Amit Paul - 2nd Karunya

man i feel really very bad amit deserved to be d indian idol

now prashant lovers plz dont bash me as i m not saying that prashant sucks or doesnt sing well

i m jus saying amit is more deserving than him

neways let his album release only kolkata police will listen to his songs

Well karunya has a hit album so if he's like karunya then i'm happy. and kaunya was out of this world talented, so again amit=karunya=me happy 😃

Def Amit is more talented and deserving than Prashant. Prashant ought to have been out b4 top 5, based on pure skill comparison!
Though i think Amit is more talented than Prashant, i cannot call him as the 2nd Karunya. Karunya was tooooooo gud!!!! I dont think it'd b fair to compare them 😳 . Karunya was a completely polished singer!! 👏
Amit is gud, but Karunya is the best 😳

Amit Paul to me is much better than Karunya - I didn't like Karunya as a singer - but Amit is the best along with Amey as far as male singers in Indian idol is concerned

Originally posted by: nsheena

Def Amit is more talented and deserving than Prashant. Prashant ought to have been out b4 top 5, based on pure skill comparison!
Though i think Amit is more talented than Prashant, i cannot call him as the 2nd Karunya. Karunya was tooooooo gud!!!! I dont think it'd b fair to compare them 😳 . Karunya was a completely polished singer!! 👏
Amit is gud, but Karunya is the best 😳

I agree...
In terms of pure singing talent, I think Emon is the only one who came anywhere near Karunya, and he was still nowhere close!

actually...i felt emon was more of a karunya 😊

i think Karunya was the best so cant compare Amit with Karunya...but i can say that Prashant is second Sandeep Achayrya(no offense 😳 )

Hundred percent I agree with u, but even sandeep was wayyyyyy better than prashant, let alone amit.

I'm feeling very sorry for Amiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit 😭

*Mod's note: Please don't post too many smilies*

I cant believe that AMIT lost.

he lost not to a good singer like Karunya but a bathroom singer like Prashant .

Prashant is arguably the worst II contestant of all time

karunya is still a lot better than Amit 😳 😳