Sidharth Malhotra & Manoj Bajpayee in Neeraj Pandey's next

Frequent Posters

Indifference

@Indifference

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: DriftInfinitely

Considering most fans were happy with K&S, there's no question of 'blaming' anyone. And many fans blame Sid for picking the bad scripts, yes. Obviously that's a major factor in terms of how a film does at the box office, and Sid has poor script sense.

Fawad,Ratna,Rishi and rest walked away with KnS.Some reviews said Sid was weakest part of the movie.Then I read his fans lamenting, Sid could not match up to others since he got the least important role in the movie😆.Well in my opinion his acting is the problem not poor script sense.Many actors get praised for their earnest act even when whole movie is trashed like Varun in Dishoom,Ranbir in BV.Sid's acting was equally criticized not just the script in BBD's case

Quote

263437

Hibernated

Posted: 8 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: Indifference

Fawad,Ratna,Rishi and rest walked away with KnS.Some reviews said Sid was weakest part of the movie.Then I read his fans lamenting, Sid could not match up to others since he got the least important role in the movie😆.Well in my opinion his acting is the problem not poor script sense.Many actors get praised for their earnest act even when whole movie is trashed like Varun in Dishoom,Ranbir in BV.Sid's acting was equally criticized not just the script in BBD's case

For K&S, he got both good and bad reviews. He was with a stellar cast so perhaps you and a few critics felt that his performance was overshadowed. However, in real life, I've only heard people praising the film as a whole. It's only on the internet that you find people nitpicking and criticising actors for particular scenes, etc.

And as for BBD, other than the music, everything was criticised- the acting, the script, the direction, etc. Sid's fans weren't the only people complaining about the script.