Originally posted by: Bodhianveshika
Namaste,
At the cost of over simplifying the situation on the show, here is my take.
I find no logic in the way both Monami and Siddhart are acting and trying to dissect the sequence of events.
1.) Siddhart is a rich, spoil brat but a "loyal" friend to Monami who has been asked by his father to live a farm life in a bid to instill responsibility and mend his ways. Siddhart, unwilling to go, lies about his proposal to Monami, escapes from home to his lone saviour, Dr.Monami Mahajan. Knowing well, she is at a military Academy to live her dream, her sole purpose.
What was he thinking? Whatever happened to the supportive, loyal friend?!
2.) During his escape he, in a drunk state, speaks to Sanjana and develops an instant connection, identifying her as a tattoo girl at the Academy.
He now needs to find that girl. His homecoming and father long forgotten. Was he expecting to drop at the Academy and return the next day with his new found love interest.
3.) He lands at the Academy and poses as Monami's fiancè who is terminally ill wanting to spend some time her loved ones i.e. his fiancee. Monami plays along, completely aware of the repercussions.
Do she and Siddhart expect random people landing at the Academy for a vacation, flouting rules and get away with it? Is it not a compromise to their own (recruits) safety and privacy?
4.) After a series of convincing, Siddhart stays at the Academy as a mess assistant and people sympathise with him.
This re-ignites Karan's prejudice and he makes Monami bear the brunt of supporting her friend on one ocassion. (I am sure this was right, though her current actions make me think otherwise.)
5.) Mr.Siddhart has found out that the Tattoo girl is none other than Sanjana and continues trying his luck by gifting her and invites her for a date where he is exposed off his claims and actions. For his mistake of betrayal and falsehood and compromising the rules of the Academy, he is rightfully put in jail. Dr.Monami tries unsuccessfully to convince Siddhart to leave the Academy and even tries to make him escape when he is caught and punishment severed.
Dr.Monami doesn't find Siddhart's actions questionable, selfish but finds Karan too harsh, what does she expect from a leader of such a big group to do? Today it is Siddhart and tomorrow it will be another with unacceptable demands.
6.) He is given an option to redeem himself by apologising and leaving the Academy. Instead he persists and is ready to bear it ALL in a bid to convince Sanjana of his intentions where as Sanjana has clearly stated her opinion in trying to convince Siddhart.
First they (Siddhart-Monami) lie, then Siddhart calls Sanjana for a date (while being apparently engaged to Monami, atleast that is what they said). Monami requests Sanjana to speak to Siddhart, which she does. But still, she complains none understands her, really? Does she understand anyone else other than herself and Siddhart?
She, in a vengeful act, alleges Karan of infidelity with No Basis whatsoever.
Can someone tell me what is her problem?
Food for thought: Once Sanjana has made it clear that she doesnt like Siddhart, is it right for Siddhart to persist on convincing her? Is it not promoting persuasion? If it is ok for Siddhart only and not others, then who decides that? Where does one draw the line?