Na Bole Tum Na Maine Kuch Kaha

janhav thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#1

Suprabhat Bhagininno! (Morning greetings in Marathi for sisters)

Today's title is for me - so that I save everyone from my heavy onslaughts 🤣 I will try to keep it short and sweet.

Okay, so the title is also for Virat and Sai (and PP, but in the end)

I am not sure if the dialogues are purposely being left loose to leave it open for interpretation but I think they can do a better job. Anyhow, taking the scene at face value:

Much hesitation, much distance but what spoke louder than the dialogues was the silence -- there was no expectation for explanations or accolades. I liked the beauty with which their understanding was highlighted in today's short scene.

In one of the threads yesterday, I mentioned how I saw the entire fight between Virat and Sai as 'normal' where he was ranting without even meaning much and Sai understood that. Although she was hurt, she did not turn it into an ego issue. She just wanted to cool off and think of a solution. His "yahan tak sab bhara hai Sai, Kuch bhi andar kaise Jayega" in the middle of all the other rant was a signal enough that this was just an "outburst" and Sai picked that up. Fights are ugly in real life as well. What we do after that is what makes a difference.

Just like the fight seemed so 'normal', their first interaction alone also was so 'normal'. The silence was deep. I LOVED it how they began the conversation with a "Thank you" instead of a sorry... Sai was actually not looking for a sorry either. Virat's standing up for her in the end had already done it for her because anyone else's opinion doesn't matter to her.

And he anyway did say 'Sorry'. She knew he did not need to explain himself further. He means it and it has been accepted.

Now coming to the Na bole, na Kaha:

I guess the dialogues felt so incomplete because it is actually a feeling that cannot be expressed in words... The beginning of an unconditional love, where there is no expectation to even be loved in return.

"Main aapki lagti hi kya hoon..."

"Mujhse mat poocho... Apne aap se poocho main tumhara kya Lagta hoon..."

'Main kaise samjhaun Sai ki main.... Ruk Jao"

And the clincher:

"Aaj ke baad na main tumhe is kamre se jaane ko kahunga... Aur na hi jaane doonga.."

(Sai, you are smart. That's Chavan saheb's way of saying, "I am just taking back my assurance that I gave you - tum doctor ban jaogi toh ye Shaadi chhodhkar chali jaana. Main tumhe Nahi baandhunga... I have changed my mind. Ab Nahi jaane doonga." 😎 Your deal wali marriage is official over. It is now a journey to find the answer to 'jaane tu Mera kya hai...' 😉 and in Chakram niwas, it will be full of roller coaster rides...)

To what extent will he be able to live up to this, we'll see (since most of us have killed the cat with our curiosity anyway 🤣)

Sai has rejected the 'dosti' offer. OBVIOUSLY na, Chavan saheb, aapki dosti ka definition 3 din me Dekh Kar koi bhi aisa hi bolega and wo toh Sai hai, Sai 😅 Pata Chala, the next morning you plan a "three best friends" wala outing saying, "A is friend with B and A is best friend with C so B and C can be 'just friends' na? No, Sai, it's not worth the risk. Don't take that. But he didn't really feel the rejection either. Wo Kaunsa sach me dosti offer Kar Raha hai 🤣 we all know, he can't tell her that her hair clip is missing 😂😂. And if he doesn't get his good night's sleep, DIG will set up another departmental inquiry, so Sai, please stay back and build your Sinhagadh.

Last two lines:

PP ko bhi Virat Ka 'Na bole tum Na Maine Kuch Kaha' samajh me aa Gaya. I liked how she checked out her rang badalta mangalsutra in the mirror in her room. But unfortunately, her disturbing association of the mangalsutra with the unreasonable idea with which she allowed Samrat to tie it is going to bring her more gloom. I wish this intelligent girl finds her purpose in life and starts afresh. And if you ask me, it cannot be with Samrat because she has married for the wrong reasons. In her mind, she hasn't married him at all. She needs to walk out of this entire situation, the entire marriage and free Samrat and herself from it and reboot her life. (We know it won't happen, but it was free advise)

I liked how she said "Main MATURE hoon, Apne faisle khud Leti hoon"

Virat, it's time for you to relieve yourself and her from the weight of the vaada because (as moronic as you are) she has made her OWN decision to marry her husband. Seriously, it's not your baggage to carry. Sometimes the more you push back the inevitable, the more it comes back to bite you.

Today's episode has already set the tone for how difficult it's going to be for Sai and Virat to leave behind this monster called 'vaadas', outside the saat vachans, that they have given each other. They are going to feel the pull, yearn and yet, allow the silence to speak. Ek doosre se door ho kar bhi, ek Saath...

With that, I bow out.

Waiting to hear from you all...

Edited by jankiraghav - 5 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

26

Views

3.3k

Users

17

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

Rajashri389 thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#2

Iiked your post

And one sentence "rang badal ta Mangalsutra" is👌

Blackwind thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#3

Well... first thing first.. I loved your title❤️😳

Secondly I believe that the conversation between SaiRat was left open...many things can be interpreted from that and thirdly Pakhi...I think I really can't understand her character🤔so no thoughts from me for her...😆

Ishradivani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#4

Huge huge respect for analysing the situation in an excellent wayy ❤️

I have no words to say anything ........ I keep waiting for your posts everyday


The line " rang badalta mangalsutra " is just bomb. Everyday I used to think abt that mangalsutra and those colors but never thought in this way.

Great respect to you❤️

LadyWhistledown thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#5

Januuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!!!!! 🤗

This is exactly what I was waiting for. As soon as I finished watching today's episode, I scouted the forum to look for any posts that you have made. When I didn't see anything, I was thinking, "Arre, yeh kahan gayab ho gayi?"😆

Even I noticed the fact that the dialogues have no proper conclusion, and there is less clarity. But it does stick true to what the characters are feeling and experiencing.

I really love the fact that SaiRat seldom need words to express what they are feeling. I think that the silence speaks louder than words. It also shows that unsaid comfort that lingers between them, where no words are required.

Sai was completely right when she said to PP, "agar aap nahi aate, toh bhi yeh shaant ho jaate." Virat just wanted to vent it out, and Sai would have let him. PP just added fuel to fire and watched them burn. I loved how Sai was the voice of reason after everything that was said to her and did not turn it into such an issue.

Though I was disappointed with the apology scene, because I wanted Virat to suffer a bit (sadistic... I know😆), I think that the scene was beautifully executed. Sai was definitely not looking for an apology, and she was not expecting a thank you either, because, for Sai whatever she did was nothing praiseworthy. She did what she had to do in order to save Virat's career and it was the most normal thing in the world.

And coming to the main part...

"Main aapki kya lagti hoon...", "Tum khud se poocho ki main tumhara kya lagta hoon...", it sounded very confusing, but that's how it should be. Both of them know that their dynamics are slowly changing. Both of them are not ready to come to terms with it yet. Because there are so many other things binding them.

And when Virat said, "Main kaise samjhaun Sai ki main.... Ruk Jao", is it just me, or did Virat actually sound quite vulnerable. Like he was letting his guard down and asking her to stay.

And that "Jaane nahi doonga" dialogue😆. I don't think it's just restricted to the kamra any more.

And yeah! Sai... she wants nothing to do with his dosti🤣 She has seen what it is like, and she'll never get into that mess.


Now, coming to Pakhi, her sequences had me confused to most.

I liked mangalstura-mirror sequence because it was very symbolic. She definitely deserves her happy ending too, despite everything. And contrary to what you feel, I do think that this can happen with Samrat. It is true that the reason that she got into this marriage is completely wrong. But it would be a very beautiful sequence if she stays back for the right reasons. Because, I've said this before too, Samrat has given Pakhi a lot more respect in the 2 days that he knew her, than Virat, whom she's supposedly in love with. Samrat too deserves to be happy, either with her or someone else, but it would be symbolic if it is with Pakhi because she was the one who broke his heart (more Virat, but yeah) and she can help him heal, while Samrat also helps pull her out of the rut she got herself into. They'll be good for each other. But I don't even know if the CVs remember Samrat's existence.


Virat, it's time for you to relieve yourself and her from the weight of the vaada because (as moronic as you are) she has made her OWN decision to marry her husband. Seriously, it's not your baggage to carry. Sometimes the more you push back the inevitable, the more it comes back to bite you.

This is just so true! Only he can relieve himself and Pakhi of the vaada, and that can be done only by self-reflecting on his mistakes and being honest about it (and I guess that will take a long time).


Today's episode has already set the tone for how difficult it's going to be for Sai and Virat to leave behind this monster called 'vaadas', outside the saat vachans, that they have given each other. They are going to feel the pull, yearn and yet, allow the silence to speak. Ek doosre se door ho kar bhi, ek Saath...

This, you've summed up so beautifully🤗. They have a long way to go before they can even come to terms with what they are feeling, but each journey will only make them stronger.


@blue - I used to watch this show called "Saraswathichandra". And the title track of that show sums up SaiRat's relationship so beautifully...

"Rahe na kuch bhi darmiyaan, mithe yeh saari dooriyan, milke bhi hai adhoori si yeh dastaan.". I think this is the core of SaiRat's relationship.


Chalo, ab maine bhi ek essay likh diya🤣 How many marks do I get?

Jalebi-Bhai thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#6

WOW. That was amazing. I'm sitting here reading this eating chocolate cookies and I REALLY enjoyed that. First off, you write beautifully.


Also quick dumb question but the whole analysis based on that one line, was it from the show? I have been skipping and watching so I'm like I can't believe I missed such a great dialogue.


I love how you used that one line and went into so much depth with the characters and where they stand.


I LOVED how you talked about him changing his mind and wanting to always have her by his side. It was such a heavy sentence and I really hope Sai got what he meant.

scarlett22 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 5 years ago
#7

Thank you once again for such a beautiful post. There were lot of gaps in understanding for me today. And I'm determinedly avoiding watching the other 2 versions.

All the characters have so much of a back story. Even Virat, it could not have been easy for him to watch his mother being put down and humiliated throughout his childhood.

Ok, I'm babbling. I need to watch the episode again😆

Blackwind thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: LadyWhistledown

Januuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!!!!! 🤗

This is exactly what I was waiting for. As soon as I finished watching today's episode, I scouted the forum to look for any posts that you have made. When I didn't see anything, I was thinking, "Arre, yeh kahan gayab ho gayi?"😆

Even I noticed the fact that the dialogues have no proper conclusion, and there is less clarity. But it does stick true to what the characters are feeling and experiencing.

I really love the fact that SaiRat seldom need words to express what they are feeling. I think that the silence speaks louder than words. It also shows that unsaid comfort that lingers between them, where no words are required.

Sai was completely right when she said to PP, "agar aap nahi aate, toh bhi yeh shaant ho jaate." Virat just wanted to vent it out, and Sai would have let him. PP just added fuel to fire and watched them burn. I loved how Sai was the voice of reason after everything that was said to her and did not turn it into such an issue.

Though I was disappointed with the apology scene, because I wanted Virat to suffer a bit (sadistic... I know😆), I think that the scene was beautifully executed. Sai was definitely not looking for an apology, and she was not expecting a thank you either, because, for Sai whatever she did was nothing praiseworthy. She did what she had to do in order to save Virat's career and it was the most normal thing in the world.

And coming to the main part...

"Main aapki kya lagti hoon...", "Tum khud se poocho ki main tumhara kya lagta hoon...", it sounded very confusing, but that's how it should be. Both of them know that their dynamics are slowly changing. Both of them are not ready to come to terms with it yet. Because there are so many other things binding them.

And when Virat said, "Main kaise samjhaun Sai ki main.... Ruk Jao", is it just me, or did Virat actually sound quite vulnerable. Like he was letting his guard down and asking her to stay.

And that "Jaane nahi doonga" dialogue😆. I don't think it's just restricted to the kamra any more.

And yeah! Sai... she wants nothing to do with his dosti🤣 She has seen what it is like, and she'll never get into that mess.


Now, coming to Pakhi, her sequences had me confused to most.

I liked mangalstura-mirror sequence because it was very symbolic. She definitely deserves her happy ending too, despite everything. And contrary to what you feel, I do think that this can happen with Samrat. It is true that the reason that she got into this marriage is completely wrong. But it would be a very beautiful sequence if she stays back for the right reasons. Because, I've said this before too, Samrat has given Pakhi a lot more respect in the 2 days that he knew her, than Virat, whom she's supposedly in love with. Samrat too deserves to be happy, either with her or someone else, but it would be symbolic if it is with Pakhi because she was the one who broke his heart (more Virat, but yeah) and she can help him heal, while Samrat also helps pull her out of the rut she got herself into. They'll be good for each other. But I don't even know if the CVs remember Samrat's existence.


Virat, it's time for you to relieve yourself and her from the weight of the vaada because (as moronic as you are) she has made her OWN decision to marry her husband. Seriously, it's not your baggage to carry. Sometimes the more you push back the inevitable, the more it comes back to bite you.

This is just so true! Only he can relieve himself and Pakhi of the vaada, and that can be done only by self-reflecting on his mistakes and being honest about it (and I guess that will take a long time).


Today's episode has already set the tone for how difficult it's going to be for Sai and Virat to leave behind this monster called 'vaadas', outside the saat vachans, that they have given each other. They are going to feel the pull, yearn and yet, allow the silence to speak. Ek doosre se door ho kar bhi, ek Saath...

This, you've summed up so beautifully🤗. They have a long way to go before they can even come to terms with what they are feeling, but each journey will only make them stronger.


@blue - I used to watch this show called "Saraswathichandra". And the title track of that show sums up SaiRat's relationship so beautifully...

"Rahe na kuch bhi darmiyaan, mithe yeh saari dooriyan, milke bhi hai adhoori si yeh dastaan.". I think this is the core of SaiRat's relationship.


Chalo, ab maine bhi ek essay likh diya🤣 How many marks do I get?

@bold thats my most favourite ost❤️....I love listening to it and somedays back even I was referring it to SaiRat while listening

Edited by Blackwind - 5 years ago
SonuRani thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Rajashri389

Iiked your post

And one sentence "rang badal ta Mangalsutra" is👌

🤣🤣👍

I-Am-SherLOCKED thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: jankiraghav

Suprabhat Bhagininno! (Morning greetings in Marathi for sisters)

Suprabhat!!

Today's title is for me - so that I save everyone from my heavy onslaughts 🤣 I will try to keep it short and sweet.

Okay, so the title is also for Virat and Sai (and PP, but in the end)

I am not sure if the dialogues are purposely being left loose to leave it open for interpretation but I think they can do a better job. Anyhow, taking the scene at face value:

They definitely can do a better job. If they were aiming for "open to interpretation"- it fell sort of flat. I have no clue what was going on.

Much hesitation, much distance but what spoke louder than the dialogues was the silence -- there was no expectation for explanations or accolades. I liked the beauty with which their understanding was highlighted in today's short scene.

True that. I was dreading the new SaiRat customised Ghum song with the besura singer but thank heavens, no OTT music or hair flying. Sweet and simple.

In one of the threads yesterday, I mentioned how I saw the entire fight between Virat and Sai as 'normal' where he was ranting without even meaning much and Sai understood that. Although she was hurt, she did not turn it into an ego issue. She just wanted to cool off and think of a solution. His "yahan tak sab bhara hai Sai, Kuch bhi andar kaise Jayega" in the middle of all the other rant was a signal enough that this was just an "outburst" and Sai picked that up. Fights are ugly in real life as well. What we do after that is what makes a difference.

Just like the fight seemed so 'normal', their first interaction alone also was so 'normal'. The silence was deep. I LOVED it how they began the conversation with a "Thank you" instead of a sorry... Sai was actually not looking for a sorry either. Virat's standing up for her in the end had already done it for her because anyone else's opinion doesn't matter to her.

This was also highlighted when Usha Maushi told Sai "Damadji hamesha tera sath dete hain, tujhe galat nahin saabit hone diya." That slight smile which came on her face but she quickly brushed it off. That was so sweet.

And he anyway did say 'Sorry'. She knew he did not need to explain himself further. He means it and it has been accepted.

Now coming to the Na bole, na Kaha:

I guess the dialogues felt so incomplete because it is actually a feeling that cannot be expressed in words... The beginning of an unconditional love, where there is no expectation to even be loved in return.

"Main aapki lagti hi kya hoon..."

"Mujhse mat poocho... Apne aap se poocho main tumhara kya Lagta hoon..."

'Main kaise samjhaun Sai ki main.... Ruk Jao"

And the clincher:

"Aaj ke baad na main tumhe is kamre se jaane ko kahunga... Aur na hi jaane doonga.."

(Sai, you are smart. That's Chavan saheb's way of saying, "I am just taking back my assurance that I gave you - tum doctor ban jaogi toh ye Shaadi chhodhkar chali jaana. Main tumhe Nahi baandhunga... I have changed my mind. Ab Nahi jaane doonga." 😎 Your deal wali marriage is official over. It is now a journey to find the answer to 'jaane tu Mera kya hai...' 😉 and in Chakram niwas, it will be full of roller coaster rides...)

To what extent will he be able to live up to this, we'll see (since most of us have killed the cat with our curiosity anyway 🤣)

Sai has rejected the 'dosti' offer. OBVIOUSLY na, Chavan saheb, aapki dosti ka definition 3 din me Dekh Kar koi bhi aisa hi bolega and wo toh Sai hai, Sai 😅 Pata Chala, the next morning you plan a "three best friends" wala outing saying, "A is friend with B and A is best friend with C so B and C can be 'just friends' na? 🤣🤣🤣

No, Sai, it's not worth the risk. Don't take that. But he didn't really feel the rejection either. Wo Kaunsa sach me dosti offer Kar Raha hai 🤣 we all know, he can't tell her that her hair clip is missing 😂😂. And if he doesn't get his good night's sleep, DIG will set up another departmental inquiry, so Sai, please stay back and build your Sinhagadh.

Totalpura wala attempt. Usko Sai se dosti shosti nahin karni, bas usse baatein karne ke liye bahane chahiye.

Last two lines:

PP ko bhi Virat Ka 'Na bole tum Na Maine Kuch Kaha' samajh me aa Gaya. I liked how she checked out her rang badalta mangalsutra in the mirror in her room. But unfortunately, her disturbing association of the mangalsutra with the unreasonable idea with which she allowed Samrat to tie it is going to bring her more gloom. I wish this intelligent girl finds her purpose in life and starts afresh. And if you ask me, it cannot be with Samrat because she has married for the wrong reasons. In her mind, she hasn't married him at all. She needs to walk out of this entire situation, the entire marriage and free Samrat and herself from it and reboot her life. (We know it won't happen, but it was free advise)

I liked how she said "Main MATURE hoon, Apne faisle khud Leti hoon"

Yes, same. Pakhi does have her moments and as a person, she has tremendous potential. She was awesome before the yoga wala love ruined her life. She needs to find herself first and get rid of her emotional marriage with Virat and legal marriage with Samrat.

Virat, it's time for you to relieve yourself and her from the weight of the vaada because (as moronic as you are) she has made her OWN decision to marry her husband. Seriously, it's not your baggage to carry. Sometimes the more you push back the inevitable, the more it comes back to bite you.

Today's episode has already set the tone for how difficult it's going to be for Sai and Virat to leave behind this monster called 'vaadas', outside the saat vachans, that they have given each other. They are going to feel the pull, yearn and yet, allow the silence to speak. Ek doosre se door ho kar bhi, ek Saath...

With that, I bow out.

Waiting to hear from you all...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".