Roshni Chopra speaks on KS,Jhoom and KC

Awww.. he's fasting aswell.. so sweet! 😳

Taking a break?.. 👍🏼

I dont like Pia, but miss Roshni in the show. Wish shes back soon. Hopefully good this time.

Thanks for sharing the article.

If singing is a different ball game, dancing too is a very hard and tough ball game. 😆

Awesome article!

Thanks for posting this Preet! 👍🏼

It's great to see that her and her husband are both fasting on this day - seriously, that's a sign of a them being a fantastic couple. Despite a tough schedule she is sticking to traditions that she believes in and also her husband is fasting as well 👏

Also, I'm DELIGHTED to know that she is NOT permanently leaving the show 👍🏼

So much for the bakwaas about her having issues with co-stars 😆

Anyways, she is right about the dancing stuff though... despite it being very tough, with lots of effort, it can be learnt - as part of my training for boxing, even I got enrolled onto dance classes and even though I started off with nothing short of 2 broken left legs, at the end of it, the 2 teachers said that I was the second best in the class of 12 😃

With singing though, if you have a bad voice, then it's game over before you even start! It's great to see that Roshni ji's talent will be put to great use in the new show 😊

So I wish Roshni ji all the very best for Jhoom India, and I look forward to seeing her back in KS! 😃

God bless.

Well, some might think that dance is easy. But NO art form is better than the another. Be it dance, singing or drawing. Every art form can be learnt. If one can learn to dance and so can on learn to sing.

Yes, some have it with them naturally and that only helps them to reach to a even higher level than those who try to learn. Thats all, nothing more.

And trust me, dance is also just like singing. Either you can do it very well or you cant. For singing, we need a voice, then for dancing we need graceness which a not all can have.

I dont know, if RC made digs or not, but she is just wrong in comparing the two art forms and saying that one can be learnt while another cannot.

Do you know, how many dance forms are there? There are lifts in some dance, in some we have shake our belly which all are not that easy.

Ms Chopra, speak only stuff that are relevant. There was no need to talk about dance at all. 😛

Cheers,
Meena

Put SRK, Big B, Salman Khan, Amir Khan Sanjay Dutt onto a singing show, and chances are that if the judges are fair, they will boot them in the first round! 😆

All of those are unlikely to claim to be good singers... SRK, Sanjay Dutt and those lot pretty much sang to give those tracks a boost via curiousity value - not really to show their talent.

And singing being easier? If EVERYONE was blessed with a wonderful singing voice, then of course... it's a pity that isn't the case though. I for am not that lucky... and so my singing stays strictly in the shower.

And grace in dancing... that is definitely something that comes through training and practice with lots of effort. Well, that is what I was taught in the dance classes anyway. I mean, I just trusted my teachers when they said that with effort anyone can get the timing, movement and all the requirements of good dancing right. But of course, some people probably would still know better than teachers 😉

Sour grapes... for taking a break from KS? 😆

God bless.

Well, if practise can bring in graceness, then the same practise can make the singing better. A song sounds good only when it is sung with sur and taal and feel. A voice can be trained. When we say, someone has bad voice, it only means that they just cant give the feel to the song and cant sing in the sur and taal. With practise and trust in your teacher, if one can learn to dance, then one can learn to sing as well.

If everyone can learn dance, then I think by now, EVERYONE who learnt dance should have been in the great dancers list. But only some make it to the top, because dance is not just about movements and timing, it is also about expressions. For expressions to be good, they need that facial structure or features which you can either have it or not. Expressions when it combines with graceness, will then create magic. Not just movements and perfect timing which can be learnt.

Ask ppl who breath dance, they will tell what it takes to be a great dancer.

I see your point Je_aime... but what I was trying to get at is that I was heavily disagreeing with what fsam was suggesting about singing being easier than dancing.

Bad voices often do mean the lack of sur and taal... no doubt about that. However, a lot of peoples voices (I'm a great example) would still sound terrible even if those two things were achieved. The voice just isn't there... and in a lot of cases, very high or very low notes just cannot be hit by a conventional voice. That again is why I don't buy into singing being easier.

You did say that "if practise can bring in graceness, then the same practise can make the singing better", and to that I totally agree... but the question is, can practice make turn a bad voice into a good voice? Give me all the training and practice in the world, but I don't think I'd have a shot at it - not because of lack of effort, but because my voice just isn't meant for singing (and song's like Abhishek Bachchan's from bluffmaster don't really count! The guy was talking! 😆 )

Voices can probably be trained the way you are saying... but I really do think that the prerequisites for singing are somewhat tougher than the prerequisites for dancing.

I've danced, and despite being aweful to start off with - like having two broken left feet - after a few weeks I was the second best in the class. It definitely was very deceptively tough, frustrating and took a lot more patience and effort than I had imagined... but unlike singing, I actually stood a chance.

And so experience is what I based my comments on when partially agreeing to Roshni ji's words.

God bless.

Sorry Mr. RaviMalhotra69,

I am not saying that singing is easier than dance or vice versa.

My only point is that, if dancing can be learnt and you dont need that natural talent in you, then i think even singing can be learnt and we dont need any natural talent.

I understand that you are talking from your experience. But have you given a try to learn singing? Without even having trying, how can you conclude that you cant do it at all?

I see that initially you did not think you can dance and was amazed when you got second in class. Congrats on that. But see, initially you thought you cant do it but after learning you understood otherwise. Same can be applied to singing.

I totally disagree with the fact that prerequisites for singing are somewhat tougher than the prerequisites for dancing. My view that is any art form has the same prerequisites as others, be it singing, dancing or drawing. My 2 cents.