Originally posted by: narobi
probably those comments i read mean that they both chose anti hero scripts only.
Well i have not watched any scene of bashar momin or zakham but what i realised ki he rapes his wife atleast the first time, i mean i know husband wife ho but zabardashti shadi mein physical hona for me is rape only and still women of the show falls in love with him, so far i guess muqaddar mein bhi yahi tha , the concept like how the F a woman can fall for her rapist.
Still ye shows purane hai to i might give them benefit of doubt.
but muqaddar to bc pichle saal ka hi hai, yes you killed the guy but only after that bechari ladki fell for her husband twice the age, matlab wtf man.
Though i saw few scenes available on youtube, i felt FQ actor to hai, he did take efforts for the character in muqaddar but itna shit script hai like i cant even watch it full and i wont.
But haan after all this i fail to understand why is FQ given sucha big stature, he is good but i cant call him legend after few years when he gets old or so. Idk much though but i felt his scripts are quite regressive, feroze aur danish jo karte hain unhein consequences to milte hain na, yahan to 2020 ka show hai muqaddar he abducts a woman half her age, almost his daughter's age and marries her by blackmailing and consummating the marriage without her will is rape only and wo ladki ko usse mohabbat ho bhi jaati hai, kya bc kya dikhana chahte ho yaar.
okay in ishq hai, if i was at isra place , after shaq thing main nai maanti kabhi bhi, infact fathers death ke baad hi nahin maanti , moreover aisi situation aati nai. To make sense i feel ki ishq hai main bhi separating ending ho sakti thi ya agar hoti toh sense ban jaati sahi but still it was a happy after but usmein ladki first instance se involved thi equally, kuch bhi yunhi bila wajah nai hua tha. she did love him when the circumtsances were normal in their life. ishq hai ki ending kaafi debatble hai, at times you feel accepting guy back was not right decision but at times you do feel they both did love each other when truly and both were equally involved at some point of their life and it depends on the writer how they want to mould the plot.
whereas in Fq shows har show mein vo heroine ki kahin aur mangni tudwata hai fir shadi karta hai , fir forcefully consummate karta hai, fir ladki ko pyaar hojata hai and fir vo uske bache paida karti hai and sab kuch hasi khushi hojata hai, ye kaafi nonsense hai.
Well idk what he has said for india but i ll read it soon. mujhe banda kahin se attractive bhi nai laga , matlab humanyun saeed being danish in MPTH, still the chracter attracts you some point of the time, even bilal is also has that calibre that these two guys by their acting make a normal stupid chomu guy attractive too. Danish by his face looks and his actings being good makes anti hero attractive so well, the same attraction i dont feel for feroze anti hero characters.
Usman mukhtar is a commendable guy, i mean he made his character so hateful. though i feel too that they might make a happy ending in HKKST.
But if the show really wants to go above all, what i feel is that once mahira comes back in senses and aswad helps her by making his mistakes mend but last mein 3-4 minutes ke liye aap kisi aur ache hero ko la sakte ho after time leap that mahira ko vo mil gya. I mean how difficult is that, this does happen in bollywood movies, last mein bahaut chhota sa guest appearance hai and ladki koi chajj ka banda mil gya , zaroori hai kya itni toxicity ke saath aap fir se use usi bande ke saath happy ending de do. aisi ending se socitey aur industry grow hi karegi.