Could anyone have played this role better than Karan? - Page 4

Originally posted by: braveheartdoc

But really I'm amazed to see the responses here to a person expressing something against their favourite.

Literally noone would have responded if one did not question someone's dedication and versatility in a shit show like this. If one is okay with making those comments about an actor,then one should be okay with getting questioned about what makes the other others so versatile and dedicated to the character. Its only fair 😆 When one does it thats honest critique but others doing it is 'cant take opinions against their fave'. Wah bhai! 😆

Originally posted by: dahibhalle

I have said it before and I will repeat it again -KSG as Bajaj was a total mismatch with the show.....It's like putting a Ferrari in a showroom full of run down Ambassadors.

They need to get a really mediocre actor as the next Bajaj to fit in with the general vibe of the show.

😆 LMAO!

Originally posted by: _charu_

When they ruined the character completely what can the actor do? Any actor in his place wouldnt be able to do anything meaty ..karan individually was good but his pairing with erica looked very out of place..I blame ericas non acting for that..he did best with whatever shit was offered to him..he over estimated ekta lol ..

Charu, i would disagree with on following points.

*The ruined character is true for all leads here, why should B actor only get the benefit..Without naming you know some actor have done splendid despite crass dialogues and all kind of butchering more than B actor here in this serial. I can even name some non lead doing it..It is just that because it is character B or actor playing it people want to defend.

*I also do not agree chemistry of KSG and Eri..It takes two tangy. Apparently with blind Fans actor can create chemistry with any one..But then when it is not created it is FL' fault..While i am not denying there can be scenes which corroborate you view, such blanket passes to actor does not bode well.

*Surely some one overestimated Ekta or the serial or its writers..Just because it did not click it is mistake but otherwise would have been preferential or favorite treatment!

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Literally noone would have responded if one did not question someone's dedication and versatility in a shit show like this. If one is okay with making those comments about an actor,then one should be okay with getting questioned about what makes the other others so versatile and dedicated to the character. Its only fair 😆 When one does it thats honest critique but others doing it is 'cant take opinions against their fave'. Wah bhai! 😆

Firstly I didn't refer to you in particular but you quoting me shows that you took it to yourself. So I'll make it clear I was not referring to you in particular.

Secondly everyone has their own favourite and also their opinions. So the person you're referring to here expressed her opinion which if you don't agree with.... it's absolutely fine. But many here are mocking her, calling the other fandom children and what not.... What does that show?

In one of your comment you mentioned about versatility of the leads... you're most welcome to make topics regarding them if you want to.... I don't think anyone has a problem with that. But here in this thread whatever responses were given to that comment I wrote regarding that only.

In the end once again I'll say everyone has their own likes and dislikes and not liking your favourite doesn't make them a child or whatever you've been calling her. With due respect to your opinion I choose to not respond to you if you choose to quote me again.

Peace out from my end. Take care 😊

Originally posted by: braveheartdoc

Firstly I didn't refer to you in particular but you quoting me shows that you took it to yourself. So I'll make it clear I was not referring to you in particular.

Secondly everyone has their own favourite and also their opinions. So the person you're referring to here expressed her opinion which if you don't agree with.... it's absolutely fine. But many here are mocking her, calling the other fandom children and what not.... What does that show?

In one of your comment you mentioned about versatility of the leads... you're most welcome to make topics regarding them if you want to.... I don't think anyone has a problem with that. But here in this thread whatever responses were given to that comment I wrote regarding that only.

In the end once again I'll say everyone has their own likes and dislikes and not liking your favourite doesn't make them a child or whatever you've been calling her. With due respect to your opinion I choose to not respond to you if you choose to quote me again.

Peace out from my end. Take care 😊

Naaaah. If one appreciates dedication and versatility so much they should be ready to practice what they preach. Like i said,its only fair! 😆 If you throw stones, you gotta be prepared for them in return 😆 Cya! And you dont have to respond to me lmao. Not really waiting on it lol. Bye! :D

Yes .... IQBAL Khan

And If KSG is not coming back , I hope Ekta considers IQ .

Also want to say ..... for the replies in this thread the case is similar to “Grapes are sour” 🤣

the show has had shittt writing since start .... Naveen track was just better than the rest but underlying crap writing has always been there. So it really takes huge efforts for Actors to rise above such writing and make ppl watch the show . Some Actors have that a talent some don’t. Nothing wrong in it .

Bajaj , KSG , and Bajaj track did not work also failed to get viewers involved .... so accept this gracefully and move ahead rather then shitting on others and trying to pull down actors and the show.

also want to add this season Bajaj and Prerna had a Thanda Chemistry 😆

Originally posted by: Paricarocks

Karan played ok but he dint dedicate his acting to bajas role corectly.

But first of all he could not carry the character with grace. It was just hyped.

Ksg was not correct choice for bajajs role. He cant carry such a role the way it was in before season.

We had better versatile actors in telly who could have played better bajaj than ksg

Ksg lagged in role bajaj👎🏼

Hope we get better bajaj in future if bajajs role is introduced again.

Anyways ksg ke liye good luck hope he chooses characters in future which suits his genre.

Not a bajaj fan but, it's too much to say karan failed at his job. Saying this after watching his scenes on IG. Not to mention the bajrag scenes!!

Also, Had bajaj's whitewashing continued he had a good chance of acceptance from trp audience too.

My tiny winy wish was to see parth Amna bajaj trio enacting together onscreen. People wud hv dumped prerish anupre fanwars to ship anukom and bajkom😆

Originally posted by: braveheartdoc

I agree with you Madhu Barun Sobti is really good in such roles. But even I think that whosoever enters this crapfest is bound to suffer bcoz of the poor writing. Eri being brilliant as Sonakshi has absolutely nothing for her here to perform. But as the thread is about KSG I'll stick to that. So even you had issues with his dialogues .... thank God I'm not the only one.

But really I'm amazed to see the responses here to a person expressing something against their favourite.

Exactly, and leave Sonakshi, Erica was fabulous in certain scenes where the makers have written her character properly. Yes, I did have issues with dialogues at the same time i loved few for instance, the “then die basu” one, it was really good and there is no writer’s interference over there, its pure good work of KSG.

For few other replies above, just coz I’m a fan of Parth doesn’t mean i need to be prepared for a counter attack against him only to defend KSG, in a post which is completely irrelevant to Parth. I have very well right to gracefully comment/appreciate KSG in any manner, regarding any attribute of acting without bringing Parth or Erica.

Originally posted by: Madhu_Scarlet

Exactly, and leave Sonakshi, Erica was fabulous in certain scenes where the makers have written her character properly. Yes, I did have issues with dialogues at the same time i loved few for instance, the “then die basu” one, it was really good and there is no writer’s interference over there, its pure good work of KSG.

For few other replies above, just coz I’m a fan of Parth doesn’t mean i need to be prepared for a counter attack against him only to defend KSG, in a post which is completely irrelevant to Parth. I have very well right to gracefully comment/appreciate KSG in any manner, regarding any attribute of acting without bringing Parth or Erica.

This is the same policy which the writers followed.... to establish Bajaj they first ruined the essence of Prerna and then tried their hand at Anurag but failed miserably 😆 So it's not necessary to bring down others to put support your favourite. But it's fine Madhu let's not get further into this 🤗

First of all, this comes from a HUGE Parth fan, so I will try to answer some chemistry related accusations and mocking.
Its okay to have OPINIONS and not mock each other.
Also, telling someone to ACCEPT gracefully and move on is 🤔

Whatever happens at a creative level is NOT your calling. It’s our SPECULATIONS and ASSUMPTIONS!
And that’s why we have OPINIONS and NOT FACTS.

So, do not Quote me for having an opinion.

KSG was and will be Bajaj for me. There could be ENDLESS possibilities about what and who could have done better. But, by far he did great JUSTICE to his ROLE.
His role was a quiet sharp man of few words and LOWER DECIBELS.

The contrast between the BASU decibels and Bajaj was clearly done from day 1. His character had been INTRODUCED as a FOIL to the LEADS and everything what he did was top NOTCH script wise.

So, I give it to HIM for fascinating people.

Parth is a fabulous actor and whatever he is doing with Anurag deserves accolades. But I don’t see any chemistry between Anupre at all. I am entitled to my opinion and I respect everyone else’s who love them. Understandable and rightfully so.

PreRish chemistry was SUPPOSED to be ONE Sided because PRERNA doesn’t love Bajaj, she LOVES Anurag and that is the TRUTH. ACCEPTANCE !

But, KSG created that chemistry from his side and with all shades involved. It was ONE SIDED and that’s how their story is SUPPOSED to be.

They will have a story in FUTURE and hopefully so!

A story need not be based on INSTANT love but it could be much more. JODIs are not always romantic. There are stories about UNSPOKEN feelings too.

The show is SHIT, we all AGREE! But, one should know before signing up for an EKta show. It’s disheartening to see all of us mocking each other for our CHOICES in a BLOODY FICTIONAL show!!!

Breathe and let breathe!