What if PP was a positive character - Page 3

Originally posted by: musicalstorm

For the bolded lines....The powerpuff girl in your DP was my first reaction...🤣 But the purple lines you wrote made me think it happens.

Dont hit me but my Bhabhi says that she like PP more just because of her looks. And then she says PP ekdum pagal hai kya karti hai. She also says Sai nahi achhi lagti mere ko looks wise par phir bolti hai Virat ke Saath to Sai hi achhi lagti hai 🤣

I have this multiple expressions Cheeku watching it with my Bhabhi

If we are discussing characters, I'd like to add my POV, it's just my opinion

This show leaves no scope for any other character be it Virat, Pakhi, Kaku or anyone else, The show revolves around Sai, There is a reason why no other character is loved. One can say they accept negative characters but when a successful actress plays a negative character, her huge fandom rallies behind her to support her character, I remember she also justified her character killing people, how else are you going to play a character, if you don't think it is right?

If you can't think from your character's perspective, you can't play it

Which grey character has been embraced by ITV audience? Why wouldn't they write grey characters, if it worked? They write mahan FLs because that's what gets the TRP and its absolutely right as it is about money in the end

Even in happiest moment of her life, Devi is given dialogues to present that she is on Sai's side like today

Remember when Virat was injured and his mom was more interested in asking Pakhi to leave the hospital than care about Virat, which mother will care about Pakhi's presence there? But they had to show that Ashwani is on Sai's side against Pakhi

This show is about Sai

Negative is people against Sai or anything which goes against Sai

Positive is people who support Sai

You'll see how ML goes from negative to positive on basis of above mentioned criteria

I strictly believe acting is an opinion not a skill because if you hate a person, you don't like anything about them and 3rd wheel in every show is worst actor of planet Earth (I have done it too, not taking any high ground), its just how it works on ITV

It is not about positive or negative. It is about accepting role as it is. I don't think aiswarya is that innocent to not to google about kusum dola when they came to know about remake. So 99% she knew this from starting itself that pakhi is a vamp in making.

May be somehow she expected viewers to accept pakhi and vp story in their positive days but that didn't happened.. people loved sairat from gc days itself and after marriage they directly jumped to hit pair.. may be she thinks if pakhi is positive character people will accept her and vp even now.. so she tries to show it as positive and a victim even when scene projects opposite..Thus end up in giving contradicting expressions.so i believe if she accept character as negative she can perform better as pakhi...

Playing a negative character is difficult, and it tests a actors ability a lot to play such characters, without making others cringe. There is a reason why well played negative characters have so much fan following, be it Maya from Beyhadh or SRK from Darr. These characters don't have much redeeming qualities, yet they are loved by many, even more than the protagonists. And that is because of the acting prowess of the actors who did those roles. That is precisely why Aishwarya fails as an actress, at least for me. If she was a better actress, then the character would have been loved or at least tolerated by many.

Originally posted by: NoraSM

If we are discussing characters, I'd like to add my POV, it's just my opinion

This show leaves no scope for any other character be it Virat, Pakhi, Kaku or anyone else, The show revolves around Sai, There is a reason why no other character is loved. One can say they accept negative characters but when a successful actress plays a negative character, her huge fandom rallies behind her to support her character, I remember she also justified her character killing people, how else are you going to play a character, if you don't think it is right?

If you can't think from your character's perspective, you can't play it

Which grey character has been embraced by ITV audience? Why wouldn't they write grey characters, if it worked? They write mahan FLs because that's what gets the TRP and its absolutely right as it is about money in the end

Even in happiest moment of her life, Devi is given dialogues to present that she is on Sai's side like today

Remember when Virat was injured and his mom was more interested in asking Pakhi to leave the hospital than care about Virat, which mother will care about Pakhi's presence there? But they had to show that Ashwani is on Sai's side against Pakhi

This show is about Sai

Negative is people against Sai or anything which goes against Sai

Positive is people who support Sai

You'll see how ML goes from negative to positive on basis of above mentioned criteria

I strictly believe acting is an opinion not a skill because if you hate a person, you don't like anything about them and 3rd wheel in every show is worst actor of planet Earth (I have done it too, not taking any high ground), its just how it works on ITV

Well, there are many shows in which 3rd wheel/negative character is bashed but actors are appreciated even when they are not played by not so popular ones.. Actually negative characters made them popular.. for example tapsya in uttran... Reshmi's acting was widely appreciated. In fact more than tina. Ada khan in naagin. Original tanu in kumkum bhagya, amrapali in qubool hai, kamya punjabi in banoo mein teri dulhan..Etc..

And if we consider ghum, the actress played pakhi's role in bengali version is also appreciated for her performance and in tamil the original actress got appreciated but the second one was pretty bad...

Ayesha was criticized for her poor performance in initial days..called out for Her dialogue delivery, hospital scene in front of icu etc..

In case of aiswarya people do appreciated her initial days to be precise sairat reception/ her return to maayka.. similarly in yesterday's episode too.

And in scenes today's episode everyone can see how bad she is.. even her fans can't disagree that it's too much..

Originally posted by: JugniPH

Well, there are many shows in which 3rd wheel/negative character is bashed but actors are appreciated even when they are not played by not so popular ones.. Actually negative characters made them popular.. for example tapsya in uttran... Reshmi's acting was widely appreciated. In fact more than tina. Ada khan in naagin. Original tanu in kumkum bhagya, amrapali in qubool hai, kamya punjabi in banoo mein teri dulhan..Etc..

And if we consider ghum, the actress played pakhi's role in bengali version is also appreciated for her performance and in tamil the original actress got appreciated but the second one was pretty bad...

Ayesha was criticized for her poor performance in initial days..called out for Her dialogue delivery, hospital scene in front of icu etc..

In case of aiswarya people do appreciated her initial days to be precise sairat reception/ her return to maayka.. similarly in yesterday's episode too.

And in scenes today's episode everyone can see how bad she is.. even her fans can't disagree that it's too much..

Ansh from kyunki saas bhi kabhi bahi thi

Originally posted by: JugniPH

Actually negative characters made them popular.. for example tapsya in uttran... Reshmi's acting was widely appreciated. In fact more than tina. Ada khan in naagin. Original tanu in kumkum bhagya, amrapali in qubool hai, kamya punjabi in banoo mein teri dulhan..Etc..

I would also like to add that Aalisha Panwar was loved more as Tara than as Arohi, even though Tara was a psycho. Also Tejasswi was appreciated for playing a negative Ragini in Swaragini, even though the character was hated by many. There are many more in this list.

Originally posted by: musicalstorm

Ishaani meri maa ke saath dekhun to mein has has ke paagal ho jaau...

Akele hi dekhna chahiye shows....From a past week watching with them and I am like

Oh yeah, my mum gives running commentary along with the show🤣

Originally posted by: musicalstorm

Hey forum people...Hope you all are safe and happy

From the day one when PP was shown she was a positive character till the entrance of Sai. After Sai's entrance this character has disappointed us a lot...

Now point is that when Aishwariya was offered the role of Patralekha, she thought it was a positive one and accepted the role. Afterwards she came to know it was a grey shade or a negative one. She has no clarity in her mind that what type of her character is. Aishwariya justifies Pakhi always. Where I have seen other actors always accept the negativity of the character they play.

Now seeing her playing Devi in the play, I feel her acting is good. The part of her acting which is nourished is to play a positive role, but for negative role she has to work hard. If she was a positive character (though grey), opposite to Samrat then she would have done a much better job

Here the CVs have done a wrong casting for a negative character. They had no clarity in their while constructing Patralekha and same has passed to Aishwariya

If she was a positive character she might have done a good job

I guess even if she accepts her role whole heartedly,like she accepted that she is playing devi during the skit, most things will get better.

As in ,we can't stop character bashing of Patralekha, but Aish will be at peace. Cuz a negative character is bound to get dislike and she will be satisfied by her work,no need to justify it.❤️

Originally posted by: janecastle

I would also like to add that Aalisha Panwar was loved more as Tara than as Arohi, even though Tara was a psycho. Also Tejasswi was appreciated for playing a negative Ragini in Swaragini, even though the character was hated by many. There are many more in this list.

Actually I am watching swaragini again nowadays and I feel Ragini ka character is what Pakhi’s could have been

Ragini was positive initially but in middle apne pyar ko paane ke liye she became negative but when you see her scenes she never behaved as vamp she always behaved like she is the victim very well portrayed