Singing Star 2020 on Sony Marathi - Page 3

Originally posted by: kamalsh56

But Ajay Purkar as a contestant and Rohit Raut as a mentor? Can't take that.

Article in TOI about this show.

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/tv/news/marathi/exclusive-yashoman-apte-sharayu-date-sankarshan-karhade-ketaki-bhave-joshi-and-others-share-their-singing-star-experience/photostory/77411462.cms?picid=77412291

Originally posted by: RPRRR42

its a general tendency of marathi industry ,that if anybody gets a huge success in hindi ,he or she will b on a high ride ,as rohit raut was one of d 3 finalists in current indian idol show,so he has to there.

and if this is d background od yashoman apte,then one finalist is sure😆i.e he.and other will b astad kale as i guess he was also a part of anandi,if i m not wrong.

and have u noticed,yashoman's mentor is again a much appreciated sharayu date,offcourse ,she has a lovely voice ,even i like her,bt this pair is also getting appreciated,.

swanandi will b there ,for more time ,may not come as finalist.

i have heard archana singing,and she also has a good voice alao ,pournima also sings very well.

so all r first to b heard and then should b judged,bt reading d comments on sm insta i was upset.

lets hope ,it doesnt turn out to b a biased show like other shows.

I feel yashoman apate and Rohit Raut with his partner will be finalist or top contenders. Not judging on their singing skills but reality show Sathi lagnarya ingredients madhle te important ingredients vatat😆 fame,followers and entertainment..

I have seen Ajay Purkar performing in some Sangeet nataks on TV. He is a highly accomplished classical singer(I think he has performed alongside Rahul Deshpande and Anand Bhate) even can be considered at par with Prashant Damle in the judge's panel. Rohit is basically a showman.

I believe that a singer with a strong classical base can sing in any song format (if he wants to). Take the example of Shankar Mahadevan.

So question is whether the show is based on showmanship/popularity rather than ability.

I agree Ajay Purkar is too accomplished a singer to be a competitor in this show, competing against mainly untrained singers and when those with less ability are their as mentors just because they are full time singers.

Btw, Rohit is not Ajay's mentor. Will have to see who is his mentor .

I hope they don't use autotune to make certain people sound better.

Singing I'm solitude is way different from singing in front of an audience. You're not going to sound the same.

Originally posted by: kamalsh56

I have seen Ajay Purkar performing in some Sangeet nataks on TV. He is a highly accomplished classical singer(I think he has performed alongside Rahul Deshpande and Anand Bhate) even can be considered at par with Prashant Damle in the judge's panel. Rohit is basically a showman.

I believe that a singer with a strong classical base can sing in any song format (if he wants to). Take the example of Shankar Mahadevan.

So question is whether the show is based on showmanship/popularity rather than ability.

Co-incidentally just saw Ajay purkar in Fatteshikast which premiers today. He has played a small role.

Originally posted by: mishkil88

then why did he accept this offer as a participant ? As a judge he won't suit as he lacks authenticity, aura, popularity like the 3 judges of this program.

@mishkil.....the q u have raised abt ap'acceptance as contestant is perfect.

see these r all actors,so they must b charging for participation.AP may b d highest paid actor among all contestants and due to lockdown for 3 to 4 months ,these people were withoutany income,so if AP is getting this opportunity with d amt he wanted,why he will reject d offer? afterall they also have home to run.

q is abt judges roles and offcourse chaneel's participation which fianlly will decide d fate.

या सर्व discussion वरून मला असा वाटतंय की आपण सगळ्यांच एकच मत आहे , आणि ते असा की कोणी ही ही स्पर्धा फक्त लोकप्रियतेच्या लाटेवर आरूढ आहे म्हणून जिंकु नये, तर स्वतः च्या अंगभूत talent अणि मेहनतीवर जिंकावी.