SHEHR E ZAAT MISPLACED KNOWLEDGE ON ISLAM!?

Nkapoor3 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Shehr-e-Zaat and its misplaced knowledge of Islam

2 hours ago

Ever wondered what kind of a message we are conveying to our children by applauding Fifi's behaviour towards her mother? PHOTO: ONLINE

Is it just me or does anyone else find this drama seriously annoying? I sometimes do get the feeling that it's just me.

The comments I see online about Hum TV's Shehr-e-Zaat, show that the viewers applaud the lead character in the drama, Falak, for her new-found piety and shunning of the material world and its pleasures, while always looking peaceful.

For those who have not been enlightened with the story of the drama (I myself have not yet watched the last episode), Shehr-e-Zaat is the story of beautiful, rich, young Falak, affectionately known as 'Fifi' and thus inferring the bourgeois lifestyle that goes along with such a nickname. She is an art student, and while leading on her best friend Hamza, who is madly in love with her, she makes a sculpture of her ideal man's face, and lo and behold, he appears into her life.

This sculpting exercise is causing constant friction between Fifi and her know-it-all Naani who hates all this kufar nonsense about making 'idols'. So Fifi and Salman (the sculpture-face guy), also from a rich family, get married to each other and have the wedding of the century. Salman never claims to love Fifi and tells her straight out that he is not the affectionate kind.

Salman eventually has an affair with an unattractive, illiterate woman, crushing Fifi. He is so in love with her that he marries her, leaving everyone shocked. Fifi goes back to her parents' home, and under the influence of Naani dearest, proceeds to blame all her problems on the fact that she 'forgot about Allah (SWT)'.

Where do I begin? Firstly I am, to no end, appalled by Fifi's terrible behaviour towards her mother, who is by far the only sensible person in this entire drama. The mother is a socialite and therein lies her cardinal sin. Throughout the drama, we only see her vie for the best for her child. However, because she is a socialite, of course she is evil. Fifi throws many a fit directed at her mother and blames her for not 'teaching her how to worship/love Allah (SWT)'.

Our dear viewers just lapped this up and supported Fifi for finally 'seeing the light'. Firstly, Fifi blames her problems on her mother, arguably the only person who loves her, and secondly, ignores the misery her mother is going through on her behalf, making her feel guiltier every day about what has come to pass.

What a terrible idea to promote! Did the producers of this show forget the teachings of Islam and our beloved Holy Prophet (pbuh) here? A mother, as our religion teaches, deserves the utmost respect; she should be treated as though heaven lies beneath her feet.

Yet, the idea promoted here is that if your mother isn't a religious person and likes her friends, it is perfectly commendable to treat her like dirt.

I am sorry to burst your bubble all those who worship this show, but it is insulting to the beautiful image of Islam to show that it is okay for a daughter to treat her mother as so. Ever wondered what kind of a message we are conveying to our children by applauding Fifi's behaviour towards her mother?

Let's not forget Naani dearest, the worst of the lot, with her patronising voice, expressions and medieval ideas. She is against divorce, and encourages Fifi to be as fervently religious as possible, claiming that in this alone will she find the answers to everything that is wrong with her. She is a great favourite of the viewers - someone that makes my skin crawl.

Whether or not Fifi had been a panj-waqta namazi (a person who prays five times a day), would have had no bearings whatsoever on Salman and his passion for his new girlfriend. Preaching to the viewer that praying will avoid all the heartache in life is not only wrong, but misleading. Yes, prayer is important, but to say that by doing so, life will be all peaches, is wrong to say in the least. Hurdles in life are a test by Allah (SWT) and this is the idea that should be promoted. Prayer is a way to calm the effect of these the troubles life throws at you. It gives you the patience to overcome hurdles.

Viewers may get the wrong idea here and be very antagonistic if the expectation is drilled in their heads that if you pray day and night, life will not deal you a bad hand. Let me remind the readers that there was none so pious as our Holy Prophet (pbuh) and he faced his fair share of grief during his life. It is not that he didn't pray, it's just that this is how God tests us. It is called aazmaaish, and it shouldn't be treated like the wrath of God.

Propagating this false idea is highly immature and unprofessional.

While I believe that the drama is executed well and the depth of the characters is commendable, I feel as though the themes picked up by this story (especially religion) have been played upon in the most distasteful ways possible.

Leading such a impressionable population to believe in a slanted version of Islam is unethical and the producers should have known better.

Moreover, as far as saying 'Allah behtar jaanta hai' (God knows best) to every problem faced, of course He will help you, but then again, He only helps those who help themselves.

Does Shehr-e-Zaat depict the correct version of Islam?

  • Yes
  • No
Edited by Nkapoor3 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

137

Views

11.6k

Users

25

Likes

148

Frequent Posters

hunybutt thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
I think she only complains with her mother that whe she is unaware of teachings of islam she doesnt misbehave doesnt get rude ...she z like restless soul who has a guilt of not having knowledge of her religion ...
pk14 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
i think falak's charaacter was confused and at the point when she was shown bieng rude to her mother then it was her phase of life when she started acknowledging that she was on wrong path and second thing this novel sheh re zaat was based on a girl who was moved from ishq e majazi from salman towards ishq e haqiqi ...so when falak becomes paanch waqt ki nimaazi she actually becomes a bit senseless about her emotions for salman ...and its jst a drama at the end written by a writter who feels that way ...every one have his or her own opinion ...
Raindrops. thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
These liberals are the most conservative people ever 😆...they cannot just accept if something like religion is shown on tv ...They think only they are entitled to give opinion on anything and everything ... they can accept something like vulgar dances, showing alcohol consumption in dramas, girls posing nude and openly kissing in public but they would still come up with something like oh fifi did not respect her mother... ridiculous
Guess they are only scared that some people may actually turn to God after watching this drama
Namaz is compulsory in Islam and yes she turns to God in her sad times but even in her happy times later on she continues to pray ...she did say that she does not pray for anything but God ...nothing else really matters to her more than pleasing him
Mothers have a responsibility to give their children right guidance and on the day of judgement they are answerable to God on how they raised their children
BlackStar. thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Your mother's lap is the first place to learn..
It's a common notion that if the father is the breadwinner of the family, then the mother is the one who you spend most of your time with and she teaches you both worldly and Islamic knowledge..
How is Falak wrong to say her mom didn't teach her religion? I can give my example and say the basic knowledge of Islam, the foundation I got was all due to my mom..
If she hadn't taught me things I would've been a different person altogether.
Why can't people accept that the drama showed good things? It showed the truth.
If your parents are doing something wrong, your allowed to pin-point their mistakes and help them..
As we see Mehr-un-Nissa wasn't exactly kind to her servants and people from a lower class than her in the beginning of the drama..
Liberal people may have a problem with it because oh the rich people are shown as big bad wolves, but it's the truthh. Not all rich people follow life-styles like her but most do.. and the truth was shown in the drama.

Secondly, I think the person who chose to write this article needs to go and study Islam in further depth..
Prayer is MANDATORY! It's one of the five pillars of Islam..
The drama didn't show that your supposed to only pray and remember Allah in your bad times..
The message Naani taught to Falak was to thank Allah for both your good and bad times..
I just heard the other day that it's said if an Azmaish doesn't come to you for forty days, any type of hurdle, then a person should worry about their Iman.. Allah's tests are only a path which'll lead you to Jannah.. and why should the drama only focus on tests from Allah? Why can't we form a spiritual connect with Allah.. People should at-least try and worship Allah in a quiet place by themselves and they'll realize how much peace they'll receive and how good they'll feel about life.
Edited by BlackStar. - 12 years ago
BlackStar. thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
This part of the article is totally bull-crapp.. I think the writer couldn't handle what was being shown in the drama could they.. Or maybe they just didn't understand it/want to understand itt. Simple.

Who even said in the drama that if you pray five times a day your life will be all peace and no problems? If anything, people who pray five times a day face so many problems in their life.. They definitely do not live a peaceful life.. But the thing is they have patience and they don't give up on Allah.. They thank him for his blessings and they also believe in Him for fixing their problems..

Whether or not Fifi had been a panj-waqta namazi (a person who prays five times a day), would have had no bearings whatsoever on Salman and his passion for his new girlfriend. Preaching to the viewer that praying will avoid all the heartache in life is not only wrong, but misleading. Yes, prayer is important, but to say that by doing so, life will be all peaches, is wrong to say in the least. Hurdles in life are a test by Allah (SWT) and this is the idea that should be promoted. Prayer is a way to calm the effect of these the troubles life throws at you. It gives you the patience to overcome hurdles.
BlackStar. thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail Engager 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
One thing this article forgot to mention is how Hijab wasn't emphasized in the drama?
How come their not pin-pointing something so important?
I bet if she had donned one these are the same people who would've labelled her as an extremist.

Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Are you kidding me? The person who wrote this article has either been misguided or don't know what theyre talking about :S
What was wrong with Falaks behaviour towards her mother? When did she misbehave? She never did, infact at the end SHE was the one who brought her mother to the right path.
Meeph thumbnail
Anniversary 16 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
O Bhai,Bhang pee ke article likha tha kya?
Nkapoor3 thumbnail
Anniversary 12 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I agree with the article, FIFI was rude to her mum for no reason, and this show does give u the idea that if u r non believer in god u will face bad times!
Edited by Nkapoor3 - 12 years ago
Top