Abhimanyu the victim.........

Blurlaa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#1

This is the dumbest narrative I have seen on here and in all honesty I was going to ignore it until I saw people shifting the blame to Akshara. Abhimanyu doesn't deserve any rights towards Abhir, him missing Abhir's life is all because of his own actions. People keep saying that "Oh Akshara could have tried harder to reach out to him", how much did you want here to reach out to him, how much. She tried, Abhinav tried, heck even Manish tried and he didn't budge once and don't tell me Akshara didn't know that Manish had asked him to come with him cause she heard BP saying Abhimanyu didn't want to come and this wasn't over the span of one day, it was over multiple, maybe even multiple months. People can make rash decisions in anger but over that time did he even once think how Akshara was or where and what she was doing by herself?


White Day for one was not Akshara's fault. People keep saying she should've prioritized her kids and Neil but what kind of parent are you going to be towards your kids if you knew you had the chance to save those kids and chose to do nothing and those kids died. Even with calling the police and leaving the scene, the kids probably would've still died and Akshara who was about to be a newborn mother, how'd you think she'd feel if those kids died and how would she be able to look at her own children with the death of all those kids hanging in her conscience, providing her with extreme guilt. Akshara wasn't trying to get her kids killed, nor did she at the moment realise what result her actions would end up having. and for Neil, Neil was not a kid, nor was he manipulated or gaslighted by Akshara into going there, he went in there because he as a person who was about to be a father wasn't willing to find out what would happen to those kids if they didn't do anything. Neil could've gone away, he could've taken Akshara with him but he chose to be there that day and in turn Akshara risked her life to save him. What happened as a result - Neil died and Akshara lost 1 of the twins. She just miscarried, thought she lost both her kids and her brother in law and was probably feeling a lot of piled up guilt as a result and you could see her apologise to Abhimanyu multiple times but what came of her apologies and sadness? Divorce, getting kicked out of the house, being blamed for multiple deaths that happened because of unfortunate circumstances. Abhimanyu is a doctor and so he must've seen many women who have miscarried over his time at the hospital but even though he was a doctor do you know what he did, he focused on his pain, his sadness, his loss. I get that your angry and I get that you've lost a lot but you aren't the only one who has lost stuff, Akshara has too but Abhimanyu was too far gone in his own anger to see that.


Heck he even went so far to push on a bruise Aarohi had created and said that Aarohi was right, Akshara was the reason Sirat was dead. Now like I said above I get that people make rash decisions in anger and pain but Abhimanyu had so much time, so much time. Not once even in 7 months did he even think to call and talk to Akshara or even realise that how much wrong had happened to her as well, meanwhile Akshara on the other hand was completely willing to forget how unfairly she had been treated, all the insults she had got and tried to communicate with Abhimanyu that one of the babies was still alive but Abhimanyu never let her finish her talk or Abhinav's talk and no wonder Akshara doesn't want the man who kicked her out at her lowest to be in her sons life as a father over the man who supported her at her lowest and saved her and her son. Heck we saw another example of Abhimanyu unwilling to listen to what she said again after Kairav impulsively handed Abimanyu court papers and people still question why Akshara doesn't love Abhimanyu or want him in her son's life. People also say "Oh Akshara didn't need to deal with all this inconvenience, she could've gone back to her home", why the hell would she ever want to go home?? especially after she overheard her own grandfather take Abhimanyu's side and blame Akshara for everything that happened.


Abhimanyu and his mother are all about hypocrisy. He tells Akshara not to interfere with his family matters (completely ignoring they were now her family too) but constantly drags himself into her family matters without asking if she wants or needs his help. He berates her for hiding Abhir's parentage truth but defends his mother for hiding Neil's parentage truth. I'm sorry but in no way, do I find Abhimanyu to be the victim in all this as his lack of empathy, trust and care for Akshara are what led to his situation. You can keep trying to deny that he's not toxic, it doesn't change what's shown in the show. For example, on his sons birthday when his son hugs him, he's grinning at Akshara and Abhinav instead of being happy his son hugged him, thats how pathetic his character is. Also, whether people want to ignore it or not, Abhimanyu literally gaslit Akshara into confessing to him because he practically told her would commit suicide otherwise. He also divorced her the first time in a rash decision, a precedent for his actions on white day and is unwilling and unable to communicate with her. and then after the 6 year leap, he miraculously remembers Akshara is the love of his life?? Did he conveniently just forget it on White Day or the 6 months after when Akshara was giving birth to Abhir or even during the 6 year period.

And when finally he realised about his so called love, he didn't apologise for his actions and instead told Akshara that they complete each other and she should leave her husband and her son and her life in Kasauli to come back to him and also in the process ignored his and Aarohi's relationship and Ruhi. He says he cares about Ruhi but ditched and barely called her to go live with Abhir for a month and in his month there, interferes in conversations he has no rights to be included in and makes demands. His mother also isn't any better and now is willing to destroy Abhinav's life and Aarohi and Ruhi's in order to make her sons life complete. She herself got pissed and made a big noise about Abhirs paternity but when it came to Neil she allowed him to become a source of mockery in their household and got pissed at Akshara when she indirectly told Neil the truth. Heck she even made Abhir feel he was dirty before she realised that he was Abhimanyu's son. These 2 are horrible people and only do good things when it suits them or makes them look nice to others.

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

5.3k

Users

17

Likes

135

Frequent Posters

Ajab.Pehchan thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#2

From now on my caps will be doing the talking

IMG_3714.jpeg

Edited by Criticiser - 2 years ago
Posted: 2 years ago
#3

I have said this multiple times, but it's about perspective. People can choose to like whomever they want. Lots of people like Abhi because of who he is; all the negatives, so to speak, are actually positives. Obviously, not how the events transpired, but his reactions to things are more understandable than Ak's. That is all. In general, no one is really right. They are all just characters looking at things from their own perspective.

Priyrabha thumbnail
Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail 4th Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 2 years ago
#4

Yaar your words are true.

focus7 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 2 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: lagjagale

I have said this multiple times, but it's about perspective. People can choose to like whomever they want. Lots of people like Abhi because of who he is; all the negatives, so to speak, are actually positives. Obviously, not how the events transpired, but his reactions to things are more understandable than Ak's. That is all. In general, no one is really right. They are all just characters looking at things from their own perspective.

I am not denying that AbhiM didn’t go through a lot of pain during white day. He didn’t follow up after he came to know she married someone, to an extent I can understand he feels hurt. But what about the time in between, the 7 months, what about after few months didn’t he get curious on why his ex wife called him? Is she okay? Didn’t he realise his mistakes then? There is no justification for this and I can never like him for it, in top of not realising he goes on to propose a married woman, claiming they are soulmates. This not just a perspective difference or a grey shade behaviour.

The abhiM now may have calmed down, maybe he is in the path of redemption, but still equally dense. Now since arohi is arohi, doesn’t mean whatever he is doing to her is right. He is repeating the same mistakes, cut off the relationship and explain to Ruhi like an adult would.

Everyone is flawed, but among the flawed chars in yrkkh, I choose abhinav Akshara and tbh arohi( the curren arohi, and only if she doesn’t flip obv) even over abhiM

Anyways it’s ITV, and most folks watch ITV for the ships which is fine, as long as they can accept what is right and wrong, not give endless justifcaruons and twisted reasoning for wrongdoings of a character. Fans do it even if the char onscreen accept their faults. Above statement is not for you especially, just a general statement after reading multiple posts.

Posted: 2 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: focus7

I am not denying that AbhiM didn’t go through a lot of pain during white day. He didn’t follow up after he came to know she married someone, to an extent I can understand he feels hurt. But what about the time in between, the 7 months, what about after few months didn’t he get curious on why his ex wife called him? Is she okay? Didn’t he realise his mistakes then? There is no justification for this and I can never like him for it, in top of not realising he goes on to propose a married woman, claiming they are soulmates. This not just a perspective difference or a grey shade behaviour.

The abhiM now may have calmed down, maybe he is in the path of redemption, but still equally dense. Now since arohi is arohi, doesn’t mean whatever he is doing to her is right. He is repeating the same mistakes, cut off the relationship and explain to Ruhi like an adult would.

Everyone is flawed, but among the flawed chars in yrkkh, I choose abhinav Akshara and tbh arohi( the curren arohi, and only if she doesn’t flip obv) even over abhiM

Anyways it’s ITV, and most folks watch ITV for the ships which is fine, as long as they can accept what is right and wrong, not give endless justifcaruons and twisted reasoning for wrongdoings of a character. Fans do it even if the char onscreen accept their faults. Above statement is not for you especially, just a general statement after reading multiple posts.


First, they had a different track in mind until the first Udaipur visit. So they showed that during the seven months, Abhi was just busy trying to keep Manjari alive and Arohi stable since they were both critical. Even that famous phone call happened while Manjari was getting an attack. But......somehow, none of that is even discussed now. Whatever Abhi went through at that time is thrown under the rug to fit the narrative that he didn't care about Ak so she gets to not care about his rights as a father. Knowing Abhi, the person who was okay with giving up his fatherhood for Ak's safety, who was unwilling to take even a 10% chance with Ak's health, he would never have ignored her for seven months. Hence people don't accept white day or the seven months after that or this whole leap cause it's just not Abhi.


Second, the temple confession I wholeheartedly support, lol. I have no qualms about it. With a love story like theirs, it is not entirely inconceivable that Ak might still love him, especially after he saw her running to him and holding him like she would die if something happened to him. And if there is love, then the barriers of society don't really matter - that's what Abhi was thinking. He was under a lot of drugs and had a lot of conflicting emotions, and I feel like he just took the chance because she was leaving Udaipur forever.


But to your last statement, in my opinion, Abhi has done nothing wrong in confessing to Ak. He loved her; what is the point of not confessing and marrying someone else? It's much better to get things out in the open, no matter whose sentiments they may hurt. Ak rejected as she should, and that is that.

Posted: 2 years ago
#7

Agree with all you said!

I am sad why he had to pull akshara in middle of pheras. Can't he wait till wedding is over. She missed the best moment of brothers marriage And in precap MAA beta so impatient to tell him truth.

I don't even want to talk about Manjiri. They are just concerned about them. Selfishness at it's peak.

Susi26 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3

Team Critics

Posted: 2 years ago
#8

People sympathise with Abhimanyu because of his lonely life in those 6 years. He cannot love anyone except Akshara, What happened on white day is purely because of Ak’s negligence and Abhimanyu’s arrogance.

Suppose in those 6 years Abhimanyu married Arohi or someone else and Ak stayed as single mom struggling day and night raising Abhir then definitely Akshara would seem to be a victim and Abhimanyu the selfish, arrogant and abusive husband.

It’s all about narrative of how the characters are being shown. Otherwise there are hell lot of flaws in both of them and hence they are not together now.

There is no wrong Akshara falling in love with Abhinav and Abhimanyu getting married to other person. And coparenting Abhir.. But makers are hell bent to show that the soul love wins over reality. And Abhira FD cannot accept the reality.. In this process all the cringe in shown to us.

Posted: 2 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: PeacefulLove

Agree with all you said!

I am sad why he had to pull akshara in middle of pheras. Can't he wait till wedding is over. She missed the best moment of brothers marriage And in precap MAA beta so impatient to tell him truth.

I don't even want to talk about Manjiri. They are just concerned about them. Selfishness at it's peak.

Maybe you missed the part where abhir tries to tell something to abhi and then keeps quiet. This made abhi impatient to tell the truth, as he understood that abhir is suffering silently just for his parents!!

And that was the urgency there, not that he wanted to blurt out the truth..

Posted: 2 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: JustaFan13

Maybe you missed the part where abhir tries to tell something to abhi and then keeps quiet. This made abhi impatient to tell the truth, as he understood that abhir is suffering silently just for his parents!!

And that was the urgency there, not that he wanted to blurt out the truth..


Add to this the fact that, as Manjari pointed out, his month is ending. He is going to be leaving soon. If Abhir doesn't know the truth, then what is Abhi supposed to keep staying in Kasauli until he does? Go back without his son? So he figured the best time is to tell Nav after the wedding and then Abhir before Abhi leaves. So they three can handle the fallout together and hopefully have Abhir be stable before he leaves.


Besides, he isn't wrong. Abhir knows half the truth and has asked both docman and his mom. If docman is his dad but keeps this from him, that would break their relationship. Why should Abhi sacrifice his relationship with his son cause Ak doesn't want to break her and Nav's delusions?

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: graphicd96 · 1 months ago

Hey, I've seen team abhimanyu and team Abhinav badges in many members profile So how can I get these badges? Any help please.it will be...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".