Subtle and Simple. And In That Lies The Beauty...

Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

Today was the much-anticipated scene between Advay and Chandni. And what did I think of it? Very emotional but also beautiful. Poignant and yet in a weird way, serene. Here we had a troubled soul, a young girl replaying a painful experience in her mind, and speaking of it so openly, in a descriptive matter for the very first time. Chandni's account of those three days and the aftermath left me with a heavy heart. As a viewer, I felt her pain and it simply reconfirms that Chandni too is a victim, just like Dev

Her account of the horrendous experience was saddening, but at the same time there was something very serene about the way everything unfolded today. Chandni placed her head on Advay's chest and tugged at his clothing tightly. And all he did was listen. All he did was absorb. Initially Advay restrains from hugging her back until the account becomes too much to bear and he finally, but gently places his arms around her. And as she slipped into a state of unconsciousness, he softly places his hand on her head, almost out of reassurance, in a protective manner. It was a very touching moment 😳

But there was nothing romantic about it. Well, at least that is my perception of it. That moment between them was pure. It was real. It was genuine. But it was also a vulnerable and raw moment between two people who know each other so well, and yet claim that they don't. There was no friction. No anger or accusations. There was just Advay, Chandni and that moment. And I'm so glad Advay got to see Chandni in such a vulnerable state. She's a broken young girl who craves for love, affection and acceptance.

Will this stop Advay from going ahead with his plans? No. But what it has shown him is that Chandni is harbouring a lot of pain within her and he needed to see that. In recent episodes he's been angry and annoyed at her. But today he came to her as Dev. Her friend. Her companion. No one can deny that deep down, Advay DOES care about Chandni. But his burning desire for revenge has engulfed his feelings of affection. Nice touch by CVs to have Nani's words playing in Advay's mind as he held Chandni in his arms. He's thinking. Maybe not changing but still thinking. And that's a start! 😆

But the beauty of this entire scene was in its simplicity. There were no dramatics, it wasn't epic and it wasn't supposed to be. It was subtle and that's what made it feel very natural. I also liked how Chandni uttered Dev's name in the pub, and Advay felt something. It could've easily been filmi. But it came out nicely. And what made it even better was Barun's expression 👏 This is what we call Dil se Dil ki raah. Both Dev and Chandni are connected on a spiritual level ❤️

Kudos to the little dynamite Shivani Tomar 👏 she was simply splendid in portraying Chandni's fear. She stammered and fumbled with her words as she described what had happened to her. The quivering lips, the crying in between... Shivani you beauty! 😳 It all seemed very natural, and all too real! And Mr Sobti, you are a class act! Advay didn't have much to say but his eyes said everything. The look of anger upon hearing Chandni's experience, the moist eyes and clenched fist. Barun was bang on point! 👏 Therefore I maintain that he has no equivalent. Even without uttering a single dialogue in that moment he still commanded presence. I must say, he and Shivani complement each other onscreen like bread and butter 😆Kya combination hai yaar!!

It was good to see Mama Ji delivering some home truths to Indrani. But as expected it fell on deaf ears. Indrani is consumed by her greed. She will not listen to anyone, and today she once again showed her heartless self by ignoring Chandni's call. She is not going to stop at anything until she gets what she wants. But she is an unfortunate woman. Chandni dotes on her, and look at what Indrani is giving her in return. This is the price Chandni is paying for being a dutiful daughter. It's funny how both Nani and Mama Ji were trying to knock some sense into Advay and Indrani, who are unwilling to change their minds 😆 But the only difference is neeyat (intention). Advay is no Indrani.

I don't know. I'm in a weird mood today. Maybe because Advay and Chandni's scene had an impact on me. Two broken souls. Both truly shattered They need each other, otherwise they will never heal. Ah! Damn the hopeless romantic in me!! 😆


Subtle and simple - and in that lies the beauty. IPK3 has my heart ❤️

Edited by Stargazer. - 8 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

1.2k

Users

14

Likes

100

Frequent Posters

ArnieBoyBarun thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
😭 She remembered her Dev and he heard her! The silent whisper "Chandni" Uff! The hug! it could have been a simple hug, but i don't know what barun does, it became so monumental! left me heavy-hearted. kinda traumatized after today's episode. Shivani was living as chandni. Well said!
uma111 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Stargazer.

Today was the much-anticipated scene between Advay and Chandni. And what did I think of it? Very emotional but also beautiful. Poignant and yet in a weird way, serene. Here we had a troubled soul, a young girl replaying a painful experience in her mind, and speaking of it so openly, in a descriptive matter for the very first time. Chandni's account of those three days and the aftermath left me with a heavy heart. As a viewer, I felt her pain and it simply reconfirms that Chandni too is a victim, just like Dev

Her account of the horrendous experience was saddening, but at the same time there was something very serene about the way everything unfolded today. Chandni placed her head on Advay's chest and tugged at his clothing tightly. And all he did was listen. All he did was absorb. Initially Advay restrains from hugging her back until the account becomes too much to bear and he finally, but gently places his arms around her. And as she slipped into a state of unconsciousness, he softly places his hand on her head, almost out reassurance, in a protective manner. It was a very touching moment 😳

But there was nothing romantic about it. Well, at least that is my perception of it. That moment between them was pure. It was real. It was genuine. But it was also a vulnerable and raw moment between two people who know each other so well, and yet claim that they don't. There was no friction. No anger or accusations. There was just Advay, Chandni and that moment. And I'm so glad Advay got to see Chandni in such a vulnerable state. She's a broken young girl who craves for love, affection and acceptance. Will this stop Advay from going ahead with his plans? No. But what is has shown him is that Chandni is harboring a lot of pain within her and he needed to see that. In recent episodes he's been angry and annoyed at her. But today he came to her as Dev. Her friend. Her companion. No one can deny that deep down, Advay DOES care about Chandni. But his burning desire for revenge has engulfed his feelings of affection. Nice touch by CVs to have Nani's words playing in Advay's mind as he held Chandni in his arms. He's thinking. Maybe not changing but still thinking. And that's a start! 😆

But the beauty of this entire scene was in its simplicity. There were no dramatics, it wasn't epic and it wasn't supposed to be. It was subtle and that's what made it feel very natural. I also liked how Chandni uttered Dev's name in the pub, and Advay felt something. It could've easily been filmi. But it came out nicely. And what made it even better was Barun's expression 👏 This is what we call Dil se Dil ki raah. Both Dev and Chandni are connected on a spiritual level.

Kudos to the little dynamite Shivani Tomar 👏 she was simply splendid in portraying Chandni's fear. She stammered and fumbled with her words as she described what had happened to her. The quivering lips, the crying in between Shivani you beauty! 😳 It all seemed very natural, and all too real! And Mr Sobti, you are a class act! Advay didn't have much to say but his eyes said everything. The look of anger upon hearing Chandni's experience, the moist eyes and clenched fist. Barun was bang on point! 👏 Therefore I maintain that he has no equivalent. Even without uttering a single dialogue in that moment he still commanded presence. I must say, he and Shivani complement each other onscreen like bread and butter 😆Kya combination hai yaar!!

It was good to see Mama Ji delivering some home truths to Indrani. But as expected it fell on deaf ears. Indrani is consumed by her greed. She will not listen to anyone, and today she once again showed her heartless self by ignoring Chandni's call. She is not going to stop at anything until she gets what she wants. But she is an unfortunate woman. Chandni dotes on her, and look at what Indrani is giving her in return. This is the price Chandni is paying for being a dutiful daughter. It's funny how both Nani and Mama Ji were trying to knock some sense into Advay and Indrani, who are unwilling to change their minds 😆 But the only difference is neeyat (intention). Advay is no Indrani.

I don't know. I'm in a weird mood today. Maybe because Advay and Chandni's scene had an impact on me. Two broken souls. Both truly shattered They need each other, otherwise they will never heal. Ah! Damn the hopeless romantic in me!! 😆


Subtle and simple - and in that lies the beauty. IPK3 has my heart ❤️


Bang on. and amazing post 👏
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ArnieBoyBarun

😭 She remembered her Dev and he heard her! The silent whisper "Chandni" Uff! The hug! it could have been a simple hug, but i don't know what barun does, it became so monumental! left me heavy-hearted. kinda traumatized after today's episode. Shivani was living as chandni. Well said!



Thanks :)

Oh yes! That silent Chandni uttered by Advay. Gave me goosebumps 😳 Barun is just too good and every time I try to say something about how friggin brilliant he is, well I FAIL 😆 And Shivani also showed us once again that Gul Khan was right to zero in on her as Chandni...

Even I feel weird after that episode. Need to shake it off!
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: uma111


Bang on. and amazing post 👏



Thanks Uma. Much appreciated :)

My fingers were itching to talk about the scene 😆 So beautiful ❤️
2filmy thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Now whenever Indrani says something
I find her words fully double meaning and hollow
When she told Chandni to call her if she is scared
I knew that even if she calls her Indrani will not bother at all
Chandni always flinches from PP touch
where as she has no problem with Advay touch
She knows he is not a lecher
Indrani knew that if Chandni told all that Mahantni is a witch
Then people will believe her as children never lie
She was so manipulative right from the start
Is Niru Mama gay ?
Indrani seemed to hint that
Chandni has no relation on whom she can get support
Mama is there but he can be silenced by Indrani
Advni have a proper soul connection
As soon as she whispers Dev Advay is seen uneasy and anxious
Advay intuition about Chandni is so strong
She whispered Dev and he knew she needs him
Then he rushes to the hotel and saves her
The first hug was so special
As Chandni initiated it
Advay tried hard to control himself
but at last he gave in to his emotions
The cheek caress was so tender and soft
When she hugged him he had clenched his fists
But when he heard her speak his stance changed
He remembered Naani words and unclenched his fists
Naani words finally have some good effect on him
Finally he got to know something about her past now
Even if he does not believer her fully he will not taunt her with this
His behaviour towards her may soften to an extent
Loved how Niru Mama supported Chandni against Indrani
He is not much before Indrani but still he stood up for Chandni
That gesture is really important
Mogwai thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: 2filmy

Now whenever Indrani says something
I find her words fully double meaning and hollow
When she told Chandni to call her if she is scared
I knew that even if she calls her Indrani will not bother at all
Chandni always flinches from PP touch
where as she has no problem with Advay touch
She knows he is not a lecher
Indrani knew that if Chandni told all that Mahantni is a witch
Then people will believe her as children never lie
She was so manipulative right from the start
Is Niru Mama gay ?
Indrani seemed to hint that
Chandni has no relation on whom she can get support
Mama is there but he can be silenced by Indrani
Advni have a proper soul connection
As soon as she whispers Dev Advay is seen uneasy and anxious
Advay intuition about Chandni is so strong
She whispered Dev and he knew she needs him
Then he rushes to the hotel and saves her
The first hug was so special
As Chandni initiated it
Advay tried hard to control himself
but at last he gave in to his emotions
The cheek caress was so tender and soft
When she hugged him he had clenched his fists
But when he heard her speak his stance changed
He remembered Naani words and unclenched his fists
Naani words finally have some good effect on him
Finally he got to know something about her past now
Even if he does not believer her fully he will not taunt her with this
His behaviour towards her may soften to an extent
Loved how Niru Mama supported Chandni against Indrani
He is not much before Indrani but still he stood up for Chandni
That gesture is really important



Hi Priya :)

I agree.

Even I feel that Advay's behaviour will soften to some extent. He won't change or back off in his plans. But today he's seen a different side to Chandni and the affect will kick in for sho.

Gosh. Such a good episode. Heartbreaking but something so beautiful about it . Oh my heart!!! 🥺


ChitraGS thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Hello Zinnai my luv ,

Todays Epi so truly Subtle and Simple , just like your analysis.
I simply love your simplistic take on the episodes. amazing 👏!!

Todays epi has deeply affected me at many levels. I have felt both joy and sorrow. 😭
Shivani is one hell of an actress, She is the perfect Chandini, hands down !!!

I could feel everything that chandini felt today, that how beautifully Shivani emoted 😭. Her phobia, her need to get out of the place, her fear at the memory of her traumatic past and above all the way she blurts everything clinging on to Advay.😭
My heart went out for her today. Today for the first time , we too as viewers got a glimpse of the extent of Chandinis trauma. She maybe a feisty lil cat at home, but put her outside and she is nothing but a trembling leaf.
I too loved the scene where she calls out to Dev ( what is noteworthy is that she calls out to DEV even before she calls out for her mum) So thats how deep her relationship with Dev is .

Barun today was exceptional yet again UFFF!!! This man is unparalleled bollywood or hollywood, television or otherwise.

In the hug scene, he really didn't have any dialogues, yet he manages to convey everything , the internal conflict, his need to hold her, his anger when she hears about her past, his heartbreak to see how broken she is, and eventually Advays defeat, as Dev manages to win and holds Chandini close to his heart.
GOSH Barun really made us live through every emotion just with his eyes and with his expression. I dont think there is any other actor today who can even half emote as well as Barun does. No wonder he is the KING !!!

I really loved your take, keep them coming

Cheers, Chitra
Varsh.r thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
I So Agree with you that is was subtle and simple and no romantic scene , it was not meant to be romantic in the first place as chandni was sharing some very painful incident of her life and advay was suppose to listen to it with complete indulgence ,which was there!!!!
so loved it!!!👏
-MeMyselfI thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
IPK3 is a breath of fresh air (when it does it right) 😆
Advay was feeling her pain as another human being and as her friend... there was nothing romantic about it and that is just the way I wanted it... I want him to fall in love during the period when he tries to help her overcome her fears...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".