Ham kahan kay sachay thay (HUM TV)- Usman Mukhtar, Kubra K, Mahira K - Page 50

No wonder trps are falling

Originally posted by: -shabz-

I’m glad the police officer didn’t have much to say in today’s episode.

Nothing happened in today’s epoiside. Shabbo has something to do Mashals death, either she mistakenly mixed up the poisoned food or something else, so she’s covering her butt.

My guess that super screwed up Mashal committed suicide so everyone thinks Mehreen killed her...

Mehreen😭 God girl - why wont you accept help from Safwaan, comeon man😡 !!! Best scene of the episode was Safwaan and Mehreen's interaction - ughh please protect these two babies and just please make them have a happy ending!😭😭

I have no words for Aswad, he is going to make us hell annoyed and angry throughout the show🤬 misogynistic and such dated thinking yikes, he is such a regressive person!

Also I am also annoyed with Salhya Baaji - she should never have forced Aswad-Mehreen into getting engaged. Even she is a grey character!

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Mahira was just outstanding in this episode - its insane how good the performances are. Kubra stole episode 8 with that scene where she wears red chunari on her head! Uff!

And Mehreen in jail and talking to herself about how she dint kill Mashal, or when she meets Safwaan or when she meets her Khala..the start of her mental health break down - it hit so hard man! One of the few shows where I have seen such a strong focus on mental health issues and psychological damage! Such complex emotions and Mahira is doing a stellar job man, as if she is tapping into her own vulnerabilities to perform Mehreen!

I won't comment on good or bad because I am so much into the story ..some epis will be good some will be OK, I am ready for it.

I think mehreen is not stable ..unfortunately, there is nobody who could pull her from this abyss. Safaan is a true friend but mehreen asking him to not help is kinda complicated..may be.. she knows she will have to go through hell but can't pull safaan in it...The last line of the epi was so powerful where mashal says main marr ke bhi zinda hoon and tum zinda hoke marr gayi. Means mashal and what she did, will continue to trouble her..

Mahira was awesome..she is just plain awesome in each and every scene..

Flashbacks of this night plus their past will keep coming up and the layers of their story will be slowly revealed ..that's the best part of the story ..its being narrated extremely well..

Saleyah and all elders in the drama are totally useless and responsible for everything , yet nobody acknowledges. Saleyah continues to blackmail aswad to do what she thinks is correct. She doesn't realize she is pressurizing him so much..probably if she didn't force them into marriage and care to expose mashal instead , he would have seen the truth from his own eyes and said yes for mehreen aise bhi... He is not allowed to think , nor act , nor decide , he is also losing it ..its visible..I totally understand aamna in SH when she said aswad is a victim like the other 2. He is a victim of jealousy of these cousins ..he was so much brainwashed that he lost the sense of right and wrong ..n his mother is not helping him to see things in perspective, rather force her opinion on him.

I enjoyed the epi overall..the haunting music which comes towards the end of every epi ,I love that..

i also love that haunting music . it gives me such sad vibes.im loving all the episodes. can not expect all of them to be riveting . the story telling is amazing.

Even after aswad gave the ring she still wants him to help maybe because she also needs closure from him as he has misunderstood mehreen still as he still does not know the truth. He is still regurgitating what mashal has said about mehreen.

I'm not hating aswad as he said he was a joker in the middle of it all.

He is also feeling guilty that maybe he should have done something that night.

Obviously shabo knows everything and how people have twisted each other in the house and from ost I can see her having words with the mother etc so maybe giving the hard core facts.

I think mishal tried to posion mehreen and somehow maybe got poisoned accidently herself.

The police man and parts of him listening to mehreen were nicely done although his annoying.

What zq was saying to aswad in this episode about mehreen was really referring more to her daughter.

So looking forward to the rest of the episodes.

But feel really sad and awful what she still will go through with nightmares etc.

Originally posted by: dreamstar77

i

Even after aswad gave the ring she still wants him to help maybe because she also needs closure from him as he has misunderstood mehreen still as he still does not know the truth. He is still regurgitating what mashal has said about mehreen.

I can't blame him completely..he was being brain washed for years against mehreen. And when he came bk she also tried to prove it to him..he may not look at Saffan and mehreen that way in normal circumstances but based on what mashal told him, he is being judgemental about it. From his pov , mashal is a victim . First mehreen tells him that she will refuse for shadi then she says yes ..how can aswad trust her ? He was away from them , n he was in contact with only 2 people. Mashal and his mother..who always said the opposite things. I dunno how saleyah was so normal about this whenever he badmouthed mehreen. She could have tried to remove this mu .

He is feeling guilty for a lot of things . Starting from , avoiding mashals death if his mother wasn't this persuasive ..to saying yes to mehreen for marriage...abhi bhi he is constantly asking his mother to not force him to marry mehreen but saleyah doesn't budge. He arranged arranged a lawyer on this condition...She might say mehreen has been acquitted so marry her or even worse , have a heart attack or something n say this is her last wish 🤢 I like mehreens mother better , at least she is consistent ..n the most helpless after mehreen 😆

I am not justifying him..as a character he has his weaknesses ..but I can see where he is coming from..of course , punishing mehreen will be worse 🤢N that too for mashal , for whom he couldn't take a stand .

Originally posted by: _charu_

I won't comment on good or bad because I am so much into the story ..some epis will be good some will be OK, I am ready for it.

I think mehreen is not stable ..unfortunately, there is nobody who could pull her from this abyss. Safaan is a true friend but mehreen asking him to not help is kinda complicated..may be.. she knows she will have to go through hell but can't pull safaan in it...The last line of the epi was so powerful where mashal says main marr ke bhi zinda hoon and tum zinda hoke marr gayi. Means mashal and what she did, will continue to trouble her..

Mahira was awesome..she is just plain awesome in each and every scene..

Flashbacks of this night plus their past will keep coming up and the layers of their story will be slowly revealed ..that's the best part of the story ..its being narrated extremely well..

Saleyah and all elders in the drama are totally useless and responsible for everything , yet nobody acknowledges. Saleyah continues to blackmail aswad to do what she thinks is correct. She doesn't realize she is pressurizing him so much..probably if she didn't force them into marriage and care to expose mashal instead , he would have seen the truth from his own eyes and said yes for mehreen aise bhi... He is not allowed to think , nor act , nor decide , he is also losing it ..its visible..I totally understand aamna in SH when she said aswad is a victim like the other 2. He is a victim of jealousy of these cousins ..he was so much brainwashed that he lost the sense of right and wrong ..n his mother is not helping him to see things in perspective, rather force her opinion on him.

I enjoyed the epi overall..the haunting music which comes towards the end of every epi ,I love that..

Loved your post, I agree I liked this episode too! I only dint like the episode where Mashal actually dies, but it was an attempt to build up a thriller for the actual events of that night in the next couple of episodes, so it makes sense now why it was shot that way.

IKR, I totally dont understand why Saleyah couldnt clear up the MUs pertaining to Mehreen, by giving him substantial evidence about Mehreen being an award winning painter or poetess and academic laurels..why she and Aswad chose to always talk in circles. What is this crap about pressurizing your son to marry whoever you chose for him? She knows Mehreen, but she made no effort to help Aswad clear his misconception about Mehreen.

I cannot connect with Aswad for the most part, but even I understand why it was so wrong to force him to marry someone. Having said that, Aswad is a git - he is partly responsible for Mashal taking the extreme step of committing suicide..or maybe it was accidental death by poison..but she was unstable because of how indecisive and non-committal he was towards her as well. Plus I hated how he washed his hands off their relationship, by terming it as platonic friendship..and I totally dislike his judgemental a** when it comes to Mehreen too.

Originally posted by: -FreeLancer-

I cannot connect with Aswad for the most part, but even I understand why it was so wrong to force him to marry someone. Having said that, Aswad is a git - he is partly responsible for Mashal taking the extreme step of committing suicide..or maybe it was accidental death by poison..but she was unstable because of how indecisive and non-committal he was towards her as well. Plus I hated how he washed his hands off their relationship, by terming it as platonic friendship..and I totally dislike his judgemental a** when it comes to Mehreen too.

He wanted to marry mashal n he was committed to her too n he backed out ainvayi like it's normal..he was wrong there I agree.... but this didn't push mashal to suicide. Whatever aswad had for mashal, she was only pretending to be in love with him.....She was after him bec she knew khala will choose mehreen for aswad and mehreen also loved aswad. Her sole aim was to snatch everything dear from mehreen. Aswad was caught between their war. He was used by mashal and mehreen both. The girls didn't care for his opinion..both used him to get bk at eCh other.

His mother is fully responsible for this shit..this time also when he said uske dost hain help karne ke liye , she doesn't say mehreen is not like that , college mein friends hote hain..she is telling him Haan dost haij but phir relative kyun hote hain..she never asked mehreen about Saffan ? seriously ek toh ye pagal aurat..if saffan is helping her let him.help...what's the problem? Aswad said law will take its course and pata lag jayega mehreen is guilty or not..toh let him have the satisfaction at least but nai.

Haan we can say his own judgement is clouded..he can't differentiate ..I think nobody in his position can..mashal went to extremes to hurt mehreen . Nobody can imagine she could do this, either in aswads love or in jealousy with mehreen

Originally posted by: Neel_M

My guess that super screwed up Mashal committed suicide so everyone thinks Mehreen killed her...

You just summarized the whole plot in one line😆

Episide 10...watched it....and i was crying tons n tons.....

ASWAD toh bhai ...hum kahan ke stupid the....wala haal hai uska....matlab bandi dikh rahi hai kya launde fasane wali....matlab kuch bhi aa...aur woh khud kya hai ....mama's boy ....usse accha toh woh motu hai jo jail mein bar bar aata hai (naam bhool gayi).

Mashal ke mai n baap....ek number ke rokhoode , chid chide ....ek dum pagal types hai ...kya karna cha rahe ho....har time sirf ladayi chilana ....ek dum woh jhahil type feeling aati hai....

Mashal ...her obession for things , to win and against Mehreen was quiet obvious to everyone. But i think she wanted to play smart in the end by killing mehreen....i think she thought since Mehreen is astama patient and if she consumes poison it would be difficult for doctors to save her. But then doosare ki kabar mein khood hi gir gayi....i guess her maid did it unknowingly.

By the time Aswad would know Mehreen would hve turned mad or left the country for good.

This police character is good one i guess he will also play a good role. May be he is Mehreen's step father.

Read Mashal's diary Aswad ...you will cry tons like me ...😂😂