Isn't Anandi equally to be blamed? - Page 26

if only we had a bunch of Sanchi fanatics... Jag too was a villian in those days, just like Sa.. And in BV majority of the characters don't remain negative for long... Sanchi will also soon become a sant mahatma like Mr Jagdish 'innocent' singh..

Where did I or anybody else place him on a rapist's level? 😕
And you made a statement---A can never be the same as B. I simply asked the reason why. Isn't that what we do in debates?

Jag didn't physically abuse anyone BUT MENTALLY and EMOTIONALLY he very well DID...He was no better than Sa from any angle... Obviously fans can come and defend their favs with 37329299938331110000 baseless arguments...whats so new in that? Every action will have a 'phangurl special defense ' 😆

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

Please elaborate how Jagya was more or less inhuman than Sanchi. Not asking you to defend every action of Jagya, just asking for the reasoning behind your comparative analysis.

It is said Jagya was less inhumane than Sanchi because he used to feel bad while making mistakes.Sorry for again bringing cvs here but Cvs used to show him feeling bad...And then he used to make blunders all the time and used to get punishment and taunts for the blunders in the very next episode...On the contrary,Sanchi gets sympathy and sad background music with a bonus of lots of nashta paani even though she is wrong even after her all blunders...Even in that false case,in court room scene when Sanchi was giving her false,mangharan bayan,they were playing sad bg...And that was the first time I saw and hear creative playing sad BG seriously when a person is lying otherwise I am used to hear 'kamaulika' kind of evil BG while bad persons are shown...

The difference between Jagya and Sanchi is he got punished for his every fault and changed to a better person but in case of Sanchi cvs are showing sanchi got raped because of her past mistakes,she didn t get any punishment for her past deeds and I refuse to accept rape as her punishment...Why on earth a girl will have to face humiliation in court for getting raped to understand her mistaked and to start her redemption...CVs failed totally this time...How can they show this they themselves know...

But it is not happening. I have been waiting for it.

But how does it matter? If you do a mistake, then feel bad for sometime and AGAIN do some other mistake...Keep making mistakes and keep feeling bad..that's inconsistency and is in NO way better ! His list of sins are too long to ignore... Did he ever sit and reflect upon his EACH and every mistake? No naa? Coz its not possible, the list is too long.. Did he ever apologize to Anandi for that disgusting back rash comment? Did he apologize to Shiv for that nasty comment? Did he ever confess to his family and Anandi TILL DATE that the Amnesia drama was FAKE? Its not a small thing, not a small lie , but a VERY DISGUSTING act on his part! He didn't confess , till date. So how can we even think of keeping him on a higher pedestal than Sanchi? Yes, he is a changed man now, but he was no better a year back...

@Shanky: Yes, Jayga got punished for his crimes but Sanchi didn't, and I guess that's what is causing people to be unforgiving towards her despite her rape. But if we put their crimes on the spring balance, then Jagya's side would be more tilted IMO. But I agree that this rape track was uncalled for, they should've shown her getting rescued by PayNandi and then gradually realising/reflecting on her mistakes.

I think let us not make anymore BRILLIANT, out of the world, pure KEKTAISH assumptions and actually wait and see how this track unfolds...The writer claims that this track is to give out a strong social message that the victims should fight back for justice and get the assaulter punished. So, i really don't think showing Sanchi getting pregnant and getting her married to any of the Cobras would serve the purpose..It will totally dilute the whole message that the writers are claiming to send through this date-rape track...

Originally posted by: Theepetronauss

But how does it matter? If you do a mistake, then feel bad for sometime and AGAIN do some other mistake...Keep making mistakes and keep feeling bad..that's inconsistency and is in NO way better ! His list of sins are too long to ignore... Did he ever sit and reflect upon his EACH and every mistake? No naa? Coz its not possible, the list is too long.. Did he ever apologize to Anandi for that disgusting back rash comment? Did he apologize to Shiv for that nasty comment? Did he ever confess to his family and Anandi TILL DATE that the Amnesia drama was FAKE? Its not a small thing, not a small lie , but a VERY DISGUSTING act on his part! He didn't confess , till date. So how can we even think of keeping him on a higher pedestal than Sanchi? Yes, he is a changed man now, but he was no better a year back...

It surely matters...

It like saying you have made mistake dont you dare saying sorry to me...I will not except it...

Its better to accept I have made blunder,I don't think u will be able to forgive me ever but I am really sorry..Thats the reason Ananadi has forgave him...wo agar galti na maanta to kaise koi ussko maaf karta...

As it is a serial people have to make mistakes and other people have to solve it...again they will make mistake and other will solve...Problem was cvs butchered Jagya very badly,they shouldn't have showed that bhaboot scene and that amnesia thing...When cvs knew one day they will redeem their protagonist then why showing him so low...But Cvs ne Sanchi ko Jagya se bhi jyada niche giraya...the reason is probably she was never a good girl...before going to Mumbai Jagya was a good boy but from the very first scene Sanchi was bad...So showing a redeemed sanchi through rape is a worse case...Because even though you are feeling bad for the situation you can hardly feel for Sanchi...Aur aapko bura lagta hai ke why I cant feel sympathy for a rape victim,as a girl I should but why I cant...We cant because of cvs way of handling the case...