The final beautiful song of our thorn bird - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

87

Views

5.1k

Users

16

Likes

180

Frequent Posters

Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Hari73

If can you forgive his immature act, then only you can feel for anurag, but I am not able to do so. Also when u look at from prerna point of view, the amount of pain inflicted in her, there is no comparison to his pain to her pain. He lost just prerna, but prerna lost everything.


Betwn, I thought thorn bird takes all the pain to keep his loved one happy. But here anurag gave innumerable pain to prerna sending her away from her child n loved one. He made her to believe her child dead. I don't think anyone would do that. Was it not better, if he had sent her to jail, where she would get life imprisonment. Here, he made her to believe he cheated on her. Ppl would claim, still she need to analyse n trust anu. But how can any one will trust, when they went thru such a horrible situation.


Also I hope, he n bajaj not part of this plan. How can he send her with him, whom she never loved. What kind of life he gave her.


Makers really need better screen play for him. It's better they show him sorry for his immature act than thinking that he become thorn bird, where he n thorn bird poles apart.


I am really upset from makers, never thought they will mess with my anurag character to this extent.

Hari... Unfortunately EK and CVs have built up the whole track in the same way like how the Kattappa-Bahubali track was setup. So, only towards the end of this track will the CVs let us know why and how Anu planned a twist like this. Along with that, they are also trying to play it safe by making Pre a doublesided person, to follow the path which gives them TRP. However, with the way they had to immediately start bringing up justifications for Anu, it looks like it is going in AnuPre's favor as of now, with the difference that Pre will be on the path of completely destroying Anu & the Basus....yet the focus being still on AnuPre. But TRPs will decide how long they will drag this destruction part and how they should take the track further. Since, I would want it to be in AnuPre's favor, evenif it is a tragic end, I started viewing the track from Anu's POV. Because, I was not being able to connect with Prerna or justify her love for Sneha for some reasons like how she didn't think of her kid till Bajaj informs her about Sneha being sent to orphanage and how she ignored & is ignoring her own mother's concern on wanting to see her after 8years. That doesn't mean I am oblivious to her pain. It is just that I am being able to understand only the lover part in her more, because of the careless writing of CVs and the way Eri is being directed. Whereas with Parth, his ability to rise above the script, is helping viewers like me to understand Anu & his intentions easily. That is it.

pallawi1803 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#22

The book's title obliquely refers to the mythical "thornbird" that searches for thorn trees from the day it is hatched. When it finds the perfect thorn, it impales itself and sings the most beautiful song ever heard as it dies. It directly alludes to the Parable of the Sower in the Synoptic Gospels and chapter 9 of the Gospel of Thomas.[2]

In the front matter of the book, the myth is set out:

There is a legend about a bird which sings just once in its life, more sweetly than any other creature on the face of the earth. From the moment it leaves the nest it searches for a thorn tree, and does not rest until it has found one. Then, singing among the savage branches, it impales itself upon the longest, sharpest spine. And, dying, it rises above its own agony to out-carol the lark and the nightingale. One superlative song, existence the price. But the whole world stills to listen, and God in His heaven smiles. For the best is only bought at the cost of great pain.... Or so says the legend.[3]

I was searching for thornbird n came across this...and anupre both are thornbird in Ek's story ...and the song they will keep on singing is their love for eo... they will keep loving eo even after nore n more pain they will get..n with all the pain their love will only increase for eo...they will die for their love and even God will smile looking at them...

Isn't it wat EK has shown so far...they take all the pain to save eo their love...they have loved eo n in this lifetime are going to only eo...and Durga maa is the witness of their love and hence they are the divine couple...

Hari73 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: pallawi1803


I disagree to this...wat anurag did was right or wrong is debatable..it depends on ur connection with the character however it's wrong to say pre lost everything n Anurag lost just pre...


There is no debate, utterly immeture act.



Pre lost everything but her motive to take revenge frm anurag was so strong that it kept her alive....sry to say but she hardly cares about Sharmas n that's a miss frm makers they started the show showing her getting married to Naveen for her family but after that never showed her connection with them...in these 8 yrs wen she was preparing Herself to take revenge from anurag she never thought about her family...wen she saw them in pandal still we didn't see her taking any efforts to help them...so I won't really say that it mattered to her ...I know it's rude to say but that's how it has been show...


And I meant prerna lost everything bcoz, her love trust her child everything she lost. Where as anurag he did not lost, he was not cheated, he let her go. So, he can not crib. But he had peaceful 8 yrs life, though komo was irritating. But he had his family with him.


However if u see anurag he too has lost his soul....he is living among everyone but like a corpse....he only dreamt of living with pre n cp but that too he couldn't get..he has no purpose to live but as he promised pre he is just living for her...

I know, u will disagree. Bcoz u can see only from anu point of view. You are not seeing effect of anu's immature act. He thought he gave better n safe life to prerna. But in which angle pre lived her life. She spent her 8 yrs thinking how to take revenge n never had peaceful life.


You r saying he is living corpse life. But they r showing him he is living very much like a normal family man. He loves his daughter, mother sister. He gets irritated with komo as husbands gets irritated with their wife. Only sometimes probably thinking abt prerna. Wait a min, cvs gave him dialogue that after 8 yrs he is taking her name, does it mean he never thought abt prerna in those 8 yrs😆


Betwn in kzk they keep on calling soulmates. But they don't know what really soulmates are. My parents were soulmates, after my father's death, my mother started sinking. How much ever we tried to console her n tried to divert her, we failed. She developed health issues n passed away within few yrs. Bcoz she could not live without my father.


I will not compare anupre as it's a fictional story. If tom, pre drops her revenge plan n hugs anu saying he has done so gr8 job, we cannot help it. We hv to accept it.😆

Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: pallawi1803

I do believe grace that Anu tricked Bajaj and actually didn't take his direct help...

There could be two scenarios it's either anurag tricked him to get him back or bajaj was there bcoz of his own motives...there are a lot of things which are yet to be revealed...if Anu tricked him where were his diver's.. If he didn't tricked him how bajaj knew wat papers prerna signed...n infact there was no need for anu to get those papers signed too...I mean the real property papers...so wat papers were they??

All that story he made that he is marrying prerna for Bajaj's money was fake and even komo knew it so....

That's y I said they have purposely kept bajaj mysterious as Anu's story will progress they will reveal Bajaj's truth slowly...

I am still unable to understand if bajaj was so powerful and wanted to genuinely protect pre and thought that Anu tried to kil pre like he said in precap y he didn't filed any case against anu or kom..y he waited for 8 yrs for prerna to take her revenge n even then he wasn't Letting her come...

Bold - Pallu... I think that divers part has just been included in the dialogue, just to keep the mystery around the twist intact. Or CVs might even give a dialog to Anu saying he made them ready as a backup plan incase Bajaj didn't turn up in time.

Regarding the papers signed, most probably it can be papers related to Sneha, which Anu might have convinced Shivin to inform Bajaj about it as property papers.

Enlightened21 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: pallawi1803

The book's title obliquely refers to the mythical "thornbird" that searches for thorn trees from the day it is hatched. When it finds the perfect thorn, it impales itself and sings the most beautiful song ever heard as it dies. It directly alludes to the Parable of the Sower in the Synoptic Gospels and chapter 9 of the Gospel of Thomas.[2]

In the front matter of the book, the myth is set out:

There is a legend about a bird which sings just once in its life, more sweetly than any other creature on the face of the earth. From the moment it leaves the nest it searches for a thorn tree, and does not rest until it has found one. Then, singing among the savage branches, it impales itself upon the longest, sharpest spine. And, dying, it rises above its own agony to out-carol the lark and the nightingale. One superlative song, existence the price. But the whole world stills to listen, and God in His heaven smiles. For the best is only bought at the cost of great pain.... Or so says the legend.[3]

I was searching for thornbird n came across this...and anupre both are thornbird in Ek's story ...and the song they will keep on singing is their love for eo... they will keep loving eo even after nore n more pain they will get..n with all the pain their love will only increase for eo...they will die for their love and even God will smile looking at them...

Isn't it wat EK has shown so far...they take all the pain to save eo their love...they have loved eo n in this lifetime are going to only eo...and Durga maa is the witness of their love and hence they are the divine couple...

Bold - Pallu.... 😭. You have made my belief about the end more strong, with these words.

BombayGirl10 thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#26

Grace,


Beautiful post and amazing writing 🤗though i love anurag basu and understand his stan for thornbird award but but i would not disregard to what @Hari said in her post either. Its very complicated from both anu and pre's point of view. Makers this time really have destroyed the very essence of both the characters for their bakvas twist. Remember during first komo track how anu insulted pre and pushed her away before he got married but that was very start of their relation where he thought maybe after few days pre will move in life and live. Next when pre left him at the alter and she just wished that anu would hate her once set for all and move on. But they always came back in way to seek answers and fight for their love unknowingly.

But ever since ML track they both have suffered equally especially pre. I would really hold of my judgement for my thron bird until further story is revellied to be honest ( not much expectations either since its TRP game). If you combine your post and haris post than we both the point of view there is so much contrast to what our anurag used to do for pre. He would take pain unpon pain so that pre can live can move on and be happy in life. But after all the bridge acceidnet i feel prerna's anurag is lost he would never do this. Never in his wildest dream as i said he would probably take extream measures to protect her but would never play with her feelings and love and trust after what all she went through (she even took a bullet for him) . Makers have failed to provide valid reason behind anu's actions and we know why and thats why our love for anurag basu never flatter but leaving that aside i will still wait for story to unfold before passing judgments on this new anurag basu that is definitely not pre's anurag basu atleast now. It seems like makers have taken few of his characteristics from komo 1 track and just tried to justify it but they fail to understand what they have shown prerna's anurag basu as from past 1.

I hold anu accountable when he promised pre that they will never go back to path and mistakes they did in past. How ever majboor he was because of komo but smart anurag would think about both his girls and their happiness above everyone and everything else. He would see that his push would not only create hatered in pre but her trust on love would shake so baldly that even if he wantes her to be Happy she will never be Happy away from him. That's why i am holding off my judgement until further story.

Pre made same mistake like him in last bajaj track thinking that he sacrificed for her happiness once so now she will do but both fail to understand that by doing that they are making a way for whole new painful life. In that track she failed to see he was not happy his love was way stronger to take her petty excuse for money and nonsense and how she was so insensitive towards him by staying in house his bedroom with another men 24/7. Maybe this time anu thought no petty excuse will work to push pre away so he went extreme but thats not justifiable atleast until further story unfolds.


This is kasuti and we know if they both do the normal thing like proper planning than show will end 😆 so in between gapes and mistakes are starting point of their stupid kasutis. But your post made me very emotional 😭 and lot of nostalgic feeling attached to anupre.

BombayGirl10 thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#27

Parth is just nailing the role in every way which is why i am always able to connect to anurag basu from first 1.even when he is stupid lame his character connects to me. So post leap i am watching story from his point of view mostly.

Edited by BombayGirl10 - 5 years ago
BombayGirl10 thumbnail
Rocker Thumbnail 5th Anniversary Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: grace4317

Pallu... I hope it happens like how you have said. But since, from the beginning Pre many times was referred to as Durga maa's beti or her return to BB as Durga maa ghar aa rahi hai, i am forced to think from that perspective. So Pre entering BB yesterday in a full Black attire left me thinking of one of the avatars of Durga maa. Read my PM and you will understand what I meant. 😊


Omg this reminds me of her entry during komo 1 track dam its was so amazing.

pallawi1803 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Hari73

I know, u will disagree. Bcoz u can see only from anu point of view. You are not seeing effect of anu's immature act. He thought he gave better n safe life to prerna. But in which angle pre lived her life. She spent her 8 yrs thinking how to take revenge n never had peaceful life.


You r saying he is living corpse life. But they r showing him he is living very much like a normal family man. He loves his daughter, mother sister. He gets irritated with komo as husbands gets irritated with their wife. Only sometimes probably thinking abt prerna. Wait a min, cvs gave him dialogue that after 8 yrs he is taking her name, does it mean he never thought abt prerna in those 8 yrs😆


Betwn in kzk they keep on calling soulmates. But they don't know what really soulmates are. My parents were soulmates, after my father's death, my mother started sinking. How much ever we tried to console her n tried to divert her, we failed. She developed health issues n passed away within few yrs. Bcoz she could not live without my father.


I will not compare anupre as it's a fictional story. If tom, pre drops her revenge plan n hugs anu saying he has done so gr8 job, we cannot help it. We hv to accept it.😆

I can say the same thing that u cannot understand anu's pov bcoz u r seeing it frm pre's pov...

However I m seeing frm both and hence never questioned pre's revenge and I do understand that the way she is now she wouldn't have been. If anu wouldn't have taken that extreme Step...and as far as u thinking that he is living a normal life is the difference in perception..those who have followed them since beginning can't say that they can live peacefully and a normal life without eo...he is living a loveless life...others are his responsibilities n he is fulfilling it...if u forgive the lines they gave to kaushik he is always looking for ways to be outside the house and just work n work which basically means he is living a mechanical life... without emotions without expectations without any purpose...


And yeah anu told prerna that he took her name after 8 yrs was to show her that he never remembered her ...🤷

FarhaadkiMahi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: grace4317

Moni.. I am happy that you loved my post, even when it was about your ladla being the thornbird.

Coming to the bold part, i hope EK will be meherbaan on AnuPreians to make your wish happen and we will get back our old AnuPre, though I am keeping my expectations verryyy low.

grace ji

what i m thinking if that cvs r thinking than we r in winning side but if not then dekhna hoga

as pre coming with black saree & all that bjoitiya affect is not actually bhootiya affect

its like durgaamaa raudra roop me aai.

unko shaant kaun kar sakta sirf aur sirf unke couterpart

here its our anu

in this whole world anu has that capabilty to bring back pre from this vengeful weapon to kind hearted pre not even sneha can bring

i m sure anu will back her from thos robotic pre to human

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".