Rancho12345 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#1

Im reading posts of YRKKH On IF regularly but never posted. But Cant stop myself now.


I want to know on what basis Ruhi is being called An IVF Kid?

Till date I have not come across a Single Scene Which Indicates that she is not biological child of Neil And Arohi then on what basis such statements are given? Is it just wish of Online audience of the show (Abhira Fans to be specific) and they want this prediction to be true so that Ruhi Which they in a way consider a thorn in Abhira Reunion Path Gets Cleared Like Abhinav Being A Negetive Person?

Or These Theories Are Made By Analysing Random Objects In A Scene WHICH EVEN MAKERS MIGHT NOT THINK ABOUT WHILE MAKING THE SHOW After all this is a fictional Telivision Drama Meant For Entertainment Of Telivision Audience Who Watch It For Timepass At Night After A Busy Day And Then Go To Sleep Instead Of Doing Microscopic Study Of The Scenes!


In case of Abhinav I can understand different people for whatever reason have different way to see a character/analyse his actions BUT THAT IS SUBJECTIVE.

However Ruhi being An IVF Kid IS OBJECTIVE One can't assume such things until it's Explicitly Shown By The Makers This Is Extremely Important Event Of The Show And Makers Won't Just Leave It To Assumptions If At All It Would Have Been True.


In TV Shows Many Times Couples Are Not Given Full Fledged Suhagraat Scenes To Show That They Have Consummated Their Marriage Specially If They Are Not First Leads That Doesn't Means If Wife Gets Pregnant The Baby Is Not Biological Kid Of Her Husband Specially If it's shown that husband and wife sleep in the same room as normal couple and have willingly (happily) married to each other.


Also IVF is not some magical Process that one gets Pregnant Overnight it is time taking and complicated process something which couldn't be hidden from families specially if they are always in touch with you.

Most Importantly Neil would have known if Arohi Would not have been pregnant Biologically Through Him. The Fact that he believed that she is Pregnant On Both Occassions Proves The Fact That They Have Consummated Their Marriage And Were Sexually Active Or Else It's Normal For Neil To Think How Can She Get Pregnant Without Having Physical Relations With Me?

Lastly Even Biological Pregnancy Also Takes Time that too doesn't Happen Overnight It's Possible 1st Test Show Negetive And After Some Time It Shows Positive This Much Leverage Has To Be Given To YRKKH After All It's Not Science Documentry Made For Educational Purposes Of Online Audience To Find Logic In It!

Edited by Rancho12345 - 2 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

4.2k

Users

10

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

firewings_diya thumbnail

Team Abhimanyu (Gen 3)

Posted: 2 years ago
#2

I don't remember exactly but arohi lied that she is pregnant and inorder to really become pregnant she was trying to woo neil but it never happend as she got exposed that she was never pregnant and neil asked her to leave for betraying him.

Later she was shown roaming near ivf center and some doctor tells akshu arohi is pregnant. So ppl think she might have gone for ivf in order to get back to neil.

Edited by firewings_diya - 2 years ago
Rancho12345 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: firewings_diya

I don't remember exactly but arohi lied that she is pregnant and inorder to really become pregnant she was trying to woo neil but it never happend as she got exposed that she was never pregnant and neil asked her to leave for betraying him.

Later she was shown roaming near ivf center and some doctor tells akshu arohi is pregnant. So ppl think she might have gone for ivf in order to get back to neil.


It's Quite Possible That At 1st She Didn't Get Positive Results Of Pregnancy Test After Consummating Her Marriage As It Takes Time To Get Pregnant So She Thought She Should Try Once Again To Get Intimate With Neil But Later She Would Have Got Pregnant Bcz Of 1st Love Making Session Itself.


Fact That Neil Believed That She Is Pregnant With His Child On Both Occassions Proves That They Had Physical Relations Like Husband And Wife.


Also Like I Said IVF Is A TIME TAKING And Complicated Process Which Can't Be Hidden Just Like That From People Who Are Always In Touch With You!

Posted: 2 years ago
#4

No the whole process if anyone can hide is AR. She is a dr she can self inject. Moral support is what you need more in the process. Someone like AR can hide it. But she was in touch with her friend and just overnight she got positive and I believe in that period their relationship wasn’t great. Like everything else they have kept that option open and didn’t address it. She needed to be pregnant desperately to hold on to Neil.

shwetha85 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 2 years ago
#5

I remember an episode where she was trying to get Neil's sample for AI/IUI. IVF is a long procedure unless DKP ruined this as well and showed IVF to be a cake walk.

IVF is lot costlier and time consuming with no guarantee

Posted: 2 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Rancho12345


It's Quite Possible That At 1st She Didn't Get Positive Results Of Pregnancy Test After Consummating Her Marriage As It Takes Time To Get Pregnant So She Thought She Should Try Once Again To Get Intimate With Neil But Later She Would Have Got Pregnant Bcz Of 1st Love Making Session Itself.


Fact That Neil Believed That She Is Pregnant With His Child On Both Occassions Proves That They Had Physical Relations Like Husband And Wife.


Also Like I Said IVF Is A TIME TAKING And Complicated Process Which Can't Be Hidden Just Like That From People Who Are Always In Touch With You!

Exactly I have gone through IVF myself and know how complicated that process it but it's not easy to understand by everyone as they are in different age groups.

But don't take the comments seriously. All kinds of theories are made here to get Abhinav and Aarohi out of Abhiras life. And writers can't be trusted either. They can change tracks as per their convenience. Akshara is already changing overnight. And to unite Abhira they can take any path.

Rancho12345 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: shwetha85

I remember an episode where she was trying to get Neil's sample for AI/IUI. IVF is a long procedure unless DKP ruined this as well and showed IVF to be a cake walk.

IVF is lot costlier and time consuming with no guarantee


Cost Is Not An Issue For Arohi But Ya It's Too Time Consuming (Plus No Guarantee As Well though this point can be overlooked) So It Looks Impossible To Be True I Don't Expect Logic In Tv Show But It's Too Much I Mean She Can't Get Pregnant Overnight. I can accept her being biologically pregnant without them explicitly showing Suhagraat Sequence For Neil And Arohi As It's Something Normal btwn married couples But Can't Accept Her Being Pregnant Through IVF while being sexually active with Neil (As Without that Neil Cant Believe She Is Pregnant With His Child) Without Any Explicit Scene To Prove This As It's Not Normal Btwn Married Couples.

Rancho12345 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Siasia2014

No the whole process if anyone can hide is AR. She is a dr she can self inject. Moral support is what you need more in the process. Someone like AR can hide it. But she was in touch with her friend and just overnight she got positive and I believe in that period their relationship wasn’t great. Like everything else they have kept that option open and didn’t address it. She needed to be pregnant desperately to hold on to Neil.


Ok for once let's Accept That She Can Hide This Long And Complicated Process from everyone even after staying with them BUT 2 MOST IMPORTANT THINGS ARE-


1. She can't get Pregnant overnight IVF is a long and complicated process with no success guarantee.


2. Even if at that time their relationship wasn't great shortly before it indeed was and They Have certainly consummated their marriage because of which Neil was convinced on both occasions of Arohi Being Pregnant With His Child.

Edited by Rancho12345 - 2 years ago
Posted: 2 years ago
#9

😆 no matter how complicated process is... This is ITv guys... They will never consider sensitivity of an issue and show kuch bhii...


Itna mat socha karo😆 kyunki writers ko khud nai pata woh kya dikhana chahite hai...

Rancho12345 thumbnail
3rd Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: shahsb_26

😆 no matter how complicated process is... This is ITv guys... They will never consider sensitivity of an issue and show kuch bhii...


Itna mat socha karo😆 kyunki writers ko khud nai pata woh kya dikhana chahite hai...


Ya that I know ITV can't be taken seriously but does it even remotely makes sense for a woman to become pregnant through IVF using someone else sperms (and her husband doesn't have any medical problem of not becoming father) While Her Husband Is Convinced that she is pregnant with his baby

In case she uses Neil's own sperms to become mother then Ruhi still Remains Neil's Daughter Anyways so nothing changes with respect to her equation with Birla Family.


Though It Would Be Even more messed up situation to think that a woman is ok to get impregnated with her husband through IVF but not biologically.


I'm getting Headache to even think on these lines 😕

Edited by Rancho12345 - 2 years ago

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26 · 2 months ago

Alright... Long time... No see.. So, catching up to crap this show has pulled up... Nothing refreshing in the show... Absolutely still a crap.....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".