Imlie Chat Club # 11, DT Reminder Note pg 55 - Page 100

I never even knew of IPKKND.lol.. Just to fine tune my understanding..When you say Arnav was an antihero, it means his actions were lacking in the morality department..and at times, it was deplorable. So, how didn't it receive flak back then? How was it easily acceptable by the audience? I mean..I am looking at the current heroes, the minute they eff up..I mean the moment they don't act according to what's acceptable to us, we are voicing our displeasure. Look at how Aryan is criticized.

Was Khushi & Arnav in a toxic relationship? Did it end well for both of them?

Edited: I get how apparent notions of romance makes many gloss over the obvious flaws. I mean..if you were on TT and looked at the hashtag , you would note many pro-Aryan sympathy posts. The wirdings are problematic..Standing close to each other isn't hot (in all situations)..Many are still focused on the physical aspects instead of the morality.. So I am guessing Barun's good looks & acting made all go gaga?

Originally posted by: _AmyChoco_

I never even knew of IPKKND.lol.. Just to fine tune my understanding..When you say Arnav was an antihero, it means his actions were lacking in the morality department..and at times, it was deplorable. So, how didn't it receive flak back then? How was it easily acceptable by the audience? I mean..I am looking at the current heroes, the minute they eff up..I mean the moment they don't act according to what's acceptable to us, we are voicing our displeasure. Look at how Aryan is criticized.

Was Khushi & Arnav in a toxic relationship? Did it end well for both of them?

I don't think I meant lack in moral compartment when I say he was an antihero. He wasn't Shivay Singh Oberoi; kidnapping children to force the girl to get married. What he had was a lot of mommy issues, anger issues and trust issues, unresolved. Arnav and Khushi were in a weird relationship where they never understood anything beyond their all-consuming love for each other.

Originally posted by: Deltablues

I don't think I meant lack in moral compartment when I say he was an antihero. He wasn't Shivay Singh Oberoi; kidnapping children to force the girl to get married. What he had was a lot of mommy issues, anger issues and trust issues, unresolved. Arnav and Khushi were in a weird relationship where they never understood anything beyond their all-consuming love for each other.

My bad..I was under the impression that an anti hero was a person whose actions are not ethically acceptable. I stand corrected. Shivaay..that scene still haunts me..I loved the cinematography in that scene.. the way he said 'Boom' & then Annika breaking down. His actions made no sense. The second forced marriage in IB2 was more disturbing to watch. Fun fact: Naakul said that the writer was disturbed by how it played out on screen that she couldn't write or couldn't connect with the character for a while.

Originally posted by: _AmyChoco_

My bad..I was under the impression that an anti hero was a person whose actions are not ethically acceptable. I stand corrected. Shivaay..that scene still haunts me..I loved the cinematography in that scene.. the way he said 'Boom' & then Annika breaking down. His actions made no sense. The second forced marriage in IB2 was more disturbing to watch. Fun fact: Naakul said that the writer was disturbed by how it played out on screen that she couldn't write or couldn't connect with the character for a while.

Arnav was amoral many times: I mean, just unleashing all your anger on your contractual wife without any communication is amoral and abusive to me. But, he wasn't exactly a malicious criminal. Shivay could be that if he wanted to.

Anyhow, Nox himself talked about how he couldn't just be okay with many things Shivay did. Which is correct.

Even Barun has talked about Arnav's toxic traits in not so many words.

Eavesdropping here for the first time ...

Why is no one talking about Maan singh khurana just because it's not forced marriage in that soap....

Asad too was purely toxic for me

Originally posted by: ramusk

Eavesdropping here for the first time ...

Why is no one talking about Maan singh khurana just because it's not forced marriage in that soap....

Asad too was purely toxic for me

No idea about the former. Which show?

And about Asad..was he toxic? 🤔 But then back then I didn't analyze the character as much..Honestly, don't recall much too..

Maybe @SundariP can shed some light..

Originally posted by: ramusk

Eavesdropping here for the first time ...

Why is no one talking about Maan singh khurana just because it's not forced marriage in that soap....

Asad too was purely toxic for me

I know a lot of ppl compare maan to aryan

But the point for me is , maan never grew as a character , just how was introduced in the first scene , he remained the same through out -he fell in love - he got married

People compare Aryan and arnav cause , the more screen space aryan got - the more we got to his character- layers - trauma - total softie inside

Originally posted by: ramusk

Eavesdropping here for the first time ...

Why is no one talking about Maan singh khurana just because it's not forced marriage in that soap....

Asad too was purely toxic for me

I'd love to hear some toxic behaviour of msk!

I didn't see any dudee 😥😥

Originally posted by: _AmyChoco_

No idea about the former. Which show?

And about Asad..was he toxic? 🤔 But then back then I didn't analyze the character as much..Honestly, don't recall much too..

Maybe @SundariP can shed some light..

It was the show geet or GHSP...

Originally posted by: SundariP

I'd love to hear some toxic behaviour of msk!

I didn't see any dudee 😥😥

I meant comparison part of msk n now asr.....

Msk never made me feel toxic atleast till where I saw n know