He Should Have Done This Instead!

I honestly think that Zama Habib should have made a new show called ‘Ajnabiyon Se Premiyon Tak’ where a stranger helps a pregnant woman who is lost and gives her stranger and they slowly fall in love and raise the child together. His favourite Jay Soni could’ve played the main lead and maybe the girl who plays Muskaan could’ve been the FL.
This would’ve been much better than creating a mess of this show. This proves that these people have good ideas for new shows yet still choose to show such crap and toxicity.

I guess there was a show in star plus itself stranger and widowed pregnant lady storyy

It still isn’t messy enough for them so they will make the show about 3 sisters next.

If it is indeed a good idea, why is it a bad idea to implement here in YRKKH?And if it is a good idea and Abhinav is the lead, then why this outcry about Abhinav being a theif and what not?🤔 Just because he is opposite the FL and ML stans can not accept that? Truth is there are people like Abhimanyu in real life too, who promise a million things but fulfil none, and then their partner do move on too, so its not like this does not happen and they are showing something totally off; where they lack I feel is the execution. They have rushed all the story lines, and deviated at so many points from the actual story. So I feel the idea has been fine even here, but with horrible execution and terrible writing they have ruined things, wo iss show mein karte ya kisi aur mein koi farak nahi padta

Firstly, it is about not giving Akshara’s POV - maybe her talking to herself, her thoughts in voice over or anything - they have done it purposely to keep all fandoms hooked and guessing since it suits their quest to generate TRPs.

Regarding stans and all - can’t say much but from what it appears - they already loved the old pairing and can’t adjust to the new guy - also consider that they are not even writing original scenes between the new pair - they are reusing old ones - which the viewers still remember and adore. They wish to compare characters but audience ends up comparing the pairs and they enjoyed the chemistry of the original pair more so their way of storytelling (already messy and problematic) is working against them.

If they wish to retain new pair they should write new scenes for them that the audience can connect with, without remembering the old pair. Also, Abhimanyu though has his issues but isn’t evil - so it isn’t easy for viewers to move past him. The story may have moved 6-7 years but we have watched it for just about 5 months and this move on started 1-2 months ago.

Most importantly with the new story they have rewritten many traits of most characters - so viewers feel disconnected. So they didn’t really do a very job of including this new story in the show. The concept is good but they should have at least studied the existing characters to fit the new plot into it.

Well the channel did not ask RS to bring a new show. He was asked to do something to save this sinking ship, otherwise it would have shut down. And ZH did exactly that, brought a new guy, gave a new direction to the show and saved it from shutting down. I would say he did a good job. Shows don't sustain acc. to the whims and fancies of few online fans.

Originally posted by: janecastle

Well the channel did not ask RS to bring a new show. He was asked to do something to save this sinking ship, otherwise it would have shut down. And ZH did exactly that, brought a new guy, gave a new direction to the show and saved it from shutting down. I would say he did a good job. Shows don't sustain acc. to the whims and fancies of few online fans.

Really what did the writer do deteorated the lead character original traits ,to bring his own creation and make him mahaan ,dont give fl pov,changed old narratives of pre leap to make his creation only positive character in the whole serial,dont have any own creation just copy paste old abhira sequences to his new pair ,still there no great trp that they got which however yrkkh was getting preleap without promo

I would totally buy this narrative if the writing direction and screenplay were not absolute shit.. it's bad by even ITV standards an absolute merry go round dragfest especially during the IPL ... IMHO this is ITV it's not like they're gonna show Nav is better in bed to show parallel of the romantic scenes between Abhira on AkshNav it simply reeks of unoriginality....even the tracks like surgery custody which r very typical to ITV have been botched up real bad...

Originally posted by: DevilHere

I would totally buy this narrative if the writing direction and screenplay were not absolute shit.. it's bad by even ITV standards an absolute merry go round dragfest especially during the IPL ... IMHO this is ITV it's not like they're gonna show Nav is better in bed to show parallel of the romantic scenes between Abhira on AkshNav it simply reeks of unoriginality....even the tracks like surgery custody which r very typical to ITV have been botched up real bad...

Like I said, whatever they did, they got the desired effect.. show survived. And some may be intentionally blind to it, but AkshNav are far better written than AbhiRa ever were. Itv don't run with romantic scenes and Rishta is not known for romantic scenes. AbhiRa's romance could not save this show. Anyways, AbhiRa fans will see only what they want. Makers clearly don't care about that. They wanted trp and satisfy channel, both seemed to have happened.

Originally posted by: janecastle

Well the channel did not ask RS to bring a new show. He was asked to do something to save this sinking ship, otherwise it would have shut down. And ZH did exactly that, brought a new guy, gave a new direction to the show and saved it from shutting down. I would say he did a good job. Shows don't sustain acc. to the whims and fancies of few online fans.

The channel asked Rajan Shahi to copy Ichche Nodee

Zama Habib had to come in because RS violated terms and conditions. Apart from YHC, all shows on SP were regional copies.

Except for RS no producer went overboard during the first year of launch.

During ITA he revealed the theme of 3rd generation ie Abhira are in love with the idea of being in love.

When you have two successful generations, a shallow subject for the 3rd one will fall flat.

Within a year Yrkkh lost their loyal fan base.