Gritty Witty Crew - Chat Club Thread 17 # Shoot The Breeze (IO) - Page 25

As expected only.. vedargal won.. but the advantage didn't help them much... all struggled, put 200% effort to win...

Who going to get eliminated today is another tough one.. but I am expecting they may vote out Amzadh as they don't want to vote out their tribe member coming with them from first.. Amzadh s certainly not a weak link... but they take decisions emotionally I think.. let's see..

Originally posted by: Honeyarjun

This is the foul llptch talked abt I think. The rule for the barrel is, you have to cross it without anyone’s help. Umapathy didn’t leave the barrel , his body was half on it. For Aishwarya , Saran supported by pushing the barrel with his legs . Thats why Aishwarya was called out foul, uma wasn’t.

see the video in this tweet

https://twitter.com/Wolverinetamil/status/1452026036762431488?s=20

I still don’t think this counts Honey. There were others also in similar situation who were holding on to the barrel but as they were underwater they were asked to restart (e.g. Kash later). At least Aishwarya was on both the ropes connecting the barrel and on top of the water, but she was told foul. In one attempt Saran even crossed the barrels and reached the plank but as his legs landed in the water Arjun asked him to redo. Since Vedargal were in Arjun’s viewpoint, plus Amzath kept screaming from the other side, Arjun kept calling them foul but couldn’t notice/ignored what Kadargal did.
To me it looked like Aishwarya didn’t shout because they were getting the stick from Kash, but because they started without the 6 sticks. Which was the rule told to them early on. Vikranth twisted that and spoke as though Aishwarya was shouting for him helping Kash and have some humanity. They weren’t clear what to do since Kash dropped out of the game, and since Vedargal already crossed to the other side they couldn’t see anything what happened with Kash. Vanessa choice of words on Aishwarya “romba thulra” was quite distasteful. Even when Vedargal won after a long time they were very respectful of the others. They celebrated within themselves but didn’t taunt others. They even went and comforted the other team.

Narayanan might be weak in tasks, but I can see that all in Vedargal have good respect for him. He advises them well, and they all take his comments to heart. In previous episodes he could be seen trying to help Parvathy gel with the team, but she didn’t take his advice. He told Saran where he went wrong in triggering Arjun by talking over him, and to forget all that and continue playing for the team. Even when Aishwarya wanted to confront Inigo soon as he came back from Kadargal’s camp, he told to her to wait first and then later speak separately. With Nandha as well he is seen partly listening to him but also partly giving his own opinion.

Seems Lady Kash also has an immunity idol... so they can't vote out LP and lady kash.. so among Uma,vanessa, vikranth and amzadh any one will go... still I think it will be Amzadh.

Originally posted by: Honeyarjun

This is the foul llptch talked abt I think. The rule for the barrel is, you have to cross it without anyone’s help. Umapathy didn’t leave the barrel , his body was half on it. For Aishwarya , Saran supported by pushing the barrel with his legs . Thats why Aishwarya was called out foul, uma wasn’t.

see the video in this tweet

https://twitter.com/Wolverinetamil/status/1452026036762431488?s=20

Actually Umapthy fell between first and second barrel and he should have started from the first barrel all over again .

Even Arjun comments that Umapathy fell now during that part but later didn't notice when Uma continued from second barrel by swimming . The clip shows him trying in second barrel but he fell off from the first barrel completely into the water and didnt try again from start but swam too second barrel and tried from there hence foul .

You can watch the episode again and you will notice Uma did indeed fell and continued without doing it again . I tried uploading the part but couldn't now , will post the picture later if I can .

See in this picture Uma is completely in the water and Aishwarya is still hanging on , Uma will come up again from the water and cross to the side and Arjun will be shouting foul for Aishwarya he didn't notice Uma crossing that time .

I have the whole video of 17 seconds but can't upload it now , will do it later when I can .

Originally posted by: BlurredLines

See in this picture Uma is completely in the water and Aishwarya is still hanging on , Uma will come up again from the water and cross to the side and Arjun will be shouting foul for Aishwarya he didn't notice Uma crossing that time .

I have the whole video of 17 seconds but can't upload it now , will do it later when I can .

Thanks for taking the time to post the pic and explain this. It seemed like Uma fell into water but didn’t leave the rope in the barrel. I am not sure if that is a rule. They didn’t show this whole task properly, lot of editing so couldn’t understand what exactly happened. Also they said, there were many fouls so they redid the barrel task again (only part of it was shown). Couldn’t get the time to watch uncut version past 2 days, not sure if they discussed anything abt this in the episode.

Originally posted by: llptch

I still don’t think this counts Honey. There were others also in similar situation who were holding on to the barrel but as they were underwater they were asked to restart (e.g. Kash later). At least Aishwarya was on both the ropes connecting the barrel and on top of the water, but she was told foul. In one attempt Saran even crossed the barrels and reached the plank but as his legs landed in the water Arjun asked him to redo. Since Vedargal were in Arjun’s viewpoint, plus Amzath kept screaming from the other side, Arjun kept calling them foul but couldn’t notice/ignored what Kadargal did.
To me it looked like Aishwarya didn’t shout because they were getting the stick from Kash, but because they started without the 6 sticks. Which was the rule told to them early on. Vikranth twisted that and spoke as though Aishwarya was shouting for him helping Kash and have some humanity. They weren’t clear what to do since Kash dropped out of the game, and since Vedargal already crossed to the other side they couldn’t see anything what happened with Kash. Vanessa choice of words on Aishwarya “romba thulra” was quite distasteful. Even when Vedargal won after a long time they were very respectful of the others. They celebrated within themselves but didn’t taunt others. They even went and comforted the other team.

Narayanan might be weak in tasks, but I can see that all in Vedargal have good respect for him. He advises them well, and they all take his comments to heart. In previous episodes he could be seen trying to help Parvathy gel with the team, but she didn’t take his advice. He told Saran where he went wrong in triggering Arjun by talking over him, and to forget all that and continue playing for the team. Even when Aishwarya wanted to confront Inigo soon as he came back from Kadargal’s camp, he told to her to wait first and then later speak separately. With Nandha as well he is seen partly listening to him but also partly giving his own opinion.

Agree about what you said abt Narayan and his social skills. When I mentioned Narayan as a weak link , it was only based on performance. He was the one of the main reason they lost many challenges .

I still take the same stand abt Aishwarya. Something makes me not like her. She is a super woman, does the tasks amazingly. Still thinks only in the point of games and lacks empathy even for her own teammates. When Amzad was injured , the red team made him feel insecure enough so he wasn’t even able to share the pain with the team. He was scared they would vote him out citing the injury. They were being partial. Ravi was also injured but he was treated differently among tribe members.

Originally posted by: Honeyarjun

Thanks for taking the time to post the pic and explain this. It seemed like Uma fell into water but didn’t leave the rope in the barrel. I am not sure if that is a rule. They didn’t show this whole task properly, lot of editing so couldn’t understand what exactly happened. Also they said, there were many fouls so they redid the barrel task again (only part of it was shown). Couldn’t get the time to watch uncut version past 2 days, not sure if they discussed anything abt this in the episode.

As I said before Arjun doesn't really explain what is foul and not foul , even he didn't seem to understand it and goes by the calls of the contestant as they keep pointing each other and calling foul.

Others were called foul for even smaller issue than what Uma did , like legs in the water and all . So yeah it was a foul in my pov and regarding redid the task , we were shown Aishwarya and Naryanan doing it again , so does LP and Kash after that comment about lot of fouls hence redid that part.

But they didn't show Uma doing it again ,maybe he did as well and it wasn't shown in that case I am okay with it but when they didn't show I am going to not assume he also redid the task.

My problem is that contestant have to keep shouting to register foul in the first place , I know Arjun can't be able to notice everything but it creates a lot of confusion like this one when both viewers as well as contestants are not made aware of what is right and wrong .

The better option would be to clearly state what is foul and what is not before the start of the game and not discuss it during the game

Agree about what you said abt Narayan and his social skills. When I mentioned Narayan as a weak link , it was only based on performance. He was the one of the main reason they lost many challenges .

I still take the same stand abt Aishwarya. Something makes me not like her. She is a super woman, does the tasks amazingly. Still thinks only in the point of games and lacks empathy even for her own teammates. When Amzad was injured , the red team made him feel insecure enough so he wasn’t even able to share the pain with the team. He was scared they would vote him out citing the injury. They were being partial. Ravi was also injured but he was treated differently among tribe members.

[/QUOT

Aishwarya is too task driven I agree, she thinks it only in game perspective but it also make her little too honest in my opinion. From twitter ,I heard she went on and on about why Nanda couldn't hold the rope a little longer when he was obviously injured and Naryanan had to step in and explain he was hurt that he couldn't hold the rope.

So I get why Amzad felt little insecure but even Kadargal are going to vote him out stating the same reason , in a game of survivor injured person always gets voted out first .

Even in American survivors people tend to hide the extent of their injury ,one player got his knee twisted but pretended it didn't happen so they won't vote him out and so on

Originally posted by: Psurya

Seems Lady Kash also has an immunity idol... so they can't vote out LP and lady kash.. so among Uma,vanessa, vikranth and amzadh any one will go... still I think it will be Amzadh.

How did u know she also has an immunity idol ? Promo didn’t show that, right? She has an extra vote scroll she received as a leader. Not sure when she got the immunity idol .