Who sang Pehli Nazar mein ... better??? - Page 4

to be honest .. i didnt like both of them
Sonu , Shaan , KK or even Rahul can sing this song much better than the original & debojit !!!

Originally posted by: a406a4

You ought to read carefully before drawing wrong conclusions. I said most members who post here are undeniably teenage girls with no musical sense, not "all who do not consider him besura is a teenage girl".

And yes Atif is besura, if you diagree, you are entitled to your opinion, but you are not entitled to your own facts. Anyone with even an elementary understanding of music can tell you he's besura, the end product you hear has undergone so many filters/synchronisations/effects/compression during the mixing stage that you can't even imagine.

People are comparing Atif's recorded and thoroughly mixed track with Debojit's live performance, that's like comparing apples to oranges, compare like with like.

Even Sunidhi Chauhan said he can't sing, now before anyone accuses her of being "jealous" or what not, think carefully whether that accusation even makes any sense.

relax we knw how much transition it goes...

and i have seen atif performing LIVE and still hes a hero😳

im nt sayin debojit sings horribly..i dun like his singin..he shud hv chosen a bttr song nt the atif one knowin its the latest hit nowadays...

n u say sunidhi said he cnt sing.....jus 1 person said right...she herself is nt some top singer???? if atif cudnt sing he wudnt hav sung in movies !!!

Originally posted by: a406a4

You ought to read carefully before drawing wrong conclusions. I said most members who post here are undeniably teenage girls with no musical sense, not "all who do not consider him besura is a teenage girl".

And yes Atif is besura, if you diagree, you are entitled to your opinion, but you are not entitled to your own facts. Anyone with even an elementary understanding of music can tell you he's besura, the end product you hear has undergone so many filters/synchronisations/effects/compression during the mixing stage that you can't even imagine.

People are comparing Atif's recorded and thoroughly mixed track with Debojit's live performance, that's like comparing apples to oranges, compare like with like.

Even Sunidhi Chauhan said he can't sing, now before anyone accuses her of being "jealous" or what not, think carefully whether that accusation even makes any sense.

sirji ... it was a gist which means a general picture and not a conclusion ... am sure u know the difference 😉 😊 and well if u think that was not the general pic that ur posts conveyed, i suggest u read again ...

fact!!!! 😲 and what fact have i stated except for the fact that i am feeling young 😉😆 which i really am ... believe me ... 😆

and yup u r entitled to ur views just like i am to mine ... i dont think my post counters ur view at all ... it was just a gist u c ... and completely formulated by my teenage mind 😃

fir bhi agar aap ko bura lag gaya to I dont mind restating -

Atif is supposedly besura and most/majority who think he is not are teenagers or rather teenyboppers 😉 😆

yeh chalega na? 😆

Originally posted by: smallwonder

atif if besura or not, the song is copied or not, one thing is sure - his songs are a treat and yes, they are mesmerizing... i dont care for each taan or murki😆 if it sounds the way it does in pehli nazar mein, its a pleasure to hear and just awesome... i wish he doesnt change his singing style by any bit or his musical know-how...😆

Very well said Sachin 👏

And i think this is what most 'teenagers' here mean! The emotions he puts into the songs he sings are difficult to match be it the anguish and pain in 'Aadat' or the romance in 'Pehli Nazar' and hence his songs are tough to sing! And let me add that i dont think he is a great singer technically and nor am I a big fan of his! But saying Debo is better than him is a bit too much IMO!

Originally posted by: a406a4

You sound very confused, I suggest you take a class in logic. 😊

i just modified my statment based on what you wanted ... and u feel i am confused? now i think i am 😕😆

Originally posted by: kiti_g

Very well said Sachin 👏

And i think this is what most 'teenagers' here mean! The emotions he puts into the songs he sings are difficult to match be it the anguish and pain in 'Aadat' or the romance in 'Pehli Nazar' and hence his songs are tough to sing! And let me add that i dont think he is a great singer technically and nor am I a big fan of his! But saying Debo is better than him is a bit too much IMO!

I think pehli nazar mein is the most passionate song I heard in a long long time😛 Its unmatchable...👏 Theres a raw appeal or kind of "madness" in the song... The only thing coming close to it that I can think of is Sonu Nigam's "Is Pyar Ko" from Mujhe Kuch Kehna Hai...

Moderator's Note: Topic is being closed. Author can open it again for discussion. Members are being warned not to go for name calling for fellow members. You cannot call your fellow members as stupid or question their musical knowledge in improper language. See that this is not repeated again.