Originally posted by: rinki_99
Tbh, I was also surprised momentarily and thought that Urmi's soul had possessed Haseena and was just messing with Pushpa ji for fun but then it turned out to be actually Haseena
right?! even I thought it was just for fun. even later when she appointed Karishma, I thought she was just continuing the act (the credit for this one goes to urmilla cause I cannot tell when haseena is serious or joking anymore. the mannerisms in which she was first informed Pushpa Ji about this had me thinking she was kidding and trying to control her laughter.).
But then I decided to think not like Haseena but as SHO Haseena Mallik, the station in charge. Now Haseena knows how capable her MPT members are and along with that she also knows their flaws and incompetencies.
I agree to a certain extent that she does know their capabilities, flaws and incompetencies. but I don't think she truly understands them/or realises that they have grown (this is a whole other topic). but in this given scenario, I agree that she knows enough about them to make such a decision.
Whether she understands the responsibilities she is delegating is where I would digress and say, she doesn't. like I said earlier counselling isn't everyone's cup of tea. yes, it requires patience (hence she chose Karishma) but also a lot of other skills that even if Pushpa Ji doesn't display (lack of judgment, active listening, empathy, understanding non-verbal cues), I believe has (she wouldn't have made it this far in the field if she didn't). so keeping these in mind, I would have thought she would want to find someone else (a new character even if it's temporary) to replace Pushpa Ji when she does retire.
that being said, I do understand the entire thing was so the kid stuck to Karishma and the plot could proceed forward.
For example:
Pushpa ji: there have been many instances when Pushpa ji has had lost track of the counselling and has transformed from a responsible constable and counsellor into a helpless and tortured mother-in-law during counselling sessions or has randomly entered lalla ke pappa's la-la land. Also, there have been times when her counselling had also led to some serious repercussions for the MPT.
I can completely agree with this. the older she gets, the more she messes up (intentional? possibly). because in the earlier episodes she did do a decent job at counselling (i cant remember them XD but if anyone else does, please do enlighten me!). but recently, like ever since the mummy case, she has become a little more irresponsible and is constantly on Karishma's case, forgetting whatever is happening around her.
Karishma: Lucknow renowned for her temper and philosophy, "pahele mukka aur laat, baad mein baat". What more do Isay here?
but she has grown up a lot. like the cricket boys weren't afraid of her bhukal in the slightest and she did handle that case pretty well in my opinion (it was blown out of proportion later but that was a misconception issue more than a Karishma issue.). so I guess even Lucknow knows that she has become a little more patient and perceptive.
Cheetah: By right and in most cases, he is the person who is supposed to be doing the counselling because he is the qualified women psychologist of the MPT. But our Cheeteshar Chaturvedi is usually either sleeping, daydreaming of Santu ji, following his Santu ji like a puppy, arguing with Billu or taunting Pushpa ji about her eating habits and complaining habits or he does all of them together.
NGL, I do wonder how he got his degree. but yes, it has become especial more apparent since urmilla came into the picture because I cant seem to remember when he actually did his job properly (save for when my masumiyat wasn't present in the last few episodes). actually, she should have appointed him instead so he wouldn't be so occupied with his ek tarfa pyaar ka bohoot.
Santosh: Uff yeh masoomiyat... Need I say more?
this would have been applicable pre-episode 337. after haseena's death, there isn't a shadow of doubt in how much she has grown and become responsible, dare I say more than Pushpa Ji.
I find Haseena to be someone who is always trapped between the devil and the deep blue sea. She is the one who has to deal with all the sticky situations that arise in the thana irrespective of who the cause is. So with this perspective, I think Haseena was just trying to grasp the floating straw like a drowning person. She saw a change in Karishma with the latest case (even though we know it was a sham and she found out later too), she just decided to give her a try.
I completely agree to this. Except Urmi track, she has been the one who answerable for anything that happened within MPT and that's fair. She is the boss so she will be the one who will be questioned. I agree with Rinki here that counseling requires specialization that Karishma lacks and Haseena could have brought someone new to take the responsibility. But I guess she wanted to give Karishma a chance because leads do this (in my working place as well 😆). They give opportunity to people who might not be professionally certified but they think are capable enough to take the responsibility.
this is an interesting perspective. I am lowkey surprised the people of Lucknow had no time to come and protest outside of the station. maybe they all had gotten their jobs back from Bakshi Ji so now dont have time to do so.
I do agree that it looked like she had run out of options momentarily. so maybe appointing Karishma/anyone else for this case specifically was an understandable option. no harm in trying after all. I didn't have a problem with that. I was confused as to why she wanted Karishma to do counselling for all the other cases. like yes, it worked for this one, but why all the other future cases? (goes back to my point about the expertise required.)
Just like sometimes good bosses do rotations in the offices for professional development and to see how an employee does with the new/added job description given to them.
I will give her props for trying something new and wanting to give them more responsibilities. but which responsibility it is should also be taken into account. counselling, as I said requires a multitude of skills and if not done right can cause more harm than good (like we saw with Bunty). then again, she isn't wrong for wanting to try.
I don't see any malice or ulterior motives behind Haseena doing this. I think she genuinely felt that Karishma should be given a chance at it. Also, Pushpa ji is close to retirement as we know so someone will have to take her place eventually, so why not start training someone now?
I don't see any ulterior motive behind haseena doing that either. until the last moment, I still thought it was a joke. Pushpa Ji will still come back to the station and try to be part of it despite her retirement 🤣
This is just an assumption in terms of the possibility of Haseena's train of thoughts.
only haseena knows what haseena means XD
This entire thing was a filler as per my thoughts considering the ladies had been given breaks so my assumption for this whole phone call happening was to keep a KarEena scene in place.
as in the cast had been given off days?
Bhavika was in Thailand on vacations and Yukti went to her hometown for couple of days. Hence the fruit vendor case.
I completely agree with Karishma not needing to prove anything to anyone, not to Haseena and definitely nothing to Pushpa ji when it comes to her doing her duties. She has done a lot and if people cannot see that then that's their loss.
Completely agreed. Karishma doesn't need to prove her worth to anyone, be it Haseena, Pushpa Ji or anyone else. Everyone is knows how capable she is and she is best as she is.
hayeee, I cannot agree more with this. Karishma, behen, app kab samjhogi is baat ko?
And anyway, she is yet to receive appreciation for doing all the work in those 3-6 months when Haseena wasn't around or when she had become Urmila completely. Where is that darn appreciation from everybody?
it will come after the confrontation everyone has been highly anticipating I believe...i think...I hope... I wish...
She deserves the appreciation for all she did. It has to be given to her. And I hope the day comes soon.
The ehsaas wala pyaar still cracks me up. Twitteretis are still asking for his return and it's not even to redeem his character anymore, it's for AnuSeena., and am like, ab bas bhi kar yaar. Let the guy get a successful show as a more prominent character. He deserves more consistency in his professional life and not work just for a few months per year.
i really want to ask them, for what will anubahv come back? perhaps to rekindle his ehsaas wala pyaar for the fourth time and to leave haseena standing at the wedding dias this time because he has to go on a super-secret undercover life endearing mission that he is too spineless to tell maddam malik about.
Even I see people on Twitter asking for Anubhav and I don't understand why do they want him back. If it's to get his character the due respect he deserved, fair enough but if for Anuseena, please spare both of them. It's not only about Haseena, it's about Anubhav as well. I might be the only one but I always felt neither Haseena deserves Anubhav nor Anubahv deserves Haseena. They both need someone who would break the walls both these characters have built around themselves. They both deserved better and are better without each other. Two people who are obsessed with their duty cannot be happy together. Either of them has to tone it down and I don't think that's possible. Let both of them find right partners for themselves.
She did right. I even liked that tune they used during her scene.
the tune was so calming, I want a full version.
after writing all this, I actually don't know what I am trying to say or what my point is. but I hope I made a tiny bit of sense.
not proofread.
