Originally posted by: AreYaar
Hey Biraj....lockdown life, or more precisely, pandemic life continues on one day at a time I suppose.....2020 continues to be a record crazy year in many ways and we are only halfway through.
Hope you and your family are doing well.
I watched Thappad a few days back too and really loved it. The script itself was especially superb with the way each character's journey/set of interactions were woven in alongside that of Amrita, and then the performances elevated it. The movie is hard hitting precisely because it doesn't take the route of sloganeering and posturing as would be the easy way to depict a societal issue.....instead the movie makes its points in the quieter/gentler moments which hit you in a searing manner.
The slap was the incident that became a catalyst....but it is everything that happens before and after the slap that leaves a strong impression. I am not like Amrita, but I see many women like her around me.....women who pour their all into a husband or the man they love to the point of being consumed and losing their sense of self.....not everyone has a moment of awakening like Amrita did....precisely because society is engineered for a woman to not be allowed that sense of introspection and expectation of respect, of not being taken for granted. To question it is to "stir trouble" and "create rifts in a family".....that is what Amrita is told from various people around her....not just the "conservative" family members but even the "modern" lady who is her lawyer....and it was important to see that simply a modern haircut and having a career doesn't free a woman of those mental shackles even then.
It is the unraveling of her husband that is also noteworthy....the spoilt and entitled man-child.....so very common in society....he is so very used to his every whim and fancy being catered to that he isn't even able to fathom why there could even be a ripple over the fact that he slapped his wife like that. One of the most notable moments in the movie is when his boss tells him that I was also arguing with you but you didn't feel like you could slap me....somehow you felt you had the right to slap her. Feeling a right on someone does not entitle you to slap them and then behave as if it was hardly a blip on the radar. Because the slap becomes a manifestation of how very much you demean her and don't realize it.
A woman is a nurturer by nature....the fact that she pours so much nurturing into every relationship....whether it is that of a mother-son, a brother-sister or the ultimate intimate relationship of a husband-wife has been so strangely skewed in society. Getting that kind of love and nurturing is a blessing....but somehow, instead of valuing it, being grateful for it, society abuses it, takes it for granted. That nurturing is not something anyone is ENTITLED to.....a woman chooses to provide that nurturing out of love....she is not some vessel from which you can pluck this per your demands no matter how you demean and abuse her. Even a flower doesn't bloom if you don't give it sunlight.....so why is a woman expected to provide that nurturing endlessly when the light inside her is extinguished in such a manner?
Ofcourse as the story progresses, we also see the expected sight of a man retaliating as his ego is challenged and then trying to even more deliberately suppress and intimidate the woman who dared to even slightly challenge what he demands.
But by the end, it was good to see the man get some level of awareness atleast.....I liked their last scene on the day of the divorce.....it is a tragedy even as they both move on....but Amrita's whole point was simply to make him understand that the relationship cannot stand if he cannot see just what he broke, that he killed the love she had for him with the slap and the aftermath....and he somewhat realized this by the end.
I also liked that even as she was cordial with her in-laws, she made the important point that her husband's behavior was a culmination of his upbringing and all he saw around him....the other striking point was when she noted that even as her in-laws were nice to her, not a single person came to see her at her parents home to talk to her as a person....their only association with her was as an attachment to their son.....the fact that this girl poured so many years of her life into their family somehow still didn't entitle her to be approached for herself as a person and not just as an appendage to her husband.....these are the bigger societal questions that many people need to introspect about.
I really liked Dia's character too....how subtly they showed the way she is resented for being a single rich woman....lol as if no one can believe she can earn that money, that car, that house on her own capabilities...."aisa kya karti hai that she has that car"?.....and her response in the scene when Amrita's husband asked her to lie and say nothing happened at the party....."I want to believe most men are good...so I'm going to pretend you didn't just ask me to do that".
It's a truly excellent film...Anubhav Sinha is just growing from strength to strength....previously with Article 15, now Thappad.
961