Jab yaad meri aaye, milne ki dua karnaa.

MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#1


Its always hard to say goodbye, especially when you have a secret and the one you are waving your hands at has no knowledge of it. When you know that you are doing something both selfless and selfish, when you are making a choice for both of you, when you know that the one who is waving a goodbye and blowing kisses at you will perhaps need a glucose drip when the secret is revealed, when you are walking away with no intentions of coming back, when you know that now the loved one will only be in your memories and your heart, when you are already hoping that you meet again in some other lifetime and some other situation. To know that you are betraying someone, backstabbing someone, leaving someone behind with an emotional quicksand and yet to know that it was the right thing to do and live with it- its a different kind of hell and you are all alone in it.

Paro was , is and will always be the woman of her word and her faith. She felt sorry for herself only for 2.5 minutes and then, she realized that its she who had made the choice and she cannot go back on it. She has no right to feel that way. The immense strength of her character is what i have always liked , even when she has behaved a little nutty.

But its a complicated paradox you know. Paro made a decision and a commitment not just for herself but for Rudra as well. She is not alone in this misery , she is taking Rudra along as well. He doesn't deserve this at all but then, when two rights are right, you can only have endless debates on who is wrong.

Now, if you think about it from here, its a good thing that Rudra never told Paro that he loves her. Ek adhoori kahaani... as she had said today with a tearful smile. To love a man and then, walk out of his life without knowing his answer... maybe its a good thing.

Coming to the episode today, first of all - crappy editing of the window scene , the sleeping scene. It was shot well as you saw in SBS but in telecast , all the NG shots were used. The only good thing was the capturing of Paro's emotions. Secondly, patchy and incomplete screenplay which had no continuity of Thakur Sa , which did not need Sumer's and Mohini's scene and which sent the whole Ranawat family to local fair even as Rudra and Paro left for Mumbai. All scenes of Rudra and Paro were lovely but damaged at the editing table.

Scenes were hastily put together but the actors - Sanaya, Ashish , Geetanjali did a more than decent job.

Patchy writing , chhaapogiri execution but good acting and awesome dialogues.

RR needs to avoid body doubles and concentrate on better execution. This story is too intense to turn a blind eye to body doubles. Ashish Sharma needs to be on sets for all his scenes since he himself said that RR will not be compromised. So, i hope he sticks to his words.

P.S- The best moment of the episode was when Paro told Rudra tearfully that she loves him the most in this world. Rudra was moved, he wanted to say something but she covered his mouth because she didn't want to hear it.

Edited by MoronsKiMallika - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

99

Views

10k

Users

43

Likes

481

Frequent Posters

JJKKL thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Gotcha...
Not read your post yet. Am first writing down the song I was reminded of

Bhula dena mujhe
Hai alvida tujhe
Tujhe jeena hai mere bina
Safar yeh tera, yeh raasta tera
Tujhe jeena hai.. mere bina

Hai alvida tujhe

Tujhe jeena hai mere bina
Safar yeh tera, yeh raasta tera
Tujhe jeena hai.. mere bina

Ho teri saari shoharatein
Hai yeh duaa..
Tujhi pe saari rehamatein
Hai yeh duaa..


Tu hi hai kinaara tera
Tu hi to sahaara tera
Tu hi hai taraana kal ka
Tu hi to fasaana kal ka


Milungi main iss tarah, waada raha
Rahungi sang main sada, waada raha
Tujhe jeena hai mere bina!

*******************************************************************

I did see the body double. The one who walked similar to Laila. Nothing like Paro. Not even her height I guess.

I did see the shabby editing.

I did see the unnecessary Mohini-Sumer scene

I did notice the absence of the rest of the Parivar

But none of the above affected me.

I was thinking of myself in Paro's shoes.
To be the one to say good bye to your loved one.
To be spending the last day with your loved one knowing you will leave him because of a promise you believe in
Trying to enjoy the last day to the core
Telling him you love him more than anything else in the world
With the hope that he will remember these last lines after you are gone
With the hope that he will not think you are a traitor
With the hope that he will not equate the situation to his mother's
With the hope that he will not go into depression
With the hope that he will hope that people are trust worthy and worthy of love even if they leave you
I felt a lump in my throat

I also thought of myself in Rudra's shoes
About how Paro gave him breakfast in the room
How she gave dinner in the room
How she listed the things he liked
How she equated him to the moon in her life
How she said there is no daag in him despite his past
How she wanted to put a tika on him to take buri nazar away
How she conveyed her love towards him
Unconditional love !!
How he was more precious to him than anything else in this world
It break his heart that she did not allow him to say the same things to her
Before she left - for reasons which meant a lot to her


I felt bad for both of them





Edited by JJKKL - 11 years ago
Jaz1990 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Yay! I will res! Haven't watched, but u already know dat lol!!
gunji thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
seriously the editing is getting worse day by day...SBS scenes were much better than the epi😲

but I loved Paro's confession today...for me its her 1st confession...i dont consider that maang-bharo tamasha to be confession at all...


ThithliDhost thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Aww Vicky sa!! What an episode! I loved it for what it conveyed. Beautiful love story. Some scenes were sooo touching - such deep dialogues that brings tears to your eyes.
Sanish emoted well.

You said it Vicky. Saying GOOD BYE is very difficult. Esp to the one whoms you love more than life itself.

I have always loved Paro for her emotional strength, steadfastness and faith. And above all her selfless/unconditional love for Rudra.

Today all these characteristics of Paro was highlighted so well.. But what made it all even more viable for me was the fact that just as any one in love, Paro was also selfish. She was selfish to want to feel Rudra's love. Even when she knew her time with him is temporary, she had to try and make him realise that he is capable of loving. She was selfish enough to show him how their life together can be as adorable as a fairy-tale.. She was selfish enough to love him selflessly..

Paro's faith is remarkable. Not even for a moment she doubts that Rudra's arms will not be cured. She is so sure that the Doctor in Bombay will do his magic and Rudra will once again be 100% fit.
That she will have to leave him as she promised to Shivji.. If I was in her place, I would at least for a moment, hope that the Doc's treatment does not work. But then Paro is not me 😳..
She shares her secret with her Jeeja , cries for couple of moments and then moves on.
If she is to get only couple more days with her major sa, then so be it. She will live these two days in its fullest. Enjoy every moment that she gets to spend with her hubby. Make a memory book out of these 2 days. And these memories will be her sanjivini for the rest of her "gloomy" life..

For her, a life without Rudra is like a body without soul. Just a machine on key..

I loved the Parud moments today. The dialogues were so apt and touching. And each step Paro took today was IMO preparing Rudra for the separation and strengthening her hope that "He will come looking for me! My love will bring him back to me" ..

The scene were Mythili takes the aarthi and puts the thilak, made me cry.. Geetanjali was superb in that scene that her pain reached me so deep that tears started flowing..

Rudra has noticed through out the day that his Paro is not her usual cheerful self. She is talking about Adhoori kahani, Incomplete things and Loving him above life itself. For now he is putting all this down to her anxiety abt the treatment and his aloofness. Rudra is also confused why Bhabhi sa is all tearful when she was so happy for them yesterday. After all they are heading out for a good cause. Why the tears?

All this are the signs that GOD is with Parud. HE is sending enough signs to Rudra to help him out when the time comes. To help him to bring back Paro.

Since the day Paro made the VOW, the qn in my mind has been, how will Paro keep her promise and still have a life with Rudra? Will it be Rudra who will find a solution for this situation? Or will shivji guide Paro in keeping her promise and still be with Rudra? Or will shivji send a messenger to unite these love birds?

I think my questions will be answered pretty soon. Everyone fears Separation. IMO, there is no separation. It is just an opportunity to realise and acknowledge the higher power and the love these two have for each other .. This is the final push that Rudra needs. That "Moment" where he realises his love for Paro. Whether he confesses to Paro or not , he will realise that he LOVES PARO as deeply and selflessly as Paro does.

Love and hugs
Radz.

PS:

Vickysa, myself and some others have tweeted ST and team about the glitches in editing. Hopefully it will improve. I suppose BDs are here to stay until JDJ is on.. Its unfortunate that the first shoot for JDJ and Mahasangam episode shoot are happening in the same time frame. Hence the BD for AS may be ?


And love this song .. It is BEAUTIFUL...

Uski nazar usi pe ruk gayi
Yoon laga saans bhi tham si gayi

Sitare jal uthe kabhi jo woh has padi
Neendein bhi ud gayi jugnu ban gayi

Do jaan ek hone ko thi
Dhadkane bas khone ko thi

Parwaano ne hoton pe dastak kari
Ehsaas ki khulne lagi kadi






Edited by ThithliDhost - 11 years ago
CandYlicious_S thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I am in tears today sis .. 😭 What Paro did today requires Strength of heart . Yes it would break Rudra's heart along with her heart being broken to micro pieces. But the journey woukd be worth it.. Woh le ayega apni Paro ko.. ❤️

I agree about what you said regarding editing and screenplay bit. May be because they had to hastily fit in the plot with maha sangam..
Edited by CandYlicious_S - 11 years ago
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: JJKKL

Gotcha...
Not read your post yet. Am first writing down the song I was reminded of

Bhula dena mujhe
Hai alvida tujhe
Tujhe jeena hai mere bina
Safar yeh tera, yeh raasta tera
Tujhe jeena hai.. mere bina


Hai alvida tujhe

Tujhe jeena hai mere bina
Safar yeh tera, yeh raasta tera
Tujhe jeena hai.. mere bina

Ho teri saari shoharatein
Hai yeh duaa..
Tujhi pe saari rehamatein
Hai yeh duaa..


Tu hi hai kinaara tera
Tu hi to sahaara tera
Tu hi hai taraana kal ka
Tu hi to fasaana kal ka


Milungi main iss tarah, waada raha
Rahungi sang main sada, waada raha
Tujhe jeena hai mere bina!




Thank you and i understand how this song echoes Paro's current state of mind and heart for Rudra. 😃
Navyya thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Your post is as emotional as the episode, MKM. I had a sinking feeling throughout the episode & that sinking feeling is still lingering. How I wish I could sleep contineously for 15 days or so & then wake up... by then hopefully Rudra would know about her vow & on a mission of finding his Paro . Now , I don't understand what I am going to do? Can't bear the pain, the seperation & can't stay away from RR too. Do you think this seperation will last long,MKM?
You are right about the editing part & other technical flaws but I was so sad that didn't really bother about those.
_SenbonZakura_ thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Lo ji... Res karne ke baawjood second page par.
-____-


Khamma Ghani Jeeja-sa..

I had been inactive on this forum. Even though the past few episodes had been brilliant storywise.

That was because I neither wanted to share my views with anyone, or read somebody else's views and be affected by them. I did not want to pollute what I understood in the scene. Nor did I want to affect anyone else by what I saw... Cause maybe they didn't see it.

Yet, your posts are what I always read. Be it the next day, or whenever... I make sure I read them. Because, you are the only person who doesn't make me regret reading.


Today, all I felt was an underlying pain. The rosy scenes... The bhindi, the sui, the chand, the fillum wala hero, the adhoori kahaani.. All of it kept on pricking my heart like the needle that Paro was holding.



And I cannot fathom what it'll do to Rudra, once she leaves.

But what really really moved me, was the last declaration of love by her. She has always been this, honest, straight forward woman.. Something that I immensely love about her. No matter what, she wears her heart on her sleeve. And probably that is also the reason why its much more heartbreaking to watch her keep a secret from him.




Also, the Maithili-Paro scene in the end was brilliant. I could feel the separation pain of two sisters. Jeeja really does love her like her own... And Rudra is not the only one Paro will scar by leaving.



But I agree on the editing part.. The flow was missing, and the scenes rushed and unpolished. Usually, song sequences like these in RR make me drown in pain and everything... But today, it was as if the impact wasn't there. All of it felt cut-paste.



I have a kostin. The June Promo shows Paro bringing Mala back into Rudra's life.

If she is leaving the oonth in next few days, and bringing Mala back in June... Does that mean that the separation will only last for a week or so??



Aapse baat kiye hue arsaa ho gaya... Meko miss toh nahi hi kia hoga naa aapne?? 😛


Also, adhoori kahaani se hamesha yeh gaana yaad aata hai meko..



Aadhi Aadhi Jaagi Aadhi Aadhi Soyi
Aankhen Yeh Teri Toh Lagta Hai Royi
Lekar Ke Naam Hamara...


Na Jaane Koi Kaisi Hai Yeh Zindagaani
Hamari Adhoori Kahani...

Edited by _SenbonZakura_ - 11 years ago
MoronsKiMallika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: gunji

seriously the editing is getting worse day by day...SBS scenes were much better than the epi😲

but I loved Paro's confession today...for me its her 1st confession...i dont consider that maang-bharo tamasha to be confession at all...



Thank you.😳... The editor and the post-production creative need to be pulled up. The scenes are shot well and this is what is done to them later.

I loved Paro today and one must fear for Rudra's future.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".