Pranbir AT #9 - "...Kaise hua. Tu itna zaroori kaise hua?" - Page 46

Originally posted by: anandhi007

They might go about this in two ways both leading to trouble for abhigya:

1. Pragya is logical and abhi is illogical and supports Rhea well technically since Ranbir hasn't cleared up with Rhea and abhi thinks Ranbir and Rhea are in love I don't think abhi is completely illogical here. So they'll end up supporting prachi and Rhea respectively leading to problems between them and drama.

2. Pragya gives into emotions and supports Rhea while abhi is logical and supports prachi, still leading to problems between them.

We know the decision is ultimately in ranbir's hands, but even Ranbir might consider marrying Rhea for the sake of the peace between families so prachi can live in peace with her newly United parents. Let's see what they do. First this stupid Maya should be out of the picture :3 and let's not have high hopes of CVs being logical and consistent and all.

Oh no! Don't say that. Coz if Ranbir is marrying Rhea first, I'll bid farewell to pranbir. I absolutely hate the marrying your love the 2nd time around theory. All other things are welcomed but not that.

Originally posted by: anandhi007

You are underestimating Rhea's manipulations here. Rhea can completely manipulate the entire situation making her seem like a victim and it's not very hard given the circumstances and stupidity of Ranbir. Aliya will make rhea manipulate pragya emotionally. And besides pragya has gone through so much in the name of love and she herself said that to disha after the recent leap. She used to say that abhi is in her bhagya and now she says only prachi is and she thought abhi was in her bhagya and that she lost so much for love that she doesn't have the strength to lose anymore or anyone which is why she was reluctant in the beginning whenever prachi questioned about her dad. So what I am saying might be a stretch but it is logical,they can make pragya seem like love is not worth losing your peace and everything and ask prachi to compromise for a sense of security as love was what made her weak and all she wants is for prachi to live peacefully even if that means she doesn't get her love.

But will the cvs take the risk as it will turn Pragya totally selfish and unfair towards Prachi and a very grey character if not dark from the spotless white they have shown till date?

I don't know why but I feel as if when Prachi will go to confess her feelings to Ranbir or after that Rhea will reveal the bet thing while talking to Ranbir about it within Prachi's hearing and that will shatter Prachi's faith in him. Rhea will be aware of Prachi's presence but Ranbir won't. And Prachi would have left, broken, before Ranbir revealed about the bet being null and void and him falling really in love with Prachi. That may lead to love hate marriage between Pranbir. Or may be this is my wishful thinking. But they never got the Prachi's mom dad marry anyone else. So, I'm hoping that will happen with Pranbir too.

Originally posted by: Nandini25

Oh no! Don't say that. Coz if Ranbir is marrying Rhea first, I'll bid farewell to pranbir. I absolutely hate the marrying your love the 2nd time around theory. All other things are welcomed but not that.

They might show him getting ready and about to marry rhea but with some twist in the end :3 that's what they did with Purab,he was ready to marry Aliya for the family and then finally backed out

Originally posted by: anandhi007

They might show him getting ready and about to marry rhea but with some twist in the end :3 that's what they did with Purab,he was ready to marry Aliya for the family and then finally backed out

They can for the sake of stupid melodrama. But I would really love it if they show Ranbir take a stand for what is right and fair like he has till date in front of all and sundry. Till date they have shown him to be different than other ITV male characters, hope they maintain it.

Originally posted by: anandhi007

You are underestimating Rhea's manipulations here. Rhea can completely manipulate the entire situation making her seem like a victim and it's not very hard given the circumstances and stupidity of Ranbir. Aliya will make rhea manipulate pragya emotionally. And besides pragya has gone through so much in the name of love and she herself said that to disha after the recent leap. She used to say that abhi is in her bhagya and now she says only prachi is and she thought abhi was in her bhagya and that she lost so much for love that she doesn't have the strength to lose anymore or anyone which is why she was reluctant in the beginning whenever prachi questioned about her dad. So what I am saying might be a stretch but it is logical,they can make pragya seem like love is not worth losing your peace and everything and ask prachi to compromise for a sense of security as love was what made her weak and all she wants is for prachi to live peacefully even if that means she doesn't get her love.

Ugggh, for the sake of pranbir I would't want that to happen. it's not necessary all relationships work out the same. It's all down to the people involved as to how the relationship pans out.

So far ranbir has shown himself to be far different in relation to how he treats prachi compared to abhi treating pragya. Ranbir even before falling in love with prachi has consistently shown unconditional trust and support for her. He never once judged her even when evidence was against her, even when he didn't really like her... all because he simply didn't think she was the type of girl who could do the things she was being accused of. He found her annoyingly preachy and stuck-up, but despite that he saw how good and trust-worthy she is and has never doubted her. It's why without her asking any help or trust from him, expecting anything from him and without ranbir asking for any explanation, he has always trusted her and stood up for her.

Ranbir in this case has been very different, hence we can't say that for sake of peace, prachi loving and wanting a relationship with ranbir isn't worth it. If there are many positive things that outweigh negatives in their relationship, then it is worth it. So far the only negative in heir relationship is from outside forces, otherwise there's no major concerns between the two like trust issues, lack of respect or lack of communication, Yes the bet thing is one issue, but if the misunderstanding is cleared in prachi's mind that ranbir never has any ill motives against her and his love for her is true, then that would make things all fine.

Also I doubt pragya is a skeptic about love or even concerned about prachi going through the issues she did. Remember how happy and psyched she has been about prachi-ranbir and encouraging prachi to realise her feelings for ranbir? She's happy with the idea of her daughter finding love and is encouraging it.

Originally posted by: sammy17

Ugggh, for the sake of pranbir I would't want that to happen. it's not necessary all relationships work out the same. It's all down to the people involved as to how the relationship pans out.

So far ranbir has shown himself to be far different in relation to how he treats prachi compared to abhi treating pragya. Ranbir even before falling in love with prachi has consistently shown unconditional trust and support for her. He never once judged her even when evidence was against her, even when he didn't really like her... all because he simply didn't think she was the type of girl who could do the things she was being accused of. He found her annoyingly preachy and stuck-up, but despite that he saw how good and trust-worthy she is and has never doubted her. It's why without her asking any help or trust from him, expecting anything from him and without ranbir asking for any explanation, he has always trusted her and stood up for her.

Ranbir in this case has been very different, hence we can't say that for sake of peace, prachi loving and wanting a relationship with ranbir isn't worth it. If there are many positive things that outweigh negatives in their relationship, then it is worth it. So far the only negative in heir relationship is from outside forces, otherwise there's no major concerns between the two like trust issues, lack of respect or lack of communication, Yes the bet thing is one issue, but if the misunderstanding is cleared in prachi's mind that ranbir never has any ill motives against her and his love for her is true, then that would make things all fine.

Also I doubt pragya is a skeptic about love or even concerned about prachi going through the issues she did. Remember how happy and psyched she has been about prachi-ranbir and encouraging prachi to realise her feelings for ranbir? She's happy with the idea of her daughter finding love and is encouraging it.

I completely agree with each and every point you said about Ranbir. And you are absolutely right about relationships working out in different ways for different people,like there's no textbook strategy on this is how things should be done. Abhigya's relationship can be seen as toxic from a third person's pov but when you see in the eyes of Pragya,he has done a lot for her and that according to her probably outweighs the other bad stuff and she has been shown to grow stronger because of her relationship with Abhi. Like she is no longer the timid Pragya they showed in the beginning,she is a loud woman who stands up for what she believes in right no matter who supports her or not. Her weakness and strength is love. I am not justifying their relationship but for her it's justified and we won't understand why and that's fine.

One thing I have always hated about Ekta's shows are that she shows the female lead as someone who strongly supports her family no matter what in the beginning and once she falls in love,her lover is everything. She forgets about her family completely :3 like even before the 7 year leap they stopped showing sarla randomly. And pragya kept saying who do I have other than you to abhi,well her mom and her newly found sisters :3 now let's assume sarla and all passed away as it's been like 30 years already but they could still show pragya missing her sister bulbul once in a while like how they show her missing Kiara. I get that disha is like a sister for her but she can't just forget her real sister who died saving her?

Anyway, sorry I got carried away. What I am trying to say is you and I are discussing everything based on logic and practicality. But the above points I have mentioned shows that this show doesn't really follow logic, it's all about random emotions which can give rise to drama. I am not saying Prachi doesn't deserve her love because her peace of mind is more important. I am saying Pragya might think that way. She was happy about pranbir but she doesn't know about rhea being involved in this mess and more importantly Aliya. It's one thing when it comes to you standing up for your love and fighting against all odds even if that might cost your respect,life and peace of mind but it's another thing wanting that for your daughter. Pragya is very protective of Prachi and she has already lost Kiara and she has no idea about her other daughter. The emotional state she is in, she'll probably just want peace between/for her daughters so they don't go through what she went through. The thing is just for the heck of drama I am sure the cvs might show either Abhi or Pragya taking Rhea's side. And Ranbir supports Prachi always but then again both Ranbir and Prachi's weaknesses are their families. So if it has to come down to their love and peace among their families, they'll mostly choose their families. Again for the sake of drama it might turn up like giving up on their love and last minute mein things working out. But I really hope they show something different like you said. Let's see,I can't wait for the next episode to be released :3

Originally posted by: Nandini25

They can for the sake of stupid melodrama. But I would really love it if they show Ranbir take a stand for what is right and fair like he has till date in front of all and sundry. Till date they have shown him to be different than other ITV male characters, hope they maintain it.

But his weakness is also family like any other male lead. They haven't shown that any different. But atleast so far his family members are nice and logical and has nothing against Prachi unlike other shows. So let's see what they do

Originally posted by: anandhi007

IOBut his weakness is also family like any other male lead. They haven't shown that any different. But atleast so far his family members are nice and logical and has nothing against Prachi unlike other shows. So let's see what they do

Yeah and pallavi for now seems to have gone back to liking prachi.... I just have a bad feeling writers after lockdown when rhea reappears may again go back to showing pallavi against prachi, else why through this maya track did they suddenly show pallavi becoming anti-prachi? 🤢I hope I am wrong as rhea and aliya are enough for he anti-prachi brigade. Plus There is still possibility just for maya track they showed pallavi like this.... I hope

Originally posted by: ican

But Pragya has been shown from time immemorial to be someone who has always sacrificed everything for love.

About the manipulation, yes you are correct.

Rhea can also manipulate Pragya saying Prachi has not yet fallen in love but me and Ranbir were in love.

I hope when the start the twin revelation

That first show Sahana Aryan Ranbir and Prachi actually investigating

Aliya disha and Purab

Which then gradually leads to Mr mehra and Pragya's truth coming out.

Ao even the bonding of these 4 can be highlighted.

Hmmm, I doubt rhea will say that prachi isn't in love with ranbir as she thinks even prachi is interested in him and after him because he's rich and all that rubbish she says, plus pragya now knows that ranbir loves prachi. She suspected, but then it was confirmed for her when she went to visit ranbir in jail when he was arrested in maya case and in that conversation ranbir pretty much confirmed in a way to pragya that he has feelings for prachi. And ranbir was blushing in front of pragya when she told him prachi trusts him etc and pragya gave him a sort of teasing smile.