should SOAPS be allowed to hurt national sentiments ?

drHfan_in thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Oh... u people did it...
got victimized by those terror funding intellect society from enemy country...
u have def ministers male female both simulating !!! you have an industrialist name simulating just to give true biographical image..!!
extremely bias... I was the person praising the family values in both the countries ... even at terror gangs Head ... but what u did... you have problems with all Indian lovers... and pakistani considerate... you are provoking.. anti pak .. senti in most possible cruel way...
those who came back to India... you made their life socially miserable... the person choosing pak ... girl ... though true indian were ... love bond oriented... and even favored ... that !!😲🥱👏
but you have irritating story.. for indian based guys... to destroy a DRONACHARYA kind Vikram...personality at the hands of his own and indian martyr level soldier ... turned by a so called school attack ? which is propagandized heavily by enemy centres...and indirect hinting that industrialist politicians of india are responsible for all these KAOS ??
Lala is better then Vikram in noursing the soldier ? Lala is thought full and ok I admire ... but he should be less violence lover... perhaps it seems you are aiming at...
then let Sid be a peace hero..!! like 2000 secrets under the Sea... a submarine founder torpidoes... the less known war tech to X and Y both miltary bases ... he is against weapons... so does it... not taking on hospitals... not killing hostage...!!!!
India or Pak no country likes a traitor...and terrorist... has no country... no religion... only victim of some aspirants whose families money wealth are secured... in neutral countries... and are playing with extreme sentiments... let Sid ... expose them... for larger interest... TRP gain would be much more if you follow natural POETIC JUSTICE ...rather then some hear say thing twisting in with some real time line incidents , look a like characters...putting your hidden agenda popularizinganti socialite in our simple innocent derivable audience ... it is obvious you are focusing shikh Jat sentiments for some local heroics in hospital...and some balanceing act by imaan so anti muslims turn a little national muslims have something to cheer upon...


Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

39

Frequent Posters

drHfan_in thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
you have replace bolywood favourite MAA senti with Sis Shobha and is shown worried.. in re thinking FBs about SID... is he...???
kind..her suspicion is superbly shown..
I said the story to the kid and asault on school horrified ... so that one can understand the attack on civilian is not good...!!! and then killing a hostage ???!!! terrorists only have Policies... end result twists and turns their script writer is also seating elsewhere... getting their ullu correct... by their sleeper cells... you do it by your characters... but why harm...Ashoka had change of heart... but he went for non violence and BUDHDHA ... not to enemy country's hand in glow techs... Vibhishan defected but openly only after Rawan was so over confident... about his virtues..and capacities... he abducted Sita but never did hindi film rape try...Lord Ram even says to Laxman to get lessons from Dying Rawan... !!! This is a country of veracity and wisdom our Mythological Epics are having good vincible reasoning and full of POETIC JUSTICE... not this stupid victim of secessionist forces..even in art form... I quote Lord Budhdha ... He favored Chess... as killing on chess board..of bishops rooks pawns nights and queens never really drew BLOOD... violence carried out the FIRE Hunger from within ... petted out giving psychological thrills but not drowing actual ...
maaneet_forever thumbnail
Anniversary 14 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Well said points sir
We should wait and watch how they are going to cumulate things at the end
Themarauder thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
While criticism is always invited, I don't understand one thing, drHfan_in. If you have numerous problems with the very content of the show, and every sphere in which the story is directed, why do you even bother watching it?
This is a fictional show which brings out human emotions from the crux of each character, their trials and tribulations in an excellent manner. Truth is people change, and this show tries to portray reality to the closest quarters. If you would follow twitter you would know that everything about the show has only ignited the love of one's country. Even the recent frames which you think are encouraging anti-Pak sentiments or siding with terror, have posed questions to the perpetuation of hate & terror, instead of fuelling anti-Pak / anti-nationalist behaviours.
Nationalism or Humanity require action, not words.
And I refuse to accept that the makers have had anything communal in mind when they selected the characters, which you keep highlighting. We all are Indians first, then we maybe a Bengali, a Tamilian, a Christian, a Hindu or a Jain. Our identity should be Indian and our religion should be Humanity. Especially for soldiers, bcuz it is always country above all for them. Above gender, caste, creed, colour, religion or social standing.
And, with all due respect, it would be lovely to see any country's name begin with a capital letter, they are proper nouns you know... '
TheMachine thumbnail
Group Promotion 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
I hope you're just trolling. But I'll bite anyway.

So your question, based on the topic title, is "Should free speech be banned?" To which I say no. Your sentiments would be more appropriate in a nation like China, or North Korea. Being blind to reality is something that exists in those countries, when a nation takes drastic measures to appear perfect to the population. Such perfection is not possible. In fact, it is important to address these flaws so people do not get defensive and try to defend what is wrong, and so they try to do their part to fix it. How is it that other adaptations of this concept run wonderfully in other countries, and actually become popular? Because people don't challenge the reality of it, or they watch it as a fictional show should be watched.

Aside from the hypothetical, I can mention something real as well: POW isn't going anywhere. Sorry. You should have protested to STAR when they made the decision to air it. Complaining now does no good, because it's almost over, and honestly, even if you decided to take action instead of just complaining, nothing would happen, because all of your statements are unfounded.

I don't understand how people manage to get offended over everything. Doesn't it make life hard? Less than 10 episodes before the show is over, suddenly a bunch of people are complaining about the story and the characters, not understanding that it's part of the script and part of the plot, all written deliberately. Change your perspective. It helps.
Edited by TheMachine - 7 years ago
MS-meghasharma thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 6 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
If you don't like it , don't watch it . It's as simple as that . Everyone knew it is inspired from hautufim & homeland so why the fuss now . both the shows have the same storyline & why is it hard to accept that ppl might change . He lived with a jihadi commander for years & he has brainwashed him completely so he is behaving the way he is which is what is happening in real world also . Educated ppl like software engineers, doctors left their jobs , families to join Isis & fight with them .
AayaTohModiJi thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
TM has full rights to criticize the content if he or she don't like the thing...
FOE is for one way always when other used it y making it as troll or bashing...
liking content or not liking content everyone has FOE ...
about fiction or reality nothing has right to hurt national sentiment
now coming to the show till now they didn't except the fact about peshwar attack n linking Indian name other that was big blunder I will say ( well u can keep calling me troll or advice me anything )
other than this I don't think Show has done anything to harm national sentiment n will wait for the last epi
drHfan_in thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
What makes u irritated...???
Till now all of us enjoyed this remake. ...it's only creators right...
We all are hunger prone for entertainment...
It is gaining so real time stance that. Only this possible pl refine it urge...not just a rough...shrug "Bolana. Nahi hai , buy it or khisko..."...Indian should not say this...(ok now SIR ! )..I have never opposed. Critically objecting is so difficult to answer out ???
As many agree till now they have not crossed the Laxman Rekha in spite of coming so close with fear of crossing...
Themarauder thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
What makes us irritated?
Criticism does not. Go ahead with it.👏 But, complaining about every angle introduced in the show does. Introducing communalist views to that section of the society which gives away everything (very rightly shown in the show) to protect their nation and their people does . And, complaining about every sphere of the show in its very forum, which, by the way, is meant for healthy discussions, and cross questions, is overtly infuriating.😡
And, just so you know it, it's a "Ma'am", not Sir. Need neither of the addresses though.
Swetha-Sai thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
@Themarauder and @TheMachine
Completely agree with the POV's of both of you!
Top