Put forum members into Hogwarts houses. - Page 11

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

She deserved Dementors kiss. Death idk. I don't feel comfortable wish rape on even a fictional character

Dementors kiss is worse than death or rape. You don't even get an afterlife because your soul is sucked.

Another thing. Some people theorize to create a horcrux u HV to cannibalize on your murder victim.

Harry Potter is actually pretty dark if u think about it.

Originally posted by: Looney86

Dementors kiss is worse than death or rape. You don't even get an afterlife because your soul is sucked.

Originally posted by: Looney86

How many think that Umbridge deserved to get raped?

I don't think she got raped, I mean she was mean bitch in DH too, atleast nothing from book or show gave me that feeling..

No nobody deserve to get raped

Originally posted by: Charaiveti

it's never cleared. She's taken away later she's shown all traumatized n delusional. I don't think Rowling intended that tbh, she's a woman after all. It's mostly fan theory which makes a lot of sense given centaur lores. But I do not think jk Rowling thought of that when she wrote it.

Even more disturbing,some people think those muggle boys assaulted Ariana Dumbledore,thus she never got over the trauma n it was something infuriating enough for Dumbledore's dad to go harm those muggles knowing he'd be sent to Azkaban for it. I personally don't want to think such a disturbing thing.

Ariana even I got that feeling while reading that she was raped:(

Originally posted by: Stark_Wolf

Ariana even I got that feeling while reading that she was raped:(

Death Hallows film almost totally erased the whole tragedy that was Albus Dumbledore n his family

Originally posted by: Looney86

How many think that Umbridge deserved to get raped?

Nobody deserves to get raped. Period.

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique

Nobody deserves to get raped. Period.

Nobody deserves to die as well? Because for me death is worse than rape.

There is no passage that suggests Umbridge's rape. The lores around centaurs are many but Rowling always has hidden eggs in the books about any possibilities she doesn't explicitly pen down. Like all those sexuality theories,f family tree theories,the Nagini-Voldemort relationship theory. Hidden eggs. But if indeed Umbridge was punished that way,we would know. Potterheads just project the worst of punishments on her on every fansite possible but there is no proof.

Stop using rape rape... It's disgusting. Rape should never be used as a tool to teach someone lesson or as a punishment. Even if the woman is a villain, her gender should not be used to make her feel like a trash. If she was he, would the question arise ? Will anyone say did he deserve to be raped ?!

She should be hung like any other man or needs to be put in a prison.