms of withdrawal in his own child

Ether he has taken Abhir for granted or overlooked his state of mind.

No offense to anyone.

My post is a pointer to all those MBBS grads in Birla house. Family members are living under one roof without any bonding. Relationships aren't healthy at all, therefore a tilt in the balance disturbs entire household.

ITV will use domestic violence, physical/ mental disabilities as a drama plot device for it's convenience always, but will never use such tracks to inform the audience of the importance of people being given the help they need or learning to seek help. Such tracks are wrapped up without appropriate conclusions, with deep-rooted and/or serious mental health issues of characters just disappearing when writers choose to shift the story another direction. This is exactly what they did with akshara's panic attacks and abhi's anxiety/ depression.

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Mahima, Parth and Shivu have plans to suck the life out of Abhir.

A senior doctor should have some knowledge of child psychology. Mahima rightly pointed out inconsistencies in Manjiri's behaviour however at the same time physically intimidates a six year old.

This track won't work, meaning we are watching child abuse.

Shefali hasn't opened up at all.

Abhimanyu retaliated when the situation went out of control otherwise he is in denial.

too much of negativity won't do good.

Shivu can cause permanent damage. Shefali is the right person to bring Birlas back to their senses provided she opens her mouth

@bold sge doesn’t deserve to be called a doctor…this shows writers have lost it …kiss practicing surgeon ke paas yeh gharelu draame karne ka time rehta hai first of all

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Did he ask Abhir do you want to stay with me? Mama aur Papa ne kya bola apko? counsellors are absolutely necessary in Abhir's case.

Screenplay writer Bhavna Vyas has absolutely no clue about the mental turmoil that goes on in six year old.

Abhir does not exhibit age appropriate behaviour.

Abhimanyu hasn't recognised basic symptoms of withdrawal in his own child

Ether he has taken Abhir for granted or overlooked his state of mind.

No offense to anyone.

My post is a pointer to all those MBBS grads in Birla house. Family members are living under one roof without any bonding. Relationships aren't healthy at all, therefore a tilt in the balance disturbs entire household.

Why abhi should ask abhir when his so called parents ruthlessly crushed his little heart by telling him go stay with your bio dad as u are a burden to us? Like abhir abhi wasn't given a choice too to gently tell abhir the truth. That's what abhi was screaming other day to ak on case u missed it . Abhir himself was like let's go to your home, and abhi has understood since the first time abhir is in depressed mode. He's trying to ask him, telling him to forgive his mom. Writing 6 year old lmao this same kid was destroying people's property back on kasauli. In some serials kids play cupid to bring leads together, leads ask kids for love advice. Yckkh was never an ideal written show that now they will decide to properly write a kid. Who was brought to force so called leap.

Birlas were always like this no denial on this. But goenkas aren't ideal too - lying to each other and playing happy family for the heck of it. This same family had so many broken relationship - kartik didn't talk to his dad for years, naira wasn't happy here, mimi was a witch, Manish was reason for this abhir mess, they have raised three criminal kids. If you mean Sharma's are ideal lol nope. No family is perfect here doesn't mean abhi is the only person has to understand and give up. Him winning custody is the only thing running the show. Or else we will get 1000 round of ak ka gloating on how she's purrrfect maa with her purrfect Phamily 🤣🤣😏

Originally posted by: Krinya

Which problem? Manjari problem ?

No one says Goenkas r sane

We all have seen their toxicity in S2 and their hypocrisy and nonsense in S3.

Idk whenever Birlas r called out for toxicity why Goenkas r brought in between.

Birla house is the shittiest place to live in.