Sanjivani 2 Forum: Chat club #1 - Page 24

Originally posted by: Girl_InMedicine

Neurosurgery is superspeciality. To become a neurosurgeon, you should first take surgery in your residency and then take Neurosurgery in superspeciality. Whereas OBG is a separate residency itself

Well, then I guess then it's just one the many inaccuracies and impossibility in this show. I mean what Dr. Juhi did with Dr. Shashank would not have happened in American medical drama let alone in real life. Then again this is Indian soap; what more can we expect.

Originally posted by: Ayesha066

Exactly.. it's not bashing it's just that Ishani's character is becoming unbelievable.. I mean she can't be right all the time.. Tgey should show that she is learning and might be sometimes wrong in her diagnosis.. I know that she is the main protagonist but that doesn't mean she should always be correct.. To err is Human..

And all of this just pointing out the minor flaws overall the show is going smooth.. But if we don't point these little flaws and make fun then discussing a show will get all boring and monotonous..

Not every word of criticism is bashing..

i too agreed with this point yaar...u can check my previous comment...

but calling ishani a snob and saying she has ghatiya attitude...how can i accept that...i felt very much offended reading that comment...

she might be rough but she has her reasons...she complained only bcoz she had seen him sleeping in duty hours...for her it was intolerable...so she did what she practiced these many years...

Originally posted by: Gdbs

i too agreed with this point yaar...u can check my previous comment...

but calling ishani a snob and saying she has ghatiya attitude...how can i accept that...i felt very much offended reading that comment...

she might be rough but she has her reasons...she complained only bcoz she had seen him sleeping in duty hours...for her it was intolerable...so she did what she practiced these many years...

Arre Baba chill.. its okay .. I saw your previous comment as well.. it's just criticism of the character and even humans have flaws.. and this is a work of fiction so the character is bound to have many flaws.. Don't take it personal.. Sometimes it is interesting to hear others point of views and it's okay to criticise a character especially if you work in that profession u will find all the flaws.. But its okay..

And what Ishani did was correct from her perspective but as sid says not all rules are meant to be followed sometimes rules must be bent or broken.. but i guess eventually Ishani will understand it..

Also, who is this Dr. Sid's father? I think his father might be someone strong and influential. Just like when the father of that kid patient with Refsum disease was revealed to be strong, powerful, influential, and rich. Also, one more thing, there is this rivalry of Dr. Sid with Dr. Rishabh. Could it be that they are half-brothers?

It's too early to suspect who is dr Sids father.. but ehoever he is.. definetely is a very influential person.. My guess is maybe dr. Rahul😆

On the other hand.. i don't think dr Rishabh and dr sid are half brothers.. Since dr Rishabh has become what he is by following vardhans advise.. They never showed that he comes from a rich background.. Remember how he was taunting Sid that he has bought his own car because of his methods of earning..

Originally posted by: Gdbs

i too agreed with this point yaar...u can check my previous comment...

but calling ishani a snob and saying she has ghatiya attitude...how can i accept that...i felt very much offended reading that comment...

she might be rough but she has her reasons...she complained only bcoz she had seen him sleeping in duty hours...for her it was intolerable...so she did what she practiced these many years...

Dude.. correct me if I'm wrong; as far as I am concerned doctors work long hours and endless shift. Some doctors sleep when they can, while they can when they're on call. She's so non sympathetic about others taking a nap? As if she was never tired or has never done something wrong in her life?

Originally posted by: nuomi.riceball

Dude.. correct me if I'm wrong; as far as I am concerned doctors work long hours and endless shift. Some doctors sleep when they can, while they can when they're on call. She's so non sympathetic about others taking a nap? As if she was never tired or has never done something wrong in her life?

definitely i agree with you...she shouldnt act impulsively... i didnt said i wont hear anything against ishani character...i will be more than happy to know what you ppl are thinking about her, what improvement you ppl want to see in her...

but in ur comment you mentioned she is a snob and has a ghatiya attitude...thats why i replied...i found that bit too harsh...

in second week episode she put blame on herself before the board members to save sid yaar...while she is very much correct in her place but sid was the wrong one there...how can u say she is a snob...and has ghatiya attitude...

both sid and ishani have flaws and weaknesses...for sid his opinion about rich and his irresponisible behaviour sometimes...for ishani she is not good at understanding ppl around her since she was left alone in these many years...she has her mechanism of believing no matter what one should follow the rules even if that is very minor....

Ishani is bit attitudeful i agree but again she hadn't a normal childhood like others. We jave to remember it when we talk about her. Second, Ishani is very lucky to have Dr Sid as her mentor coz not every doctors would like to be questioned before their patients. I have experience to work with Both types of people.

Once i was doing round with my senior mentor. He asked me a question before a patient. He asked if i knew the answer accurately and elaboratel? I said yes. He asked me to tell him coz he didn’t knew (or couldn’t remem exactly right then). I got confused and kept looking at him and the patient. Sir urged me to speak. He was ready with a pen to note. It was an embarrassing situation for me. He's genius and I had learned a lot from him. But it was a previlliaged to let him taught by me. Later, i had done it with a few more times and our bond was different.. But i didn’t used to do that with every other doctors. Ishani however does it woth everybody. Its not bad to be curious but she ought to know that questioned can be asked later. Its very imp... Coz a patient loose his faith in his doctor in that way.

Exactly KK not everyone likes to be questioned before their patients and i guess Ishani's character needs to learn and understand that sometimes u have to hold yourself back and ask questions in private

@Kamikaze

I agree with you and this kind of attitude is not only limited to the medical professional; it is amongst all industries. Even I never questioned my boss in front of the clients when the boss is wrong; I asked it later on when the client is no longer with us. Doing so will make clients think there is no synchronisation within the company; which will further make the clients distrust us.

Ishani is insubordinate; and insurbodination to this level is breaking the rules that she holds so high and dear ṭi her heart. Dr. Sid might have let that go; that's because he is not so strict a boss. Other boss might not be as lenient as Dr. Sid; and she needs to understand that she is working with people. If she wants to have a boss like Dr. Sid so much; she should return to his team already.

Also, I disagree with having bad childhood as justifications for her behaviours. Many people have bad childhoods; it doesn't justify nor give them excuse to do whatever they want and act full on attitude. There are also many people who have bad childhood and still know how to respect others and treat others with decorum. Dr. Sid had a bad childhood being a fatherless son and illegitimate; yet, he is loved by everybody except Vardhan and maybe Dr. Anjali. Just saying dude.