Hi mam
I read ur reply where u say
1.asking the writer to be fired is wrong
2. The fan who is asking the writer to be fired, you are saying "who are you??"
3.you are saying that a person who writes a prime time show is class apart.
For 1, mam I Belong to an industry where very tough decisions are taken
When an engineer doesn't deliver he is fired.. Yes it's bad.. Coz mayb the engineer is not bad but he is just not able to perform and needs to leave this particular organization .. And yes mam it does save the organization many times and the people who are working with them from the loss of a project..
I think ur industry is same.. U also replace artists when someone leaves.. Why are you taking offense mam?
For 2, mam , to the person you are saying who are you is the fan.. A word which is everything in ur world.. They make or break the show - fans. Please mam, don't know what went wrong where but Please listen to ur fans.. Not that u never listen.. But yes when you changed the script who approved it.. When we wre constantly giving feedback why was it changed to an extent that people lost connect.. You don't want us to blame harneet fine mam.. But do you know until this day she never told she is not writing.. She cud hav told us right.. Well even if she writes screenplay
. Mam plz see advay spiderman jump please.. I don't want to list the scenes but mam don't ask fans who are you.. Please listen and take their feedback be it everyday..
For 3, agreed a person who writes a prime time is class apart.. League apart.. I agree.. I cannot do half of what he /she has done.. But mam it did fail and it failed coz that person was not in form.. Yes we have bad days.. The story was plain bad.. And then comes the acting.. Lets not even go to shivani sanaya comparison.. It's the story.. Someone was approving the screen play, the script everything.. It did go wrong.. All of it.. Yes the script change was needed but your audience was youth plus old ppl..you could not also go totally out of logic..
Have u even seen the way chandni drove with disclaimer.. No mam it din go well with any audience.. So yes the person is league apart.. But just having a bad time.. But the approving of script was equally wrong.. The screenplay too.
Please don't feel attacked.. But things needed to be told..
When ppl gave harneet some feedback for story, she tweeted no offense taken.. She cud have written she does not write the show right?
Please dont take sides like ppl are attacking harneet.. She never told she does not write the show..
This is a genuine feedback.. And m sorry if anything has hurt you in the above or the language was bad.. Hope this reaches u.. All the best to ur team and hope u flourish and always be successful in what u do.. Bad days come and go.. This is a phase it will pass..
Edited by Katto_gilheri - 8 years ago