Put forum members into Hogwarts houses. - Page 12

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

There is no passage that suggests Umbridge's rape. The lores around centaurs are many but Rowling always have hidden eggs in the books about any possibilities she doesn't explicitly pen down. Like all those sexuality theories,f family tree theories,the Nagini-Voldemort relationship theory. Hidden eggs. But if indeed Umbridge was punished that way,we would know. Potterheads just project the worst of punishments on her on every fansite possible but there is no proof.

Originally posted by: Looney86

Nobody deserves to die as well? Because for me death is worse than rape.

Funny because rape victims always say the exact opposite.

Originally posted by: 9SakthLaunda4

Stop using rape rape... It's disgusting. Rape should never be used as a tool to teach someone lesson or as a punishment. Even if the woman is a villain, her gender should not be used to make her feel like a trash. If she was he, would the question arise ? Will anyone say did he deserved to be raped ?!

She should be hung like any other man or needs to be put in a prison.

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

not to mention in the hospital wing scene where unbridge is all shaken up ,the trio n Ginny Neville etc r laughing seeing her like that. I don't think Rowling is twisted enough to make her lead characters celebrate something like that. As I said,I firmly blv Rowling didn't write it with that in mind

Definitely. I think violence was involved. Not necessarily sexual violence.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Definitely. I think violence was involved. Not necessarily sexual violence.

I personally don't think that Umbridge deserved to get raped. Just asked to know whether anyone thinks otherwise. She doesn't deserve death or dementors kiss either. That's going too easy on her. She should get a 3rd degree torture daily.

Killing is worse than rape for me is because death is the end of everything. In rape, it's very difficult but you still have the chance to move on one day. In death you are just gone, losing your consciousness forever.So taking a life is the ultimate crime.

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

yep she was beaten up n threatened to be murdered most probably. Umbridge was back to her heinouspanti in deathly hallows

Also Hermoine lead her to the centaurs. That part is important because if she was indeed raped well, Hermoine is also responsible isnt it. That's too dark and completely destroys the character.

I was trying to find this passage. Here it is. "Her usually neat mousy hair was very untidy and there were still bits of twigs and leaves in it, otherwise she seemed to be unscathed " Well,if you get raped by a bunch of Beastly centaurs you would be in a worse condition. Probably bleeding to death. So I don't think she was raped at all. That's it.

Originally posted by: crispsy

I'm the big boss and i will make sure you stay there for a long time. 🤣

Either make me winner or evict early on..,😆

I have read the books at least 7 times , not even once did it cross my mind .. Umbridge gang raped .. 🤯

I hope not .. I dont want any reason to sympathize with her .. She is out n out evil and i prefer if she stays that way .. I love to hate on her .. i dont want anything to taint the sanctity & purity of my hatred for her .. Its divine and it stays that way ..😇