Scheduled Tribe actors in Bollywood or television? - Page 5

Originally posted by: Girl_InMedicine

For real.. I didn't know what is caste until I wrote my NEET exam.

That's your caste privilege speaking.

People from lower castes are reminded of their caste status at almost every turn of their life.

I am from an upper caste too and I was ignorant to people's caste struggles. Not anymore.

Reservation is the least one could do for all the atrocities committed by our (yes our upper caste) ancestors. It will still not undo the atrocities committed in the past, but will at least decrease discrimination in the present era.

Originally posted by: ponymo

That's your caste privilege speaking.

People from lower castes are reminded of their caste status at almost every turn of their life.

I am from an upper caste too and I was ignorant to people's caste struggles. Not anymore.

Reservation is the least one could do for all the atrocities committed by our (yes our upper caste) ancestors. It will still not undo the atrocities committed in the past, but will at least decrease discrimination in the present era.

Yeah yeah.. did you read my entire comment or just jumping at one line.. I'm asking you if someone has already got reservation for the ug entrance, why do they want it again for pg? And if someone who doesn't deserve to become a doctor in the first place, treats you and God forbid something bad happens, you are going to be the first ones to whine about the bad health care system in India

Originally posted by: Girl_InMedicine

Yeah yeah.. did you read my entire comment or just jumping at one line.. I'm asking you if someone has already got reservation for the ug entrance, why do they want it again for pg? And if someone who doesn't deserve to become a doctor in the first place, treats you and God forbid something bad happens, you are going to be the first ones to whine about the bad health care system in India

What makes you think I've not read that. I don't think reservation one time is good enough. They got to get minimum representation across UG, PG and PhD as well.

As far as how they don't make for good doctors, once you step inside the college, they still have to pass exams, otherwise they don't get the degree.

If colleges are letting "bad students" pass and become doctors, that's a comment on the quality (or lack thereof) of the college/faculty and not the students themselves.

Originally posted by: LaalGulab

you are absolutely right.

The general category people are bearing the brunt of the system now.

By the way, how is reservation system going to change someone's mindset about caste based discrimination?

jaise ki your forefathers treated us like shit. ab hum tum logon ko shit jaise treat karte hai. ab bhugat.

hum: the ones who got admission into better college/uni seats with poor academics and better jobs under reservation category.

tum: despite of having better scores who find it hard to get into better colleges/Uni and better jobs just because they are from so called upper caste.

Originally posted by: ponymo

What makes you think I've not read that. I don't think reservation one time is good enough. They got to get minimum representation across UG, PG and PhD as well.

As far as how they don't make for good doctors, once you step inside the college, they still have to pass exams, otherwise they don't get the degree.

If colleges are letting "bad students" pass and become doctors, that's a comment on the quality (or lack thereof) of the college/faculty and not the students themselves.

If you dont know the difference between university subjective exams and PG entrance exams I cant do anything😆Aise toh there is no need for entrance exams only. Why do you think they dont give medical seats based on 12 th board exam marks. 😆

Originally posted by: ponymo

What makes you think I've not read that. I don't think reservation one time is good enough. They got to get minimum representation across UG, PG and PhD as well.

As far as how they don't make for good doctors, once you step inside the college, they still have to pass exams, otherwise they don't get the degree.

If colleges are letting "bad students" pass and become doctors, that's a comment on the quality (or lack thereof) of the college/faculty and not the students themselves.

its Govt which decides different pass marks for different categories.

General - 90%

OBC - 80%

BC-60%

SC - 50%

ST - 40%

its just an example. not taken from any sources.

movie mein joke bhi hai. one politician dont wanna treated by a doctor who got MBBS seat under reservation/recommendation. kyunki usse pata tha wo doctor incompetent hain😆

Originally posted by: Girl_InMedicine

If you dont know the difference between university subjective exams and PG entrance exams I cant do anything😆Aise toh there is no need for entrance exams only. Why do you think they dont give medical seats based on 12 th board exam marks. 😆

What makes you think I don't know the difference? Conceited much? I'm a post graduate myself. I've been through the drill as a general category student and I know what it takes.

As far as whether there is a need for entrance exam or 12th class marks can be considered as the entrance criteria, I'm no authority to speak on this. That's up to the ones making the decisions.

Originally posted by: hasini009

its Govt which decides different pass marks for different categories.

General - 90%

OBC - 80%

BC-60%

SC - 50%

ST - 40%

its just an example. not taken from any sources.

movie mein joke bhi hai. one politician dont wanna treated by a doctor who got MBBS seat under reservation/recommendation. kyunki usse pata tha wo doctor incompetent hain

No. Pass marks are the same for everyone.

The selection criteria for an entrance exam may set a minimum percentage requirement as 60% for general category and 45% for SC/ST category. I'm aware of this but this isn't what I was saying.

I'm saying that if a "bad doctor" is passing exams and a college is granting degrees to them, then the onus is on the college and not the student. Because as far as the student is concerned, he/she has been told they are fit to be a doctor.

Originally posted by: ponymo

What makes you think I don't know the difference? Conceited much? I'm a post graduate myself. I've been through the drill as a general category student and I know what it takes.

As far as whether there is a need for entrance exam or 12th class marks can be considered as the entrance criteria, I'm no authority to speak on this. That's up to the ones making the decisions.

The point I'm trying to make is it's not that difficult to pass university exams. There are people who open their books just one month before exams and they still manage to pass. So just because they are getting MBBS degree doesn't mean they deserve to get good PG seats as well. That's all. I am not conceited or anything. Sorry if it came across that way

Ok nazis and japenese committed murders. Their present generation should be punished by that logic bcoz their ancestors did wrong.

Sorry why should we pay for things done in past? Why our hardwork n struggle get ignored?

We all r ok with first generation reservation or economic based but if a rich sc or govt employeed sc / st children ask for reservation over a poor farmer's intelligent child who missed cut off by few marks, then their is fault in system and there is no justification

U get seat in college , university

In job as well as promotion and then expect people to have empathy. Not gonna happen. If u feel discriminated when pepple talk about your caste, then also stop using it as advantage