Wish it was written differently *Collages Added*

-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I get it that Ishita wanted to save Raman from the bad news before the wedding rituals...but now the wedding is over...so what was the point behind spending a night on the the parking lot avoiding him while he kept on asking her if something was bothering her. And Raman looks like is planning to do the same as Ishita, i.e hide the bad news from her. 😕

This is a situation where it's not a individual thing...they are a couple who are planning to have a baby...and if a roadblock comes, instead of protecting the other from the disappointment, they need to face it together as a unit.

I just did not get the episode today...I know it pushed the emotional anguish quotient of the episode a few notches up and with two actors who emote excellently, just owned the scenes with their immaculate expressions, body language and voice modulation. But then they all feel kinda void, as I feel Ishita sharing the news with Raman and both dealing with their own heartbreak and also of the one they love with their life...reeling with the shattering of their combined dream of a baby ; that would have been quite a watch. Maybe it would come eventually but as an audience I would have loved if Ishita shared that news with Raman, instead of Raman finding it out from the nurse (let's not go to the logic where the nurse divulges such news over phone call 😳) and they dealt with the heartbreak together...

Sorry I felt letdown by today's episode. While both Divyanka and Karan rocked at their performance...the writing did not back them up...and as an audience I felt something was amiss.

I'll add collages later...if you guys want them.

Sorry for the downer review...I am kinda disappointed with the episode today.

An episode displaying the acting prowess of the two pillars of YHM: Its leads, Karan Patel and Divyanka Tripathi...my tribute is to their acting caliber more than the content.:











Edited by -Gan- - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

5.4k

Users

17

Likes

170

Frequent Posters

mayasun thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2

Hi Gan,

I thought I was the only one who did not like the episode because yesterday too I could not gel with the episode but most of them thought yesterday episode was good.

Sarika grapravesh scene was nice it would have been enjoyable if sadness did not envelope our main leads.

Romi acted nicely as a new groom even though they show to the outside world they are not afraid inside they are clearly afraid to start a new relationship. The boys teasing him was so natural because that is what happens in real life too and the scene leading him to Ishita was nicely done because the boys teased him but didn't understand his problem but his bhabhi did it is also a subtle way they showed the devar/bhabhi bond is still there like when he was diagnosed impotent he was searching for his bhabhi saying she is the only one who can understand him.

Romi/Ishita talk was nice I didn't feel like she was giving lectures to him but as an elder she was advising him it shows how much he respects her and love her and in turn it shows how much she adores him it was kind of looked like how they were in the beginning of the YHM but this time I could not enjoy their bond mainly because of the venom he spewed in MU track and no apology from him so I could not go back to Bhabi/Devar special bond which used to be nice to watch without an apology Cv they have tainted this relationship too.

Romika scene was nice to watch as they pledged to start a new relationship hope there is no trouble in their little paradise.

I don't understand why the doctor is divulging confidential patient information to a third party and I can stand this Shagun who is feeling bad for Ishita.

At least today I am little bit happy because Raman noticed that something is bothering her but I was so disappointed with both of them

First for Ishita not sharing the news I can understand she did not want to say anything in the morning to spoil the mood of the marriage but every ritual was completed and everyone has gone to the bed so this is the time she should open up and show her pain to Raman what is the use of marriage if you cannot fall on your lovers shoulder to cry out your pain.

Second because Raman even after knowing something is bothering her didn't go look for her. He could have easily walked to Iyer house and told Mihika that your sister will talk to you tomorrow even if it was true and she was talking with Mihika and dragged her home to find out what the problem is because that is what marriage entails it if one partner is hiding something by hook or crook the other partner finds out what is bothering his better half.

I understand each one wanted to be strong prepare themselves mentally to support the other person when they hear the difficult news this happens in real life too but somehow the Cv didn't convey this properly it was poorly executed so it felt like they were hiding things from each other once again.

KP and DT did a fabulous job but the script was not strong enough. I hope we get to see IshRa supporting each other in this difficult time instead of suffering alone by themselves.

I am okay with all the emotional turmoil we are going to witness in this track but I want the Cv to deal with the track sensibly and not make a mockery of it because this is such a sensitive issue and I definitely don't want to watch a stupid surrogacy crap track.

Even though the actor/actress are emoting beautifully I am not able to connect mainly because of the impending doom hanging above the head and thinking when would be the last day I would be watching YHM because of the surrogacy crap.









Edited by mayasundar - 10 years ago
3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
I agree we it you both try to deal with their pain and sadness before handle or sharing pain with each other it wrong but everything for drama dear hide seak game is important for more dRama
-Anku- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
I understand where you're coming from Gan. I would have felt like that too because we have craved to see a moment between the both where they share this pain together and lessen it by supporting the other. And obviously it will come eventually. But I also got where they came from.

For Ishita this is like a replay of what happened to her before. She was hopeful, dreaming of a beautiful future and it suddenly was taken away. She fears losing the happiness, has her insecurities from the past and also seeing Raman so happy makes her want to see him like that a little while longer before the news is broken to him. It's anyway not easy to disclose something like this easily.

And same goes for Raman. He feels guilty for raising her hopes and feels scared to break them again and see her crumble in front of himself.

Yes, the logical thing here is, that both knew this could be a possibility since her pregnancy was always going to be tough. But still, this is never easy to go through.

I loved the rawness, intensity and their longing in the episode. Their love for each other so significantly shown. And the actors added more to it by their performance.

I shall come back with more on another post later maybe. And waiting for your update too.
Rekhaarvind thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
I agree with u, Gan both the actors did a fantastic job, but as something was amiss today, felt a void. I got married didn't conceive adopted and lost all hope of conceiving but 2 yrs into adopting my daughter at the age of 43 got pregnant and had a healthy son. I was watching this show because it was a show with a unique story line and actually I went through a lot of fertility treatments and when I had lost all hope I got lucky. They could have shown the audience the difficulties both emotional and physical of both and that would have been nice. Instead of bringing Shagun and making her so saintly this looks so artificial anyway medical science has advanced so much and anyway they have 2 kids who love her and whom she loves so what is the need for surrogacy. Sorry I am in U S and this is the only Indian show I watch but now I watch only if I see Gan has made a note anyway u do a good job Gan by writing the honest opinion and u r v correct all the time.
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: -Anku-

I understand where you're coming from Gan. I would have felt like that too because we have craved to see a moment between the both where they share this pain together and lessen it by supporting the other. And obviously it will come eventually. But I also got where they came from.


For Ishita this is like a replay of what happened to her before. She was hopeful, dreaming of a beautiful future and it suddenly was taken away. She fears losing the happiness, has her insecurities from the past and also seeing Raman so happy makes her want to see him like that a little while longer before the news is broken to him. It's anyway not easy to disclose something like this easily.

And same goes for Raman. He feels guilty for raising her hopes and feels scared to break them again and see her crumble in front of himself.

Yes, the logical thing here is, that both knew this could be a possibility since her pregnancy was always going to be tough. But still, this is never easy to go through.

I loved the rawness, intensity and their longing in the episode. Their love for each other so significantly shown. And the actors added more to it by their performance.

I shall come back with more on another post later maybe. And waiting for your update too.



I understand their love and their need to protect each other from the pain ..I understand Ishita's past insecurities and fear of disappointing, and Raman's guilt because of all the baby talk ...but then again...Raman has spoken to her everytime about giving her the joy of motherhood, so the insecurity wrt Raman I can't relate...because Raman is unlike any man from her past...she ought to know him that much now to know that more than anything his hurt will stem from not being able to fulfil something he wanted her to have, not because he wanted a child for himself...

I don't know... I'm talking from my own experience..if something like this would have happened to me..my husband would be the one I would share with as no one else would fully understand what I'd be going through but him...and would expect him to do the same with me...a child is a combined dream of two people..so it's a shared experience...in good and bad situation.

So yes...though I could feel the rawness, intensity and longing...I felt it could have been the same or a bit more intense with Ishita sharing it with Raman...I know it will come eventually...but as a viewer I would have appreciated that more today. hence the disconnect re.

Hope I made sense 😆

(forget about updating yesterday's post...IF ate mine when I tried to update...and after a long day at work ..I just didnt have it in me to write it again..so I just posted the collages...sorry 😳)
Edited by -Gan- - 10 years ago
s2397 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
kp and dt were good
today but i couldnot connect with the epi at all.
Breaking the promise is getting repetitive.
In such a situation i was expecting convesation of ishra but they gave a kuch bhi wala conversation of ishita and romi which was not needed.
zero expections since i think yhm cvs will not able to handle this track in a mature way
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Rekhaarvind

I agree with u, Gan both the actors did a fantastic job, but as something was amiss today, felt a void. I got married didn't conceive adopted and lost all hope of conceiving but 2 yrs into adopting my daughter at the age of 43 got pregnant and had a healthy son. I was watching this show because it was a show with a unique story line and actually I went through a lot of fertility treatments and when I had lost all hope I got lucky. They could have shown the audience the difficulties both emotional and physical of both and that would have been nice. Instead of bringing Shagun and making her so saintly this looks so artificial anyway medical science has advanced so much and anyway they have 2 kids who love her and whom she loves so what is the need for surrogacy. Sorry I am in U S and this is the only Indian show I watch but now I watch only if I see Gan has made a note anyway u do a good job Gan by writing the honest opinion and u r v correct all the time.



Aww thank you for sharing your life's joy with us...🤗 Yes I have heard stories from my friends who had gone through such fertility treatments and years of agony they have endured with some getting their life's happiness when they were almost on the verge of quitting...I would have loved if the CVs had taken that route ...and truly I still believe the CVs would not go surrogacy way eventually after the initial drama...but then again I'm not the writer or part of the creative team...so I dont know.

Shagun..these days I try to avoid talking about her as I feel her track is forced unnecessarily upon the audience just for the sake of keeping the character in the story as I can't relate to any scene or dialogue of hers. so I just skip ...but I know eventually her presence will be felt as the CVs would not let us forget that Shagun is ..ah well ..their Shagun...the center of their creativity.

And thank you so much for your vote of confidence in my post...I try to give my honest opinion..I dont claim it to be right...It's 100% my opinion though😆

Thanks again
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mayasundar


Hi Gan,

I thought I was the only one who did not like the episode because yesterday too I could not gel with the episode but most of them thought yesterday episode was good.

Sarika grapravesh scene was nice it would have been enjoyable if sadness did not envelope our main leads.

Romi acted nicely as a new groom even though they show to the outside world they are not afraid inside they are clearly afraid to start a new relationship. The boys teasing him was so natural because that is what happens in real life too and the scene leading him to Ishita was nicely done because the boys teased him but didn't understand his problem but his bhabhi did it is also a subtle way they showed the devar/bhabhi bond is still there like when he was diagnosed impotent he was searching for his bhabhi saying she is the only one who can understand him.

Romi/Ishita talk was nice I didn't feel like she was giving lectures to him but as an elder she was advising him it shows how much he respects her and love her and in turn it shows how much she adores him it was kind of looked like how they were in the beginning of the YHM but this time I could not enjoy their bond mainly because of the venom he spewed in MU track and no apology from him so I could not go back to Bhabi/Devar special bond which used to be nice to watch without an apology Cv they have tainted this relationship too.

Romika scene was nice to watch as they pledged to start a new relationship hope there is no trouble in their little paradise.

I don't understand why the doctor is divulging confidential patient information to a third party and I can stand this Shagun who is feeling bad for Ishita.

At least today I am little bit happy because Raman noticed that something is bothering her but I was so disappointed with both of them

First for Ishita not sharing the news I can understand she did not want to say anything in the morning to spoil the mood of the marriage but every ritual was completed and everyone has gone to the bed so this is the time she should open up and show her pain to Raman what is the use of marriage if you cannot fall on your lovers shoulder to cry out your pain.

Second because Raman even after knowing something is bothering her didn't go look for her. He could have easily walked to Iyer house and told Mihika that your sister will talk to you tomorrow even if it was true and she was talking with Mihika and dragged her home to find out what the problem is because that is what marriage entails it if one partner is hiding something by hook or crook the other partner finds out what is bothering his better half.

I understand each one wanted to be strong prepare themselves mentally to support the other person when they hear the difficult news this happens in real life too but somehow the Cv didn't convey this properly it was poorly executed so it felt like they were hiding things from each other once again.

KP and DT did a fabulous job but the script was not strong enough. I hope we get to see IshRa supporting each other in this difficult time instead of suffering alone by themselves.

I am okay with all the emotional turmoil we are going to witness in this track but I want the Cv to deal with the track sensibly and not make a mockery of it because this is such a sensitive issue and I definitely don't want to watch a stupid surrogacy crap track.

Even though the actor/actress are emoting beautifully I am not able to connect mainly because of the impending doom hanging above the head and thinking when would be the last day I would be watching YHM because of the surrogacy crap.





Maya ..wonderful review.
I LOVED yesterday's episode as I could understand Ishita's reason to hide it from Raman..I thought she would do it once the wedding was over. The whole bit about her sitting in the parking lot avoiding him was what I couldnt gel with. And yes what you said about Raman is true too...that he could have followed her when he felt that something is bothering her..but I feel that he tought she's at the Iyer house having a heart to heart with Mihika ..hence he didnt call either...just texted her. After the freezing shot today I felt that he'd go and break the news to her but from the pre-cap it looks like they are both going to know and avoid sharing to protect the other..and eventually we;ll have that scene where they both will probably fall apart together...but it could have been done today...but I guess the CVs are gonna milk the amazing acting ability of their leads as much as they can.

Surrogacy and Shagun..I still am not thinking about them and rather focusing on the Ishra story as it let me enjoy episodes like yesterdays...and not lose my cool and make another "dear Cvs" post...😆😆

Anuhyaa thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
G - Can understand your point but I got Ishita today...

First she needs time to comprehend the death of her dream once again...Today she was sorry for Raman and the whole family more than herself and she took the blame upon her again as how she fell short...
That too how do you say to your husband who is excited more than you and practically thinks of this one thing the entire time, that the chance has vanished...She couldn't just down his excitement just like that...

In the same way Raman too first was heartbroken for her,he was worried how she would take this blow once again...
The beauty of their relationship lies there..It was soul deep...They think about the others first and try to shield them in all ways...

and now when they finally get strong for each other and address the elephant, it would be even more beautiful...
This is just not her dream alone anymore...For all the times she faced the thing, it has a different dimension now...It is the death of both of their dreams ...

Iam really up for the rollercoaster , if only we will be free of all this nonsense spoilers...😡

Having said that I get why you couldn't connect wholly...I cannot place my finger but something was missing today...I liked the flow of events and all but I don't know somewhere there was a disconnect...

KP & DT were phenomenal once again...Ever since the haircut he is having an extra glow...Need to enjoy that while it lasts..😉
I zoned out on the whole Romi-Sarika thing, was not in the mood...
& Shagun, who?😛


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".