What do you guys think is this Ayushman story true? - Page 2

I also think it is a scam because of the story which Sonakshi is narrating to soha and soha's questions about evil person trying to take away princess, father not being there, and mother is going to rescue.... I think soon this track is going to surface devakshi's problem.... Like how Natasha's said that little iceberg was enough to sink Titanic....

This track is going to show 'k agr dono phle jaise bond share kr rhe hote then this problem might have finished within few days, but since they are not like earlier devakshi ,lack of communication will lead them to believe about cooked up story...

If you approach the topic logically, needless to say it doesn't make sense.

First of all, Suhana is too much of a miniature replica of Devakshi to not have their genes in her.

Second, when Suhana was born Devakshi were estranged & Sonakshi had reverted back to her maiden name, i.e., Sonakshi Bijoy Bose. Nowhere in patients list or doctors' chart or hospital records she was registered under her married name. Even Suhana's birth certificate did not have Dev's name in it. She was named Suhana Bose, not Suhana Dixit. How come this Ayushman's father knew that she is Dev's wife & the child is Dev's child? Even the nurse recalled her by the name Sonakshi Dev Dixit. A name she was not using at that time. That's a serious mismatch of information there.

Third, when Suhana was born, Yatin was with Sonakshi, so was her family. The moment the child was born her family would have been informed about the child's gender. How is it possible to swap a boy with a girl? Even if Sonakshi was passed out, which is unlikely, there were at least 3-4 more people for the newborn child to go missing?

Fourth, After their reunion Dev had flown out to Kolkata to know more about Sonakshi's pregnancy days. He visited the hospital, literally sat on the very same bed & came back with tons of reports, charts, ultrasonography plates & pictures. If something big like this happened, how come nothing was amiss back then? Dev used to have a private detective on his beck & call back then, no? If anything was problematic it would have come up.

So logically speaking this baby swapping theory doesn't fit in & it would look like this Ayushman's father is lying. For reasons unknown.

But I am afraid the makers aren't thinking so much about logic. They are high on creative adrenaline & most probably is out there to create new history & don't care much about previous details. They might be aiming for a social message about adoption & treating adopted child equally to biological child to gain critical acclaim and they probably think that since it's been almost 5 years since season 1, people have forgotten the details shown there. Dev is already sold to the idea that Ayushman is his son & he is seeing himself in him. That's ringing an alarming bell in my mind. Plus in the press conference they really hyped up this track & said something like a truth from the past will come to the front & it will change their lives forever. So....who knows? They might actually be showing this to be truth.

The change of writers have created this mess in my opinion. If Durjoy Dutta was on board, this probably wouldn't have happened.

i don't think they will show soha as not their daughter maybe they are delaying the DNA testing due to that😔

Originally posted by: Antaramantara

I also think it is a scam because of the story which Sonakshi is narrating to soha and soha's questions about evil person trying to take away princess, father not being there, and mother is going to rescue.... I think soon this track is going to surface devakshi's problem.... Like how Natasha's said that little iceberg was enough to sink Titanic....

This track is going to show 'k agr dono phle jaise bond share kr rhe hote then this problem might have finished within few days, but since they are not like earlier devakshi ,lack of communication will lead them to believe about cooked up story...

Yes I strongly feel it's a scam and if Dev comes in Ishwari's words and agrees to give Soha away then biological parents or not Soha should never call him 'papa' again.

Soha should only consider Sona her mother rest of the Dixits can go to hell.

We are not sure yet

But the nurse could be lying she is dishonest anyway

Interesting theories am reading here.

Am more confused with this illogicality. It doesnt make sense to show a married couple come back together after drifting apart with demanding careers, with baby swapping as the underlying factor.

It can be shown normally also. This swapping drama is so unlike Mamta & Yash Patnaiks idea of KRPKAB reboot. For me it reeks of typical Ekta drama like many have opined in other threads.

Viji

Originally posted by: NotAMuggle

If you approach the topic logically, needless to say it doesn't make sense.

First of all, Suhana is too much of a miniature replica of Devakshi to not have their genes in her.

Second, when Suhana was born Devakshi were estranged & Sonakshi had reverted back to her maiden name, i.e., Sonakshi Bijoy Bose. Nowhere in patients list or doctors' chart or hospital records she was registered under her married name. Even Suhana's birth certificate did not have Dev's name in it. She was named Suhana Bose, not Suhana Dixit. How come this Ayushman's father knew that she is Dev's wife & the child is Dev's child? Even the nurse recalled her by the name Sonakshi Dev Dixit. A name she was not using at that time. That's a serious mismatch of information there.

Third, when Suhana was born, Yatin was with Sonakshi, so was her family. The moment the child was born her family would have been informed about the child's gender. How is it possible to swap a boy with a girl? Even if Sonakshi was passed out, which is unlikely, there were at least 3-4 more people for the newborn child to go missing?

Fourth, After their reunion Dev had flown out to Kolkata to know more about Sonakshi's pregnancy days. He visited the hospital, literally sat on the very same bed & came back with tons of reports, charts, ultrasonography plates & pictures. If something big like this happened, how come nothing was amiss back then? Dev used to have a private detective on his beck & call back then, no? If anything was problematic it would have come up.

So logically speaking this baby swapping theory doesn't fit in & it would look like this Ayushman's father is lying. For reasons unknown.

But I am afraid the makers aren't thinking so much about logic. They are high on creative adrenaline & most probably is out there to create new history & don't care much about previous details. They might be aiming for a social message about adoption & treating adopted child equally to biological child to gain critical acclaim and they probably think that since it's been almost 5 years since season 1, people have forgotten the details shown there. Dev is already sold to the idea that Ayushman is his son & he is seeing himself in him. That's ringing an alarming bell in my mind. Plus in the press conference they really hyped up this track & said something like a truth from the past will come to the front & it will change their lives forever. So....who knows? They might actually be showing this to be truth.

The change of writers have created this mess in my opinion. If Durjoy Dutta was on board, this probably wouldn't have happened.

Good post 👍🏼

You are right about Sonakshi reverting to her maiden name after their separation. So it’s very difficult to believe that Rohit knew that she is married to Dev Dixit.

Also the nurse referring to her as Sonakshi Dev Dixit is a mistake but I guess they are hoping that we have forgotten all these details 😆

And yes her family and Jatin were present when Soha was born. In yesterday’s episode Sonakshi said she was unconscious as it was a c-Sec delivery, but even then it’s impossible to believe that the doctor didn’t immediately inform her family about the child’s gender

Dev was a playboy for seven years, I hope it's his illegitimate son who is currently the centre of attraction. The way he was shifting his attention from one female to another, he could have impregnated someone. It makes sense if his own blood makes way into the family in such a manner.

Originally posted by: Salutethearmy

Dev was a playboy for seven years, I hope it's his illegitimate son who is currently the centre of attraction. The way he was shifting his attention from one female to another, he could have impregnated someone. It makes sense if his own blood makes way into the family in such a manner.

You know , I was thinking the story is taking that kind of turn but this is beyond imagination , still fine with it.

It can happen in rarest of rare case !

Originally posted by: NotAMuggle

If you approach the topic logically, needless to say it doesn't make sense.

First of all, Suhana is too much of a miniature replica of Devakshi to not have their genes in her.

Second, when Suhana was born Devakshi were estranged & Sonakshi had reverted back to her maiden name, i.e., Sonakshi Bijoy Bose. Nowhere in patients list or doctors' chart or hospital records she was registered under her married name. Even Suhana's birth certificate did not have Dev's name in it. She was named Suhana Bose, not Suhana Dixit. How come this Ayushman's father knew that she is Dev's wife & the child is Dev's child? Even the nurse recalled her by the name Sonakshi Dev Dixit. A name she was not using at that time. That's a serious mismatch of information there.

Third, when Suhana was born, Yatin was with Sonakshi, so was her family. The moment the child was born her family would have been informed about the child's gender. How is it possible to swap a boy with a girl? Even if Sonakshi was passed out, which is unlikely, there were at least 3-4 more people for the newborn child to go missing?

Fourth, After their reunion Dev had flown out to Kolkata to know more about Sonakshi's pregnancy days. He visited the hospital, literally sat on the very same bed & came back with tons of reports, charts, ultrasonography plates & pictures. If something big like this happened, how come nothing was amiss back then? Dev used to have a private detective on his beck & call back then, no? If anything was problematic it would have come up.

So logically speaking this baby swapping theory doesn't fit in & it would look like this Ayushman's father is lying. For reasons unknown.

But I am afraid the makers aren't thinking so much about logic. They are high on creative adrenaline & most probably is out there to create new history & don't care much about previous details. They might be aiming for a social message about adoption & treating adopted child equally to biological child to gain critical acclaim and they probably think that since it's been almost 5 years since season 1, people have forgotten the details shown there. Dev is already sold to the idea that Ayushman is his son & he is seeing himself in him. That's ringing an alarming bell in my mind. Plus in the press conference they really hyped up this track & said something like a truth from the past will come to the front & it will change their lives forever. So....who knows? They might actually be showing this to be truth.

The change of writers have created this mess in my opinion. If Durjoy Dutta was on board, this probably wouldn't have happened.

Makers must hv thought audience must hv forgotten. But they don't know we hv watched multiple times..😆

But I always felt devakshi bond was never strong. Sona came back to dev without much dev redemption. So, I will not b surprised if devakshi breakup again.